Recent Posts

Hand-Carved and Home-Cooked: Discovering New York State’s Authentic Amish Trail

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Restaurants,New York

While Empire State travel often highlights the bright lights of Manhattan or the vineyards of the Finger Lakes, western and central New York host thriving, deeply rooted Old Order Amish communities. Choosing a slower pace of life, these communities maintain incredible multi-generational cottage industries.

By trading commercial strips for the rolling backroads, visitors can discover exceptional hand-carved craftsmanship, vibrant greenhouses, and comforting, scratch-made food. If you are looking to explore authentic heritage in New York State, these three existing Amish-owned establishments are essential stops.

1. The Old Tool Tavern (Randolph, NY)

Located right along western New York’s historic, designated “Amish Trail,” The Old Tool Tavern provides a highly unique dining experience. This rustic tavern and restaurant pairs the warm hospitality of the area with a hearty, comforting pub menu. It acts as a perfect resting spot for travelers exploring the local woodworking and quilt shops dotting Cattaraugus County.

  • Fan Favorites: Locals flock here on weekends for the traditional Friday Night Fish Fry, a western NY staple executed to perfection. The tavern is also celebrated for its thick, juicy pub burgers served on fresh-baked rolls, savory hot appetizers, and ice-cold regional beverages.
  • Location: 23 Center Street, Randolph, NY 14772

2. Weaver’s Farm Market (Morris, NY)

Weaver’s Farm Market (Morris, NY)*
Weaver’s Farm Market (Morris, NY)

Nestled beautifully in Otsego County’s historic Butternut Valley, Weaver’s Farm Market is an expansive, 4,000-square-foot indoor Amish marketplace. Located just minutes from Gilbert Lake State Park, this meticulously organized market is a paradise for home cooks and foodies seeking real, small-batch pantry goods.

  • Fan Favorites: The centerpiece of the market is the stellar deli counter, loaded with premium Aged Cheeses and custom-sliced sandwich meats. Visitors also fill their baskets with home-style jarred goods, including rich Apple Butter, local clover honey, and incredibly soft, scratch-baked cinnamon rolls. Note: In keeping with traditional practices, this market accepts cash or check only.
  • Location: 1272 East Side Road, Morris, NY 13808

3. Valley View Cheese Company (Conewango Valley, NY)

For an unforgettable country store experience, Valley View Cheese Company in the Conewango Valley is a must-visit destination. Surrounded by local blacksmiths, harness makers, and lumber sawmills, this quintessential country shop showcases the very best of traditional dairy craftsmanship.

  • Fan Favorites: The undisputed star here is their Sharp Cheddar and Smoked Cheeses, made with high-quality milk from local pastures. Alongside the cheese wheels, the shelves are packed with traditional hard candies, homemade egg noodles, small-batch preserves, and seasonal handcrafted baskets.
  • Location: 5316 Chautauqua Road, Conewango Valley, NY 14726

Southern Hospitality Meets Old-World Craft: 3 Must-Visit Amish Businesses in Tennessee

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Market

When most people think of Amish country, their minds drift to the rolling hills of Ohio or Pennsylvania. However, middle and eastern Tennessee are home to vibrant, deeply rooted Amish communities that have passed down their traditions of agricultural excellence, scratch cooking, and heirloom carpentry for generations.

If you are looking to slow down and experience authentic craftsmanship and exceptional food, these three existing Tennessee businesses deserve a prominent spot on your itinerary.

1. The Amish Market (Ethridge, TN)

Located in Lawrence County—home to Tennessee’s oldest and largest Old Order Swartzentruber Amish settlement—The Amish Market acts as an incredible gateway to the region’s local flavors. Run with a deep appreciation for community stories, this shop is a favorite among locals and travelers tracking down backroads treasures.

  • Fan Favorites: Visitors rave about the specialized cheese selection, particularly the bold ghost pepper cheese. The market is also highly sought after for its smoky summer sausage, rich homemade fudge, local sorghum molasses, and jarred apple butter.
  • Location: 1006 Brewer Road, Ethridge, TN 38456

2. Amish Creations & Country Market (Sevierville, TN)

If you are heading into the Great Smoky Mountains or returning from Pigeon Forge, this red-roofed gem in Sevierville is an essential stop. Established in 2013, Amish Creations & Country Market brings authentic Lancaster-style goods and deep attention to technical detail straight to the foothills of East Tennessee.

  • Fan Favorites: The sensory standout here is their signature Amish Light Candles line, featuring popular hand-poured scents like “Amish Quilt,” gingerbread, and apple orchard. Beyond candles, the front porch and floor showcase elite carpentry like heavy-duty cedar chests and rocking chairs, alongside pantry goods like beef jerky and small-batch jellies.
  • Location: 1235 Parkway, Sevierville, TN 37862

3. Ike’s Amish Depot and Country Store (Ethridge, TN)

Stepping into Ike’s Amish Depot is a literal time-travel experience. Originally established in 1942 by a retired policeman and kept alive by his grandson, this historic storefront features a vintage soda fountain, a Greyhound bus station setup, and actual stables for Amish horses out back. It operates as a beautifully preserved link between the local Amish community and the public.

  • Fan Favorites: On Saturdays, people crowd the vintage soda fountain for nostalgia-heavy treats like hand-dipped ice cream, milkshakes, and thick fried bologna sandwiches made with local ingredients. It is also a premier spot to grab locally grown popcorn, glass-jar penny candies, and farm-made goat soaps.
  • Location: 4004 Hwy 43, Ethridge, TN 38456

A Taste of Lancaster in South Jersey: Gathering at My Father’s Place Restaurant

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Restaurants

While New Jersey is famous for its retro highway diners and world-class pizzerias, tucked away in Cumberland County is a hidden culinary treasure operating on a completely different rhythm. Located inside the bustling Bridgeton Amish Market, My Father’s Place Restaurant has quietly become a beloved gathering spot for South Jersey locals seeking authentic, slow-cooked comfort food.

Operating on a limited weekly schedule—open only Thursday through Saturday—the restaurant rejects the frantic pace of modern dining. Instead, it offers a spacious, welcoming dining area where meals are treated as an opportunity for community, hospitality, and generous, scratch-made portions.

Fan Favorites: Comfort Food the Old-Fashioned Way

Whether you arrive for the early morning rush or a quiet dinner, the kitchen at My Father’s Place whips up traditional, hearty dishes that taste exactly like Sunday dinner at grandmother’s house. While the entire menu is crafted with care, there are a few absolute non-negotiables for first-time visitors:

  • The Saturday Morning Breakfast Buffet: The crown jewel of the week. From 7:00 AM to 2:00 PM every Saturday, crowds gather for an endless spread of breakfast classics, including thick-cut bacon, golden scrambled eggs, home fries, and fluffy pancakes.
  • The Signature Chicken Croquettes: A masterclass in Pennsylvania Dutch comfort food. Crisp on the outside and tender on the inside, these croquettes are smothered in a rich, velvety chicken gravy and served alongside real mashed potatoes.
  • Country Hamloaf: A sweet and savory traditional staple that is increasingly hard to find done right. Glazed to perfection, it pairs beautifully with the restaurant’s scratch-made sides.
  • Thursdays & Fridays Soup and Salad Bar: Perfect for a quick, fulfilling weekday lunch. From 10:00 AM to 6:00 PM, patrons can enjoy an all-you-can-eat bar loaded with hearty, rotating homemade soups, fresh greens, and warm breadsticks.
  • Beef Pot Roast: Slow-simmered for hours until it is literally fork-tender, this dish is the ultimate definition of cold-weather comfort food.

Plan Your Dining Experience

Because everything is prepared fresh and served within the lively atmosphere of the local Amish market, seating fills up quickly during the peak Saturday morning rush. If you are looking for an authentic meal that celebrates rich cultural heritage and simple, exceptional ingredients, pull up a chair and stay a while.

Location: > My Father’s Place Restaurant > (Located inside the Bridgeton Amish Market)

2 Cassidy Court, Bridgeton, NJ 08302

Step Back in Time: A Visit to Shiloh General Store in Hamptonville

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Market

Step Back in Time: A Visit to Shiloh General Store in Hamptonville

Tucked away in the scenic foothills of North Carolina’s Yadkin Valley sits a quiet haven of old-world charm: Shiloh General Store. Located in Hamptonville, this beloved destination anchors North Carolina’s only true Amish community, offering visitors a peaceful escape from the frantic pace of modern life.

Stepping through the front door feels like stepping back in time. The air is thick with the scent of fresh-baked yeast breads and warm sugar, and the shelves are meticulously stocked with handcrafted goods and pantry staples that champion simplicity and honest quality.

Fan Favorites: What to Fill Your Basket With

Shiloh General Store has earned a legendary reputation among Piedmont region foodies. While it is impossible to leave empty-handed, a few standout items have earned permanent cult-classic status:

  • The Famous Fried Pies: The absolute showstopper of the bakery section. These individual pocket pies feature a wonderfully flaky, golden crust wrapped around rich fruit fillings. They sell out fast, and for good reason.
  • Fresh-Baked Specialty Breads: Baked daily in-house, these loaves come out of the oven golden, fragrant, and incredibly soft. The sourdough dinner rolls and homemade sandwich breads are staple purchases.
  • Troyer Deli Meats and Cheeses: For the ultimate sandwich, locals flock to the deli counter, which features premium cuts sourced directly from Troyer—a hallmark name recognized by Amish food lovers for exceptional quality.
  • Signature Whoopie Pies: Another bakery triumph, featuring thick, fluffy marshmallow cream sandwiched between two soft, cake-like cookies.
  • Hand-Sewn Amish Quilts & Wooden Swings: Beyond the kitchen, the store showcases the incredible craftsmanship of the local community. Intricately patterned, locally stitched quilts and heavy-duty, classically built wooden porch swings are available for those looking to bring a piece of heritage home.

If you timing your visit around lunch, the store also offers a popular “Value Lunch Deal,” featuring a hearty deli sandwich piled high on one of their fresh-baked rolls.

Plan Your Visit

Whether you are searching for rare bulk baking ingredients, a stunning new piece of patio furniture, or just the best slice of pie in the state, Shiloh General Store delivers a genuine taste of Amish hospitality.

Plan Your Visit

Whether you are searching for rare bulk baking ingredients, a stunning new piece of patio furniture, or just the best slice of pie in the state, Shiloh General Store delivers a genuine taste of Amish hospitality.

Location: Shiloh General Store, 5520 St. Paul Church Road, Hamptonville, NC 27020

Shiloh General Store

From Soft Pretzels to Solid Oak: Why the Bristol Amish Market is a Weekend Must

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Market

A Bustling Hub of Tradition: Exploring the Bristol Amish Market

For foodies and lovers of traditional, handcrafted goods in Eastern Pennsylvania, few destinations offer the sensory delight of the Bristol Amish Market. Located in Bucks County, this vibrant indoor market brings the rich agricultural and culinary traditions of Lancaster County straight to the eastern edge of the state.

Operating three days a week (Thursday through Saturday), the market serves as a bustling community hub where visitors can bypass mass-produced grocery store items in favor of authentic, small-batch goods.

Fan Favorites: What to Taste and Buy

Walking through the doors, visitors are greeted by a symphony of aromas, from smoky barbecued meats to sugary glazed pastries. The market hosts a variety of specialized stands, making it impossible to leave empty-handed. Here are some of the absolute fan favorites that have earned a permanent spot on local shopping lists:

  • Warm, Hand-Rolled Soft Pretzels: A staple of any authentic Pennsylvania Dutch trip. From King’s Pretzels, these treats are twisted, baked, and dipped in real melted butter right before your eyes, offering a melt-in-your-mouth texture.
  • The Bakery’s Whoopie Pies: No trip to an Eastern PA market is complete without this classic dessert. Featuring fluffy marshmallow cream sandwiched between two rich, cake-like chocolate or pumpkin rounds, they are a sweet-tooth paradise.
  • Fresh-Cut Meats and Thick-Bacon: The multi-generational butcher counters offer incredibly fresh, high-quality cuts of beef, pork, and poultry, alongside specialty items like Lancaster-style sweet bologna and thick-cut hickory smoked bacon.
  • Heirloom Produce and Bulk Foods: Depending on the season, the produce stalls overflow with locally grown sweet corn, vine-ripened tomatoes, and crisp autumn apples, flanked by rows of classic jarred goods like pickled beets and sweet apple butter.

Beyond the food, the market also serves as a showcase for elite carpentry, featuring a massive selection of heirloom-quality indoor hardwood furniture and durable outdoor structures crafted to last lifetimes.

Plan Your Visit

Whether you are stocking up for a weekend barbecue, hunting for the perfect rocking chair, or simply craving a hot lunch, the Bristol Amish Market delivers a shopping experience steeped in hospitality and timeless quality.

Location:

Bristol Amish Market

498 Green Lane

Bristol, PA 19007

The Scent of Tradition: Inside the Poconos’ Newest Amish Market

Written by Dennis Regling in Uncategorized

A Taste of Tradition: The Heritage Hearth Amish Market Opens in Stroudsburg

The rolling hills of the Poconos just got a little more flavorful. Nestled on the outskirts of town, the Heritage Hearth Amish Market has officially opened its doors, bringing a slice of Lancaster County’s quiet diligence and culinary excellence to the Stroudsburg community.

While the doors are new, the traditions behind them are generations deep.

The Backstory: A Journey of Heritage

The story of Heritage Hearth began nearly two hundred miles away in the fertile farmland of Intercourse, Pennsylvania. The Stoltzfus family, led by patriarch Amos and his daughter Rebecca, had operated a modest roadside stand for decades. However, as the younger generation looked to expand while preserving their way of life, they sought a community that valued local craftsmanship and slow-living.

After a chance visit to the Delaware Water Gap, Rebecca fell in love with the rugged beauty of Monroe County. Seeing a “For Sale” sign on an old refurbished barn, the family saw a sign of their own. They spent the last year meticulously hand-restoring the timber frame, installing wood-burning stoves, and connecting with local Pocono farmers to supplement their own family-grown harvests. Heritage Hearth isn’t just a grocery store; it’s a bridge between two historic Pennsylvania regions.

Fan Favorites: What to Fill Your Basket With

Walking into the market, you’re immediately hit by the scent of warm cinnamon and fresh pine. If you’re a first-timer, here are the non-negotiables:

  • The “Midnight” Shoofly Pie: A Stoltzfus family secret, this pie features a deep, gooey molasses bottom and a crumb topping that isn’t too sweet—perfect with a cup of black coffee.
  • Hand-Rolled Sourdough Pretzels: Prepared daily and dipped in real butter, these are often still warm when you grab them from the counter.
  • Aged Sharp Cheddar: Sourced from their cousins’ dairy farm, this cheese is aged for 24 months, resulting in a crystalline texture and a bold, nutty finish.
  • Small-Batch Apple Butter: Slow-cooked in copper kettles, it contains no refined sugars—just the concentrated sweetness of autumn apples.

Visit the Market

Whether you are looking for hand-quilted linens or the freshest eggs in the county, Heritage Hearth offers a pace of shopping that encourages you to linger and appreciate the craft.

Location:

Heritage Hearth Amish Market,

1422 Old Carriage Road

Stroudsburg, PA 18360

The story of Heritage Hearth Amish Market doesn’t begin in a boardroom, but rather around a flickering kerosene lamp in the winter of 2024. For the Stoltzfus and Miller families, the decision to move from the dense, tourist-heavy corridors of Lancaster County wasn’t about escaping their roots—it was about finding enough room to let them grow.

Amos Stoltzfus, a master woodworker, and his son-in-law, Isaac Miller, a third-generation dairyman, noticed that the tradition of the “true” community market was being diluted. They wanted a place where the pace of life matched the rising time of a loaf of bread. After a scouting trip through the Poconos, they found an abandoned 19th-century dairy barn on the outskirts of Stroudsburg. While others saw rotting hemlock and a collapsed roof, Amos saw the “bones” of a new sanctuary.

The construction became a local legend before the market even sold its first jar of jam. Throughout the spring of 2025, neighbors watched in awe as dozens of men from three different church districts arrived in a fleet of grey buggies and vans. In a display of communal Froehlicheit (fellowship), they raised the fallen beams by hand, refusing the use of heavy electric cranes.

The “back story” is literally etched into the walls: if you look closely at the main support pillar near the deli counter, you’ll see the carved initials of the twenty-four men who helped raise the barn in a single weekend.

The market opened not just to sell goods, but to preserve a specific philosophy: “Slowly made, rightly shared.” The families moved their lives to Stroudsburg to ensure that the craftsmanship of their ancestors wouldn’t become a lost art, choosing a location that bridged the gap between the rugged Pocono mountains and the gentle traditions of the Pennsylvania Dutch. Every wheel of cheese and hand-stitched apron in the store is a chapter of that ongoing journey.

Heritage Hearth Amish Market