Known affectionately as the “Gateway to the North,” Clare, Michigan, is a familiar milestone for travelers heading toward the Upper Peninsula. But for those willing to venture just a few miles off the bustling US-127 corridor, a completely different world awaits. Surrounding the city is a thriving, peaceful Amish community, primarily centered around Colonville and Surrey Roads.
Here, the roar of highway traffic is replaced by the rhythmic clip-clop of horse-drawn buggies, and modern convenience gives way to time-honored, scratch-made craftsmanship. For families looking to unplug, slow down, and experience a slice of agricultural heritage, Clare’s Amish country offers the perfect, wholesome day trip.
A Backstory of Quiet Growth
The Amish settlement in Clare County began taking shape several decades ago as families migrated from larger, more crowded settlements in Indiana and Ohio seeking affordable farmland and a quieter pace of life. Over the years, the community has flourished, transforming the rolling Mid-Michigan landscape into a patchwork of meticulously maintained farms, towering silos, and flourishing homesteads.
Today, the Clare Amish community is deeply woven into the local fabric. While they maintain their traditional, off-the-grid lifestyle, they are welcoming to visitors. Through their roadside stands, bulk food stores, and incredible woodworking shops, they offer outsiders a chance to appreciate the profound beauty of a life lived simply and intentionally.
Your Family-Friendly Day Trip Itinerary
To get the most out of your visit, it is best to arrive early and take your time. Here is a perfect, family-approved itinerary for exploring the area:
9:00 AM: A Sweet Start on Surrey Road
Start your morning with a scenic drive down Surrey Road, keeping a respectful eye out for the iconic black buggies sharing the shoulder. Your first stop should be a local Amish bakery. While many operate as simple roadside stands at the end of farm driveways, they offer some of the best pastries in the state. Look for hand-painted signs advertising fresh baked goods. Treat the family to massive, gooey cinnamon rolls, warm fruit fry-pies, and perhaps a loaf of fresh sourdough for later.
10:30 AM: Heirloom Shopping at Benchley’s Amish Furniture & Gifts
Next, head over to Benchley’s Amish Furniture, a staple of the Clare community. While the kids might not be in the market for a dining set, the sheer craftsmanship on display is mesmerizing for all ages. The sprawling showroom features incredible, hand-hewn oak and cherry furniture, beautifully stitched traditional quilts, and a variety of smaller, handmade wooden toys and crafts that make perfect, durable souvenirs for younger travelers.
12:00 PM: Stocking Up at the Colonville Country Store
By midday, you will likely be hungry again. Navigate over to the Colonville Country Store (or one of the similar Amish-run bulk food and discount grocery stores in the area). This is a fascinating experience for the whole family. The aisles are packed with bulk spices, massive blocks of raw-milk cheese, locally tapped maple syrup, and unique old-fashioned candies. Have the deli slice up some thick hickory-smoked meats and local cheeses to pack a rustic, incredibly fresh picnic lunch.
1:30 PM: A Countryside Picnic and Greenhouse Hopping
Take your deli haul to a nearby park or a quiet scenic pull-off to enjoy a family picnic. Afterward, spend the afternoon winding through the dirt roads looking for Amish greenhouses. From late spring through early autumn, these greenhouses are bursting with vibrant hanging baskets, hardy perennials, and fresh, organic produce. It is a wonderful opportunity to chat with the local farmers and let the kids see exactly where their food comes from.
Tips for Visiting
- Bring Cash: Most traditional Amish businesses do not have electricity or card readers.
- Respect the Culture: Remember that this is a living community, not a theme park. The Amish strictly prohibit photographs of their faces, so keep the cameras pointed at the beautiful landscapes, buildings, and food instead of the people.
- Drive Safely: The speed limit drops significantly when sharing the road with horse-drawn buggies. Take your time, pass slowly and with wide clearance, and enjoy the view.
A day spent in Clare’s Amish country is more than just a shopping trip; it is a gentle reminder of the value of hard work, family, and tradition. It is the perfect detour to ground yourself before heading further North.