Slicing Into Tradition: Xenia Welcomes a Brand New Amish Deli Downtown
There is a distinct aroma that fills the air when you step inside a true, heritage-driven market—the unmistakable blend of hickory-smoked meats, sharp aged cheeses, and yeast dough rising in the back kitchen. Downtown Xenia just became a lot more delicious with the grand opening of Main Street Amish Deli, a specialty grocery and lunch spot bringing time-tested culinary traditions straight to the heart of Greene County.
The Backstory: Planting Roots in Greene County
The journey to Main Street began over a decade ago in the rolling hills of eastern Ohio, where the Troyer family ran a modest roadside produce and bakery stand. For years, their scratch-made egg noodles and slow-churned apple butter drew travelers from miles away. However, head of the household Levi Troyer always envisioned a permanent brick-and-mortar space where the community could gather over a hearty, honest meal.
When a historic storefront became available in Xenia’s revitalized downtown district, the family knew they had found their new home. Over months of quiet renovation, they transformed the space into a warm, inviting market featuring exposed brick, rough-hewn oak shelving, and a massive glass deli case packed with regional delicacies. The deli represents a bridge between rural culinary heritage and the bustling energy of downtown Xenia.
From the Deli Case: Fan Favorites
While the shelves are stocked with everything from jarred pickled peaches to house-made granolas, the real star of the show is the lunch rush. Everything is sliced to order, and the portions mirror the generosity of a traditional farmhouse table.
As you can see in the freshly prepared sandwich above, the kitchen does not skimp on the layers. Notice the perfectly even distribution of house-cured meats and crisp, local toppings—a hallmark of their focus on freshness.
A few early customer favorites include:
- The “Greene County Giant” Sandwich: A mammoth creation piled high with house-smoked turkey breast, lean ham, real colby jack cheese, crisp lettuce, tomato, and a generous smear of their signature sweet-hot mustard on thick-cut, scratch-baked multi-grain bread.
- Amish Roll-Butter Blend Potato Salad: A rich, savory side dish made with red-skin potatoes, hard-boiled eggs, and a creamy dressing enriched with authentic, slow-churned roll butter.
- Fried Blackberry Hand Pies: Flaky, lard-crust pastries packed with tart blackberry filling, glazed to perfection, and delivered fresh to the counter every morning.
Whether you are looking to restock your pantry with premium baking supplies, pick up a pound of real smoked Swiss cheese, or sit down for a lunchtime sandwich that requires two hands to hold, Main Street Amish Deli delivers an authentic taste of heritage.
Location & Hours
Address: Main Street Deli, 124 W. Main Street, Xenia, OH 45385
Hours: Monday – Saturday, 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM | Closed Sunday