Recent Posts

Sourdough and Slow Living: Inside Florence’s Newest Culinary Obsession

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Market

The Slow Rise of Dough: Miller’s Country Market Brings Amish Tradition to the Pee Dee

FLORENCE, SC – In a city known for its medical prowess and bustling interstate commerce, the concept of “slow food” often feels like a luxury reserved for fine dining. But as of this week, the slowest food in town—bread that rises for 12 hours and butter churned by hand—is being served up on West Palmetto Street.

Miller’s Country Market, a sprawling new bakery and bulk food store located at 2650 West Palmetto Street, officially opened its doors on Monday. The response was immediate. By 8:00 AM, the line snaked out the front door, past the handcrafted rocking chairs for sale, and into the parking lot.

The market fills a unique void in Florence’s culinary landscape. While the Pee Dee region has its share of barbecue joints and Southern meat-and-threes, authentic Pennsylvania Dutch baking has been noticeably absent. The Miller family, who relocated from Holmes County, Ohio, earlier this year, aims to change that.

A Sensory Experience

Walking into Miller’s Country Market is an exercise in sensory nostalgia. The industrial hum of Florence’s traffic fades the moment the heavy cedar doors close behind you. The air inside is thick and warm, carrying the distinct, sweet perfume of yeast, caramelized brown sugar, and savory spices.

The interior is simple but striking. Exposed wooden beams run the length of the ceiling, and the lighting is soft and golden. There are no neon signs, no digital menu boards, and perhaps most jarringly for a modern retail space, no background pop music. The soundtrack is the rhythmic chopping of vegetables from the open deli kitchen and the low murmur of conversation.

“We wanted a place that felt like a pause button,” says Caleb Miller, the family patriarch, wiping flour from his hands as he restocked a shelf of apple butter. “In Ohio, the market is the center of the community. It’s where you get your news and your nourishment. We want to be that for Florence.”

The Menu: Comfort in Bulk

The market is divided into three main sections: the bakery, the deli, and the bulk food aisles.

The bakery is the undisputed star of the show. The glass cases are lined with rows of Glazed Donuts, colloquially known as “fry cakes,” which are nearly double the size of their commercial counterparts. But the item that has already sparked a social media frenzy is the Cinnamon Roll.

cinnamon roll

These rolls are colossal—easily six inches in diameter—spiraled with generous amounts of cinnamon and drowned in a caramel-cream cheese frosting that is applied while the dough is still steaming hot.

“I bought one for breakfast and didn’t need to eat again until dinner,” laughed Sarah Jenkins, a nurse at nearby McLeod Regional Medical Center. “It’s heavy, it’s sweet, and it’s arguably the best thing I’ve put in my mouth in years.”

Beyond the sweets, the bakery produces loaves of bread that are dense and substantial. The Jalapeño Cheddar Sourdough has quickly become a favorite, offering a sharp, spicy kick that pairs perfectly with the deli’s offerings.

The deli counter in the back serves up made-to-order sandwiches on that fresh-baked bread. The “Florence Farmhouse” sandwich is a local nod, stacking thick-cut roasted turkey, sharp cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and a house-made sweet pepper relish that adds a tangy crunch.

The Bulk Aisles: A Baker’s Paradise

For home cooks, the center of the store is a treasure trove. The bulk food aisles are lined with clear bins filled with everything from six different types of flour to soup mixes, dried fruits, and spices.

The pricing is aggressive, often undercutting local grocery chains, but the draw is the freshness. The spices, repackaged from large Amish distributors, smell potent and vibrant. A bag of cinnamon here smells like Christmas morning, a far cry from the dusty jars often found in supermarket aisles.

The shelves are also stocked with jarred goods that read like a tour of a country pantry: Pickled Beets, Chow-Chow, Peach Habanero Jam, and the mysterious “Traffic Jam,” a blend of strawberries, cherries, and cranberries that is surprisingly addictive.

Amish donuts
Amish donuts

Community Embrace

Despite being open for less than a week, the community has embraced the new arrival with open arms—and empty stomachs.

Local food bloggers and Google Reviewers have been quick to weigh in.

“Finally, somewhere to get real, honest food in Florence. The deli meat is sliced paper-thin just how I like it, and the staff is incredibly polite. It’s a bit of a culture shock to see the bonnets and suspenders right next to the Magnolia Mall, but the food speaks for itself. Do not leave without a fry pie.” — Jason T., Google Local Guide

“I stopped in just to look and left with $50 worth of spices and a Shoofly Pie. The pie is exactly like my grandmother used to make in Pennsylvania. The wet bottom is perfect—gooey molasses and a crumbly top. This place is dangerous for my waistline.” — Amanda R., Facebook Review

One particular review highlighted the service, a hallmark of the Amish business model.

“It was packed, shoulder-to-shoulder, but the young lady at the register was so patient. She wrapped my bread like it was a gift. In a world where customer service is dying, this place is a breath of fresh air.” — Review from ‘PeeDeeEats’

Looking Ahead

The Miller family admits they are still adjusting to the South Carolina heat (“It’s a different kind of humidity down here,” Caleb jokes), but they are committed to putting down roots. Plans are already in the works to expand the outdoor seating area to include a covered pavilion for spring picnics.

For now, they are just trying to keep up with the demand for cinnamon rolls. As of 10:00 AM on Wednesday, the “Sold Out” sign was already taped to the bakery case, a testament to Florence’s hunger for a taste of the simple life.

Miller’s Country Market

Address: 2650 West Palmetto Street, Florence, SC 29501

Hours: Monday – Friday 8am – 6pm; Saturday 8am – 4pm; Closed Sunday.

Must-Try Items: Colossal Cinnamon Rolls, Jalapeño Cheddar Sourdough, Traffic Jam Preserves, Roast Beef Deli Sandwich.

Miller's Country market

Sun, Sand, and Shoofly Pie: A Guide to Florida’s Unique Amish Oasis

Written by Dennis Regling in Other States

When travelers dream of Florida, they typically envision neon-lit boardwalks, mouse-eared theme parks, and crowded beaches. They rarely picture black-brimmed hats, three-wheeled bicycles, and the aroma of pot roast simmering in a kitchen that feeds thousands. Yet, Sarasota is home to one of the most unique cultural enclaves in the American South: Pinecraft.

Pinecraft is often jokingly referred to as the “Amish Las Vegas,” not because of gambling or nightlife, but because it is the premier vacation destination for Plain people from Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Indiana. Here, the strict rules of the north often relax slightly under the subtropical sun. It is a place where snowbirds trade buggies for tricycles and heavy coats for suspenders and short sleeves.

For the “English” (non-Amish) visitor, Pinecraft offers a culinary escape that stands in stark contrast to the seafood shacks and fusion grills of the coast. The businesses here are legendary for their portions, their prices, and a commitment to scratch-made quality that has survived generations.

Here are three popular Amish businesses in Sarasota, Florida, that define this sunny slice of the simple life.

1. Yoder’s Restaurant & Amish Village

If Pinecraft has a heart, Yoder’s is undoubtedly its beat. Established in 1975 by Levi and Amanda Yoder, this establishment began as a small takeout window and has exploded into a sprawling campus that includes a gift shop, a produce market, and a restaurant that serves over 1,500 people on a busy day.

Yoder’s is not just a place to eat; it is a logistical marvel. The line frequently wraps around the building, filled with a mix of hungry locals, sunburned tourists, and Amish families conversing in Pennsylvania Dutch. The interior is decorated with homey, country kitsch—quilts on the walls and sturdy wooden tables—but the focus is entirely on the plate.

Florida’s Unique Amish Oasis

The menu is a testament to farm-style endurance. The fried chicken is the gold standard in Sarasota—crispy, golden, and pressure-cooked to lock in juices. The roast beef is slow-cooked until it falls apart, served alongside mashed potatoes that are unapologetically rich with butter. However, the true icon of Yoder’s is the pie case. Towering slices of Coconut Cream, Chocolate Peanut Butter, and seasonal Strawberry Rhubarb are less “dessert” and more “architectural feat.”

Address: 3434 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34239

What the Locals Say:

The fanaticism for Yoder’s pies is well-documented. One long-time patron shared on a local food forum:

“You don’t go to Yoder’s for a light snack. You go there to hurt yourself in the best possible way. The fried chicken is the best in the state, no contest. But the peanut butter pie? It’s life-changing. It’s like eating a cloud made of peanut butter and happiness. If the line is long, just wait. It moves fast and it is worth every second.”

Another review from a vacationer noted:

“We felt like we were sitting in someone’s grandmother’s kitchen. It’s loud, it’s busy, and the servers are running around constantly, but they still make you feel welcome. And the portions are massive. My husband ordered the roast beef and we had leftovers for two days.”

Florida’s Unique Amish Oasis

2. Der Dutchman

Just down the road from Yoder’s sits its primary “rival” in the world of comfort food: Der Dutchman. Part of the larger Dutchman Hospitality Group based in Ohio, the Sarasota location is a massive, two-story structure that feels less like a village restaurant and more like a temple to the buffet.

While Yoder’s offers a cozy, frantic energy, Der Dutchman offers sweeping hospitality. The building sits atop a hill, offering views of the surrounding neighborhood from its banquet rooms. The draw here is the sheer variety. The bakery on the ground floor is a destination in itself, pumping out thousands of donuts, long johns, and loaves of bread daily.

Florida’s Unique Amish Oasis

But the main event is the upstairs buffet. It is a “barn-raising” style feast available to the public. The salad bar is crisp and extensive, but the hot bars are where the magic happens. Trays are constantly refilled with broasted chicken, roast turkey, stuffing, creamy noodles, and vegetables that are often cooked with enough bacon to qualify as a meat dish. It is the closest thing to a traditional Amish wedding feast that an outsider can experience without an invitation.

Address: 3713 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34232

What the Locals Say:

Fans of Der Dutchman often cite the consistency and the salad bar as major draws. A review on TripAdvisor captures the sentiment:

“This is our go-to spot when we miss home cooking. It’s basically Thanksgiving dinner every single day of the year. The salad bar is always fresh and clean, which I appreciate, but the noodles are the star. They are thick and chewy and soaked in chicken broth. It’s comfort food on a massive scale.”

A frequent visitor from Ohio mentioned:

“It feels just like the locations back home in Walnut Creek, but with palm trees outside. The view from the upstairs dining room is great. It’s huge, so even when it’s busy, you don’t feel as cramped as you do at other places. And do not leave without a box of donuts from the bakery downstairs.”

Der Dutchman fried chicken

3. Big Olaf Creamery

After a heavy meal of fried chicken and stuffing, the Pinecraft tradition dictates a walk to Big Olaf Creamery. Located right in the thick of the neighborhood, Big Olaf is a throwback to a simpler era of dessert.

Florida’s Unique Amish Oasis

While Big Olaf ice cream is distributed throughout the area, the Pinecraft location offers the quintessential experience. It is a cash-only establishment, a detail that adds to its vintage charm (though an ATM is available for the unprepared). The scent of freshly pressed waffle cones wafts out to the sidewalk, luring in pedestrians.

The ice cream itself is known for its high butterfat content, making it denser and creamier than standard commercial brands. Flavors range from the traditional to the eccentric, with “Kahlua Krunch” and “Trash Can” (a vanilla base loaded with various candy bar pieces) being perennial favorites. It is common to see groups of Amish teenagers and tourists alike sitting on the benches outside, racing to finish their cones before the Florida heat wins the battle.

Address: 3350 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34239

What the Locals Say:

The “cash only” and “old school” vibe are points of pride for regulars. A Google Local Guide wrote:

“An all-cash establishment in the middle of plasticville? Yes, please. This is the real deal. The waffle cones are made right in front of you. The Kahlua Krunch is uniquely their own and I haven’t found a flavor like it anywhere else. The owner is often there and he’s a character. It’s a must-visit.”

Another review highlighted the atmosphere:

“There is nothing fancy here. No gimmicks. Just incredible, high-quality ice cream. It’s the perfect place to people-watch in Pinecraft. You see the tricycles go by, you eat your butter pecan, and you relax. It’s a Sarasota institution for a reason.”

Pilgrimage to the Paunch: Why Shady Maple is an Amish Country Must-Visit

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Restaurants

The Belly of the Beast: Experience the Shady Maple Phenomenon

If there is a golden rule for visiting Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, it is this: If you leave Shady Maple hungry, it is entirely your own fault.

Located in East Earl, amidst the rolling farmland of Amish Country, Shady Maple is not merely a restaurant; it is a destination. To call it a “buffet” feels like an understatement. It is a sprawling complex comprising the Shady Maple Smorgasbord—widely cited as the largest buffet in the United States—and the Shady Maple Farm Market, a grocery store that rivals any high-end supermarket in quality and sheer volume.

For tourists and locals alike, a trip to Shady Maple is a rite of passage. Here is what you need to know before you grab a tray.

The Smorgasbord: 200 Feet of Food

Shady Maple

The crown jewel of the complex is the Smorgasbord. The statistics are staggering: the buffet line stretches over 200 feet, featuring multiple grilling stations, carving blocks, and dessert islands.

The cuisine is unapologetically Pennsylvania Dutch. While you can find standard American fare like burgers and pizza, the real draw is the comfort food. We’re talking about dried beef gravy over biscuits, buttered noodles, ham balls, fried chicken that rivals any southern recipe, and scrapple (a regional breakfast staple that is better tasted than explained).

The breakfast buffet is particularly legendary, featuring made-to-order omelets, pancakes, and piles of thick-cut bacon. If you visit for dinner, check the daily specials—Seafood Night and Prime Rib Night are local favorites that draw massive crowds. And don’t skip the dessert bar, where shoofly pie, whoopie pies, and warm apple dumplings await.

Pro Tip: If you visit on your birthday (with valid ID) and bring a paying adult, your meal is free. It is arguably the most popular birthday club in Pennsylvania.

The Farm Market: A Baker’s Paradise

While the Smorgasbord gets the glory, the Farm Market downstairs is the unsung hero. It is a full-service grocery store, but “supermarket” doesn’t quite capture the vibe. It feels like an oversized country store.

The bakery alone is worth the trip. Shady Maple donuts are iconic—yeast-raised, massive, and generously glazed. You will also find an endless variety of fry pies, sticky buns, and artisan breads. The produce section is stocked with local fruits and vegetables from neighboring farms, and the meat department features high-quality cuts and house-made sausages.

Beneath the market lies a sprawling gift shop (the “Gift Shop at Shady Maple”), offering everything from authentic Amish quilts and furniture to kitschy souvenirs and home decor.

The Amish Country Context

Shady Maple

It is important to note that while Shady Maple is a commercial powerhouse, it operates with PA Dutch values at its core. The efficiency is marvel-worthy; despite seating over a thousand people, the lines move fast, and the service is impeccable. Furthermore, in keeping with local tradition, the entire complex is closed on Sundays.

Whether you are a serious foodie, a family looking to feed a small army, or a traveler curious about Pennsylvania Dutch culture, Shady Maple delivers an experience of abundance that you won’t soon forget. Just remember to wear your stretchy pants.

Amish “Marry Me” Chicken Casserole

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Recipes

Amish “Marry Me” Chicken Casserole

This casserole is rich, creamy, and has a wonderful tang from the sun-dried tomatoes (which you can find in the bulk food aisle at the dry goods store).

  • Prep Time: 20 mins
  • Cook Time: 30 mins
  • Total Time: 50 mins
  • Servings: 8 hearty portions

Ingredients:

  • The Noodles: 6 cups of cooked medium egg noodles (Homemade is best, but a bag from the store works just fine).
  • The Meat: 2 ½ cups chopped cooked chicken (This is perfect for using up leftover Sunday roast chicken, or you can use 2 pints of canned chicken, drained).
  • The Sauce:
    • 4 tablespoons butter (we prefer real butter, not margarine)
    • 1 medium yellow onion, finely chopped (replaces the shallots)
    • 1 tablespoon minced garlic
    • ¼ cup all-purpose flour
    • 1 ½ cups chicken broth (or water mixed with good chicken base)
    • 1 cup whole milk
    • ½ cup heavy cream
    • 1 teaspoon dried thyme (or poultry seasoning if that’s what you have)
    • ½ teaspoon salt (more to taste)
    • ½ teaspoon black pepper
    • ⅔ cup sun-dried tomatoes, drained of oil and chopped rough
    • Dash of red pepper flakes (optional, if you like a little heat)
  • The Cheese: ¾ cup grated Parmesan cheese
  • The Topping: ½ cup crushed Ritz crackers or buttery breadcrumbs mixed with the remaining cheese.

Instructions:

  1. Get the Oven Ready: Preheat your oven to 350°F (180°C). Grease a standard 9×13 casserole dish or a 2-quart baking dish with a little butter.
  2. Cook the Noodles: Boil a large pot of salted water. Cook your egg noodles until they are al dente (just a little bit firm). If you are using fresh homemade noodles, this will only take a few minutes. Drain them well and set them aside.
  3. Start the Roux: In a large skillet or dutch oven, melt the butter over medium heat. Add the chopped onion and cook until it’s soft and see-through, usually about 3-4 minutes. Stir in the garlic, thyme, and red pepper flakes (if using) and cook for just another minute until it smells wonderful.
  4. Make it Thick: Sprinkle the flour over the onions and butter. Stir constantly for about 2 minutes to cook out the raw flour taste. It will look like a thick paste.
  5. Create the Cream Sauce: Slowly pour in the chicken broth while whisking so you don’t get lumps. Then add the milk and cream. Stir in the chopped sun-dried tomatoes. Let it bubble gently until it thickens up into a nice gravy (about 5 minutes). Taste it and add your salt and pepper.
  6. Mix it All Up: Remove the skillet from the heat. Stir in ½ cup of the Parmesan cheese until melted. Add your cooked chicken and the drained noodles right into the sauce and toss until everything is coated well.
  7. Bake: Pour the mixture into your greased casserole dish. In a small bowl, mix the crushed crackers with the remaining ¼ cup of Parmesan cheese. Sprinkle this over the top of the casserole.
  8. Finish: Bake uncovered for 25-30 minutes, or until the sauce is bubbly and the cracker topping is golden brown. Let it sit for 5-10 minutes before serving so the sauce sets up a bit.

Kitchen Notes:

  • Vegetables: If you want to stretch this meal further, you can stir in a cup of frozen peas or cooked green beans before baking.
  • Leftovers: This warms up beautifully the next day for lunch, though the noodles might soak up a bit more of the sauce.

The Slow Food Movement Finds a Home in Salisbury: Dutch Country Kettle Opens its Doors

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Restaurants

SALISBURY, MD – On a stretch of North Salisbury Boulevard usually defined by the frantic pace of beach traffic and chain restaurants, a new sign has caused drivers to tap their brakes in curiosity. The neon glare of fast-food arches has been interrupted by a simple, hand-lettered sign featuring a horse-drawn buggy and a promise: “Authentic Family Recipes.”

This is the home of The Dutch Country Kettle, a newly opened Amish-style restaurant at 2300 N Salisbury Blvd, occupying the space that formerly housed a generic buffet. But the similarities end at the building’s footprint. Inside, the carpet has been replaced with wide-plank floors, the plastic booths swapped for sturdy oak tables, and the atmosphere transformed from frantic to serene.

The arrival of The Dutch Country Kettle marks a significant culinary shift for Wicomico County. While the Eastern Shore is famous for its blue crabs and fried chicken, the distinct, hearty flavors of Pennsylvania Dutch cooking have largely been absent—until now.

A Bridge Across the Bay

The restaurant is the brainchild of the Stoltzfus family, who relocated from Lancaster County, PA, earlier this year to bring their traditions to the Delmarva Peninsula.

“We saw a hunger here,” says Samuel Stoltzfus, the family patriarch who can often be found manning the carving station during the dinner rush. “People in Salisbury appreciate good food. They know what fresh corn tastes like. They know good chicken. We just cook it a little differently.”

That difference is evident the moment you walk through the double oak doors. The air is thick with the scent of browned butter, sage, and yeast. There is no background music—no pop hits or country twang. The soundtrack is the clatter of silverware and the hum of conversation, a deliberate choice to encourage fellowship over distraction.

The Dutch Country Kettle

The Menu: Comfort in Every Bite

While The Dutch Country Kettle offers a standard menu, the centerpiece of the experience is the “Harvest Table” Buffet. It is an impressive spread that prioritizes quality over sheer, overwhelming quantity.

The star of the show is, undeniably, the Broasted Chicken. Unlike the heavy, battered fried chicken typical of the South, the Amish style is pressure-fried. The result is a golden-brown skin that is impossibly crisp and thin, shattering to reveal meat that is incredibly juicy and lightly seasoned.

“I’ve lived on the Shore my whole life, and I thought I knew fried chicken,” says Martha Lewis, a Salisbury resident dining with her grandchildren. “This is different. It’s not greasy. You can taste the chicken, not just the breading. I might be a convert.”

Sitting next to the chicken are trays of Roast Beef, cooked low and slow until it shreds at the touch of a fork, swimming in a rich, dark gravy that demands to be poured over the Brown Butter Mashed Potatoes.

But the real surprises are found in the side dishes. The Dried Corn—a PA Dutch staple where corn kernels are dried, reconstituted, and simmered in cream and butter—offers a nutty, caramelized sweetness that is entirely unique. The Buttered Noodles are thick, uneven, and homemade, tossed simply with parsley and browned butter.

The Bakery: Leave Room for Dessert

It is effectively a rule that one cannot leave an Amish restaurant without visiting the bakery, and The Dutch Country Kettle enforces this rule strictly. The bakery counter, located near the entrance, acts as both a greeting and a farewell temptation.

The Whoopie Pies are the size of saucers. While the classic chocolate with vanilla cream is the bestseller, the seasonal Pumpkin with Cream Cheese Filling has already developed a cult following.

“I came in for lunch and left with three dozen whoopie pies for my office,” reads a Google review from local real estate agent Mark D. “I’m pretty sure I secured a promotion just by bringing these in. The cake is so moist it sticks to your fingers.”

For those seeking a slice of history, the Wet-Bottom Shoofly Pie is a must. The sticky, molasses-rich bottom layer contrasts perfectly with the crumbly, brown sugar topping. It is a dessert that was invented to survive long winters without fresh fruit, but it tastes like pure luxury.

Dutch Country Kettle
Dutch Country Kettle

Favorite Menu Items:

  • Broasted Chicken: Crisp, pressure-fried, and juicy.
  • Amish Pot Roast: Slow-cooked beef served with carrots, onions, and potatoes.
  • Buttered Noodles: Thick, homemade egg noodles.
  • Peanut Butter Cream Pie: A rich, whipped peanut butter filling in a flaky crust.

A Different Kind of Atmosphere

The service at The Dutch Country Kettle is as distinct as the food. The waitstaff, dressed in traditional plain clothing, move with a quiet, practiced efficiency. There is no rushing. Water glasses are refilled before they are empty, and plates are cleared with a smile, but the interaction is gentle and polite.

“It’s the calmest place in Salisbury,” says Greg Thompson, a student at Salisbury University. “My roommates and I come here during finals week. You eat some pot roast, you eat some apple dumplings, and your stress just kind of melts away. It’s cheaper than therapy and tastes better.”

The restaurant also features a small retail section selling bulk foods—spices, jams, and pickled vegetables. Jars of Chow-Chow (a tangy vegetable relish) and Beet Eggs (hard-boiled eggs pickled in beet juice) line the shelves, offering a way to take the flavors home.

Community Reaction

The response from the Salisbury community has been overwhelmingly positive. In its opening month, lines have frequently wrapped around the building on Friday and Saturday nights.

“Finally, a place where ‘homemade’ actually means homemade. The green beans taste like they were snapped this morning. And the price? You can feed a family of four for under $60 and have leftovers. This is exactly what Salisbury needed.” — Sarah J., Yelp Review

“I drove past three times before I finally stopped. Now I’m here twice a week. The breakfast buffet is a game changer—the sticky buns are warm and the size of my head.” — Comment from the “What’s Happening in Salisbury” Facebook Group

The Slow Food Movement Finds a Home in Salisbury: Dutch Country Kettle Opens its Doors
Dutch Country Kettle Opens its Doors

The Verdict

The Dutch Country Kettle is more than just a novelty; it is a return to basics. In a world of fusion cuisine and deconstructed plates, there is something profoundly comforting about a scoop of mashed potatoes that tastes like potatoes and butter. The Stoltzfus family has brought a slice of Lancaster County to the Eastern Shore, and based on the crowds, Salisbury is more than ready to pull up a chair.

The Dutch Country Kettle

Address: 2300 N Salisbury Blvd, Salisbury, MD 21801

Hours: Monday – Saturday, 7:00 AM – 8:00 PM (Closed Sundays)

Phone: (410) 555-0199

Dutch Country Kettle

The 5:00 AM Club: Why Early Risers Flock to Middlefield’s Amish Country Market

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Bakery

The New Heart of Geauga County: A Taste of Tradition at The Amish Country Market

MIDDLEFIELD, OH – The morning fog still clings to the cornfields along Route 87 as the first buggies clip-clop their way toward town. It is 5:00 AM in Middlefield, the center of the world’s fourth-largest Amish settlement, and while most of Northeast Ohio is still hitting the snooze button, the lights are already blazing at 15711 West High Street. Inside, a symphony of flour, yeast, and sugar is reaching its crescendo.

This is The Amish Country Market, a destination that has rapidly transformed from a simple roadside stop into a culinary cornerstone of Geauga County. While the area is dotted with cheese co-ops and bulk food stores, The Amish Country Market offers something distinctly different: a fusion of traditional Amish baking, modern comfort food innovation, and an atmosphere that feels less like a grocery store and more like a community living room.

A Fresh Approach to Tradition

For years, visitors to Middlefield expected a certain “script” from their Amish country experience: buy a block of Swiss cheese, grab a fry pie, and head home. The Amish Country Market, however, flips the script. Housed in a spacious, welcoming building on the main drag of West High Street, the market is a testament to the entrepreneurial spirit of owner Danny Kuhns and his team.

What started as a mobile venture—a humble food truck trailer serving pretzels—has blossomed into a brick-and-mortar emporium that houses three distinct culinary experiences under one roof: The Pretzel Bar, Elliott’s Ice Cream, and a full-service Amish Bakery.

Walking through the double doors, the first thing that hits you is the smell. It isn’t just the singular scent of baking bread; it is a complex, layered aroma of caramelizing sugar, frying dough, and the savory tang of grilled chorizo. It is the scent of “homemade” amplified to an industrial scale, yet retaining that specific warmth that only comes from hands-on preparation.

Middlefield’s Amish Country Market

The Pretzel Bar: A Twist on the Classic

While the market offers many delights, the undeniable anchor of the operation is The Pretzel Bar. If you think you know what a soft pretzel tastes like based on mall food court experiences, you are in for a startling re-education.

The pretzels here are born from a unique family recipe that emphasizes a lighter, fluffier interior enclosed in a perfectly golden, slightly chewy skin. They are hand-rolled and twisted daily, ensuring that no two are exactly alike—a hallmark of artisan quality. But where The Amish Country Market truly innovates is in how they utilize this dough.

The menu features “Pretzel Wraps,” a concept that has developed a cult following among the local workforce and visiting tourists alike. Imagine a breakfast sandwich where the biscuit or bagel is replaced by fresh, warm pretzel dough wrapped around farm-fresh eggs, cheese, and meats. The result is a portable pocket of comfort that is simultaneously savory, slightly salty, and buttery soft.

“The Chorizo Wrap is the sleeper hit,” says Mark Miller, a delivery driver from Chardon who stops by twice a week. “It’s got that little bit of spice from the sausage, but the pretzel dough soothes it out. It’s the best breakfast in the county, hands down.”

For purists, the classic cinnamon sugar pretzel remains a best-seller. Dipped in real butter and coated generously in a cinnamon-sugar blend, it bridges the gap between snack and dessert.

The Amish Country Market

The Bakery: The 5:00 AM Standard

In Middlefield, baking is a serious business. The competition is stiff, with generations of family recipes floating around the community. The Amish Country Market has carved out its niche by focusing on freshness that borders on obsessive.

The donut case is the first stop for the early morning crowd. These are not factory-stamped donuts. They are large, irregular, and boast the distinct “fry ring” that marks a perfectly proofed yeast donut. The glaze is applied while the donuts are still hot, creating a delicate, crackling shell that gives way to an airy interior.

“You have to get there early for the apple fritters,” advises Sarah Jenkins, a local resident and frequent patron. “They are the size of a catcher’s mitt and loaded with actual apple chunks, not just filling. By 9:00 AM, they are usually gone.”

Beyond donuts, the bakery produces loaves of bread that recall a time before preservatives. The white bread is soft enough to compress into a dough ball but sturdy enough for a heavy sandwich. The cinnamon swirl bread, often sold still warm in the bag, needs nothing more than a toaster and a pat of butter to become a gourmet meal.

Elliott’s Ice Cream: A Sweet Expansion

Recognizing that man cannot live on bread alone, The Amish Country Market integrated Elliott’s Ice Cream into its operations, making it a year-round destination for frozen treats. This isn’t just a freezer in the corner; it’s a full-service dip shop offering hard scoops, sundaes, and their famous ice cream cakes.

The synergy between the bakery and the ice cream shop is where the magic happens. Visitors can order a “donut sundae”—a fresh glazed donut split open and filled with a scoop of butter pecan or vanilla bean, topped with hot fudge. It is an exercise in decadence that has become a bucket-list item for foodies exploring Geauga County.

During the sweltering Ohio summers, the market becomes an oasis. Families crowd the tables, enjoying hand-spun milkshakes made with real milk and generous scoops of ice cream, offering a cool respite after a day of touring the local furniture shops and antique malls.

The Amish Country Market

More Than Just Food

While the calories are the main draw, The Amish Country Market has evolved into a true general store. The retail space is lined with products that showcase the craftsmanship and agricultural prowess of the surrounding community.

Shelves are stocked with bulk foods—spices, soup mixes, and baking supplies—packaged simply and priced fairly. You can find jars of locally tapped maple syrup, a staple of the Geauga County economy, alongside pickled beets, chow-chow, and vividly red strawberry jams.

Outside, the market showcases another pillar of the Amish economy: poly furniture. Rows of colorful, indestructible Adirondack chairs and patio sets line the storefront. Made from recycled plastics but designed to look like painted wood, these pieces are built to survive Northeast Ohio winters and have become a popular souvenir for visitors looking to take a piece of the “simple life” home to their suburban patios.

The market also features a rotating selection of seas onal items. In the spring, the front walk is bursting with hanging baskets and bedding plants. In the fall, it transforms into a harvest display of pumpkins, mums, and cornstalks.

The Service Ethos

Perhaps the most defining characteristic of The Amish Country Market is the atmosphere. In an interview with the Geauga County Maple Leaf, owner Danny Kuhns emphasized that the act of service is just as important as the quality of the product. “If (customers) have a bad day, they can walk out feeling better,” he stated.

This philosophy is palpable. The staff, a mix of Amish and non-Amish employees, operate with a quiet, friendly efficiency. There is a lack of urgency that is refreshing; transactions are not rushed, and conversations about the weather or the roads are commonplace. It is a place where “How are you?” is an actual question, not just a greeting.

Reviews on social media frequently mention this hospitality. “The staff is so polite and quiet. It’s a nice break from the noise of the world,” wrote one reviewer. Another noted, “I dropped my ice cream cone right after paying—total klutz move. They replaced it instantly with a smile and didn’t charge me. That’s rare these days.”

The Verdict

The Amish Country Market is more than just a grocery store or a bakery; it is a successful bridge between the traditional Amish lifestyle and the modern consumer’s desire for authentic, high-quality experiences. It honors the heritage of Middlefield while offering products—like the chorizo pretzel wrap or the bubble tea now available at The Pretzel Bar station—that appeal to contemporary tastes.

For the traveler driving through Northeast Ohio, seeing the sign for 15711 West High Street is a signal to hit the brakes. Whether you are in search of a 5:00 AM coffee and donut, a hearty pretzel lunch, or a gallon of premium ice cream, this market delivers with a consistency and warmth that keeps the parking lot full and the bell on the door ringing.

The Amish Country Market

Address: 15711 West High Street, Middlefield, OH 44062 Phone: 440-313-6230

Hours: Monday – Friday, 5:00 AM – 4:00 PM; Saturday, 5:00 AM – 3:00 PM (Closed Sundays)

Must-Try Items: Chorizo Pretzel Wrap, Apple Fritter, Cinnamon Sugar Pretzel, Hand-Dipped Ice Cream.