Taste of Simplicity: McArthur’s Amish Market Revolutionizes Local Food Scene

A Taste of Tradition: New Amish Market Brings Old-World Charm to McArthur, Ohio

In the heart of Vinton County, a new Amish market is breathing fresh life into the local food scene. The McArthur Farm Market, which opened its doors in January 2025, has quickly become a bustling hub of activity, drawing both curious locals and out-of-town visitors eager to experience a slice of Amish culture and cuisine.

Located at 62130 Locker Plant Rd in McArthur, Ohio, the market occupies a newly constructed 24,000 square foot building that has transformed the local shopping experience. Now, it’s a vibrant marketplace filled with the aromas of freshly baked goods, the colorful displays of farm-fresh produce, and the gentle clip-clop of horse hooves in the parking lot.

John Stoltzfus, one of the market’s founding members, explains the vision behind Eldora Farm Market: “We wanted to create a place where our Amish community could share our traditions and craftsmanship with our English neighbors. It’s about building bridges and preserving our way of life.”

The market features over 20 vendors, each offering a unique taste of Amish culture and cuisine. One of the most popular stops is Sarah’s Bakery, where the aroma of freshly baked shoofly pies and whoopie pies fills the air.

“I never expected such enthusiasm for our traditional recipes,” says Sarah Miller, the bakery’s owner. “On weekends, we often have lines out the door. It’s a blessing to share our food with so many people.”

Another crowd favorite is Yoder’s Preserves, where master craftsman Eli Yoder creates an array of homemade jams, jellies, and pickled vegetables. “Each jar tells a story of our harvest,” Yoder says. “We use locally sourced produce and methods passed down through generations. It’s gratifying to see how much our English customers appreciate the flavors of our tradition.”

The market’s produce section, run by the Lapp family, has become a go-to spot for local chefs and home cooks alike. “We’re bringing back small-scale farming to an area that had seen many family farms disappear,” explains Rebecca Lapp. “People appreciate knowing where their food comes from and how it’s produced.”

One of the biggest draws to the Eldora Farm Market is the Saturday chicken barbecue, which runs from 10 am until sold out. “Our chicken barbecue has become quite the event,” says Jacob Fisher, who oversees the operation. “Folks come from all over the county for a taste. It’s not uncommon for us to sell out before noon.”

The market also boasts a variety of other businesses, including Plain & Simple Farmhouse, offering rustic home decor, and Dunkle Leather, showcasing handcrafted leather goods. The Amish Country Soap Company provides natural skincare products, while Miller’s Coins attracts collectors from across the state.

For many visitors, the market offers more than just shopping – it’s an experience. Emily Thompson, a McArthur resident and regular customer, shares her thoughts: “Coming here is like stepping back in time. The quality of the products is outstanding, and there’s something special about buying directly from the people who made or grew what you’re purchasing.”

The market has also become a popular destination for tourists. Tom Jenkins, visiting from Columbus, was impressed by his first visit: “I’ve never seen anything quite like this. The attention to detail in everything from the hand-stitched quilts to the homemade root beer is remarkable. It’s well worth the drive.”

However, the market’s success hasn’t come without challenges. The influx of visitors has led to increased traffic in the area, and local officials have had to work closely with the Amish community to ensure safety, particularly for horse-drawn buggies sharing the roads with cars.

County Commissioner Mark Thompson acknowledges the adjustments: “It’s been a learning process for everyone, but the Amish have been great partners in finding solutions. Their presence has added a unique character to our community.”

The Amish vendors have also had to navigate the delicate balance between maintaining their traditional lifestyle and meeting the demands of a modern marketplace. Many have embraced solar power for refrigeration and wind energy for cash registers, demonstrating a pragmatic approach to technology.

Samuel Lapp, who runs a small engine repair shop in the market, explains: “We’re not against all technology. We simply try to use it in ways that don’t disrupt our family and community life. It’s about being intentional with our choices.”

As the market continues to grow in popularity, there are plans for expansion. Bishop Amos Stoltzfus, a community leader, reflects on the future: “Our goal is to create a sustainable marketplace that stays true to our faith and values while contributing positively to the wider McArthur community.”

The Eldora Farm Market represents more than just a new shopping destination – it’s a bridge between cultures, a celebration of traditional craftsmanship, and a reminder of the enduring appeal of simple, authentic experiences in our fast-paced world.

The market is open Monday to Friday from 9 AM to 5 PM and Saturday from 9 AM to 4 PM, offering ample opportunity for both locals and tourists to experience the best of Amish country. With its wide variety of homemade preserves, pickled vegetables, canned fruits, and fresh baked goods, including whoopie pies, brownies, cookies, shoofly pies, and assorted fruit pies, the Eldora Farm Market has quickly become a must-visit destination in Vinton County.

Local resident Mary Johnson sums up the sentiment of many: “Having the Amish market here has been a real blessing. They’ve brought new life to our area, and their work ethic and sense of community are truly admirable. It’s like stepping back in time, but in the best possible way.”

As the sun sets over the rolling farmland surrounding McArthur, the clip-clop of horse hooves and the laughter of children playing in the market’s courtyard serve as a gentle reminder that sometimes, moving forward means taking a step back – to a simpler, more connected way of life.

Citations:

Peach Bottom’s New Market Brings Tradition to Your Table

A Taste of Tradition: New Amish Market Brings Old-World Charm to Peach Bottom, PA

In the heart of southern Lancaster County, a new Amish market is breathing fresh life into the local food scene. The Eldora Farm Market, which opened its doors in January 2025, has quickly become a bustling hub of activity, drawing both curious locals and out-of-town visitors eager to experience a slice of Amish culture and cuisine.

Located at 1920 Lancaster Pike in Peach Bottom, PA, the market occupies a newly constructed building that replaced the original roadside stand known as Corner Stand Produce. Now, it’s a vibrant marketplace filled with the aromas of freshly baked goods, the colorful displays of farm-fresh produce, and the gentle clip-clop of horse hooves in the parking lot.

For many visitors, the market offers more than just shopping – it’s an experience. Emily Thompson, a Peach Bottom resident and regular customer, shares her thoughts: “Coming here is like stepping back in time. The quality of the products is outstanding, and there’s something special about buying directly from the people who made or grew what you’re purchasing.”

The market has also become a popular destination for tourists. Tom Jenkins, visiting from Baltimore, was impressed by his first visit: “I’ve never seen anything quite like this. The attention to detail in everything from the hand-stitched quilts to the homemade root beer is remarkable. It’s well worth the drive.”

The market is open Monday to Friday from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. and Saturday from 8 a.m. to 6:30 p.m., offering ample opportunity for both locals and tourists to experience the best of Amish country. With its wide variety of homemade preserves, pickled vegetables, canned fruits, and fresh baked goods, including whoopie pies, brownies, cookies, shoofly pies, and assorted fruit pies, the Eldora Farm Market has quickly become a must-visit destination in southern Lancaster County.

As the sun sets over the rolling farmland surrounding Peach Bottom, the clip-clop of horse hooves and the laughter of children playing in the market’s courtyard serve as a gentle reminder that sometimes, moving forward means taking a step back – to a simpler, more connected way of life.

Citations:

New Amish Market Brings Old-World Charm to York, PA

A Taste of Tradition: New Amish Market Brings Old-World Charm to York, PA

In the heart of York County, Pennsylvania, a new Amish market is breathing fresh life into the local food scene. The Maple Grove Amish Market, which opened its doors in January 2025, has quickly become a bustling hub of activity, drawing both curious locals and out-of-town visitors eager to experience a slice of Amish culture and cuisine.

Located on the outskirts of York, the market occupies a sprawling 20,000-square-foot building that was once a defunct warehouse. Now, it’s a vibrant marketplace filled with the aromas of freshly baked goods, the colorful displays of farm-fresh produce, and the gentle clop of horse hooves in the parking lot.

John Stoltzfus, one of the market’s founding members, explains the vision behind Maple Grove: “We wanted to create a place where our Amish community could share our traditions and craftsmanship with our English neighbors. It’s about building bridges and preserving our way of life.”

The market features over 30 vendors, each offering a unique taste of Amish culture and cuisine. One of the most popular stops is Sarah’s Bakery, where the aroma of freshly baked shoofly pies and whoopie pies fills the air.

Another crowd favorite is Yoder’s Furniture, where master craftsman Eli Yoder creates bespoke pieces using time-honored woodworking techniques. “Each piece tells a story,” Yoder says. “We use locally sourced wood and methods passed down through generations. It’s gratifying to see how much our English customers appreciate the craftsmanship.”

For many visitors, the market offers more than just shopping – it’s an experience. Emily Thompson, a York resident and regular customer, shares her thoughts: “Coming here is like stepping back in time. The quality of the products is outstanding, and there’s something special about buying directly from the people who made or grew what you’re purchasing.”

The market has also become a popular destination for tourists. Tom Jenkins, visiting from Baltimore, was impressed by his first visit: “I’ve never seen anything quite like this. The attention to detail in everything from the hand-stitched quilts to the homemade jams is remarkable. It’s well worth the drive.”

The Maple Grove Amish Market represents more than just a new shopping destination – it’s a bridge between cultures, a celebration of traditional craftsmanship, and a reminder of the enduring appeal of simple, authentic experiences in our fast-paced world.

As the sun sets over the rolling farmland surrounding York, the clip-clop of horse hooves and the laughter of children playing in the market’s courtyard serve as a gentle reminder that sometimes, moving forward means taking a step back – to a simpler, more connected way of life.

Citations:

From Buggies to Businesses: Inside Indiana’s Newest Amish Community

A New Frontier: Amish Community Blossoms in Southern Indiana

In the rolling hills of southern Indiana, a new Amish settlement is taking root, bringing with it a blend of traditional values and entrepreneurial spirit. The Maple Grove Amish community, established in early 2023, has quickly become a hub of activity, drawing both curious visitors and those seeking a simpler way of life.

Located in the picturesque countryside of Washington County, the settlement has grown to include over 40 families in just two years. The community’s rapid expansion has been fueled by a combination of natural growth and families relocating from more established Amish areas in Pennsylvania and northern Indiana.

John Stoltzfus, one of the first settlers in Maple Grove, explains the appeal: “We were looking for a place where we could maintain our way of life while also having opportunities for our young people. This area has provided that perfect balance.”

The new settlement has brought an economic boost to the region, with several Amish-owned businesses quickly becoming local favorites. The Maple Grove Bakery, run by the Miller family, has become renowned for its fresh-baked goods and homemade ice cream.

“We never expected such a warm welcome from our English neighbors,” says Sarah Miller, co-owner of the bakery. “On weekends, we often have lines out the door for our shoofly pie and whoopie pies. It’s a blessing to share our traditional recipes with the community.”

Another popular spot is the Yoder’s Furniture Workshop, where master craftsman Eli Yoder creates bespoke pieces using traditional woodworking techniques. “Each piece tells a story,” Yoder says. “We use locally sourced wood and time-honored methods passed down through generations. It’s gratifying to see how much our English neighbors appreciate our craftsmanship.”

The influx of Amish families has also revitalized local agriculture. The Maple Grove Produce Auction, held twice weekly, has become a bustling marketplace where Amish farmers sell their fresh fruits, vegetables, and flowers to both local residents and restaurant owners from as far away as Louisville and Indianapolis.

Rebecca Hershberger, who runs a small dairy farm with her husband, notes the community’s impact on local food systems: “We’re bringing back small-scale farming to an area that had seen many family farms disappear. People appreciate knowing where their food comes from and how it’s produced.”

The settlement’s growth hasn’t been without challenges. Local officials have had to adapt to the presence of horse-drawn buggies on rural roads, installing new signage and widening shoulders in some areas to improve safety.

The Amish families have also had to navigate their own cultural transitions. While maintaining their traditional lifestyle, many have embraced certain modern conveniences for business purposes, such as solar-powered refrigeration for dairy operations and wind-generated energy for cash registers in their shops.

Samuel Lapp, who operates a small engine repair shop, explains the delicate balance: “We’re not against all technology. We simply try to use it in ways that don’t disrupt our family and community life. It’s about being intentional with our choices.”

The community’s impact extends beyond economics. Local schools have seen increased enrollment as some non-Amish families, attracted by the simpler lifestyle, have moved to the area. This cultural exchange has led to new friendships and understanding between the Amish and their “English” neighbors.

Emily Roberts, a local teacher, has observed this firsthand: “It’s been fascinating to see how the children interact. There’s a genuine curiosity and respect on both sides. We’re all learning from each other.”

As the Maple Grove settlement continues to grow, it faces the challenge of maintaining its cultural identity while adapting to its new surroundings. Community leaders are already discussing the possibility of establishing their own school and forming additional church districts to accommodate the expanding population.

Bishop Amos Stoltzfus reflects on the community’s future: “Our goal is to create a sustainable community that stays true to our faith and values. We want to be good neighbors and contribute positively to the wider area.”

The emergence of the Maple Grove Amish settlement represents a new chapter in the long history of Amish communities in Indiana. As these families put down roots in Washington County, they bring with them a rich cultural heritage and a commitment to faith, family, and community that resonates with many in today’s fast-paced world.

For visitors, the new settlement offers a glimpse into a different way of life and the opportunity to purchase high-quality, handcrafted goods. For the Amish themselves, it represents a chance to preserve their traditions while adapting to the challenges of the 21st century.

Jane Thompson, a longtime resident of Washington County, shares her enthusiasm: “The Maple Grove Market has been a wonderful addition to our area. The quality of their products is outstanding, and it’s always a pleasure to interact with the Amish families who run it.”

As the sun sets over the rolling farmland of Maple Grove, the clip-clop of horse hooves and the laughter of children playing remind us that sometimes, moving forward means taking a step back – to a simpler, more connected way of life.

Citations:

New Amish Community Flourishes in Washington County, Ohio

Amish Roots Take Hold: New Community Flourishes in Washington County, Ohio

In the rolling hills of southeastern Ohio, a new Amish settlement is breathing fresh life into Washington County’s rural landscape. Established in early 2023, the Maple Creek Amish community has quickly become a vibrant addition to the area, bringing with it a blend of traditional values and entrepreneurial spirit.

The settlement, which now comprises over 30 families, has its origins in a small group of Amish who relocated from more established communities in Holmes County, Ohio, and parts of Pennsylvania. Moise Miller, one of the first settlers, explains the appeal of Washington County: “We were seeking a place where we could maintain our way of life while also providing opportunities for our young people. This area offered that perfect balance”[3].

The influx of Amish families has revitalized local agriculture and commerce. The Maple Creek Produce Auction, held twice weekly, has become a bustling marketplace where Amish farmers sell their fresh fruits, vegetables, and flowers to both local residents and restaurant owners from as far away as Marietta and Parkersburg.

Sarah Yoder, who runs a small dairy farm with her husband, notes the community’s impact on local food systems: “We’re bringing back small-scale farming to an area that had seen many family farms disappear. People appreciate knowing where their food comes from and how it’s produced”[1].

One of the most popular new businesses is the Palmer Square Market, an Amish-owned establishment that has quickly become a favorite among locals and tourists alike. “Our market offers a truly authentic buying experience,” says Daniel Hochstetler, the owner. “From freshly baked goods to bulk foods, meats, cheeses, and even patio furniture, we strive to provide a wide range of high-quality products”[6].

The market’s success has not gone unnoticed by the local community. Jane Thompson, a longtime resident of Washington County, shares her enthusiasm: “The Palmer Square Market has been a wonderful addition to our area. The quality of their products is outstanding, and it’s always a pleasure to interact with the Amish families who run it.”

Another thriving business is the Wheat Ridge Furniture Workshop, where master craftsman Eli Lapp creates bespoke pieces using traditional woodworking techniques. “Each piece tells a story,” Lapp says. “We use locally sourced wood and time-honored methods passed down through generations. It’s gratifying to see how much our English neighbors appreciate our craftsmanship”[1].

The arrival of the Amish has not been without its challenges. Local officials have had to adapt to the presence of horse-drawn buggies on rural roads, installing new signage and widening shoulders in some areas to improve safety. County Commissioner Mark Wilson acknowledges the adjustments: “It’s been a learning process for everyone, but the Amish have been great partners in finding solutions. Their presence has added a unique character to our community”[1].

Samuel Stoltzfus, who operates a small engine repair shop, explains the delicate balance: “We’re not against all technology. We simply try to use it in ways that don’t disrupt our family and community life. It’s about being intentional with our choices”[3].

As the Maple Creek settlement continues to grow, it faces the challenge of maintaining its cultural identity while adapting to its new surroundings. Community leaders are already discussing the possibility of establishing their own school and forming additional church districts to accommodate the expanding population.

Bishop Amos Hershberger reflects on the community’s future: “Our goal is to create a sustainable community that stays true to our faith and values. We want to be good neighbors and contribute positively to the wider area”[1].

The emergence of the Maple Creek Amish settlement represents a new chapter in the long history of Amish communities in Ohio. As these families put down roots in Washington County, they bring with them a rich cultural heritage and a commitment to faith, family, and community that resonates with many in today’s fast-paced world.

Don Ward, a neighboring farmer, sums up the sentiment of many locals: “Having the Amish here has been a real blessing. They’ve brought new life to our area, and their work ethic and sense of community are truly admirable. It’s like stepping back in time, but in the best possible way”[1].

As the sun sets over the rolling farmland of Maple Creek, the clip-clop of horse hooves and the laughter of children playing remind us that sometimes, moving forward means taking a step back – to a simpler, more connected way of life.

Citations:
[1] https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/Amish-enclave-moves-to-Washington-County-16411219.php
[2] https://www.ohiotraveler.com/mom-and-pop-amish-shops/
[3] https://www.bedlamfarm.com/2021/05/01/mosie-and-me-another-road-trip-the-amish-way-how-mosie-miller-became-my-neighbor-and-friend/
[4] https://www.circleofblue.org/2024/world/amish-farmers-partnership-with-beef-giant-produces-manure-mess/
[5] https://amishamerica.com/amish-supercounties/
[6] https://mariettaohio.org/directory/palmer-square-market/
[7] https://www.sideeffectspublicmedia.org/community-health/2019-09-11/how-the-amish-live-uninsured-but-stay-healthy
[8] https://www.wyso.org/news/2015-06-30/ohios-amish-county-reacts-to-marriage-ruling-by-supreme-court
[9] https://www.transportation.ohio.gov/wps/wcm/connect/gov/b3b86275-f673-4a2b-b4ae-69a58f82c194/AmishPopulationTrends.pdf?MOD=AJPERES&CONVERT_TO=url&CACHEID=ROOTWORKSPACE.Z18_K9I401S01H7F40QBNJU3SO1F56-b3b86275-f673-4a2b-b4ae-69a58f82c194-nAkqhqh
[10] https://ohiosamishcountry.com/oacbr
[11] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ohio_Amish_Country
[12] https://theamishmarket.net

Simple Living, Thriving Community: The Rise of Maple Grove’s Amish Settlement

A New Amish Frontier: Thriving Community Emerges in Northeastern Pennsylvania

In the rolling hills of northeastern Pennsylvania, a new Amish settlement is taking root, bringing with it a blend of traditional values and entrepreneurial spirit. The Maple Grove Amish community, established in early 2023, has quickly become a hub of activity, drawing both curious visitors and those seeking a simpler way of life.

Located in the picturesque Endless Mountains region, the settlement has grown to include over 50 families in just two years. The community’s rapid expansion has been fueled by a combination of natural growth and families relocating from more established Amish areas in Lancaster County and Ohio[1].

The new settlement has brought a economic boost to the region, with several Amish-owned businesses quickly becoming local favorites. The Maple Grove Bakery, run by the Miller family, has become renowned for its fresh-baked goods and homemade ice cream[2].

Township supervisor Mark Thompson acknowledges the adjustments: “It’s been a learning process for everyone, but the Amish have been great partners in finding solutions. Their presence has added a unique character to our community.”

The Rise of Maple Grove's Amish Settlement

The emergence of the Maple Grove Amish settlement represents a new chapter in the long history of Amish communities in Pennsylvania. As these families put down roots in the Endless Mountains, they bring with them a rich cultural heritage and a commitment to faith, family, and community that resonates with many in today’s fast-paced world.

Citations:
[1] https://amishamerica.com/pennsylvania-amish/
[2] https://www.discoverlancaster.com/blog/amish-owned-businesses/
[3] https://ideaexchange.uakron.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1019&context=amishstudies
[4] https://www.bedlamfarm.com/2021/06/14/the-amish-and-their-long-struggle-with-the-modern-world/
[5] https://www.visitsmicksburg.com/top-amish-towns-to-visit-in-pennsylvania/
[6] https://www.discoverlancaster.com/blog/shopping-in-amish-country-pa/
[7] https://www.businessinsider.com/man-left-traditional-amish-community-explore-modern-world-cars-planes-2024-8
[8] https://marine.copernicus.eu/marine-paragraph/iframe-render/https:%7C%7Cxn--80aaagbsbcsvewu1agfr.xn--p1ai%7Ccqmdpzwbazfe85m
[9] https://amishamerica.com/amish-business-directory/

Recent Posts

Taste of Simplicity: McArthur’s Amish Market Revolutionizes Local Food Scene

Citations:

Like this:

Peach Bottom’s New Market Brings Tradition to Your Table

Citations:

Like this:

New Amish Market Brings Old-World Charm to York, PA

Citations:

Like this:

From Buggies to Businesses: Inside Indiana’s Newest Amish Community

Citations:

Like this:

New Amish Community Flourishes in Washington County, Ohio

Like this:

Simple Living, Thriving Community: The Rise of Maple Grove’s Amish Settlement

Like this:

Recent Posts

Citations:

Share this:

Like this:

Citations:

Share this:

Like this:

Citations:

Share this:

Like this:

Citations:

Share this:

Like this:

Share this:

Like this:

Share this:

Like this: