Exploring Hidden Gems: Five Large Yet Lesser-Known Amish Communities

Exploring Hidden Gems: Five Large Yet Lesser-Known Amish Communities

When we think of Amish communities, places like Holmes County, Ohio, and Lancaster County, Pennsylvania often come to mind. These well-known communities draw a significant amount of attention and visitors due to their size and tourist appeal. However, there are several sizeable Amish settlements that remain relatively obscure. These communities, while overshadowed by their famous counterparts, have unique characteristics and offer an authentic glimpse into Amish life. In this article, we’ll introduce you to five such lesser-known but substantial Amish communities.

1. Hopkinsville, Kentucky

Established in 1989, the Amish community in Hopkinsville, Kentucky, is one of the first in the Bluegrass State to be settled by Amish from Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. What sets this community apart is its diverse range of occupations. While it started primarily as a farming community, it has evolved to include carpenter crews, produce farmers, and a few dairy farmers. Remarkably, this community is spread across four different counties – Christian, Todd, Trigg, and Caldwell County, covering a vast area of approximately fifty miles from east to west and a similar distance from north to south.

A Glimpse into Hopkinsville’s Amish Life

1. Idyllic Countryside: Hopkinsville’s charm begins the moment you arrive. You’ll be greeted by the soothing sights of rolling hills, verdant farmland, and horse-drawn buggies ambling peacefully along the tranquil landscape. The serene ambiance serves as an ideal retreat from the noise and rush of modern life.
2. Amish Artistry: Hopkinsville boasts a thriving Amish community of skilled craftsmen and artisans, each dedicated to their craft. As a tourist, you’ll have the privilege of exploring local shops and workshops, where Amish artisans create exquisite handcrafted furniture, intricately stitched quilts, and charming wooden toys. These authentic creations, crafted with precision and care, make for cherished keepsakes to remember your visit by.
3. Produce Auctions: A highlight of visiting Hopkinsville is the chance to participate in Amish produce auctions. These gatherings offer a glimpse into the agricultural traditions of the community. Here, you can purchase fresh, locally grown fruits, vegetables, and other farm-fresh products. It’s an experience that allows you to savor the flavors of the region while supporting the local economy.
4. Homemade Amish Feasts: Hopkinsville’s Amish families are renowned for their delectable homemade meals. Some Amish homes extend a warm welcome to visitors for hearty, traditional dishes. These gatherings offer more than just delicious food; they provide an opportunity to engage in heartfelt conversations with Amish hosts who are eager to share their stories and traditions.
5. Amish Schoolhouses: Hopkinsville features charming Amish schoolhouses that provide a window into the Amish education system. While you may not enter these schoolhouses, witnessing Amish children traveling to and from school in their horse-drawn buggies is a heartwarming and educational experience.

2. Conewango Valley, New York

New York boasts its oldest Amish community, founded in 1949 in the Conewango Valley. This thriving settlement now comprises 17 church districts and over 2,500 Amish residents. The landscape here is characterized by rolling and flat land, making it suitable for various livelihoods. The residents engage in dairy and produce farming, sawmilling, carpentry, and woodworking. Notably, in the 1960s, a cheese factory and produce auction were established, showcasing the community’s adaptability and economic diversity.

A Glimpse of Conewango Valley’s Amish Life

1. Scenic Beauty: Conewango Valley is a place where the natural beauty of the countryside takes center stage. The moment you arrive, you’ll be greeted by rolling hills, lush farmlands, and horse-drawn buggies gently traversing the serene landscape. The calm and tranquil atmosphere offers a serene escape from the bustle of modern life.
2. Amish Craftsmanship: Conewango Valley is home to a thriving Amish community of craftsmen and artisans, each dedicated to their unique craft. As a tourist, you’ll have the opportunity to explore local shops and workshops, where Amish artisans create exquisite handcrafted furniture, beautifully stitched quilts, and charming wooden toys. These authentic creations, meticulously crafted by skilled hands, make for cherished souvenirs to commemorate your visit.
3. Produce Auctions: A highlight of visiting Conewango Valley is the chance to partake in Amish produce auctions. These gatherings provide insight into the agricultural traditions of the community. Here, you can purchase fresh, locally grown fruits, vegetables, and other farm-fresh goods. It’s an experience that allows you to savor the flavors of the region while supporting the local economy.
4. Homemade Amish Cuisine: Conewango Valley’s Amish families are renowned for their delicious homemade meals. Some Amish homes open their doors to visitors for hearty, traditional dishes. These gatherings offer more than just food; they provide an opportunity to engage in meaningful conversations with Amish hosts who are eager to share their stories and traditions.
5. Amish Schoolhouses: Conewango Valley is dotted with charming Amish schoolhouses, providing a glimpse into the Amish education system. While you may not enter these schoolhouses, observing Amish children traveling to and from school in their horse-drawn buggies is a heartwarming and educational experience.

3. Troutville, Pennsylvania

Troutville, located in Clearfield County, Pennsylvania, is home to a flourishing Amish community that was established in 1971. The settlement has grown to encompass sixteen church districts. Over the years, the community has transitioned from predominantly farming to various occupations, with a focus on construction. Some residents operate sawmills and home-based businesses. In this sprawling community, farmers cover a vast area, ranging from Punxsutawney to Dubois in Clearfield and Jefferson counties.

A Glimpse of Troutville’s Amish Life

1. Scenic Countryside: The moment you arrive in Troutville, you’ll be greeted by rolling hills, lush farmland, and horse-drawn buggies gently navigating the picturesque countryside. The tranquil atmosphere creates the perfect backdrop for relaxation and contemplation, offering a much-needed break from the hustle and bustle of modern urban life.
2. Amish Artistry: Troutville boasts a thriving community of Amish craftsmen and artisans, each dedicated to their craft. As a tourist, you can explore local shops and workshops where Amish artisans create stunning handcrafted furniture, intricately stitched quilts, and charming wooden toys. These exceptional creations, crafted with meticulous attention to detail, make for cherished keepsakes to remember your visit by.
3. Produce Auctions: One of the highlights of a visit to Troutville is the opportunity to partake in Amish produce auctions. These gatherings offer insight into the agricultural traditions of the community. Here, you can purchase fresh, locally grown fruits, vegetables, and other farm-fresh products. It’s an experience that allows you to savor the flavors of the region while supporting the local economy.
4. Homemade Amish Delicacies: The Amish families in Troutville are renowned for their mouthwatering homemade meals. Some Amish homes welcome visitors to enjoy hearty, traditional dishes. These gatherings offer not just a taste of the region’s culinary delights but also a chance to engage in heartfelt conversations with Amish hosts who are eager to share their stories and traditions.
5. Amish Schoolhouses: Troutville is dotted with charming Amish schoolhouses, providing a glimpse into the Amish education system. While you may not enter these schoolhouses, observing Amish children traveling to and from school in their horse-drawn buggies is a heartwarming and educational experience.

4. Lodi, Ohio

Situated close to the well-known Amish settlement in Holmes County, Ohio, Lodi is one of the largest Swartzentruber Amish communities. Often referred to as “Homerville,” this community extends its presence across Medina, Ashland, Wayne, and Lorain counties. The Amish here have shifted their primary occupations from dairy farming and sawmilling to produce farming, thriving with a bustling produce auction. Additionally, cabinet shops and construction crews play a significant role in the local economy.

For tourists seeking an authentic and enriching experience, Lodi, Ohio offers a unique opportunity to step back in time and immerse themselves in the captivating world of the Amish.

A Glimpse of Amish Life

1. Tranquil Countryside: Lodi, Ohio, is a place where modernity takes a back seat to tradition. As you journey through the countryside, you’ll be greeted by rolling hills, meticulously maintained farms, and horse-drawn buggies that crisscross the landscape. The serene atmosphere creates an ideal backdrop for relaxation and reflection, making it a perfect escape from the hustle and bustle of urban life.
2. Amish Businesses: Lodi boasts a thriving community of Amish craftsmen and artisans who take pride in their skills. Visitors can explore local shops and workshops, where Amish craftsmen create exquisite handcrafted furniture, beautifully stitched quilts, and wooden toys that reflect their dedication to craftsmanship. These one-of-a-kind creations make for meaningful souvenirs to take home.
3. Produce Auctions: One of the highlights of visiting Lodi is the opportunity to attend Amish produce auctions. These events offer a glimpse into the agricultural traditions of the community. Here, you can purchase fresh, locally grown fruits, vegetables, and other farm-fresh goods. It’s a chance to savor the flavors of the region while supporting the local economy.
4. Homemade Amish Meals: Lodi’s Amish families are renowned for their delicious homemade meals. Several Amish homes welcome visitors to share hearty, traditional dishes. These gatherings offer more than just food; they provide an opportunity to engage in meaningful conversations with Amish hosts who are eager to share their stories and traditions.
5. Amish Schoolhouses: Lodi is dotted with charming Amish schoolhouses, offering a glimpse into the Amish educational system. While you may not enter the schoolhouses themselves, observing Amish children traveling to and from school in their horse-drawn buggies is a heartwarming and educational experience.

5. Kingston, Wisconsin

The Kingston Amish community emerged in 1977 as an offshoot of the larger Elkhart-LaGrange County, Indiana settlement. Today, Kingston boasts fifteen church districts, sixteen parochial schools, and even a “special needs workshop,” although the nature of this workshop remains ambiguous. In Kingston, approximately thirty to forty percent of families make a living through various forms of farming, including dairy, beef, sheep, chickens, produce, and greenhouses. The community also hosts a produce auction from April to October and operates a cheese factory, predominantly handling milk in cans.

Nestled in the heart of picturesque Wisconsin lies a hidden gem that beckons travelers seeking a unique and authentic experience. Kingston, a quiet village with rolling green hills and a serene countryside atmosphere, is home to a thriving Amish community that has managed to preserve its traditional way of life amidst the modern world’s hustle and bustle. For tourists in search of a genuine encounter with the Amish culture, Kingston offers an unforgettable journey into simplicity, craftsmanship, and a warm sense of community.

Visiting Kingston is like taking a step back in time. The Amish community here has intentionally chosen to live without many of the conveniences and distractions of the modern world. As a result, you’ll find horse-drawn buggies instead of cars, traditional craftsmanship instead of mass-produced goods, and a peaceful ambiance that soothes the soul.

Exploring Kingston’s Amish Community

1. Breathtaking Countryside: Kingston’s countryside is a canvas of rolling hills, lush farmland, and meandering country roads. Travelers can embark on scenic drives that offer stunning views of the Amish farms and their well-tended fields. The tranquil setting invites relaxation and contemplation, making it a perfect escape from the hectic pace of city life.
2. Amish Businesses: Kingston boasts a variety of Amish-run businesses, each offering a glimpse into the craftsmanship and skills that define this community. Visitors can explore local shops, where Amish artisans create handcrafted furniture, wooden toys, quilts, and more. Don’t miss the opportunity to purchase unique, high-quality items that make for memorable souvenirs.
3. Produce Auctions: Kingston’s Amish community takes pride in its agricultural traditions. Throughout the growing season, they host produce auctions where you can purchase fresh, locally grown fruits and vegetables. It’s a chance to savor the flavors of the region and support the local economy.
4. Delicious Homemade Meals: When it comes to food, the Amish know how to delight the taste buds. Many Amish families open their homes to visitors for hearty, homemade meals. These gatherings offer not only delicious dishes but also an opportunity to engage in meaningful conversations with Amish hosts who are eager to share their stories and traditions.
5. Amish Schoolhouses: Kingston is dotted with Amish schoolhouses where you can observe the Amish educational system in action. While you may not enter the schoolhouses themselves, witnessing Amish children traveling to and from school in their horse-drawn buggies is a charming and educational experience.

While Kingston welcomes tourists eager to learn about the Amish way of life, it is essential to approach your visit with respect and sensitivity. The Amish community values its privacy and simplicity. Remember to adhere to local customs, such as refraining from taking photographs of community members without permission and dressing modestly when visiting Amish homes or businesses.

Kingston, Wisconsin’s hidden Amish enclave, offers travelers a chance to escape the ordinary and immerse themselves in the extraordinary. With its tranquil countryside, authentic Amish businesses, and opportunities for meaningful interactions, Kingston provides an enriching experience for those seeking to understand and appreciate the Amish culture. So, take a step off the beaten path, embrace the slower pace of life, and discover the timeless charm of Kingston’s Amish community.

These lesser-known Amish communities, though often hidden from the public eye, have rich histories and unique characteristics that deserve recognition. Over time, these settlements have evolved and adapted to changing circumstances, showcasing the resilience of Amish culture.

One of the remarkable aspects of these communities is their ability to diversify their livelihoods. While farming was once a dominant occupation, these settlements have embraced various professions, including construction, woodworking, and produce farming. This adaptability is a testament to the Amish commitment to self-sufficiency and sustainability.

Incorporating Traditional Values

Despite the changes in occupation, the core values of Amish life remain steadfast in these communities. The commitment to simplicity, faith, and strong communal bonds continues to be the bedrock of their existence. As they navigate the modern world while adhering to traditional principles, these communities offer valuable insights into the balance between heritage and progress.

The Role of Community

The sense of community is a defining feature of these lesser-known Amish settlements. Residents work together to support one another, whether through farming cooperatives, produce auctions, or carpentry businesses. This collaborative spirit not only strengthens their community bonds but also ensures their economic sustainability.

Unique Contributions

Each of these communities has its own story to tell and unique contributions to offer. For instance, the Conewango Valley, New York settlement boasts a wooden toy shop, highlighting the craftsmanship and creativity of its residents. Similarly, Kingston, Wisconsin, is home to a “special needs workshop,” demonstrating the community’s commitment to inclusivity and support for all members.

While Holmes County, Lancaster County, and other prominent Amish communities often steal the spotlight, these lesser-known Amish settlements offer a unique and authentic perspective on Amish life. With diverse occupations, rich histories, and a commitment to traditional values, these communities remind us that the Amish way of life thrives far beyond the tourist’s eye. As we explore these hidden gems, we gain a deeper appreciation for the resilience and adaptability of the Amish people as they continue to grow and flourish.