Wait, There’s Amish Country in Maryland? Inside St. Mary’s Best Kept Secret

Slower Paces and Hidden Treasures: The Ultimate Maryland Amish Country Day Trip

While many people flock to Lancaster, Pennsylvania for a taste of the Plain life, a vibrant, thriving, and authentically “daughter” settlement is tucked away in the scenic farmlands of Southern Maryland. A day trip to St. Mary’s County offers a more peaceful, intimate experience than its famous Pennsylvania counterpart, where you can drive backroads, purchase impeccable handicrafts, and taste legendary baked goods—all while dodging the heavy tourist crowds.

Centered primarily around the towns of Mechanicsville and Charlotte Hall, the St. Mary’s Amish community was founded in 1940 by families looking to preserve their traditional ways. Today, it is a bustling community of over 1,000 people across eight church districts. Farms dotted with tobacco and corn line the lanes, and the distinctive Lancaster-grey buggies—often looking slightly “squatter” with small back windows—are a common sight.

Here is how to plan the perfect day trip back in time.

---

savoring the flavor: legendary baked goods

Finding a massive, sit-down “Amish Restaurant” in rural St. Mary’s County can be a challenge; the community’s focus is on home and farm. However, their contribution to the Maryland culinary scene is legendary, particularly through bakeries and farmers’ markets. Your first priority must be to seek out their baked goods.

Favorite Items: The undisputed champions are the freshly baked donuts. They are yeast-rising, massive, light as a feather, and glazed to perfection. You must also try a traditional Shoofly Pie, a deep-dish molasses crumb cake, or Whoopie Pies—soft chocolate cake discs with a fluffy marshmallow filling.

---

shopping the bounty: farm markets & master craftsmanship

Amish commerce in St. Mary’s is incredibly diverse, ranging from small roadside stands to large furniture showrooms. These are family-run operations where quality and durability are non-negotiable.

The Barns at New Market

This is a must-stop central hub. While not entirely Amish-run, it features many Amish vendors, especially on Saturdays. It’s a perfect microcosm of the county’s agriculture and crafts.

• Address: 29133 Thompson Corner Rd, Mechanicsville, MD 20659
• Favorite Items: Stock up on Walnut Creek meats and cheeses, specialty grains in bulk, hand-dipped candles, and seasonal, non-GMO produce.

Roadside Discoveries & Master Crafts

For the truest experience, drive the back roads (like Route 236) and look for simple, hand-painted signs at farm entrances. These are the hearts of local business.

• Quilt Shop: You can find masterfully hand-stitched quilts that represent hundreds of hours of labor.
  • Address: 27744 Thompson Corner Rd, Mechanicsville, MD 20659
• Loveville Leather: For incredible, durable leather harnesses, belts, and tack.
  • Address: 40625 Parsons Mill Road, Leonardtown, MD 20650

---

seeing the sights: scenic drives and auctions

Sightseeing here is a peaceful endeavor, best enjoyed through the window of a car moving at a respectful pace.

Scenic Backroads

The primary pastime is simply driving the “back loop.” Head out along Route 236 (Thompson’s Corner Road) and peel off onto Parsons Mill Road or Busy Corner Road. Be prepared to share the lane with horse-drawn buggies and farming equipment. You’ll pass beautifully maintained farmhouses, one-room schoolhouses, and lush fields.

• Tip: Remember to be respectful. It is against Amish religious beliefs to be photographed, so please do not take pictures of people, their homes, or schoolhouses without explicit permission.

Loveville Produce Auction

If your trip falls on a Monday (11 a.m.), Wednesday, or Friday (9 a.m.), you must visit the produce auction. It is a spectacle of commerce, where wholesale buyers and locals bid on massive quantities of farm-fresh fruit and vegetables. It’s loud, fast-paced, and fascinating.

• Address: 40454 Bishop Road, Loveville, MD 20656

---

what people are saying: real reviews

The draw of Maryland’s Amish country is its quiet authenticity, a sentiment echoed by those who make the journey.

“We stopped on a whim while driving downGA-236 and it was the best decision of the trip. The soft glaze donut was a revelation. The staff were so friendly, and the whole environment is wonderfully calm.”

— Review from traveler Sarah T.

“Having a place right here St. Mary’s where I can get that same quality furniture I used to travel to Pennsylvania for is a absolute game-changer for my family. My dining room table from them is a masterpiece.”

— Review from Google user Mark T.

“Loveville Leather has the best belts and leather tack. It isn’t a tourist trap; it is a real working shop where you see the craft happening right in front of you.”

— TripAdvisor user Michael R.

---

---