The gentle drone of life along the historic Erie Canal just welcomed a beautiful new melody rooted in old-world tradition. Brockport has officially become home to a spectacular new destination for lovers of fine foods and heirloom craftsmanship. Located just steps from the water, Erie Canal Amish Treasures has opened its doors, combining a fully stocked deli counter with a gorgeous showroom of handcrafted gifts, textiles, and woodcrafts.
The Backstory: Bringing Tradition to the Victorian Village
The roots of Erie Canal Amish Treasures began more than two decades ago in a tight-knit farming community in western New York. The Borntrager family was widely celebrated among neighbors for two distinct passions: their exceptionally rich, slow-smoked deli meats and their meticulous eye for hand-woven basketry and woodwork. For years, the family operated a seasonal roadside stand, dreaming of a year-round space where they could connect with a broader community.
When looking for a permanent home, the family fell in love with Brockport’s beautifully preserved Victorian architecture and its historic identity as a bustling canal port. They envisioned a warm, multi-functional mercantile where busy college students, local families, and canal travelers could step back in time.
Over several months of careful renovation, the Borntragers transformed a spacious downtown storefront into a stunning hybrid market. The left side of the shop features a gleaming, temperature-controlled deli case packed with regional delicacies, while the right side opens into an inviting showroom lined with rough-hewn pine shelving and the comforting scents of cedar and pure beeswax.
From the Counters: Early Favorites
Erie Canal Amish Treasures bridges the gap between a hearty lunchtime stop and a boutique gallery, making it incredibly easy to grab a premium sandwich and a timeless home accent in a single visit.
A few early signature favorites capturing the attention of local shoppers include:
- The “Canal Boatman” Triple-Decker: A massive, two-handed sandwich loaded with house-cured sweet ham, hickory-smoked turkey, aged baby Swiss cheese, crisp local greens, and a generous layer of their signature honey-maple mustard on thick slices of scratch-baked salt-rising bread.
- Fresh-Squeezed Lemon Glazed Donuts: Made fresh every single Thursday and Saturday morning using a traditional yeast recipe, these airy, oversized donuts are dipped warm into a tart lemon glaze that keeps locals lining up down Main Street.
- Steam-Bent Oak Gathering Baskets: Beautifully displayed on the showroom floor, these rugged storage baskets feature double-reinforced oak bottoms and thick leather handles, designed to serve as a functional heirloom for generations.
Whether you are seeking the ultimate overstuffed deli lunch to enjoy by the water, restocking your pantry with small-batch apple butter, or hunting for a masterfully crafted wedding gift, Erie Canal Amish Treasures delivers an unmatched level of quality, care, and countryside hospitality.
Location & Hours
Address: 68 N. Main Street, Brockport, NY 14420 Hours: Tuesday – Saturday, 8:30 AM – 5:30 PM | Closed Sunday & Monday