Recent Posts

Miller’s Homestead Deli In Dayton: A Taste of Amish Country Without the Drive

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Market

Stop Everything: Authentic Amish Fry Pies Have Landed on Wayne Avenue

There is a specific kind of hustle that defines downtown Dayton on a Tuesday afternoon—a mix of suit-clad professionals power-walking to meetings and creatives dodging traffic on scooters. But this week, that rhythm has been interrupted. If you walk past the newly renovated storefronts near the Fire Blocks District, you will see people slowing down. Then they stop. Then, inevitably, they sniff the air.

The smell is unmistakable: fresh yeast, smoked meat, and the sweet, caramelized scent of fruit filling bubbling over a crust. It is coming from Miller’s Homestead Deli, a new arrival that has brought the slow, deliberate pace of Amish Country right into the heart of the Gem City.

Simple Roots in a Concrete Jungle

Miller’s Homestead Deli , 114 E. Third St, Dayton, OH 45402

Hours: Monday–Saturday, 7:00 AM – 3:00 PM (Closed Sundays)

Stepping into Miller’s feels like teleporting. One minute you are surrounded by the brick and mortar of downtown Dayton; the next, you are enveloped in the scent of sawdust and sourdough. The interior is stark but welcoming, featuring hand-hewn wooden beams that the owner, Caleb Miller, installed himself.

“We didn’t want to just open a store; we wanted to bring a piece of our home,” Miller says, slicing a block of Baby Swiss cheese with practiced precision. “Dayton is busy. We want to be the place where you take a deep breath.”

The contrast is striking. Behind the counter, women in traditional bonnets work alongside young local hires, assembling sandwiches on bread that was baking while most of the city was still hitting the snooze button.

Miller’s Homestead Deli

The Menu: Farm-to-City Table

The menu at Miller’s Homestead Deli is a masterclass in “plain” cooking—a term the Amish use to describe food that relies on quality ingredients rather than fancy techniques. There are no foams, no emulsions, and definitely no small plates.

Here is what you need to order before they sell out:

1. The “Holmes County” Stacker

This is the sandwich that will put Miller’s on the map. It features a quarter-pound of authentic Trail Bologna—the kind with the perfect snap—layered with thick slices of Baby Swiss cheese. It’s served on a soft pretzel bun that is baked in-house every morning. The secret weapon? A generous slathering of their house-made sweet-hot mustard, which provides a tangy kick that cuts right through the richness of the meat.

2. The Chicken & Noodle “Sundae”

Technically a side dish, but large enough to be a meal, this is pure comfort in a bowl. It starts with a scoop of buttery mashed potatoes (yes, they use real cream), topped with a ladle of thick, yellow chicken broth and hand-rolled egg noodles. It is salty, savory, and tastes exactly like a sick day at grandma’s house.

3. The Roast Beef & Cheddar “Haystack”

Inspired by the traditional Amish “haystack” community meals, this open-faced sandwich starts with a slice of sourdough. It’s piled high with roast beef that has been slow-cooked for 14 hours, then smothered in a white cheddar sauce and topped with crispy fried onions. It requires a knife, a fork, and possibly a nap afterwards.

4. Fry Pies

If you leave without a fry pie, you have made a mistake. These crescent-shaped hand pies are filled with fruit—cherry, apple, peach, or elderberry—and then deep-fried until the crust is flaky and golden. While still hot, they are dipped in a thin vanilla glaze that crackles when you bite into it. The cherry version, tart and sweet, is already a local favorite.

5. Amish Peanut Butter Spread

Miller’s serves this as a side with their soup combos, but patrons are already begging to buy it by the pint. It’s a whipped mixture of marshmallow crème, peanut butter, and a secret syrup blend. It defies physics—lighter than air but rich enough to coat your tongue in sugary bliss.

Fry Pies Millers-Homestead-Deli-In-Dayton

The Buzz on the Street

Despite a quiet “soft opening” with zero advertising, word of mouth has turned Miller’s into an immediate hotspot. We caught up with a few diners who managed to snag a table during the lunch rush.

“I grew up going to Amish Country with my parents every fall. One bite of this Trail Bologna sandwich and I was six years old again. It’s the real deal. And the prices? You can’t get a fast-food meal for this cheap anymore.”

— Rebecca T., Downtown resident

“I don’t know what they put in the noodles, and I don’t care. I would bathe in that broth. I came in for a coffee and left with three quarts of chicken and noodles to take home to my family.”

— James “Big Jim” K., Construction Foreman

“The fry pie. Just… the fry pie. I tried the elderberry on a whim, and I think my life has changed. I’m texting my coworkers right now to tell them we’re doing a group order tomorrow.”

— Sarah L., Graphic Designer

A Welcome Addition

Miller’s Homestead Deli fills a void in the Dayton food scene that we didn’t realize was empty. In a world of fusion cuisine and kale salads, there is something profoundly grounding about a place that serves meat, cheese, and bread without apology.

The service is efficient but never rushed. When you order, the staff looks you in the eye. When they ask how you are, they seem to actually wait for the answer.

“We feed people,” Miller says simply, wiping down the counter as the afternoon crowd thins out. “That’s what we do. If you leave here hungry, that’s your fault.”

Dayton, consider this your warning: The portions are huge, the butter is real, and the fry pies go fast. Welcome to the neighborhood, Miller’s. We’re glad you’re here.

Miller’s Homestead Deli

Finally! Authentic Amish Cooking Has Arrived in Cadillac (And It’s Incredible)

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Restaurants

There is a particular kind of silence that falls over a table when the food is genuinely, soul-satisfyingly good. It’s not the silence of awkwardness, but the quiet of busy forks and contented sighs. That is exactly the sound—or lack thereof—you will encounter at Cadillac’s newest culinary treasure, Yoder’s Hearthside Table.

Located just off the beaten path, Yoder’s has quietly opened its doors and is already making a thunderous noise in the Northern Michigan food scene. If you have been craving the kind of meal that sticks to your ribs and warms you from the inside out, your search is officially over.

A Warm Welcome

Yoder’s Hearthside Table Address: 4810 East M-115, Cadillac, MI 49601

Hours: Monday–Saturday, 7:00 AM – 8:00 PM (Closed Sundays)

Pulling into the gravel lot off M-115, the first thing you notice is the smell. It’s a sweet, yeasty aroma of baking bread mixed with the savory, heavy scent of roasting meats. The building itself is unassuming—a simple, white-sided structure with a wide porch lined with wooden rocking chairs. It looks less like a restaurant and more like a neighbor’s farmhouse where the door is always unlocked.

Inside, the décor is refreshingly simple. There are no televisions, no neon signs, and no pretension. Just sturdy oak tables, hand-stitched quilts hanging on the walls, and the bustle of servers in traditional plain dress moving efficiently through the dining room with massive trays of food.

The Menu: A Masterclass in Comfort

The menu at Yoder’s isn’t trying to reinvent the wheel; it’s just making the wheel perfectly, rolling it in butter, and serving it with a side of gravy.

“We don’t use freezers and we don’t use microwaves,” says Sarah Yoder, the matriarch and head of the kitchen, who stopped by our table to check on the coffee. “If the mashed potatoes run out, we peel more potatoes. That’s just how it’s done.”

Here are the standout items that are already defining the Yoder’s experience:

1. The Broasted Chicken This is the star of the show. If you aren’t familiar with broasting, it is a technique that combines pressure cooking and deep frying. The result is chicken with a skin so impossibly crisp it shatters when you bite into it, while the meat inside remains juicy enough to run down your chin. It is seasoned simply—salt, pepper, and a secret blend of herbs—but the execution is flawless.

2. The “Barn-Raiser” Roast Beef Slow-roasted for twelve hours, this beef is fork-tender. It falls apart if you look at it too sternly. It’s served swimming in a dark, rich brown gravy that tastes like it started as a bone broth three days ago.

3. Real Mashed Potatoes & Buttered Noodles In Amish cooking, starch is a food group, and Yoder’s respects this. The mashed potatoes are lumpy in the best way possible, proving their origin from actual tubers. But the buttered noodles are the sleeper hit—thick, hand-rolled egg noodles drenched in browned butter and topped with a dusting of parsley.

4. The Bread Basket Every table starts with a basket of dinner rolls that are roughly the size of softballs. They come with two accompaniments: whipped butter and the traditional Amish “peanut butter spread”—a sweet, marshmallow-fluff-whipped concoction that essentially turns your dinner roll into a dessert.

5. Shoofly Pie You cannot leave without a slice. The molasses-based filling is dense and sweet, topped with a crumbly brown sugar crust that cuts the richness perfectly. If molasses isn’t your speed, the Dutch Apple Crumb Pie is a close second, piled high with apples that still have a bit of crunch.

What The Locals Are Saying

The restaurant has only been open a few weeks, but the buzz in Cadillac is palpable. We caught up with a few diners who were polishing off their plates.

“I drove past this place twice before deciding to stop, and I’m kicking myself for waiting. I had the meatloaf, and it tasted exactly like my grandmother’s. Maybe better. Don’t tell her.” > — Mark D., Cadillac resident

“The portions are absolutely out of control. My husband ordered the ‘Plowman’s Platter’ and we barely made a dent in it. We have enough leftovers for three days. And the price? Unbeatable for this quality.” > — Jennifer L., visiting from Traverse City

“It’s the peanut butter spread. I would buy it by the jar if they let me. I asked, and they said ‘maybe soon.’ I’ll be the first in line.” > — Greg T., Tustin resident

The Verdict

Cadillac has plenty of great places to eat, but Yoder’s Hearthside Table fills a specific niche that we didn’t know we were missing. It’s a place that forces you to slow down. The service is friendly but unhurried. The food is heavy but made with care. It is a reminder that sometimes, the best meals aren’t about complex emulsions or rare ingredients; they are about fresh chicken, good flour, and a whole lot of butter.

Be prepared to wait if you go on a Friday night. The secret is out, and the line often spills out onto the porch. But as you sit in one of those rockers, smelling the fried chicken wafting through the screen door, you’ll realize that some things are definitely worth the wait.

Yoder’s Hearthside Table

Oodles Of Noodles And Tons Of Honey: Inside Dutch Country Market In Middlebury, Indiana

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Market,Indiana

Dutch Country Market in Middlebury, Indiana, is one of Amish Country’s most charming small markets, famous for its hand‑rolled noodles, “tons of honey,” and shelves that feel like a well‑stocked grandma’s pantry. Set along the Quilt Garden Trail just east of town, it’s a favorite stop for tour guides, road‑trippers, and locals who come back again and again for noodles, jams, and a warm hello from the Lehman family.tripadvisor+3​

Name, Address, And Setting

Dutch Country Market is located at 11351 County Road 16, Middlebury, IN 46540 (often listed simply as “CR 16” along the Quilt Garden Trail between Shipshewana and Middlebury). Visitors’ bureaus describe it as a place where “local made is not a trend,” noting that Katie’s homemade noodles and peanut butter spread are “renowned in Amish Country.”visitelkhartcounty+2​

Outside, the market is a modest Amish‑country storefront, but it sits beside one of the area’s quilt gardens—a living flower pattern that’s part of Elkhart County’s Quilt Garden Trail. One reviewer said they stopped while following the trail, enjoyed an elevated viewing platform for the quilt garden, and then stepped inside “a good place to get local foods” run by an “interesting” Amish gentleman.tripadvisor+1​

Oodles Of Noodles, Tons Of Honey

Dutch Country Market is best known for two things: Katie’s Homemade Noodles and Dutch Country Honey, both made right on site. Promotional write‑ups invite visitors to “prepare to be amazed” as they watch Katie’s daughters rolling out dough and cutting noodles, while an observation window lets guests see bees working in a hive that Norman Lehman has tended for more than 30 years.visitshipshewana+1​

Highlights include:

Grandma’s Pantry: Jams, Fudge, And More

  • Katie’s Homemade Noodles
    The noodles are “made from scratch using no preservatives,” and guests can watch them being rolled and cut during the day. One Tripadvisor reviewer called the shop a “small Amish market with a lot to offer,” noting that “the girls were making noodles while we were there which was very interesting to watch,” and praising the reasonable prices and selection of noodles, jams, cookies, baking items, honey, spices, and seasonings.visitelkhartcounty+2​
  • Dutch Country Honey & Spun Honey
    Norman’s hives supply pure Indiana honey “from our own beehives as well as beekeeper friends throughout the state,” including 11 flavors of gourmet spun honey produced on site. Visitors can watch the bees through the interior hive window and often chat with Norm if he’s there; the market notes that he “happily answers questions concerning bees, beekeeping and honey.”visitshipshewana+1​
  • Peanut Butter–n–Honey Spread
    The shop’s peanut butter‑and‑honey spread is highlighted as a customer favorite, described alongside spun honey as something guests should definitely try.visitshipshewana​

Beyond noodles and honey, Dutch Country Market “specializes in a veritable grandma’s pantry of jams, apple butter, salsas, pickles, peaches and beets.” Shelves are stacked with preserves and canned goods ideal for stocking a home pantry or creating gift baskets.mapquest+1​

Additional favorites include:

  • Jams, Apple Butter, Salsas, Pickles, And Beets
    Visit Elkhart County highlights this broad range, emphasizing that the market is the place to find old‑fashioned spreads and condiments that taste homemade.visitelkhartcounty​
  • Fudge, Candy, And Saltwater Taffy
    Guests are invited to “indulge in sumptuous fudge, 15 different flavors of salt water taffy, and locally produced maple syrup,” making the shop as much a candy stop as a grocery.visitelkhartcounty​
  • Spices, Baking Items, And Local Honey
    MapQuest’s listing describes Dutch Country Market as “a charming grocery store with a large variety of candies, jams, jellies and many Amish products and noodles,” as well as “a wide range of spices and local honey.”mapquest​
  • Locally Made Crafts And Body Products
    You’ll also find “locally made crafts, soaps, lotions, hand woven rugs and much more,” rounding out the experience with non‑food souvenirs that feel distinctly Amish Country.visitelkhartcounty​

What Visitors Are Saying

Tripadvisor and local tourism sites paint a picture of a small but memorable stop. One reviewer wrote that Dutch Country Market is “always one of our stops on our annual visit to the area,” adding that “Traffic Jam, the noodles, cookies, and other Amish homemade goodies fill our basket! The owners and their employees are always helpful, patient and kind. A true gem.”tripadvisor​

Other review snippets include:

  • “Small Amish market with a lot to offer. The girls were making noodles while we were there… Reasonable prices, noodles, jams, cookies, baking items, honey, spices, seasonings… Nice stop.”tripadvisor​
  • “Nice Market Place on the Quilt Garden Trail… It was a good place to get local foods… The shop is small but has a lot to offer. They even had an apiary inside where you can see bees doing their work.”tripadvisor​
  • “One of my favorite local spots. I’m a local tour guide, and I take many of my guests to Dutch Country Market. A perfect place to pick up some goodies to take home. My husband and I also shop there regularly for ourselves. Amish‑owned – the Lehmans are great people.”tripadvisor​
  • “Lovely Amish country store… Run by wonderful Amish people. It has food & items reflecting the local culture.”tripadvisor​

Together, these comments underscore why the market stands out: live noodle‑making, an indoor hive, genuinely friendly Amish owners, and the sense that you’ve stumbled onto something both authentic and approachable.

A Perfect Stop Between Shipshewana And Middlebury

Travel forums often advise visitors choosing between Shipshewana and Middlebury to make time for Dutch Country Market. One suggestion reads, “While in Middlebury, suggest you pop out to the Dutch Country Market east of town on Route 16. It’s run by an Amish family, and they make their own noodles on site,” framing it as a must‑see stop for food lovers and curious travelers.tripadvisor+1​

Because it sits along County Road 16, the shop fits easily into itineraries that include:

  • Exploring Shipshewana’s flea market and downtown shops.
  • Driving the Quilt Garden Trail, with Dutch Country Market hosting one of the 16 quilt gardens and offering a viewing platform.visitelkhartcounty+1​
  • Visiting other Amish‑owned businesses and farm stands scattered through the countryside.

Open Monday–Friday from 8:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. and Saturday from 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m., Dutch Country Market is ideal for morning or afternoon stops—long enough to watch noodles being made, sample peanut butter‑and‑honey spread, and pick up jams, fudge, and honey before moving on.visitelkhartcounty​

Check sources

  1. https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g37317-d23498301-Reviews-Dutch_Country_Market-Middlebury_Indiana.html
  2. https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attractions-g37317-Activities-Middlebury_Indiana.html
  3. https://www.visitelkhartcounty.com/listing/dutch-country-market/268/
  4. https://visitshipshewana.org/listings/dutch-country-market/
  5. https://www.mapquest.com/us/indiana/dutch-country-market-42068989
  6. https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowTopic-g37526-i1293-k15329350-Shipshewana_vs_Middlebury-Shipshewana_Indiana.html
  7. https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowTopic-g37526-i1293-k14164591-Foodie_Cook_grocery_stores-Shipshewana_Indiana.html
  8. https://www.facebook.com/VisitShipshewana/posts/at-dutch-country-market-you-can-see-noodles-being-made-by-hand-and-pick-up-some-/964155009088954/
  9. https://www.yelp.com/biz/dutch-country-farmers-market-laurel
  10. https://www.asherycountrystore.com/shop/pasta-and-noodles/dutch-country/dutch-country-noodles-fine-16oz/

This Amish Bakery, Deli, And Ice Cream Shop Might Be Delaware’s Sweetest Hidden Gem

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Market

Dutch Country Market in Laurel, Delaware, is a favorite Amish‑style stop on the Delmarva Peninsula, known for its Pennsylvania Dutch comfort foods, bustling bakery, and shelves full of jams, jellies, bulk goods, and hand‑dipped ice cream. Tucked just off busy Route 13, it feels like a small slice of Lancaster County transplanted to the Eastern Shore, complete with staff in traditional Amish and Mennonite dress and a loyal following of locals and travelers.dutchcountrymarket+2​

Name, Address, And Setting

The full listing appears as Dutch Country Market, 11233 Trussum Pond Rd, Laurel, DE 19956, right off Route 13 (Sussex Highway) and across from the Route 13 Outlet Market. The market describes itself as the place to go in Laurel “to enjoy authentic Pennsylvania Dutch foods,” inviting guests to stop in for lunch, a coffee break, or baked goods, and to “bring your family for hand‑dipped ice cream” or shop for favorite jams and jellies.dutchcountryfurniture+2​

Company information notes that Dutch Country Market has been bringing traditional Amish and Mennonite foods and values to the southern Delaware community since the late 1980s and 1990s, with a focus on comfort foods, natural ingredients, and a welcoming, small‑scale atmosphere. Visitors immediately notice staff wearing head coverings and Lancaster‑style plain clothes, emphasizing the market’s strong Amish and Pennsylvania Dutch roots.linkedin+1

​

Bakery, Deli, And Favorite Foods

Dutch Country Market combines a food market, bakery, and coffee shop under one roof, making it a one‑stop destination for meals, desserts, and pantry staples. The market’s own overview highlights a wide range of goods: “homemade meals, desserts, and baked goods,” along with candies, seasonings, jellies, condiments, salads, baked goods, and “excellent meats & cheeses.”dutchcountrymarket+2​

From the official menu and shopping description:

  • Bakery Favorites
    A dedicated bakery added in 2016 allows the market to offer an expanded selection of fresh goods “made right here in Laurel, DE,” including whoopie pies, pies, breads, rolls, cookies, cupcakes, scones, donuts, muffins, bear claws, fry pies, and sticky buns. They also sell Pellman cakes, McClure’s pies, Spring Glen desserts, and other Lancaster County treats, giving the bakery case a deep bench of Pennsylvania Dutch classics.dutchcountrymarket​
  • Bulk Foods & Baking Supplies
    Dutch Country Market’s bulk aisles stock baking supplies, gluten‑free baking items, bulk candy, nuts, dried fruit, canned vegetables, and an array of jams, jellies, relishes, sauces, and other canned goods sourced from Amish and Mennonite suppliers in Pennsylvania. Their “famous Apple Butter,” made annually on site from an heirloom recipe, is called out as a signature product that reflects generational food traditions.dutchcountrymarket​
  • Deli, Meats, And Prepared Foods
    The market positions itself as a deli and sandwich shop as well as a bakery, with “excellent meats & cheeses” and prepared salads available both for eating in the café and taking home. Visitors can stop for lunch or dinner, order hot and cold sandwiches, and pick up classic Pennsylvania Dutch sides such as deli salads, coleslaw, and other ready‑to‑serve items.dutchcountryfurniture+1​
  • Ice Cream, Coffee, And Treats
    Dutch Country Market invites families to come for “hand‑dipped ice cream,” pairing it with coffee and dessert for a low‑key outing. Between the ice cream counter, bakery sweets, and candy selection, the market is as much a dessert destination as it is a grocery.dutchcountrymarket+1​

Real Reviews And Guest Impressions

Reviews featured on the market’s own site paint a picture of a well‑loved local gem. One prominently quoted comment reads:

Dutch Country Market

“Great selection of various goods. Wide varieties of candies, seasonings, jellies & condiments, salads, baked goods, excellent meats & cheeses and the best dill pickles. Everything is fresh and delicious. Highly recommend.”dutchcountrymarket

​

Tripadvisor’s restaurant listing describes Dutch Country Market as bringing “the Amish food experience to Laurel, DE,” noting that staff are hired from a Dover, Delaware Amish community and inviting guests to “sample our homemade baked goods and Amish‑style meals.” One visitor who stopped in after buying furniture next door reported that “the food was very good and the portions are ample,” mentioning a meatball sandwich, a roast beef sandwich, and a pie that was “very good,” and calling the place “a pretty awesome hidden gem.”tripadvisor​

Another reviewer noted that the restaurant is “a market where meats, cheeses, candies, cakes and other goods are sold,” praising “very tasty” turkey and “fantastic” sweet potato biscuits while highlighting the “cute Amish‑clothed women” working in the kitchen and servers, with bottomless drinks and “excellent” prices without sales tax compared to Virginia. Together, these observations underscore the market’s blend of value, authenticity, and distinctive Amish atmosphere.tripadvisor​

Why It’s A Must‑Visit On The Eastern Shore

From a tourist‑editor point of view, Dutch Country Market works on several levels: it is a convenient roadside stop right off Route 13, a destination for people who love Amish and Pennsylvania Dutch foods, and a family‑friendly place to eat and browse. Its focus on “authentic Pennsylvania Dutch foods” and visible Amish and Mennonite staff connect it directly to Lancaster County traditions while grounding it firmly in the culture of southern Delaware.linkedin+2

Dutch Country Market

​

Travelers can:

  • Stop for lunch in the café, choosing from hot sandwiches, Amish‑style meals, salads, and sides.
  • Finish with hand‑dipped ice cream, donuts, or sticky buns from the bakery.
  • Take home staples like apple butter, jams, bulk baking supplies, meats, cheeses, and candies for a longer‑lasting taste of the Eastern Shore.dutchcountrymarket+2​

Located roughly midway between Salisbury and Dover, Dutch Country Market also makes a natural waypoint on broader Eastern Shore itineraries, pairing easily with outlet shopping, small‑town exploring, or beach trips. For anyone who loves Amish markets in places like Pennsylvania or New Jersey, this Laurel stop offers a similar experience without leaving Delaware.dutchcountryfurniture+1​

  1. https://www.dutchcountrymarket.net
  2. https://www.dutchcountryfurniture.com/locations/dutch-country-market/
  3. https://www.linkedin.com/company/dutch-country-market
  4. https://www.dutchcountrymarket.net/shopping/
  5. https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g34027-d12936630-Reviews-Dutch_Country_Market-Laurel_Delaware.html
  6. https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g41224-d3460962-Reviews-Dutch_Country_Farmers_Market-Laurel_Maryland.html
  7. https://www.yelp.com/biz/dutch-country-farmers-market-laurel?start=320
  8. http://www.laureldutchmarket.com/specials
  9. https://www.facebook.com/p/Laurel-Dutch-Country-Farmers-Market-100063775083876/
  10. http://www.laureldutchmarket.com

Step Into An Old‑Fashioned Amish Market: Dutch Country Market, The Sweetest Stop In Western New York

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Market,New York

Dutch Country Market in Lyndonville, New York, is one of the most beloved Amish‑style markets in the state, combining a well‑stocked grocery, bakery, deli, and country décor shop into a single stop along scenic Route 18 near Lake Ontario. Visitors praise its friendly service, old‑fashioned atmosphere, and wide selection of baked goods, bulk foods, and Amish‑made items that make it feel like a slice of Pennsylvania Dutch country in western New York.orleanscountytourism+1​

Name, Address, And Atmosphere

The full listing appears as Dutch Country Market, Route 18, Lyndonville, NY 14098, a “charming grocery store” described as an Amish market right on Route 18 in Orleans County. Local tourism information highlights it as an “Amish market including bakery, deli, bulk food, produce and Amish‑made décor such as handmade quilts, bird houses and Adirondack chairs,” open Monday through Saturday from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m.mapquest+1​

Recent reviews mention how clean and inviting the store is, with one commenter calling it “very clean” and praising the “old fashion feel of the store,” which fits the classic country‑market image many travelers are looking for on rural drives through upstate New York. Wooden shelves, seasonal displays, and home décor items like birdhouses and Adirondack chairs reinforce the market’s mix of practical food shopping and leisurely browsing.orleanscountytourism+1​

Favorite Foods And Market Highlights

Dutch Country Market earns repeat visits for its combination of bakery, deli, bulk foods, produce, and Amish‑made décor. Customers mention a “great selection of baking supplies, garden decor, home decor, groceries, deli, [and] baked goods like apple fritters [and] turnovers,” emphasizing both variety and quality.mapquest+1​

Some of the standout items include:

  • Bakery Treats
    Visitors single out “fried pies and breads” as favorites, with one reviewer saying, “We love getting the fried pies and breads. The selection is great and I love the old fashion feel of the store.” Apple fritters, turnovers, and classic sweet breads are also noted in reviews, making the bakery case a major draw for road‑trippers looking for something fresh from the oven.mapquest​
  • Bulk Foods And Baking Supplies
    Like many Amish and Mennonite markets highlighted in upstate New York roundups, Dutch Country Market carries bulk flours, sugars, spices, baking mixes, and snacks, described as a “great selection of baking supplies” ideal for home cooks who like to stock up.amishamerica+2​
  • Deli And Grocery Items
    The Lyndonville shop is noted for its deli and general grocery selection, including cheeses, lunch meats, and pantry staples. This follows the pattern seen across Amish and Mennonite food outlets in the state, where markets serve as one‑stop destinations for “essential groceries, fresh produce, bulk foods, deli [and] frozen foods.”justplainbusiness+3​
  • Produce And Seasonal Goods
    Tourism descriptions mention produce alongside bulk foods and bakery, suggesting that Dutch Country Market offers fresh fruits and vegetables in season, echoing other Amish outlets that tie into local farms and New York State’s produce auctions.homeinthefingerlakes+1​
  • Amish‑Made Décor
    Handmade quilts, birdhouses, and Adirondack chairs are highlighted as signature non‑food items, blending practical crafts with decorative pieces that give travelers something lasting to bring home beyond pie and bread.orleanscountytourism​

Real Reviews And What Visitors Say

Dutch Country Market

Online reviews for Dutch Country Market are solidly positive, with MapQuest showing a 4.5‑star rating and recent comments focusing on service, selection, and the baked goods.mapquest​

A few examples:

  • “Amish market located right on route 18 in Lyndonville. Very clean! Great selection of baking supplies, garden decor, home decor, groceries, deli, baked goods like apple fritters, turnovers…”mapquest​
  • “Service is fantastic! We love getting the fried pies and breads. The selection is great and I love the old fashion feel of the store.”mapquest​

These remarks echo broader sentiments expressed about Amish and Mennonite food stores across upstate New York—where shoppers describe “GREAT meats,” “old‑fashioned” atmospheres, and the pleasure of finding bulk foods, smoked meats, and scratch‑baked items in one place. Dutch Country Market stands out in that landscape for its combination of bakery, deli, bulk foods, and décor under one roof along a scenic lakeside route.amishamerica+3​

Why It’s A Must‑Stop In New York State

From a tourist‑editor perspective, Dutch Country Market works as both a destination and a detour: it’s appealing enough to warrant a special trip, yet easy to fold into a day of exploring Orleans County and the southern Lake Ontario shoreline. Travelers can pair a stop here with nearby farms, orchards, and small towns, using the market as a hub for snacks, picnic supplies, and gifts.orleanscountytourism+1​

Dutch Country Market

In the wider context, guides to Amish and Mennonite outlets in upstate New York describe a network of markets—such as Troyer’s General Store, Weaver’s Farm Market, Dutch Country Market in Fort Plain, and various Mennonite stores—that offer bulk foods, cheese curds, spelt bread, smoked meats, and other “old‑timey” staples. Dutch Country Market in Lyndonville fits squarely into that tradition, but with the added charm of Amish décor and bakery specialties that reviewers repeatedly label as standouts.homeinthefingerlakes+4​

For anyone tracing an “Amish food trail” across New York State, Dutch Country Market deserves a spot near the top of the list: an accessible, friendly, and authentically country stop where you can taste, shop, and linger for a while before heading back on the road.amishamerica+2​

Check sources

  1. https://www.orleanscountytourism.com/destinations/dutch-country-market
  2. https://www.mapquest.com/us/new-york/dutch-country-market-778536260
  3. https://amishamerica.com/12-amish-mennonite-food-outlets-in-upstate-ny/
  4. https://homeinthefingerlakes.com/amish-and-mennonite-food-stores-in-new-york/
  5. https://justplainbusiness.com/dutch-country-market/
  6. https://www.iloveny.com/listing/sunnycrest-markets/32812/
  7. https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g46439-d3521913-Reviews-Dutch_Country_Farmers_Market-Flemington_New_Jersey.html
  8. https://sunnycrestmarkets.com/about/
  9. https://www.mapquest.com/us/new-york/sunnycrest-orchards-442460903
  10. https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Market&find_loc=New+York%2C+NY

This Amish Peanut Butter Chocolate Pie Is So Addictive, You’ll Regret Reading This Recipe

Written by Dennis Regling in Uncategorized

Here’s a rich, crowd‑pleasing Amish‑style peanut butter chocolate pie you can make at home. It uses a simple chocolate crumb crust, a silky peanut butter cream filling, and a soft chocolate layer underneath for that “Amish bakery” feel. ​

Amish Peanut Butter Chocolate Pie

Ingredients

For the chocolate crumb crust

  • 25 chocolate sandwich cookies (like Oreos), crushed very fine ​
  • 6 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted ​

For the chocolate layer

  • 1 cup semi‑sweet chocolate chips​
  • 1/3 cup heavy cream or evaporated milk
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract

For the peanut butter cream layer

  • 1 cup creamy peanut butter ​
  • 8 ounces cream cheese, softened ​
  • 1 1/4 cups powdered sugar, sifted ​
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 1 cup cold heavy whipping cream or 8 ounces whipped topping, thawed​

For topping (optional but recommended)

  • 1/2 cup cold heavy whipping cream
  • 2 tablespoons powdered sugar
  • Chocolate shavings or mini chips
  • Crumbled chocolate cookies or a drizzle of melted peanut butter
Amish Peanut Butter Chocolate Pie

Step 1: Make and bake the crust

  1. Heat oven to 350°F (175°C).
  2. Finely crush the chocolate cookies (food processor or sealed bag + rolling pin).
  3. In a bowl, mix cookie crumbs with melted butter until evenly moistened. ​
  4. Press firmly into the bottom and up the sides of a 9‑inch pie plate.
  5. Bake 6–8 minutes, just until set; do not overbake. ​
  6. Cool completely before filling.

Step 2: Prepare the chocolate layer

  1. In a small saucepan over low heat, combine chocolate chips and cream (or evaporated milk).
  2. Stir constantly until melted and smooth; remove from heat and stir in vanilla. ​
  3. Pour the warm chocolate over the cooled crust and tilt the pan so it forms an even layer.
  4. Chill 15–20 minutes, until the chocolate is just set but not rock‑hard.

Step 3: Make the peanut butter filling

  1. In a mixing bowl, beat the peanut butter and softened cream cheese until smooth and creamy. ​
  2. In a separate bowl, whip the heavy cream to stiff peaks or measure out your whipped topping. ​
  3. Gently fold the whipped cream/topping into the peanut butter mixture in 2–3 additions, just until combined and fluffy.

Step 4: Assemble the pie

  1. Spread the peanut butter cream filling over the cooled chocolate layer, smoothing the top with an offset spatula.
  2. Chill at least 4 hours, or until the filling is set enough to slice cleanly (overnight is ideal). ​

Step 5: Add the topping

  1. Whip 1/2 cup heavy cream with 2 tablespoons powdered sugar until soft‑to‑medium peaks form.
  2. Spoon or pipe over the chilled pie.
  3. Garnish with chocolate shavings or chips and a sprinkle of crushed cookies, or drizzle a little warmed peanut butter in a zigzag over the top.

Tips and variations

  • For extra “Amish” flavor, use a graham‑cracker or traditional pastry crust if you prefer a lighter base under the chocolate and peanut butter. ​
  • Add a thin layer of crushed peanut butter “crumbs” (peanut butter mixed with powdered sugar until sandy) on the crust before the chocolate for added texture, a trick often used in Amish peanut butter pies. ​
  • If you want it less rich, use half the peanut butter in the filling and keep the chocolate layer thin so the pie eats a bit lighter. ​

Serve this pie well‑chilled with small slices—it is very rich and velvety, exactly the kind of dessert that feels at home in an Amish country restaurant case.

Amish Peanut Butter Chocolate Pie