Cheese Nirvana in Ohio: A Delicious Day Trip for Dairy Devotees
Calling all cheese enthusiasts! Ohio beckons with a delightful adventure for your taste buds. Ditch the grocery store pre-packaged slices and embark on a road trip through the “Buckeye State” to discover a world of creamy, sharp, and everything-in-between cheese magic.
Our curated Ohio Cheese Trail clocks in at a leisurely two-hour drive, leaving you ample time to savor samples and stock up on your favorites.
First Stop: Sugarcreek, Ohio’s “Little Switzerland“
Let’s begin in Sugarcreek, a charming village proudly showcasing its Swiss and German heritage. As the name suggests, Swiss cheese reigns supreme. Don’t leave without indulging in some freshly made cheese, and be sure to snap a picture with the World’s Largest Cuckoo Clock – a quirky landmark adding to the town’s unique charm.
Heini’s Cheese Chalet: A Dream for Cheese Lovers
Next, we head to Millersburg’s Amish Country, where Heini’s Cheese Chalet awaits. This haven for cheese aficionados offers a glimpse into cheesemaking history and a chance to tantalize your taste buds with complimentary samples from their impressive selection of over 50 cheese varieties. (Heini’s Cheese Chalet: 6005 Co Hwy 77, Millersburg, OH 44654)
Shisler’s Cheese House: A Family Tradition of Flavor
Prepare to be surprised by Shisler’s Cheese House in Orrville. This family-run gem hides a treasure trove of deliciousness. From creamy Marble cheese to classic Swiss, their offerings will have you reaching for seconds. And the bonus? Pair your cheese with their fantastic smoked sausage, beef jerky, or famous Trail Bologna. (Shisler’s Cheese House: 55 Kidron Rd., Orrville, OH 44667)
Grandpa’s Cheesebarn: A Family Affair Since 1978
Our next stop transforms a former dairy farm into a cheese lover’s paradise – Grandpa’s Cheesebarn. Located conveniently off Interstate 71, this Ashland gem offers a delightful blend of family-friendly charm, a well-stocked cheese shop, and a gift shop filled with goodies. Since 1978, the Baum family (Grandpa and Grandma included!) have been welcoming cheese enthusiasts with open arms and exceptional dairy delights. (Grandpa’s Cheesebarn: 668 US-250, Ashland, OH 44805)
The Grand Finale: Melt Bar and Grilled
This is not an Amish business, but after a day of indulging in pure cheese bliss, what better way to end the adventure than with an epic grilled cheese creation? Melt Bar and Grilled in Akron offers a haven for cheese-centric comfort food. Their menu boasts a seemingly endless variety of gourmet grilled cheese concoctions, including the legendary “Mighty Macaroni” – a childhood dream come true, combining macaroni and cheese with the magic of a perfectly toasted sandwich. (Melt Bar and Grilled: 3921 Medina Rd., Akron, OH 44333)
Beyond the Cheese Trail: Unveiling More Amish Cheese Delights in Ohio
Ohio’s Amish Country is a haven for cheese lovers, offering a bounty of handcrafted delights beyond the stops on our curated Cheese Trail. Here are a few hidden gems waiting to be discovered:
1. Lehman’s Cheese House (Millersburg): Nestled amongst Amish farms, Lehman’s boasts a reputation for their melt-in-your-mouth Colby and Monterey Jack cheeses. They also offer unique spreads like horseradish cheddar and garlic dill, perfect for adding a zing to your cheese board.
2. Walnut Creek Cheese (Sugarcreek): This family-run Amish cheese shop offers a charming atmosphere and a wide variety of cheeses. Sample their Havarti, known for its creamy texture and mild flavor, or their smoked cheddar, packing a smoky punch. Don’t forget to grab a loaf of their homemade Amish bread – the perfect partner for any cheese.
3. The Country Store at Walnut Creek (Walnut Creek): This haven for all things Amish offers a diverse selection of cheese alongside other local delights. Look for their brick cheese, a traditional Amish cheese with a slightly crumbly texture and a nutty flavor. Pair it with some local honey for a truly unique taste experience.
4. Miller’s Amish Cheese House (Millersburg): This Amish-owned shop focuses on classic cheese varieties, all made with fresh, local milk. Their cheddar is a crowd-pleaser, coming in mild, medium, and sharp options. They also offer unique cheese curds, perfect for snacking on or adding a delightful textural element to salads.
5. Guggisberg Cheese (Berlin): This Amish cheesemaker is known for their dedication to time-tested techniques. Their Swiss cheese is a must-try, boasting a nutty flavor and a firm texture. They also offer a variety of cheese spreads, perfect for adding a cheesy kick to sandwiches or crackers.
A Bonus Stop: The Amish Country Cheesehouse Auction (various locations): While not a physical location, these bi-weekly auctions offer a thrilling way to score amazing deals on Amish cheese. Bid on wheels of cheddar, Swiss, and other varieties, all crafted with traditional methods. It’s an experience that combines the excitement of an auction with the satisfaction of finding a delicious cheese treasure.
Planning Your Amish Cheese Adventure:
Remember, many Amish businesses operate with limited hours and may not accept credit cards. Call ahead or check online for specific details. Cash is always king in Amish Country. Embrace the slower pace of life, enjoy the friendly atmosphere, and get ready to discover a world of cheese unlike any other.
So, are you ready to embark on this cheesy adventure? We’ve provided a starting point, but feel free to customize your Ohio Cheese Trail and share your discoveries!
