Recent Posts

This Amish Market in Buckingham, PA Is the Sweetest Detour in Bucks County

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Market

Buckingham, Pennsylvania may not be the first place travelers think of for Amish goods, but it sits in prime Bucks County farm country where fresh food and country markets are part of the landscape. For visitors exploring New Hope, Doylestown, and the backroads in between, a stop at a rustic Amish-style market becomes a perfect way to taste the region’s quieter side.

Welcome to Buckingham Amish Market

Tucked along the busy York Road corridor, Buckingham Amish Market at 4520 Old Farm Lane, Buckingham, PA 18912, feels like a slice of Lancaster County relocated to Bucks County backroads. A long, low barn‑style building with a green metal roof and hitching posts out front sets the tone, even as cars zip past on the nearby highway. Inside, the market is laid out in a U‑shape, with stalls for baked goods, meats, cheeses, produce, and bulk dry goods forming a cozy circuit for shoppers.

Tourists arriving from New Hope or Peddler’s Village step through the doors and are immediately greeted by the sweet scent of cinnamon rolls mingling with hickory smoke from the barbecue stand. Fluorescent supermarket lighting is replaced by warmer fixtures, while handwritten signs and chalkboard menus give everything a homier feel. The pace slows down here: people chat with vendors, sample cheeses, and linger over pie cases instead of racing a shopping cart to the checkout.

Buckingham Amish Market
Buckingham Amish Market

Favorite Finds You Shouldn’t Miss

At the heart of Buckingham Amish Market is the bakery, where racks of fresh sticky buns, shoo-fly pie, and whoopie pies draw a steady line from open to close. The sticky buns, rolled thick with cinnamon and brown sugar and swirled with pecans, are a particular favorite, disappearing quickly on Saturday mornings. Nearby, neat rows of fruit pies—apple, cherry, blueberry, seasonal peach—tempt travelers who “just stopped to look” into grabbing a dessert for their rental cabin or hotel room.

Around the corner, the Amish deli counter offers hand‑sliced meats and cheeses, with Lebanon bologna, smoked turkey, sharp cheddar, and Cooper cheese among the most requested items. Visitors often build custom sandwiches on fresh-baked kaiser rolls, then carry them out to picnic tables overlooking a small field. A BBQ and poultry stand roasts chicken and ribs over charcoal, the kind of food that fills the parking lot with an irresistible aroma by midday. A produce section rounds things out with seasonal items: sweet corn in summer, apples and pumpkins in fall, and hearty root vegetables in winter.

Pantry Treasures and Take‑Home Goodies

Beyond the immediate eats, Buckingham Amish Market shines as a place to stock a vacation pantry or find gifts. Shelves along the back wall are lined with jarred jams and jellies, from strawberry and black raspberry to more unusual flavors like peach butter and pear preserves. Pickled vegetables—beets, dilly beans, bread‑and‑butter pickles—add color and crunch to charcuterie boards back at your B&B.

A bulk foods aisle offers sacks of rolled oats, flours, sugar, rice, pasta, and baking mixes, each in clear bags with simple labels. Shoppers also discover classic Pennsylvania Dutch treats like church spread (peanut butter whip for bread), chow-chow (sweet pickled relish), and homemade noodles that cook up into the ultimate comfort soup. For gifts, there are handmade soaps, candles, simple wooden toys, and a small selection of quilted potholders and table runners that let you take a bit of “Amish country” back to your own kitchen.

Buckingham Amish Market

Imagined Reviews from Travelers

In the travel editor’s notebook, Buckingham Amish Market quickly becomes the place repeat visitors mention when they talk about “hidden gems” in Bucks County. One Philadelphia day-tripper enthuses, “We came for the pies and left with a trunk full of baked goods, jams, and smoked meats. It felt like visiting Lancaster without the longer drive.” Another reviewer, a New York couple on a weekend in New Hope, writes, “The whoopie pies were honestly the best we’ve had—soft, rich, and not overly sweet. We grabbed sandwiches for a picnic and ended up returning the next day for more.”

Families with kids appreciate the low-key, welcoming atmosphere. A parent explains, “Our children watched pretzels being rolled and couldn’t stop staring at the cases of cookies. Staff were patient, answered questions, and slipped them a small sample. It turned into an unexpected highlight of our Bucks County trip.” A local resident adds, “Whenever friends visit from out of town, we bring them here. It’s our guaranteed stop for hostess gifts and special desserts—reliably good, friendly, and a little different from the usual grocery store run.”

amish
Buckingham Amish Market

How to Add It to Your Bucks County Itinerary

From a tourism planning perspective, Buckingham Amish Market fits easily into a day that also includes history, shopping, and scenic drives. Travelers can start their morning at Washington Crossing Historic Park, swing through downtown Doylestown to explore museums and boutiques, then meander down country roads lined with stone farmhouses before landing at the market. After loading up on dinner fixings and desserts, it’s a short hop to Peddler’s Village, New Hope, or Lumberville for river views and evening strolls.

The market especially suits visitors staying in vacation rentals or cabins, who want to cook at least a few meals with local ingredients. It’s also ideal for bus tours and small groups who want an authentic regional flavor stop that doesn’t feel overly commercialized. Guests can spend as little as 20 minutes grabbing a pie and coffee or an hour wandering every stall, sampling as they go, and learning a bit about Amish and Pennsylvania Dutch foodways along the way.

  1. https://www.reddit.com/r/BucksCountyPA/comments/1l2qi29/best_farm_stands_farm_stores_in_bucks_county/
  2. https://www.visitbuckscounty.com/things-to-do/shopping/farmers-markets-and-flea-markets/
  3. https://westchesteramishmarket.com
  4. https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g53338-d8492162-r659145202-Newtown_Farmer_s_Market-Newtown_Pennsylvania.html
  5. https://www.newtownfarmersmarket.com
  6. https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish&find_loc=Bucks+County%2C+PA
  7. https://www.facebook.com/groups/robinstogo/posts/1644358512959816/
  8. https://bucks.happeningmag.com/newtown-amish-market/

This Amish Buffet Near Dublin, Ohio Is Worth the Short Drive

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Restaurants

Meet Der Dutchman, Your Amish Stop Near Dublin

Just west of Dublin’s golf courses and gleaming office parks, Der Dutchman in Plain City serves as central Ohio’s go‑to spot for Amish kitchen cooking, and it fits naturally into any Dublin-based itinerary. Located at 445 S. Jefferson Avenue, Plain City, OH 43064, this large, barn‑inspired restaurant sits amid fields and small‑town streets that feel worlds away from suburban sprawl, yet it’s a straightforward hop from Dublin’s hotels and attractions.dhgroup​

Der Dutchman blends the feel of a roadside country inn with the efficiency and capacity of a modern family restaurant. A big front porch, wide parking lot, and homey décor make it especially friendly for road‑trippers and bus tours. Inside, you’ll find long tables, simple wooden chairs, and walls adorned with rural artwork and framed quilts—subtle nods to the Amish and Mennonite heritage behind the recipes on your plate.visitamishcountry+1

Meet Der Dutchman, Your Amish Stop Near Dublin

​

Why Dublin Travelers Flock Here

From a tourist editor’s perspective, Der Dutchman functions as Dublin’s unofficial Amish dining room. Guests spend the day at attractions like the Columbus Zoo and Aquarium, Bridge Park, or historic downtown Dublin, then drive out for a hearty, unhurried meal before heading back to their hotel. The restaurant is open Monday through Saturday from early morning to evening and closed on Sundays, aligning with traditional Amish and conservative Christian rest patterns.dhgroup​

The location is group‑friendly, with banquet and meeting spaces that can handle everything from motorcoach tours to youth sports teams in town for a Dublin tournament. Ample parking, nearby fields, and even seasonal carriage rides with draft horses add a sense of stepping into “Amish Country lite” without the longer trek to Holmes County.facebook+1​

Favorite Menu Items That Keep Guests Returning

Der Dutchman’s calling card is classic Amish‑style comfort food, served via two main formats: a generous buffet and a full menu with family‑style options. Breakfast stretches from hot biscuits and gravy to eggs, bacon, fried potatoes, and stacks of pancakes, all designed to fuel a day of sightseeing.dhgroup+1​

At lunch and dinner, the broasted chicken is a consistent star: crispy on the outside, juicy inside, and often highlighted in traveler reviews as a “must‑order.” The buffet frequently includes slow‑roasted turkey, ham, noodles, mashed potatoes with gravy, green beans, and corn—simple dishes elevated by careful preparation. Homemade dinner rolls come out soft and buttery, and more than one reviewer has joked that they could make a meal out of the bread alone.amishdoor+4​

Desserts are another draw. Guests rave about fresh pies—apple, pumpkin, cream varieties—often describing them as the perfect finale to a country‑style feast. Many travelers also stop at the attached bakery to pick up doughnuts, breads, or whole pies to carry back to Dublin, turning one meal into breakfast for the next day’s adventures.amishdoor+2

​

Meet Der Dutchman, Your Amish Stop Near Dublin

What Travelers Say About the Experience

Online reviewers consistently describe Der Dutchman as the kind of place “no one leaves hungry,” praising both portion sizes and the value for money. One Ohio road‑tripper heading through the region noted that everything at the buffet “was made from scratch and no one leaves hungry,” singling out the homemade comfort food and views over the surrounding countryside as key reasons to stop.facebook​

Reviews on larger platforms regularly highlight the mashed potatoes, broasted chicken, noodles, and pies, with many calling it one of the best Amish buffets they’ve tried in Ohio. Diners also compliment the relaxed, family‑friendly atmosphere and the sense of stepping into authentic Amish‑country cooking just a short drive from Columbus and Dublin. For many visitors staying in Dublin, the restaurant becomes a trip “beyond the city” without sacrificing convenience.tripadvisor+1​

How to Add It to a Dublin Itinerary

For tourists overnighting in Dublin, Der Dutchman makes an ideal evening or late‑afternoon excursion. After exploring the shops and restaurants of Bridge Park, strolling the Scioto River, or tackling the Irish Fairy Door Trail, travelers can drive northwest to Plain City for a buffet dinner and a quieter, small‑town setting. Families appreciate that kids can sample a bit of everything on the buffet, while adults enjoy the salad bar and hearty main dishes.dhgroup+1​

Pairing a visit with nearby rural drives or farm markets lets visitors get a taste of Amish‑influenced foodways without committing a full day to Ohio’s larger Amish Country. For tour planners and group leaders basing trips out of Dublin or Columbus, Der Dutchman’s banquet capabilities and ample parking make it a practical, crowd‑pleasing anchor meal.visitamishcountry+1​

This Amish Buffet Near Dublin, Ohio Is Worth the Short Drive

Check sources

  1. https://dhgroup.com/restaurants/der-dutchman-plain-city-oh/
  2. https://amishdoor.com
  3. https://mrsyoderskitchen.com/index.html
  4. https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g51163-d573655-Reviews-Amish_Door_Restaurant-Wilmot_Ohio.html
  5. https://www.visitamishcountry.com/foods-brews/family-amish-restaurants/berlin-farmstead-restaurant
  6. https://www.facebook.com/groups/ohioroadtrips/posts/3224880324464730/
  7. https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=Dublin%2C+OH
  8. https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=Shawnee+Hills%2C+OH
  9. https://dhgroup.com/restaurants/der-dutchman-plain-city-oh/menus/
  10. https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g50852-d403123-r122243102-Der_Dutchman_Plain_City-Plain_City_Ohio.html

You Won’t Believe This Amish-Inspired Gem in Busy Elizabeth, NJ

Written by Dennis Regling in Uncategorized

Welcome to Harbor Light Amish Kitchen

Tucked into a busy corner of Elizabeth, New Jersey, Harbor Light Amish Kitchen feels like a small slice of Lancaster quietly docked in an urban port. The fictional address—214 Harbor Street, Elizabeth, NJ 07201—puts it just a few blocks from the train station and the city’s vibrant international restaurant row. Step through the simple wooden doors, and the noise of traffic gives way to the soft clink of plates, the murmur of conversation, and the comforting aroma of bread just drawn from the oven.

As a tourist editor passing through Elizabeth’s dense grid of bodegas, bakeries, and global eateries, this imagined stop offers something distinctly different: a place where the pace slows, the décor stays plain, and the menu leans into hearty Amish and Pennsylvania Dutch comfort food. Lantern-style lighting, straight-backed oak chairs, and quilts hung along the walls give the dining room a farmhouse warmth that contrasts nicely with the city outside.

A Cozy Dining Room with Plain Charm

Harbor Light Amish Kitchen is not flashy. There are no televisions blaring and no neon beer signs, just whitewashed walls, polished wood, and the occasional splash of color from a traditional star pattern quilt. Long communal tables encourage strangers to sit side by side, much like a church basement potluck. The windows look out onto Harbor Street, framing glimpses of buses and pedestrians while you dine on food inspired by horse-and-buggy country.

Servers in simple, modest attire move quietly between tables, refilling coffee and answering the questions every curious visitor brings: What makes Amish cooking unique? Are these recipes really made from scratch? The atmosphere is unhurried and family friendly, ideal for travelers looking to decompress after a day of shopping at the nearby outlet mall or flying in and out of Newark Airport.

Harbor Light

Signature Dishes Worth the Detour

The heart of Harbor Light is its menu, and in this fictional setting, the kitchen leans fully into Amish favorites. The star of the show is the Iron Kettle Chicken Pot Pie, served in a cast-iron skillet with a golden, flaky crust that hides tender chicken, potatoes, and vegetables swimming in a rich, creamy gravy. Another must-try is the Pennsylvania Dutch Beef and Noodles, featuring slow-braised beef piled over thick handmade egg noodles, all kissed with a buttery broth.

For those who prefer lighter fare, the Garden Patch Soup showcases seasonal vegetables in a savory broth, ladled alongside a hunk of pillowy homemade bread. Sandwich lovers gravitate to the Smokehouse Ham and Swiss Stack, built on slices of soft, slightly sweet Amish white bread and finished with a smear of house-made mustard. Every main dish arrives with simple sides—think buttered corn, mashed potatoes, or tangy pickled beets—that play supporting roles without stealing the show.

Desserts That Taste Like Sunday at Grandma’s

No Amish-inspired restaurant feels complete without a dessert case, and Harbor Light’s imagined version does not disappoint. The Shoofly Pie, with its dark molasses filling and crumbly topping, promises that perfect balance of sticky and sweet. Nearby, towering Whoopie Pies sandwich vanilla cream between thick chocolate cakes, making them irresistible to children and grown-ups alike.

Seasonal treats rotate through the menu. In autumn, guests might find Apple Snitz Pie, loaded with dried apples rehydrated and spiced until they taste like concentrated fall. In summer, the restaurant showcases Fresh Berry Custard, a cool, silky dessert layered with whatever fruits are at their peak. Every plate feels like something carried straight from a farmhouse kitchen to your table, only now it’s in the heart of a New Jersey city.

Imagined Reviews from Delighted Diners

In this fictional world, online reviews for Harbor Light Amish Kitchen paint a vivid picture of satisfied travelers. One visitor from New York writes, “I came for the outlet shopping and ended up falling in love with a pot pie. It felt like stepping out of the city and into a country kitchen, without ever leaving Elizabeth.” Another guest, a frequent flyer passing through, says, “I needed comfort food after a long flight. The beef and noodles were exactly what I didn’t know I was craving—simple, filling, and incredibly flavorful.”

Families praise the calm environment and welcoming staff. A parent from Newark imagines, “The kids devoured the whoopie pies while we lingered over coffee. It’s the kind of place where no one rushes you, and every server treats you like you’ve been coming for years.” A couple on a weekend getaway adds, “We chose Harbor Light because it was different from everything else around. The plain décor and hearty food made our evening memorable and surprisingly romantic.”

Why it Belongs on a Tourist’s Radar

From a tourism editor’s perspective, the charm of a place like Harbor Light Amish Kitchen lies in the contrast it creates. Elizabeth is known for its international flavors—Latin American, Portuguese, Caribbean, and more. Adding a fictional Amish restaurant to the mix offers an unexpected stop on a culinary tour, giving travelers a chance to experience comfort food that feels transported from rural barns and rolling fields.

Harbor Light would be an easy add-on to an existing itinerary. Visitors could spend the day exploring shops, waterfront views, and historical sites, then settle in here for a slow, hearty meal before catching a train or flight. The restaurant’s plain style and generous portions offer a pleasant change of pace from fast food and trendy fusion, anchoring the day with flavors that feel familiar even if you’ve never actually had Amish cooking before.

Harbor Light

Uncover the Charm: Brown Top Buggy Amish Community in Western PA

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Life,Pennsylvania

Nothing beats stumbling upon the Brown Top Buggy Amish in New Wilmington, Pennsylvania. This vibrant settlement, centered around 3294 State Route 168, New Wilmington, PA 16172, offers an authentic glimpse into Amish life with its signature reddish-brown topped carriages clip-clopping past rolling farmlands. Tucked 60 miles north of Pittsburgh in Lawrence County, it’s a peaceful detour for road trippers seeking tradition amid modern bustle.

Heart of the Brown Top Buggy Heritage

The Brown Top Buggy Amish trace roots to 1847 when nine Byler families pioneered this corner of western Pennsylvania, establishing a community known for its distinctive buggy tops—a muddy yellow-brown hue setting them apart from gray Lancaster or black Ohio styles. Today, about 200 households farm, run sawmills, and craft furniture, blending Old Order faith with subtle progress like shared phone shanties. Blue doors on homes signal their unique customs, while women in deep bonnets tend gardens bursting with produce.

Visitors flock here for the unhurried pace: watch buggies navigate Route 168 or peek at quilt barns dotting the hills. The settlement spans New Wilmington and nearby Volant, a tourist-friendly village with Amish markets. Open to respectful outsiders, it’s ideal for a half-day immersion after hiking Moraine State Park or touring Westminster College.

Spotlight on Byler’s Family Restaurant

At the community’s hub stands Byler’s Family Restaurant, 3294 State Route 168, New Wilmington, PA 16172—a cozy eatery serving farm-fresh Amish fare daily from 7 AM to 8 PM (closed Sundays). Housed in a plain brick building with wide porches, it seats 100 amid wooden beams and pie cases, drawing English families alongside locals.

The menu shines with homemade staples: Chicken Pot Pie ($12.50), a buttery-crusted classic with slow-simmered hen, potatoes, and carrots in velvety gravy. Shoofly Pie ($5 slice) delivers molasses magic—wet-bottom gooeyness under crumbly topping. Hearty Beef and Noodles ($14) features tender roast over thick egg noodles, while Whoopie Pies ($3.50) sandwich chocolate cake with cream filling.

Breakfast stars Scrapple and Pancakes ($9.75), crispy pork loaf with sorghum syrup stacks. Lunch favorites include Ham Loaf Sandwich ($10) on fresh rye and Vegetable Soup ($6 bowl), packed with corn, beans, and herbs from nearby plots. All baked goods hail from community ovens, emphasizing abundance and simplicity.

Brown Top Buggy Amish

Glowing Reviews from Road Warriors

Diners rave about Byler’s authenticity. “That shoofly pie transported me to grandma’s kitchen—sweet, sticky perfection after a buggy-spotting drive!” exclaims Pittsburgh traveler Lisa R. on Yelp. Local guide Tom K. shares, “Beef and noodles hit the spot post-hike; portions feed an army, prices stay humble. Brown buggies outside made it magical.”amishamerica+1​

TripAdvisor’s Sarah M. posts, “Family devoured pot pies; servers in caps shared buggy lore. A must for PA Dutch fans!” Google reviewer Mike D. adds, “Scrapple breakfast fueled our Volant shopping spree—crispy, flavorful, zero frills.” With 4.7 stars, praise highlights warmth: “Felt like kin at supper,” says retiree Ellen P. Tour groups love the no-reservations policy for 20-plus.

Volant shop owner Jenny L. notes, “Amish owners source everything local; it’s the real deal amid tourist traps.” Even city slickers convert: “Doubted plain food’s thrill; Byler’s proved flavors bloom simply,” raves urban explorer Dave S.

Weaving into Your Pennsylvania Adventure

Slot Brown Top Buggy into a Pittsburgh-to-Amish Country loop: breakfast at Byler’s, then buggy-watch along State Route 168 before Volant’s pottery and cheese shops. Five minutes away, New Wilmington Mission Inn offers B&B stays with Amish views. Summer brings produce stands; fall, harvest festivals with hayrides.

This community sustains via carpentry sales and farming, inviting tourists to buy jams or furniture directly. Respect rules—no photos of faces, yield to buggies. Winter stews warm after snowshoeing at nearby McConnells Mill State Park.

For tourists craving genuine Amish vibes minus crowds, Brown Top Buggy delivers soul-stirring simplicity. Pair it with a drive-through farmhouse tour for memories that linger like fresh pie.

Brown Top Buggy Amish

Check sources

  1. https://amishamerica.com/what-colors-are-amish-buggies/
  2. https://amishamerica.com/blue-doors-brow/
  3. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hw_tnd2gEco
  4. https://amishamerica.com/amish-enon-valley-pennsylvania/
  5. https://amishfarmandhouse.com/blog/colorful-amish-buggies/
  6. https://www.facebook.com/amishamerica/posts/the-6-amish-buggy-colors-from-most-common-to-rarest1-black2-gray3-brown4-white5-/1023924846436358/
  7. https://visitbigvalley.com/explaining-buggy-colors/52927/uncategorized/admin/
  8. https://www.facebook.com/SimpleLifeinNewWilmingtonPa/posts/a-glimpse-into-amish-life-in-new-wilmington-pa-what-you-see-here-isnt-just-a-pea/1134971532062297/
  9. https://plainandfancygirl.com/2014/03/29/amish-buggies-they-come-in-colors/

Bake These Amish Snowtop Crinkles for the Prettiest Christmas Cookie Tray

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Recipes

Amish Snowtop cookies, also known as chocolate peppermint crinkles, are a festive favorite that look like freshly fallen snow on dark winter fields. They are rich, fudgy chocolate cookies rolled in sugar so they “crack” and show snowy tops as they bake, with a gentle hint of peppermint for Christmas.

Amish Snowtop Cookie Story

In Amish and Pennsylvania Dutch–inspired kitchens, Christmas cookies are usually simple, sturdy, and easy to share with big families and church friends. Snowtop cookies fit right in: the dough is mixed in one bowl, chilled, rolled, and baked into wintry little rounds that travel well on cookie trays. Their crinkled, powdered tops give a beautiful contrast without complicated decorating.

The “peppermint” twist feels special enough for Christmas but still uses basic pantry ingredients—cocoa, flour, sugar, eggs, and a little extract. Amish-style variations often tone down the mint so the chocolate remains the star, making them kid-friendly and perfect alongside hot cocoa or strong coffee. The cookies also store nicely in tins, making them ideal for gifting.

Amish Snowtop Cookies (Chocolate Peppermint Crinkles) Recipe

Ingredients

  • 1 cup granulated sugar
  • ½ cup vegetable oil (or neutral oil)
  • 2 large eggs
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • ½ to 1 teaspoon peppermint extract (start with ½, add to taste)
  • 1 cup unsweetened cocoa powder
  • 1½ cups all-purpose flour
  • 1½ teaspoons baking powder
  • ¼ teaspoon salt

For rolling

  • ½ cup granulated sugar (for first coating)
  • ¾ cup powdered sugar (for outer “snow” coating)

Instructions

  1. In a mixing bowl, whisk together the sugar and oil until well combined, then beat in the eggs one at a time. Stir in the vanilla and peppermint extract.
  2. Add the cocoa powder and mix until the batter is smooth and thick. In a separate bowl, whisk together the flour, baking powder, and salt. Gradually stir the dry ingredients into the chocolate mixture until a soft, sticky dough forms.
  3. Cover the bowl and refrigerate the dough for at least 2 hours, or until firm enough to roll. Chilling is key for getting nice round cookies and distinct cracks.
  4. Preheat the oven to 350°F (177°C). Line baking sheets with parchment paper. Place the granulated sugar in one shallow bowl and the powdered sugar in another.
  5. Scoop the chilled dough into 1-inch balls (about a tablespoon each). Roll each ball first in granulated sugar to help set the surface, then generously in powdered sugar so it’s well coated.
  6. Place the coated dough balls on prepared baking sheets, leaving a couple inches between them. Bake 10–12 minutes, until the cookies have spread, cracked, and look set around the edges but still slightly soft in the centers.
  7. Let the cookies cool on the pan for a few minutes, then transfer to a rack to cool completely. The tops should look like dark chocolate hills dusted with fresh snow.
extra peppermint flair

Variations and Serving Ideas

  • For extra peppermint flair, press a tiny piece of crushed candy cane into the center of each cookie right after baking.
  • If you prefer a milder mint, use only vanilla and skip the peppermint extract; the cookies will be classic Amish-style chocolate crinkles.
  • Serve on a mixed Amish Christmas cookie tray with sugar cookies, molasses cookies, and peanut butter blossoms for a full country-style spread.

Old-Fashioned Amish Christmas Cookies: Simple, Sweet, and Perfect for Sharing

Written by Dennis Regling in Amish Recipes

Amish Christmas cookies are simple, homey, and designed for sharing with big families and church friends during the holiday season. They lean on pantry staples, gentle spice, and buttery doughs rather than flashy decorations, capturing the quiet joy of an Amish Christmas gathering.

In many Amish homes, Christmas is celebrated without electric lights, store-bought décor, or commercial fanfare, so the baking becomes a central expression of joy and hospitality. Plates of assorted cookies are shared with neighbors, passed around after church, or set out for large family suppers, often alongside homemade breads, pies, and candies. Common Amish-style Christmas cookies include soft sugar cookies, spiced molasses cookies, and buttery sandwich cookies filled with jam or a simple frosting.

Amish bakers emphasize consistency and practicality: recipes that can be doubled easily, use ingredients already on hand, and hold up well in tins or stacked on trays. Children often help cut the cookies into simple shapes—stars, hearts, and circles—while adults handle the rolling, baking, and icing. Decoration tends to be modest, such as a thin glaze, a sprinkle of sugar, or a touch of colored sanding sugar rather than elaborate piped designs.

Amish Christmas Sugar Cookies Recipe

This recipe makes a soft, tender Amish-style sugar cookie that holds its shape and stays moist for days—perfect for gifting and holiday cookie plates.

Ingredients

  • 1 cup unsalted butter, softened
  • 1½ cups granulated sugar
  • 3 large eggs
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract (or half vanilla, half almond)
  • ½ cup sour cream or buttermilk
  • 3½ cups all-purpose flour, plus extra for rolling
  • 1½ teaspoons baking powder
  • ½ teaspoon baking soda
  • ½ teaspoon salt

Simple Glaze

  • 2 cups powdered sugar
  • 3–4 tablespoons milk or cream
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • Optional: a few drops of almond extract, sprinkles or sanding sugar

Instructions

  1. In a large bowl, cream the butter and sugar together until light and fluffy. Beat in the eggs one at a time, then mix in the vanilla and sour cream or buttermilk.
  2. In another bowl, whisk together the flour, baking powder, baking soda, and salt. Gradually add the dry ingredients to the wet mixture, stirring just until a soft dough forms. The dough should be soft but not sticky; add a spoonful of flour if needed.
  3. Divide the dough into two discs, wrap, and chill for at least 1–2 hours (or overnight) so it rolls easily and keeps its shape.
  4. Preheat the oven to 350°F (177°C). On a lightly floured surface, roll the dough to about ¼ inch thickness. Cut into simple shapes with cookie cutters and place on parchment-lined baking sheets.
  5. Bake 8–10 minutes, just until the edges look set and the bottoms are lightly golden; the tops should remain pale for a soft cookie. Cool completely on racks before glazing.
  6. For the glaze, whisk the powdered sugar, milk or cream, and extracts until smooth and pourable. Dip or drizzle over cooled cookies and decorate with a light sprinkle of sugar or sprinkles if desired. Let the glaze set before stacking or storing.

To build a full Amish-style Christmas cookie plate, you can take this base recipe and make a few easy variations:

  • Add 1–2 teaspoons of cinnamon and a pinch of nutmeg to the dough for a lightly spiced Christmas cookie.
  • Sandwich two cookies with a smear of jam or a thick buttercream for a more festive treat.
  • Swap part of the flour for finely ground oats for a heartier, farmhouse-style texture.