Recent Posts

Amish Bakery Molasses Cookies That Stay Soft for a Week

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Recipes

(Perfect for Selling, Gifting, or Bake Sales)

If you’ve ever bought molasses cookies at an Amish bakery or farm market, you may have noticed something special about them: they stay soft, moist, and chewy for days. Unlike many homemade cookies that turn firm after a day or two, bakery-style molasses cookies remain tender almost an entire week when stored properly.

The secret is a combination of extra molasses, brown sugar, and a small amount of oil or shortening, which helps trap moisture in the cookie. Amish bakers also tend to make them larger and thicker, which keeps the centers soft even after several days.

This recipe produces large, soft molasses cookies with crackled tops and chewy centers—the exact style that sells well at bake sales, farm markets, or as packaged gifts.

Soft-for-a-Week Molasses Cookies Recipe

Yield

About 18–20 large bakery-style cookies

Ingredients

  • ¾ cup vegetable shortening (or butter)
  • ¼ cup vegetable oil
  • 1 cup brown sugar, packed
  • ¼ cup white sugar
  • 1 large egg
  • ⅓ cup dark molasses
  • 2 ½ cups all-purpose flour
  • 2 teaspoons baking soda
  • ½ teaspoon salt
  • 1 ½ teaspoons cinnamon
  • 1 teaspoon ground ginger
  • ½ teaspoon ground cloves
  • ¼ teaspoon nutmeg (optional)
  • ½ cup granulated sugar (for rolling)

Instructions

1. Preheat the Oven

Preheat oven to 350°F (175°C) and line baking sheets with parchment paper.

2. Cream the Fats and Sugar

In a large bowl, beat together:

  • shortening
  • vegetable oil
  • brown sugar
  • white sugar

Mix until smooth and fluffy.

3. Add Wet Ingredients

Beat in:

  • egg
  • molasses

Mix until fully combined.

4. Combine Dry Ingredients

In another bowl whisk together:

  • flour
  • baking soda
  • salt
  • cinnamon
  • ginger
  • cloves
  • nutmeg

5. Make the Dough

Gradually mix the dry ingredients into the molasses mixture until a soft dough forms.

If the dough feels sticky, chill for 30 minutes.

6. Form Large Cookies

Roll dough into 2-inch balls (about 2 tablespoons of dough).

Roll each ball in granulated sugar.

Place 3 inches apart on baking sheet.

7. Bake

Bake for 10–12 minutes.

The cookies should:

  • crack on top
  • look slightly underbaked in the center

This keeps them soft.

8. Cool Properly

Allow cookies to sit on the baking sheet 5 minutes, then move to a cooling rack.

They will soften even more as they cool.

amish molasses

The Secret to Keeping Them Soft All Week

For bakery-style softness, follow these storage tricks:

1. Store in Airtight Containers

Use tins or sealed containers.

2. Add a Slice of Bread

Place one slice of sandwich bread in the container.
The cookies absorb moisture from the bread and stay soft.

3. Package While Slightly Warm

For selling or gifting, place cookies in clear treat bags once barely warm.

4. Avoid Refrigeration

Cold air dries cookies out.

Bake Sale & Gift Packaging Ideas

These cookies are excellent for selling because they stay attractive and soft.

Popular packaging options:

  • clear bakery bags with twine
  • small kraft bakery boxes
  • mason jars stacked with cookies
  • parchment wrap with ribbon

Typical bake sale packs:

  • 3 large cookies per bag
  • $4–$6 per package depending on market.

Why These Cookies Sell So Well

These molasses cookies are popular because they are:

✔ Large and visually appealing
✔ Strong warm spice aroma
✔ Soft and chewy for days
✔ Affordable ingredients
✔ Perfect with coffee or tea

Their crackled tops and sugar coating also make them look homemade and traditional, which customers love.

Sweet, Dark, and Divine: Unlocking the Mystery of the “Midnight Gold” Molasses Cookie

Written by Dennis Regling in Uncategorized

Amish “Midnight Gold” Molasses Cookies

A Deeply Spiced, Old-Fashioned Treat from Amish Kitchens

If you spend any time around Amish baking traditions, you quickly learn that simplicity and richness often go hand in hand. One perfect example is the humble molasses cookie. In many Amish homes, these cookies appear regularly on kitchen tables, at church gatherings, and especially during the colder months when warm spices and dark molasses feel especially comforting.

Among these treasured recipes is a variation sometimes affectionately called “Midnight Gold” Molasses Cookies.” The name reflects the cookies’ dark, rich color and the golden warmth of their flavor. While they look deep and dark from the molasses, their taste is warm, sweet, and comforting—like something pulled from a wood-fired oven late in the evening after a long day’s work.

These cookies are soft, slightly chewy, and deeply aromatic with ginger, cinnamon, and cloves. When baked properly, they develop delicate cracks on top and a lightly crisp edge surrounding a tender center.

Why Amish Bakers Love Molasses Cookies

Molasses has long been a staple ingredient in Amish and traditional American baking. Before refined sugar became common, molasses was an affordable sweetener that added both sweetness and depth of flavor.

For Amish cooks, molasses cookies offer several advantages:

  • Simple ingredients commonly found in a farmhouse pantry
  • Long shelf life, making them ideal for storing in tins
  • Easy to bake in large batches for church events and family gatherings
  • Rich flavor that pairs well with coffee, tea, or milk

Many Amish families bake them in the evening, letting the aroma of spices fill the house as the day winds down. That cozy late-night tradition is part of why some bakers refer to them as “Midnight Gold.”

Amish “Midnight Gold” Molasses Cookies Recipe

Ingredients

  • ¾ cup shortening (or butter)
  • 1 cup brown sugar, packed
  • 1 large egg
  • ¼ cup molasses (dark molasses preferred)
  • 2 cups all-purpose flour
  • 2 teaspoons baking soda
  • ½ teaspoon salt
  • 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
  • 1 teaspoon ground ginger
  • ½ teaspoon ground cloves
  • ½ cup granulated sugar (for rolling)

Instructions

1. Preheat the Oven

Preheat your oven to 350°F (175°C). Line a baking sheet with parchment paper.

2. Cream the Butter and Sugar

In a large mixing bowl, cream together the shortening (or butter) and brown sugar until light and fluffy.

3. Add the Wet Ingredients

Beat in the egg and molasses until the mixture is smooth and well combined.

4. Mix the Dry Ingredients

In a separate bowl, whisk together:

  • flour
  • baking soda
  • salt
  • cinnamon
  • ginger
  • cloves

5. Combine

Gradually add the dry ingredients to the molasses mixture, stirring until a soft dough forms.

6. Shape the Cookies

Roll the dough into 1-inch balls, then roll each ball in granulated sugar.

7. Bake

Place the dough balls about 2 inches apart on the baking sheet.

Bake for 9–11 minutes, until the tops crack and the edges set.

8. Cool

Let cookies cool on the pan for 5 minutes, then transfer to a wire rack.

What Makes These Cookies Special

“Midnight Gold” molasses cookies have several signature characteristics:

  • Deep brown color
  • Soft, chewy center
  • Crinkled sugar-coated top
  • Warm spice aroma
  • Balanced sweetness with slight molasses bitterness

They taste even better the next day, once the spices fully settle into the cookie.

Amish Baking Tips

Amish cooks often follow a few simple tricks to perfect molasses cookies:

Use dark molasses
It gives the cookies their characteristic color and depth.

Do not overbake
The cookies will firm up as they cool.

Chill the dough if needed
If the dough feels sticky, chill for 30 minutes before rolling.

Store in a tin
Place a slice of bread in the cookie tin to keep them soft.

Serving Ideas

These cookies are wonderful served with:

  • hot coffee
  • fresh milk
  • hot apple cider
  • spiced tea

They also pair beautifully with vanilla ice cream for a simple dessert.

A Taste of Amish Comfort

In many Amish kitchens, molasses cookies represent something more than just dessert. They’re a reminder that good food doesn’t require complicated ingredients—only care, patience, and tradition.

Whether baked for a church supper, shared with neighbors, or enjoyed quietly late at night, Amish “Midnight Gold” Molasses Cookies offer a warm taste of old-fashioned farmhouse baking.

The Best Butter in Texas? Inside the Grand Opening of Lone Star Amish Market

Written by Dennis Regling in Uncategorized

Deep in the Heart of Tradition: Lone Star Amish Market Debuts in Dallas

The skyline of Dallas, TX, may be defined by glass and steel, but a new corner of the city is now smelling of fresh-churned butter and cedarwood. This morning, the Lone Star Amish Market officially opened its doors, bringing a slice of “plain” living to the high-energy pulse of North Texas. It is the first major establishment of its kind to bring the authentic craftsmanship of the Bee County and Lancaster settlements directly to the Big D.

Located at 9202 Garland Road, Dallas, TX 75218, just a stone’s throw from the Dallas Arboretum, the market has transformed a sprawling vintage warehouse into an indoor village of timber-framed stalls, bulk spice barrels, and a bakery that began running its ovens at 4:00 AM.

Texas Size, Amish Quality

While the market stays true to traditional roots, it has embraced its new home with items that blend Pennsylvania Dutch skill with Texas flair. Early visitors are already raving about the Smoked Brisket Hand-Pies, which take the classic Amish flaky pastry and stuff it with slow-smoked, pepper-crusted beef.

Other standout items making waves include:

  • “Midnight Gold” Molasses Cookies: A recipe passed down through four generations, resulting in a soft, chewy cookie that pairs perfectly with Texas pecans.
  • Hand-Rolled Garlic Herb Butter: Shipped in fresh, this roll butter is churned until it reaches a creamy consistency that makes store-bought alternatives pale in comparison.
  • The “Yellow Rose” Quilt Collection: Stunning, hand-stitched quilts featuring intricate floral patterns unique to this new Texas-based collective of artisans.
Hand-Rolled Garlic Herb Butter
Hand-Rolled Garlic Herb Butter

Voices from the Grand Opening

The heat didn’t stop a line from forming well before the ribbon-cutting. Local resident Elena Rodriguez was seen leaving with a crate of jarred “Copper Kettle” apple butter. “I usually have to wait for my sister to mail me stuff from the Midwest,” she said, wiping a bit of cinnamon sugar from her cheek. “To have a real sourdough pretzel, still warm from the oven, right here in East Dallas… it’s a game changer for my weekend routine.”

Mason Whitfield, a woodworker himself, spent nearly an hour in the furniture wing. “The joinery on these white oak dining tables is flawless. You don’t see dovetails like this in the big-box stores. It’s not just a table; it’s an heirloom. I think Dallas was hungry for something that was built to last.”

amish market

The Taste of Tradition: Why Everyone is Lining Up at this Amish-Country Landmark

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Restaurants

A Taste of Tradition: Inside Western PA’s Most Beloved Amish Eatery

The landscape of Western Pennsylvania is a tapestry of rolling farmland, industrious towns, and a deep-seated appreciation for simple, hearty living. This is nowhere more evident than in the “Amish Country” sections of Mercer and Lawrence counties, where horses and buggies share the roads with modern vehicles. In the heart of this region lies a dining landmark, a place that embodies the definition of “home cooking.”

The Tavern on the Square is not merely a restaurant; it is a pilgrimage site for food lovers seeking authenticity in an increasingly pre-packaged world. Located in a beautifully restored 1849 antebellum home within the quaint, historic village of New Wilmington, The Tavern bridges the gap between the bounty of local Amish farms and the modern diner’s plate.

Authenticity from Farm to Table

While not exclusively Amish-owned, The Tavern is uniquely situated as the community’s nexus for authentic, area-grown fare. The region surrounding New Wilmington is home to one of the largest and oldest Amish settlements in North America. The relationships The Tavern cultivates with these neighboring farms are the foundation of its menu.

Unlike tourist buffets found further east, The Tavern on the Square operates with a meticulous focus on seasonality and handcrafted quality. The bread is baked daily, the gravies are made from scratch, and the meats are often sourced from antibiotic-free local producers. The menu is a reflection of the agrarian calendar, making every visit a distinct culinary experience.

The Tavern

Commmunity Favorites and Staple Dishes

Patrons travel from across the state—and often from neighboring Ohio—for a taste of The Tavern’s signature dishes. Their menu is a mix of classic American comfort and traditional Pennsylvania Dutch elements. Some undisputed crowd-pleasers include:

  • The Tavern Signature Chicken: It is a carefully guarded secret. Lightly breaded and expertly fried to a crisp, golden brown, it remains remarkably juicy inside. It is standard comfort food executed with unparalleled precision.
  • Ham Balls with Sweet-and-Sour Glaze: A quintessential Pennsylvania Dutch dish. These hearty, smoked ground ham loaves are baked until tender and smothered in a tangy, caramelized glaze that perfectly balances the savory smoke.
  • The “Lawnmower” Salad: For a lighter option that still feels satisfying, this salad is a surprisingly hearty mix of fresh seasonal greens, hard-boiled eggs, and a signature sweet-and-sour dressing that ties it all together.
  • Homemade Pies: No visit is complete without dessert. The Tavern’s bakers are renowned. From deep-dish apple to the traditional, molasses-rich Shoofly pie, every slice is a testament to time-honored baking methods.

Real Diners, Real Reviews

The Tavern

The loyalty of The Tavern’s clientele is fierce. The restaurant frequently operates at capacity, with lines often forming during peak hours, particularly for Sunday dinner.

“We drive nearly two hours just to have the ham balls,” says Sarah T. from Cleveland, Ohio. “You simply cannot find food like this anywhere else. It’s not just ‘like’ home-cooked; it is home-cooked by people who know exactly what they are doing.”

Another local patron, James H., has been a regular for decades. “I remember coming here with my grandparents. The ownership has changed, but the spirit hasn’t. The chicken is still the best I’ve ever tasted, and the pies are exactly how my grandmother used to make them.”

“In a world of chain restaurants, The Tavern is a treasure,” shared another verified reviewer. “You can taste the quality of the local ingredients. You feel like you’re part of the history of the house when you dine there.”

If You Go

The Tavern on the Square, 108 North Market Street, New Wilmington, PA 16142

Hours: Closed Mondays and Tuesdays. Wednesday-Thursday 11 am–9 pm, Sunday 11 am–8 pm (Hours may vary by season).

The Tavern on the Square

Heritage Hills Amish Market: A Taste of the Simple Life Arrives in Worcester

Written by Dennis Regling in Uncategorized

A Simple Slice of Life: Heritage Hills Amish Market Opens in Worcester

The quiet bustle of Worcester, MA, has a new rhythm this week as the highly anticipated Heritage Hills Amish Market officially opens its doors. Bringing the time-honored traditions of the Pennsylvania Dutch to the heart of the Commonwealth, the market offers a sensory escape from the digital age, filled with the aroma of cedar, smoked meats, and sugar-dusted pastries.

Located at 512 Main Street, Worcester, MA 01608, the market is a collaborative effort from several families who have relocated from the Lancaster area. The space has been transformed into a sprawling indoor bazaar, featuring hand-carved furniture, bulk spices, and a deli that has already seen lines wrapping around the corner.

The Community’s New Favorites

While the market offers everything from hand-quilted blankets to organic produce, the early favorites are coming straight from the “Dutch Kitchen” section. Regulars from the soft opening are already calling the Buggy Track Ice Cream—a rich vanilla base swirled with thick fudge and peanut butter cups—the best treat in the city.

Buggy Track Ice Cream
Buggy Track Ice Cream

Other must-try items include:

  • The “Lawnmower” Salad: A surprisingly hearty and fresh mix of seasonal greens, hard-boiled eggs, and a signature sweet-and-sour dressing.
  • Warm Sourdough Pretzels: Rolled by hand and dipped in melted butter right before your eyes.
  • Hickory-Smoked Bacon: Thick-cut and cured using traditional methods that result in a flavor profile you simply can’t find in a grocery store aisle.
"Lawnmower" Salad
“Lawnmower” Salad

Early Reviews: A “Hidden Gem” Found

The local response has been nothing short of enthusiastic. Local resident Sarah Higgins was spotted loading her trunk with jars of “Amish Wedding” pickled beets. “I’ve been driving to Pennsylvania once a year just to stock my pantry,” she said. “Having Heritage Hills right here in Worcester feels like a gift. The quality of the butter alone is enough to keep me coming back every week.”

Another shopper, James Thorne, marveled at the atmosphere. “It’s not just about the food; it’s the pace. You walk in, and everyone is smiling and taking their time. It reminds you that life doesn’t always have to be a rush. And the shoofly pie? It’s exactly how my grandmother used to make it.”

Is This the Best Sandwich in PA? New Amish Deli Opens Its Doors

Written by Dennis Regling in Uncategorized

A Taste of Tradition: Heritage Hearth Deli Brings Amish-Mennonite Flavors to Harrison

The rolling hills of Pennsylvania have long been home to a culinary tradition rooted in simplicity, hard work, and the freshest ingredients. This week, that tradition finds a new home in our community. Heritage Hearth Deli, a family-owned Amish-Mennonite establishment, officially opened its doors this morning, bringing a “farm-to-counter” experience that local foodies have been anticipating for months.

Located at 1402 Freeport Road, Natrona Heights, PA 15065, the deli occupies a cozy, renovated storefront that now smells of yeast, hickory smoke, and cinnamon. Unlike the frantic pace of modern fast-food joints, Heritage Hearth operates on “Amish time,” where the bread is kneaded by hand and the meats are cured slowly to ensure every bite carries the weight of history.

From the Smokehouse to the Sandwich

The star of the show is undeniably the deli’s signature Lebanon Bologna, a sweet and smoky beef-based meat that is a staple of Pennsylvania Dutch culture. It’s served thin-shaved on homemade sourdough or as part of their “Heritage Stack” platter.

For those looking for a true comfort meal, the menu features:

  • Brown Butter Noodles: Thick, handmade egg noodles tossed in butter that has been browned to a nutty perfection.
  • The “Haystack” Bowl: A customizable layers of crushed crackers, seasoned meat, rice, and fresh vegetables, all smothered in a creamy, homemade cheese sauce.
  • Shoofly Pie: A deep, rich molasses pie with a crumbly topping that tastes exactly like a Sunday morning in Lancaster County.
The Haystack Bowl

What the Community is Saying

The soft opening earlier this week drew a crowd that stretched down Freeport Road. Local resident Mary Miller was among the first in line. “I grew up visiting my grandmother’s farm in Big Valley,” she shared while clutching a warm loaf of salt-rising bread. “The first bite of their chicken corn soup brought me right back. You can’t fake this kind of flavor—it comes from fresh ingredients and a lot of heart.”

Another patron, David Stinner, raved about the craftsmanship. “In a world of mass production, there’s something special about food made with love and time. The quality isn’t just better; it feels like it’s better for you. It’s the kind of place where the owner knows your name before your second visit.”