Westtown Amish Market in West Chester, PA: You Won’t Believe The Selection

Westtown Amish Market, 1165 Wilmington Pike, West Chester, PA 19382

Nestled in the heart of Chester County, Pennsylvania, the Westtown Amish Market has become a cherished destination for locals and visitors alike since its grand opening in December 2015[2][5]. This bustling marketplace, spanning just under 25,000 square feet, offers a unique shopping experience that brings together the best of Amish craftsmanship, culinary delights, and traditional goods[1].

A Diverse Culinary Haven

The market is a treasure trove of flavors, featuring an array of specialty food vendors that cater to various tastes and preferences. One of the standout attractions is Stolzfus Cheese & Deli, where patrons can indulge in a wide selection of artisanal cheeses and deli meats[1]. The aroma of freshly baked goods wafts through the air, enticing visitors to explore the numerous stalls offering everything from hearty breads to delectable pastries.

Here are some must-try products at the Westtown Amish Market:

1. Artisanal cheeses and deli meats from Stolzfus Cheese & Deli[2].
2. Fresh baked goods, including gourmet donuts and pies from Beiler’s Bakery[2][3].
3. Capt’n Chucky’s crab balls and crab cakes, which are popular among visitors[2].
4. Pennsylvania Dutch Whoopie pies, a traditional Amish treat[2].
5. Locally homemade potato chips for a crunchy snack[2].
6. Fresh produce from King’s Family Produce or King’s Garden[2][3].
7. Homemade jams and preserves[2].
8. Scrapple, a regional specialty[2].
9. Bulk dry goods and candies from Old Barn Candies and Bulk Foods[2][3].
10. Fresh meats from Dutch Family Fresh Meats[3].
11. Salads and pickled items from Fisher’s Salads & Pickle Patch[3][4].
12. Smoked specialties from Sugartown Smoked Specialties[2].
13. Poultry and BBQ items from Jarlan’s Poultry & BBQ[3][4].
14. Pretzels from Pretzels and Log House[2][3].
15. Healthy food options from Emma’s Healthy Choices[3].

The most popular bakery items at the Westtown Amish Market appear to be:

1. Freshly made donuts, especially from Beiler’s Bakery. Multiple reviewers mention these as a must-try item, with one specifically recommending the pecan praline donuts[1][5].
2. Soft pretzels, which are described as “incredible” and “to DIE FOR” by enthusiastic customers[1].
3. Pies, which are prominently featured in Beiler’s Bakery’s offerings[2][3].
4. Cheesesteak pretzel logs, a unique item that combines a pretzel with cheesesteak filling. These are highly praised for their ingredient ratios and the addition of Amish steak sauce[1].
5. Whoopie pies, a traditional Amish treat that’s likely available at the market.
6. Gourmet donuts, which are mentioned alongside pies as specialties from Beiler’s Bakery[5].
7. Various other baked goods, as the market is noted for its fresh and diverse selection of bakery items[1][4].

It’s worth noting that Beiler’s Bakery seems to be a standout vendor for baked goods at the Westtown Amish Market, with many positive mentions in the reviews. The combination of fresh donuts, pretzels, and pies appears to be particularly popular among visitors to the market[1][2][3][5].

The market also offers a variety of non-food items, such as handcrafted Amish furniture, flowers from Brenda’s Flowers, and pet products from Spotts Pet Corner[3]. For those looking for a quick meal, H&L Grill offers sandwiches and drinks at reasonable prices[2][3].

More Than Just Food

While the culinary offerings are undoubtedly a major draw, the Westtown Amish Market is more than just a food destination. Visitors can browse through an eclectic mix of handcrafted furniture, quilts, and home decor items that showcase the renowned craftsmanship of the Amish community. The market also features stalls selling organic produce, preserves, and other locally sourced products, making it a one-stop-shop for those seeking quality, artisanal goods.

A Community Landmark

Since its inception, the Westtown Amish Market has quickly established itself as a landmark location for local residents[5]. Its presence has not only provided a unique shopping experience but has also helped to strengthen the community’s connection to traditional Amish culture and values. The market serves as a bridge between the modern world and the time-honored practices of the Amish, offering visitors a glimpse into a simpler way of life.

Challenges and Growth

Like any establishment, the Westtown Amish Market has faced its share of challenges. A recent health inspection in December 2023 found all seven stalls visited to be out of compliance, with some facing multiple violations[4]. This setback highlights the ongoing need for vigilance in maintaining high standards of food safety and hygiene, especially in a market setting with multiple vendors.

The Visitor Experience

Despite these challenges, the Westtown Amish Market continues to draw crowds with its unique atmosphere and diverse offerings. Visitors often describe the market as a sensory experience, where the sights, sounds, and smells transport them to a different time and place. The friendly vendors, many of whom are from Amish and Mennonite communities, add to the charm with their knowledge and passion for their products.

Looking to the Future

As the Westtown Amish Market approaches its tenth anniversary, it stands as a testament to the enduring appeal of traditional craftsmanship and locally sourced goods. While it may face ongoing challenges in maintaining standards and adapting to changing consumer preferences, the market’s unique position in the community suggests a bright future ahead.

For those seeking an authentic taste of Amish culture, a wide variety of high-quality goods, or simply a unique shopping experience, the Westtown Amish Market offers a delightful escape from the ordinary. It’s not just a market; it’s a journey into the heart of Amish tradition, right in the midst of Chester County.

Citations:
[1] https://www.delcotimes.com/2016/03/24/the-new-westtown-amish-market-is-it-worth-the-trip/
[2] https://www.dailylocal.com/2016/01/05/review-westtown-amish-market-opens-its-doors/
[3] https://countylinesmagazine.com/article/swing-spring-delicious-dining/westtown-amish-market/
[4] https://hellowestchesterpa.com/2024/01/10/west-chester-restaurant-inspection-reports-december/
[5] https://www.chestercountylife.com/directory/westtown-amish-market-listing-1625.aspx

Find an Amish Market close to you HERE