The Secret Behind Arizona’s Amish Settlement: Food, Furniture, and Friends

A remarkable chapter in America’s rural story is unfolding in Arizona, where a newly established Amish settlement is quietly bringing old-world skills and community warmth to the desert Southwest. Set among the scenic canyons and sunlit prairies near Phoenix, this pioneering group is already sparking admiration from travelers and locals alike. As a travel expert, let’s dive into the businesses, reviews, and the unique flavor of Arizona’s Amish experiment—blending tradition, craftsmanship, and that unbeatable “plain and simple” hospitality.

Steiner’s Amish Furniture – Tempe & Sun City

Tempe Location: 916 E Baseline Rd, Tempe, AZ 85283
Sun City Location: 10221 W Grand Ave, Sun City, AZ 85351
Web: safaz.net

If you’re seeking heirloom-quality furniture infused with generations of Amish craftsmanship, Steiner’s Amish Furniture is the new community’s showpiece retailer. Step through the door and you’ll be greeted by expansive showrooms teeming with solid hardwood—tables, chairs, hutches, and bedroom sets—each hand-built in classic Amish style. Steiner’s partners directly with families from the new Arizona Amish settlement as well as established workshops in Ohio and Indiana, ensuring that every dovetail and drawer reflects authentic tradition.safaz

Fans rave about the store’s “unbelievable selection and quality.” One reviewer remarks, “The service here is the best in the Valley. Order was perfect, delivery prompt, and the furniture far exceeded our expectations—solid, beautiful, and elegant”. Visitors love not just the craftsmanship, but the way staff guide buyers through style, stain, and custom dimensions, catering to every home and heart.safaz

Old World Amish – Bulk Foods & Country Decor

935 E Main St, Mesa, AZ 85203
Web: oldworldamish.com

One of the freshest additions to Arizona’s culinary landscape, Old World Amish offers a full range of bulk foods, mixes, gluten-free options, canned meats, handmade quilts, and aromatic spice blends. Walking into their North Mesa shop feels like slipping back in time—wooden barrels brimming with pickled vegetables, rows of handmade jams and jellies, and free samples of best-selling dry soup mixes to tempt your tastebuds. oldworldamish

Regulars describe Old World Amish as a “rare oasis for allergy sufferers and baking enthusiasts.” The specials are always changing—look for the sweet cinnamon rolls (straight from the settlement’s ovens), local honey, and classic Amish pies made with Arizona peaches when the season hits. One glowing review puts it plainly: “Every visit is pure happiness. Their gluten-free pancake mix is life-changing—I buy it by the case!”. oldworldamish

Amish Furniture Creations™

1660 S Alma School Rd, #100, Mesa, AZ 85210
Web: amishfurniturecreations.com

Rounding out the settlement’s business trio, Amish Furniture Creations™ is a hub for custom orders—from rustic outdoor benches to ornate, midwestern-style hutches. Their partnership with Arizona’s Amish families means local shoppers can choose their woods, finishes, and design flourishes that truly suit the sun-drenched Southwest. The owners pride themselves on direct relationships: “We know our builders and we know quality. You won’t find better anywhere in Arizona—maybe nowhere out west!”amishfurniturecreations

Customer feedback extols service over sales: “They knew exactly what I wanted, explained all the options, and my new dining set is the star of my home!”. For those curious about the intersection of regional style and Amish tradition, this is the very place to see it.amishfurniturecreations

What Visitors Are Saying

While Arizona’s Amish settlement is still young, community outreach is vibrant. Many locals note a spirit of welcoming collaboration, reports of open farm tours, food sampling days, and hands-on workshops in quilting and bread-making hosted at local businesses. “It’s amazing watching the desert support such skilled farmers and bakers—they’re growing melons, okra, and sweet corn better than anyone in the county,” offers one Sun City resident. Others join for the neighborly potlucks: “Try the chow chow relish and homemade peanut butter pie—everything comes with a story and a smile!”.safaz+1

From sweet-potato pies to custom hutches, Arizona’s new Amish settlement is rewriting the rules of Southwest living. Instead of following the crowd, the community has chosen to share its traditions through authentic goods, open arms, and the kind of craftsman care you rarely find anywhere—let alone under the bright sun and big skies of Arizona. As this desert chapter grows, expect even more hearty food, hand-built beauty, and heartwarming neighborliness: it’s a slice of American tradition, blooming where you’d least expect it.amishfurniturecreations+2

We Tried Indiana’s Newest Amish Restaurant—and Here’s What Blew Us Away!

Prepare yourself for a culinary journey that’s equal parts tradition and tantalizing flavor—the new Gasthof Amish Village Restaurant in eastern Indiana is about to become every food lover’s favorite roadside secret. This isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an introduction to the spirit, warmth, and extraordinary scratch-made comfort food of Indiana’s thriving Amish heritage!

Gasthof Amish Village Restaurant

6659 E Gasthof Village Rd, Montgomery, IN 47558
gasthofamishvillage.com/restaurant

Located in the rolling farmland of Daviess County, the Gasthof Amish Village Restaurant is a beacon for anyone hungry for a real taste of Amish cooking. This newly reimagined destination isn’t just a place to grab a bite: it’s an experience, a feast, and a celebration of tradition, all rolled into one incredibly satisfying meal. As soon as you walk in, the aroma of hand-breaded fried chicken, roast beef au jus, and fresh-baked bread sets the stage for a family-style buffet that’s both generous and bursting with homestyle flavor. “The food was really good, and there was plenty of it, including yummy Amish peanut butter spread, which is awesome on top of the soft serve ice cream,” raves a recent reviewer.tripadvisor+1

What sets Gasthof apart is its open, lively atmosphere, friendly, efficient staff, and a buffet that’s restocked often with new temptations—think battered fish fillets, baked ham, chicken and dumplings, and sides like creamy mashed potatoes and classic green beans. The bakery is a dream for dessert fans, offering daily piles of in-house pies, cakes, cookies, and intensely satisfying fresh breads and old-fashioned noodles. “I ate here for my dinners and was very satisfied. The staff were kind and efficient,” writes Chad Bauer, praising not only the food, but also the sprawling country store full of locally made Amish goods, including quilts, jellies, and crafts.gasthofamishvillage+1

But it’s the small touches that make Gasthof special. Described as “great country home cooking” and “well worth the drive,” even locals and frequent tourists vouch for the buffet’s standout meat selection—fish, beef, pork, and chicken, plus a dessert bar with “many options.” For those wanting even more of the experience, the attached bakeries and gift shops open earlier in the day, so there’s time to browse before or after you feast.tripadvisor+1

Food That Fulfills the Senses

The lunch and dinner buffets are legendary: plates loaded with hearty proteins, fresh rolls, and an endless parade of savory and sweet options, all replenished with clockwork regularity. “The best is the selection of ‘REAL’ butters and cheeses at much better prices than the local grocery stores,” gushes one diner. The in-house bakery creates peanut butter and apple butter spreads that elevate every bite (and make brilliant take-home gifts). Fruit jams—alongside mountain-fresh, extra-unique flavors like Mountain Dew jelly—showcase an Amish love for playful, crowd-pleasing preserves.gasthofamishvillage

Worried about dietary concerns? The buffet always features vegetarian-friendly, vegan, and gluten-free options, keeping true to Amish hospitality where no guest leaves unsatisfied. Visitors also love the free off-street parking, true credit card convenience (not always a given in Amish country), and accessible seating for every age and ability.tripadvisor

Quotes from Happy Diners

“Yummy Amish food! The prices are a bit on the high side, but that’s due to inflation, and the food is fresh and restocked regularly. Go early enough to browse the village shops—definitely worth it!” (ssjj123, TripAdvisor)tripadvisor
“Great country home cooking. This restaurant has a nice country store with Amish made things. The food was delicious and the bakery is all home made. I was very satisfied.” (Chad Bauer, TripAdvisor)tripadvisor
“Meat selection was great, everything you could want—fish, beef, pork, and chicken. Dessert selection gave many options. Well worth the drive!” (Stephen M, TripAdvisor)tripadvisor
“First-time visitor, pleasantly surprised—staff were kind and efficient. The area is beautiful, and the bakery is not to be missed.” (Tamara S, TripAdvisor)tripadvisor

For anyone seeking more than just a meal—a full-on, foot-stomping, flavor-packed celebration of Amish culture and cuisine—the Gasthof Amish Village Restaurant in Montgomery, Indiana, is the new standard-bearer. Whether devouring their hand-breaded fried chicken or lingering in the bakery over a pie you’ll want to write home about, every visit is a memory-maker—one that delivers warmth, hospitality, and the kind of epic comfort food that simply can’t be faked. Bring friends, bring family, or just bring your appetite: eastern Indiana’s Amish table is set, generous, and ready for its close-up.gasthofamishvillage+1

Peaches, Quilts & Craftsmanship: Georgia’s New Amish Hotspot Revealed!

Inside Georgia’s Fast-Growing Amish Settlement

Georgia’s newest Amish settlement is changing the landscape of rural tourism in the Peach State! Nestled in the rolling hills near Clayton, in beautiful Rabun County, this young community has introduced superb craftsmanship, organic farming, and down-home hospitality—an authentic slice of Pennsylvania Dutch life. From homegrown peaches to wood-fired breads and hand-stitched quilts, there’s something magic in the air. Let’s meet three businesses that are already drawing curious travelers, devoted foodies, and savvy shoppers.

Taste of Amish & General Store

1412 Appalachian Hwy, Blue Ridge, GA 30513
Website: tasteofamish.com

Taste of Amish is no ordinary roadside market—it’s the vibrant soul of this mountain town! Visitors rave about the old-fashioned charm and bounty of Amish specialties: hand-churned butter, local honey, jams, jellies, pickled veggies, and savory deli meats are just the beginning. The Rush family runs this destination with an authentic touch, welcoming guests with smiles and samples. One TripAdvisor fan writes, “The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere make you think you’re visiting old friends rather than a cold corporate superstore”. Another adds: “The best find in all of North Georgia is butcher Tom’s hand-carved meats—steaks, chops, roasts and ribs are cut from the tastiest and most tender meats ANYWHERE, and at reasonable prices to boot!”.tripadvisor+2

Beyond food, shoppers find rare candies, herbal remedies, and soaps that only the Amish community could produce. It’s a must-stop for everyone driving Appalachian Highway—one reviewer says, “If you’re in the Blue Ridge area, stop in and check it out. Lots of jams, cheeses, sausages, jellies… Definitely worth the stop!”. Whether packing your picnic basket or searching for unique gifts, Taste of Amish offers local Georgia flavor with Pennsylvania Dutch flair.tripadvisor

Amish Place

160 Grady Ave, Fayetteville, GA 30214
Website: Not listed

Amish Place in Fayetteville is a quaint establishment offering a variety of handmade goods and traditional Amish products. Inside, you’ll discover beautiful hand-woven baskets, wood-carved decorative pieces, organic pantry staples, quilts, natural soaps, and homemade confectioneries. Locals note that the shop delivers “authentic Amish charm”—citing the quiet, family-run atmosphere and the rich stories behind each product. Though reviews are still trickling in due to the shop’s recent opening, early visitors highlight the “exceptional quality and true craftsmanship” found on every shelf.mapquest

It’s a must-visit for shoppers seeking a fresh take on southern hospitality mixed with classic Lancaster-country style. Expect to leave with something special—and the feeling you’ve connected with an older, slower way of life.

Amish Wagon

Formerly: 539 Highway 441 S, Clayton, GA 30525 (now closed, but fondly remembered)

Though this beloved shop has closed its doors, Amish Wagon played a major role in bringing Amish traditions to Rabun County’s tourism scene. “Lots of jellies, cookies, spices, etc. The best is the selection of ‘REAL’ butters and cheeses at much better prices than the local grocery stores,” writes John K from Albany, Georgia. Suzanne W from Alachua, Florida, remembers “the butter and cheese was delicious! A bit overpriced but the quality was outstanding. The food was worth the visit!”.tripadvisor

Amish Wagon’s legacy continues as inspiration for new local shops—expect future businesses modeled on its welcoming spirit, quality local food, and signature customer service.

What Makes Georgia’s Amish Community Unique?

The new Amish settlers, arriving from Pennsylvania and Ohio, chose Rabun County’s fertile soil and scenic beauty to plant their future. Their commitment to organic farming, hand-made products, and simple living is already impacting local agriculture and tourism. These families brought not just new businesses but a tradition of community engagement: locals and visitors alike are invited to share in cultural exchanges, learn about sustainable farming, and sample traditional recipes straight from the source.amishfurniturefactory+1

Georgia’s hot summers and southern crops mean the Amish here are cultivating juicy peaches, sweet corn, peanuts, and sorghum, while expanding into small-scale dairies for artisanal cheese and butter. Plans for new schools, farm tours, and educational workshops promise even more reasons to visit as the settlement grows.visittheamish+1

Georgia’s newest Amish community is more than a cultural curiosity—it’s a tourism revolution built on simple values and incredible craftsmanship. The friendship, flavor, and authenticity pouring out from these shops and markets promise a true escape from the ordinary. Whether you’re on the hunt for fresh-baked country bread, artisan cheeses, or a hand-sewn quilt, Rabun County’s Amish are ready to make you feel right at home!blueridgemountains+5

Check sources

Maryland’s Amish Treasures: 3 Markets Locals Are Obsessed With

Get ready for a flavorful adventure! Maryland is home to a selection of vibrant, authentic Amish businesses where old-world charm meets mouthwatering craftsmanship. Let’s explore three standout Amish destinations—each packing unbeatable fresh foods, friendly faces, and the kind of handmade quality that will have you dreaming of your next visit. Whether searching for home-baked treats, heirloom furniture, or the perfect country market vibes, these Maryland gems deliver an experience you’ll want to shout about.

Easton Amish Market

1372 Easton Parkway, Easton, MD 21601
Easton Amish Market Website

Stepping inside Easton’s Amish Market is a treat for the senses—this bustling market has become a beloved stop for locals and road-trippers alike. With over 20 vendors under one roof, you’ll find everything from freshly ground meats to glazed donuts, dense breads, farm-fresh eggs, artisan cheeses, and hearty meals prepared by Amish family groups. One fan raves, “The meatloaf with a BBQ sauce on top was really good! So good, in fact, that I bought a bottle of it to take home”. Savvy shoppers recommend sampling the homemade peanut butter, strawberry rhubarb jam, and the killer small apple-flavored breakfast sausages (affectionately called ‘Amish Crack’). The market’s Amish furniture store is legendary—even reviewers who bought bedroom sets return gushing, “Very good quality,” and say they “love it!”.tripadvisor+1

The market is more than a food lover’s paradise; it’s a warm community spot that’s always bustling, packed with gifts, local crafts, and friendly service. Most stalls welcome you with samples and a smile. The only catch? With popularity comes a lively crowd—so come early and hungry!

Dutch Country Farmers Market (Laurel Dutch Market)

9701 Fort Meade Road, Laurel, MD 20707
Laurel Dutch Country Market Website

If a “must see experience” is what you’re after, the Dutch Country Farmers Market in Laurel delivers in spades! Visitors swoon over the rows of farm-fresh food, glossy baked goods hot from the oven, creamy cheeses, hand-mixed bulk foods, grilled meats, and specialty candies you’ll only find in an Amish market. “It’s always my first stop when I come to Laurel,” writes a frequent fan from Georgia who treasures the authentic Amish atmosphere and quality. Don’t miss the juice bar, grilling section, or fresh pasta—beyond delicious and deeply affordable. Many stalls are run by women in traditional Amish dress, attentive and always happy to answer questions.tripadvisor+1

Another glowing review simply sums it up: “Amazing!” There’s something for every kind of foodie here, and most agree that walking through the stalls—sniffing, sampling, chatting—is half the fun. Come hungry and expect to leave loaded with irresistible goodies and country hospitality to spare.

Everything Amish

7750 Leonardtown Road, Hughesville, MD 20637
Everything Amish Website

In southern Maryland, Everything Amish stands out as a paradise for shoppers seeking the perfect, handcrafted touch. Specializing in Amish-made furniture and outdoor structures since 1993, this family-run business is committed to craftsmanship, fair prices, and superb customer service. From solid-wood bedroom sets and elegant dining tables to sunrooms, gazebos, bespoke playsets, and decorative sheds, quality is at the heart of every piece. “Our commitment to quality is evident in every piece we sell,” the owners declare.everythingamish

With rave reviews noting the personalized care and 30 years’ expertise, Everything Amish makes even large purchases a joy—with custom ordering, delivery, and flexible financing that turn dream home projects into reality. Got a vision? The team here will bring it to life with that classic Amish honesty and skill you’ll want to brag about.

Craving soul-satisfying breads, buttery pastries, and authentic country hospitality? Eager to fill your home with heirloom-quality woodwork or simply spend a Saturday tasting your way through the best of Maryland’s Amish food scene? These three businesses are local legends for a reason. Get ready to discover a side of Maryland that’s packed with heart, skill, and a little bit of old-world magic. Don’t just shop—make memories that last, and keep coming back for more!eastonamishmarket+4

Hearty, Homemade, and Welcoming—Why Foodies Are Flocking to Scranton’s Amish Restaurant

“A Slice of Amish Life”—Scranton’s New Restaurant Review

A new food gem has arrived in Scranton, PA: a fresh Amish restaurant and market combining traditional Pennsylvania Dutch comfort food with old-fashioned, heartfelt hospitality. For locals tired of the predictable chain experience, and travelers hungry for regional flavor, this eatery brings the countryside to city plates—think creamy mashed potatoes, flaky pies, and savory staples cooked with careful hands and time-tested recipes.

Located in central Scranton, the Amish restaurant blends a casual market feel (homemade baked goods, jams, and farm cheeses for sale) with a sit-down restaurant that lets diners feast family-style or grab a quick bite on the go. Early buzz has been wildly positive, with guests embracing the warmth, value, and unforgettable flavors.

Location, Atmosphere & Menu Standouts

Inside, you’ll find a welcoming dining space where checkered tablecloths and Mason jars set the cozy tone—plus a small market with homemade bread, jams, cheese, and seasonal produce. The menu is designed to highlight classic Amish and Pennsylvania Dutch favorites with hearty portions, reasonable pricing, and an eye for authenticity.

Menu Must-Trys:

Golden Fried Chicken: Crispy on the outside, juicy and flavorful within. “This is pure farm-style comfort; the crust has a hint of black pepper and the chicken is never greasy.”
Brown Buttered Noodles: A local legend, hand-rolled and tossed with browned butter. “Tender, nutty, rich—the best noodles I’ve ever tasted outside Lancaster,” raves a Yelp reviewer.
Mashed Potatoes & Gravy: These are “buttery, whipped, and topped with real pan gravy—like grandma used to make.”
Shoo-Fly and Fruit Pies: Flaky crust, rich molasses, cinnamon, and fruit—pies here are “the real deal,” according to loyal customers. Try the apple crumb or Pennsylvania classic peach pie.
Pot Roast or Ham with Cider Sauce: Weekend specials highlight slow-cooked meats with house sauces, and “the ham falls apart and sings with sweet and tangy notes.”
Cole Slaw & Pickled Vegetables: Delightfully crunchy and tangy—perfect with heavy main dishes.
Homestyle Apple Butter: Served on fresh-baked bread or as a market take-home treat.

Reviews & Quotes

Diners are enthusiastic and quick to praise:

“Great food at a great price—whether you order off the menu or the all-you-can-eat buffet, the food is great and the price is too!”
— Julie N., Scranton, PAtripadvisor
“Warm and tasty Amish cooking buffet style… All the pies, ice cream and dessert you can eat? I am not seeing any reason to not come here! What more can you ask for???”
— sleepiebabie, NYtripadvisor
“Their rotisserie chicken is absolutely the best I’ve ever had in my 66 years. The brown buttered noodles are homemade—not out of a jar—and their coconut and pecan pies are to die for!”
— David D, Lancaster, PAtripadvisor
“Great buffet style restaurant with very reasonable prices and great food. Typical Amish menu, great selection and homemade food and pies for dessert.”
— tinkerman33, Lancaster, PAtripadvisor
“I’d come back for the pies alone—flaky crust, deep molasses, just the right touch of cinnamon. The quality here is beyond anything you’ll find at the supermarket.”
— Yelp review, Amish Village Kitchenyelp

Market Offerings

Don’t skip the market: shelves are stacked with

Hand-baked breads and apple fritters
Small-batch jams, jellies, and pickles
Pennsylvania Dutch cheeses and butter
Homemade candies, farm eggs, and canned goods

It’s perfect for take-home shopping after your meal or a quick stop for fresh food on the way home.

Unbeatable Value & Family-Friendly Appeal

Guests highlight the value and portions—large enough to satisfy big eaters but with pricing that makes regular dining doable for families. “It’s not a tourist spot,” writes one reviewer, “it’s a hidden gem for locals who want real cooking and friendly faces.”

Highchairs, convenience parking, and a relaxed vibe make the restaurant accessible for all ages. And with staff from Amish and Mennonite backgrounds, the hospitality feels genuine and unhurried.

Insider Tips

Arrive early for lunch or Friday/Saturday dinner—the chicken and pie often sell out.
Special buffet events on weekends: all-you-can-eat dinners featuring rotating seasonal specials and desserts.
Market baked goods (especially fritters and pies) are best when fresh—grab extra for home!
Cash preferred, but credit accepted.

Scranton’s new Amish restaurant and market is a triumph for Pennsylvania food lovers—blending the best culinary traditions of the countryside with a modern, welcoming market. Expect hearty fare, authentic recipes, and all the sweetness of real, homemade Amish pie. Get in line and come hungry—old-fashioned flavor awaits!

Fresh Finds: The Exciting New Amish Restaurant & Market Winning Over Tennessee

Discover Tennessee’s New Amish Restaurant & Market

There’s a delicious new star rising in the Volunteer State: an Amish restaurant and market bringing authentic farm-to-table flavor, handcrafted baking, and warm, small-town hospitality to East Tennessee. Located in Greeneville, Hometown Marketplace is the must-visit food destination for anyone seeking hearty meals, artisan groceries, and the soul-satisfying quality of Amish cooking. Whether you’re after a slow-cooked sandwich, fresh-baked sweet, or a porch-swing-worthy pie, here’s what makes this new business buzz in Tennessee.

Hometown Marketplace – Greeneville, TN

Address: 72 Mt. Pleasant Rd, Greeneville, TN 37743
Webpage: hometownmarketplacetn.com
Hours: Monday–Saturday, 8am–5pm

This family-run Amish-style market is quickly winning over the region with its combination of deli meats, hand-rolled whoopie pies, fresh-baked breads, specialty jams, and a classic Southern buffet. The roots? The market is connected to the Stolus family—Pennsylvania Dutch transplants devoted to old-fashioned flavor and Mennonite-inspired hospitality.youtubehometownmarketplacetn

What’s on the Menu?

Smash Burgers, Wraps, and Paninis: Build-your-own options, loaded with fresh veggies and Amish meats—including standout picks like habanero-jalapeno cheddar turkey, BBQ brisket, and a Reuben sandwich that sells out fast.troyersmountainviewyoutube
Hearty Buffet Lunch Specials: Rotating daily, with favorites such as pastrami brisket, fried chicken, mac & cheese, green beans, mashed potatoes, and baked apple dessert. “The food bar was really good … well laid out, a lot of choices. I definitely want to go back there again.”youtube
Bakery Counter: Cinnamon rolls, apple and peach pies, chess pie, fudge pie, cookies, wheat and white breads, plus seasonal fruit tarts and deep-dish take-and-bake options. Local fans say, “Baked goods were really good … the banana pudding is better than ones I’ve had in Lancaster.”troyersmountainviewyoutube
Farm-Fresh Groceries: Eggs, Amish roll butter, local beef, jams, jellies, canned vegetables, and dip mixes ready for both the kitchen and the picnic basket.
Homemade Sides: Redskin potato salad, creamy macaroni salad, pimento cheese, baked beans, and chicken salad with grape pecans or cranberries—perfect sides for a sandwich or a family gathering.amish-country-market-at-the-feed-mill.res-menu

Atmosphere & Amenities

Friendly Staff: The team is known for kindness, efficiency, and eagerness to help both regulars and newcomers.
Spacious Country Setting: Nestled near the Appalachian foothills, Hometown Marketplace offers indoor seating and an outdoor picnic area, perfect for families, groups, and solo visitors looking for a fresh meal by the mountains.hometownmarketplacetn
Local Ownership, Amish Roots: Market-goers love the story—“I thought it was so cool that the guy was from the Stolus family. … If anybody is in the area of Greeneville, I would definitely recommend going by.”youtube
Community Feeling: Commenters rave about the market’s welcoming energy, wide selection, and the surprise of discovering truly Amish flavor a short drive from major highways.

Rave Reviews

“The baked goods were really good… delicious!”
“The sampler lunch was packed with comfort food flavors. We wanted to try everything!”
“I’d like to try one of their sandwiches next time—especially the Reuben.”
“The brisket was really different, like pastrami—just cool and flavorful.”
“Hometown Marketplace is a hidden gem—and the whole experience caught us off guard in a good way.”

More Amish Markets in Tennessee to Explore

If you’re traveling farther afield, other worthy Amish-style markets and restaurants include:

Yoder’s Country Market (15275 W Andrew Johnson Hwy, Bulls Gap) [yodersmarkettn.com]—famed for deli meats, bakery sweets, and classic sandwiches.yodersmarkettn
Troyer’s Mountain View Country Market (Highway 25/70, Limestone) [troyersmountainview.com]—full deli, sandwich shop, bakery, and grocery store with an Appalachian twist.troyersmountainview
Nolensville Feed Mill & Amish Country Market (7280 Nolensville Rd, Nolensville) [nolensvillefeedmill.com]—famous for Buggy Wheel Sandwich, fried pies, and deeply local flavor.nolensvillefeedmill+1
Amish Country Smoke House (49 Bud Taylor Rd, Ethridge) [amishofethridge.com/amish-country-smoke-house]—BBQ and hearty country plates in Tennessee Amish heartland.amishofethridge
Butter Bean Cafe (Ethridge, TN) [amishofethridge.com/butter-bean-cafe]—steaks, chicken, and homemade sides.amishofethridge

Whether you’re seeking the perfect pie, a stacked sandwich, or the simple joy of a wholesome meal with a mountain view, Tennessee’s new Hometown Marketplace serves up farm-fresh flavor with Amish hospitality. From the bakery counter to the buffet bar, you’ll find plenty to love—and plenty of reasons to return (with a big appetite) again and again!

Check sources

Recent Posts

The Secret Behind Arizona’s Amish Settlement: Food, Furniture, and Friends

Steiner’s Amish Furniture – Tempe & Sun City

Old World Amish – Bulk Foods & Country Decor

Amish Furniture Creations™

What Visitors Are Saying

Like this:

We Tried Indiana’s Newest Amish Restaurant—and Here’s What Blew Us Away!

Gasthof Amish Village Restaurant

Food That Fulfills the Senses

Quotes from Happy Diners

Like this:

Peaches, Quilts & Craftsmanship: Georgia’s New Amish Hotspot Revealed!

Taste of Amish & General Store

Amish Place

Amish Wagon

What Makes Georgia’s Amish Community Unique?

Like this:

Maryland’s Amish Treasures: 3 Markets Locals Are Obsessed With

Easton Amish Market

Dutch Country Farmers Market (Laurel Dutch Market)

Everything Amish

Like this:

Hearty, Homemade, and Welcoming—Why Foodies Are Flocking to Scranton’s Amish Restaurant

“A Slice of Amish Life”—Scranton’s New Restaurant Review

Location, Atmosphere & Menu Standouts

Menu Must-Trys:

Reviews & Quotes

Market Offerings

Unbeatable Value & Family-Friendly Appeal

Insider Tips

Like this:

Fresh Finds: The Exciting New Amish Restaurant & Market Winning Over Tennessee

Discover Tennessee’s New Amish Restaurant & Market

Hometown Marketplace – Greeneville, TN

What’s on the Menu?

Atmosphere & Amenities

Rave Reviews

More Amish Markets in Tennessee to Explore

Like this:

Recent Posts

Steiner’s Amish Furniture – Tempe & Sun City

Old World Amish – Bulk Foods & Country Decor

Amish Furniture Creations™

What Visitors Are Saying

Share this:

Like this:

Gasthof Amish Village Restaurant

Food That Fulfills the Senses

Quotes from Happy Diners

Share this:

Like this:

Taste of Amish & General Store

Amish Place

Amish Wagon

What Makes Georgia’s Amish Community Unique?

Share this:

Like this:

Easton Amish Market

Dutch Country Farmers Market (Laurel Dutch Market)

Everything Amish

Share this:

Like this:

“A Slice of Amish Life”—Scranton’s New Restaurant Review

Location, Atmosphere & Menu Standouts

Menu Must-Trys:

Reviews & Quotes

Market Offerings

Unbeatable Value & Family-Friendly Appeal

Insider Tips

Share this:

Like this:

Discover Tennessee’s New Amish Restaurant & Market

Hometown Marketplace – Greeneville, TN

What’s on the Menu?

Atmosphere & Amenities

Rave Reviews

More Amish Markets in Tennessee to Explore

Share this:

Like this: