By Elizabeth Montgomery, Food Editor
Amidst the cobblestone streets, colonial architecture, and maritime bustle of Maryland’s capital, a surprisingly cozy new culinary destination has dropped anchor. Annapolis has long been celebrated for its blue crabs and waterfront dining, but this season, the local food scene is embracing the hearty, scratch-made traditions of Pennsylvania Dutch cooking. Anchor & Hearth Amish Bakery & Eatery has officially opened its doors, offering a serene, comforting retreat just a short walk from the bustling City Dock.
A Backstory Rooted in Family and Market Days
The story of Anchor & Hearth begins a few hours north in the rolling farmland of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. For the past decade, the Lapp family made the weekly trek down to Maryland, setting up a modest but wildly popular baked goods stand at local weekend farmer’s markets. Their massive cinnamon rolls and handmade pretzels consistently sold out within hours, leaving Annapolitans always wanting more.
Recognizing the deep local appreciation for authentic, unhurried food, the family decided to take a leap. They acquired and lovingly restored a historic brick building in the Annapolis Arts District, outfitting it with heavy oak communal tables and a massive, open-concept bakery counter. The result is Anchor & Hearth—a full-time, brick-and-mortar restaurant that beautifully bridges the gap between Lancaster County tradition and Chesapeake Bay charm.
Cultivating Comfort and Community
What truly sets Anchor & Hearth apart in Annapolis is the sheer dedication to the slow craft of cooking. The kitchen bypasses modern shortcuts entirely; doughs are kneaded by hand before dawn, broths are simmered overnight, and pies are baked fresh daily. The dining room feels like a welcoming extension of the Lapp family’s own farmhouse, filled with the aroma of rising yeast, roasted meats, and warm spices.
Our Favorite Finds at Anchor & Hearth
Whether you are stopping in for a quick morning pastry before hitting the water or sitting down for a belly-warming supper, the menu is packed with authentic comfort food with a few local twists. Here are the standout favorites you absolutely cannot miss:
- The Chesapeake Crab Pretzel Roll: A brilliant nod to their new Maryland home, this appetizer features creamy, Old Bay-seasoned lump blue crab dip baked directly into the center of a hand-rolled, buttery Amish soft pretzel.
- Glazed Sourdough Sticky Buns: The undisputed stars of the bakery case. These massive, cast-iron-baked sticky buns are smothered in a rich, dark caramel glaze and loaded with toasted pecans.
- Slow-Simmered Pot Roast: The ultimate Sunday-style dinner, served any day of the week. Generous slabs of tender, slow-cooked beef are served over a bed of handmade, browned-butter egg noodles alongside a helping of sweet corn pudding.
- Brown Butter Whoopie Pies: You cannot leave without trying this quintessential Pennsylvania Dutch dessert. The bakery elevates the classic with a perfectly balanced, rich brown butter cream filling sandwiched between two incredibly moist chocolate cakes.

A Worthwhile Meal
Visiting Anchor & Hearth is more than just checking out a new restaurant; it is a grounding experience. In a town that is always on the go, this eatery is an invitation to slow down, pass the bread basket, and savor a home-cooked meal rooted in generations of tradition. Just remember to arrive early if you have your heart set on those sticky buns—they rarely make it to lunch!





