The historic city of Newburgh, New York, perched majestically on the bluffs overlooking the Hudson River, is famous for its deep architectural roots, Revolutionary War landmarks, and a waterfront dining scene. But the local culinary community has just introduced a grounded, artisanal shopping experience that trades modern commercial processing for authentic, scratch-made comfort. The Hudson Valley Amish Market has officially opened its doors, bringing the slow-cured meats, fresh-churned dairy, and legendary baking traditions of traditional farming communities straight to Orange County.
Stepping through the doors provides an immediate, peaceful contrast to the nearby highways. The expansive market space features warm, hand-planed wood accents, custom-built oak display tables, classic handwritten chalkboard menus, and beautiful display shelves filled with vibrant, hand-packed preserves.
The Backstory: From the Ridge to the River
The roots of the Hudson Valley Amish Market trace back to a multi-generational family farming collective based in the rolling pastures of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. For decades, the Stoltzfus and Yoder families operated a prominent regional farmstead and a traditional, wood-fired smokehouse, renowned by travelers for their exceptional food preservation and slow-cured provisions.
The idea to establish a permanent brick-and-mortar location in Newburgh sparked after several family members spent time in the Mid-Hudson region assisting with community orchard projects. They noticed that while Hudson Valley residents possessed an incredible appreciation for local craftsmanship and historic preservation, the urban center of Newburgh lacked a direct, daily link to authentic, small-batch country foods.
Bringing the vision to life required a beautiful, cross-state collaboration. Over several months, skilled craftsmen traveled to the site to completely transform a historic brick storefront, installing massive interior timber frames and hand-pegged oak beams to replicate the interior of a traditional bank barn. The finished space stands as a beautiful, living bridge between rural agricultural heritage and Newburgh’s energetic, historic community.
Fan Favorites: What to Order
The market operates entirely without modern shortcuts, prioritizing small-batch preparation and recipes that have been closely guarded for over a century. Whether you are packing a picnic for a walk along the waterfront or gathering premium pantry staples for a weekend family feast, these signature items are absolute crowd-pleasing favorites:
- The Overstuffed Sweet Bologna Sandwich: Piled incredibly high on freshly baked potato bread, this signature sandwich features thin-shaved, sweet-and-smoky bologna, a slice of creamy colby cheese, and a generous layer of house-made sweet mustard.
- Thick-Cut Applewood Smoked Bacon: Cured slowly in old-fashioned brick smokehouses, this premium, lean bacon fries up to a perfect crisp, filling the air with a rich, unmistakable aroma.
- Aged Golden Colby Cheese: Sourced from pasture-raised dairy herds, this premium cheese is hand-pressed and naturally aged to yield an incredibly smooth, buttery texture with a sharp, comforting finish.
- Copper-Kettle Apple Butter: Slow-cooked for twelve hours in traditional open vats, this velvety, spiced spread captures the pure, concentrated essence of autumn orchards without any refined sugars.
- Hand-Glazed Cinnamon Rolls: Baked fresh every single morning, these massive, pillowy-soft pastries are layered with rich cinnamon brown sugar and smothered in a cascading vanilla bean glaze.
Beyond the deli counter, visitors can browse an extensive bulk-food section featuring hard-to-find heritage baking flours, raw wildflower honey, and hand-packed jars of traditional sweet bread-and-butter pickles.
Plan Your Visit
Whether you are stopping by to pick up a box of fresh-baked pastries for the weekend or sitting down for a restorative, handcrafted lunch, the Hudson Valley Amish Market welcomes you with unmatched hospitality and generous, comforting portions.
Location:
Hudson Valley Amish Market
140 Broadway
Newburgh, NY 12550
