A New Chapter in Tradition: Exploring the Amish Community of Northwestern New Jersey
Nestled between the rolling ridges of the Kittatinny Mountains and the tranquil farmland of Sussex and Warren Counties, a new Amish community is quietly flourishing in northwestern New Jersey. Far from the bustling highways and city lights, this emerging settlement offers travelers a rare glimpse into the enduring traditions, craftsmanship, and rural hospitality of the Amish—right in the heart of the Garden State. For those seeking authenticity, scenic beauty, and a touch of old-world charm, the northwestern corner of New Jersey has suddenly become a must-visit destination.
A New Beginning: Amish Roots in New Jersey
The Amish have long been associated with Pennsylvania and Ohio, but in recent years, families from Lancaster and Holmes County have begun seeking new farmland and quieter lives in the lush valleys of northwestern New Jersey. Drawn by affordable land, a welcoming rural atmosphere, and the promise of close-knit community, several Amish families began settling near the towns of Blairstown, Hope, and Stillwater in 2024.
“We were looking for a place where our children could grow up close to the land and our faith,” says Eli Stoltzfus, one of the community’s founding members. “The hills and fields here remind us of home, and the neighbors have been very welcoming.”
Building Community: Amish Values Meet Garden State Spirit
The arrival of the Amish has sparked curiosity and excitement among local residents. “It’s like stepping back in time, but in the best way,” says Mary Russo, owner of Main Street Market in Blairstown. “They bring a sense of community and craftsmanship that fits right in with our small-town values.”
Amish families have quickly become known for their willingness to lend a hand, whether it’s helping with a barn raising, sharing gardening tips, or volunteering at local events. “They’re quiet, but they’re always there when you need them,” says local farmer Tom McAllister. “It’s a reminder of what rural life is all about.”
Amish Businesses: Craftsmanship and Country Flavor
One of the most exciting aspects of the new Amish community is the array of small businesses that have begun to enrich the local economy. These enterprises not only provide for Amish families but also delight visitors and locals alike.
Stoltzfus Bakery & Bulk Foods has quickly become a must-visit stop for anyone passing through the area. The scent of fresh-baked bread, pies, and cinnamon rolls greets visitors at the door, while shelves are lined with jams, pickles, and homemade noodles. “We use family recipes and local ingredients whenever we can,” says Anna Stoltzfus. “People come for the pies, but they leave with a little bit of everything.”
Kittatinny Amish Furniture specializes in handcrafted tables, chairs, and cabinets, all made using traditional joinery and local hardwoods. “Each piece is built to last,” explains craftsman Samuel Yoder. “We don’t use electricity or power tools—just hand tools and patience.”
Roadside stands are another hallmark of Amish enterprise. In summer and fall, visitors can find farm-fresh eggs, vegetables, and bouquets of wildflowers along winding Sussex County roads. “It’s a tradition that fits right in with the farm-to-table spirit of northwestern New Jersey,” says Mary Russo.
Local Businesses Embrace Amish Neighbors
The arrival of the Amish has been a boon for local businesses, many of which have formed partnerships with their new neighbors. Restaurants like The Blairstown Diner now feature Amish cheeses and butter on their menus, while the Hope Farmers Market welcomes Amish vendors selling produce and baked goods.
“We love having the Amish at the market,” says market manager Jamie Lee. “Their vegetables are incredible, and their baked goods always sell out. It’s great for the community and for tourism.”
Artisans and shop owners have also found inspiration in Amish craftsmanship. “Their woodworking is second to none,” says artist and gallery owner Ben Jacobs. “We’ve started carrying Amish-made picture frames and wooden toys in our shop, and customers love the quality.”
Voices from the Community
Despite their preference for privacy, the Amish in northwestern New Jersey are known for their friendliness and openness to respectful visitors. “We’re happy to answer questions and share our way of life,” says Eli Stoltzfus. “We just ask that people respect our customs—no photos, please, and remember that Sunday is our day of rest.”
Local residents echo the sentiment. “The Amish have brought a real sense of community back to the area,” says Tom McAllister. “They remind us what it means to work together and look out for one another.”
What to See and Do: Amish Experiences in Northwestern New Jersey
For travelers eager to explore the Amish presence in northwestern New Jersey, there’s no shortage of experiences to enjoy:
- Visit Stoltzfus Bakery & Bulk Foods for fresh bread, pies, jams, and handmade noodles.
- Tour Amish woodshops and see master craftsmen at work on furniture and toys.
- Shop at roadside stands for farm-fresh eggs, vegetables, and flowers.
- Attend the Hope Farmers Market on Saturdays to meet Amish vendors and sample local treats.
- Enjoy a meal at local cafés featuring Amish-sourced ingredients.
- Take a scenic drive through the countryside, watching for horse-drawn buggies and fields tilled by hand.
Visitors are reminded to dress modestly, avoid taking photographs of people, and respect the Amish tradition of rest on Sundays.
Preserving Heritage, Enriching the Garden State
The new Amish community is committed to preserving their heritage while embracing the unique character of northwestern New Jersey. “We want to be good neighbors and good stewards of the land,” says Anna Stoltzfus. “This is a special place, and we’re grateful to be part of it.”
Local officials see the Amish as a valuable addition to the region. “They’ve brought new energy and new opportunities,” says Sussex County tourism director Lisa Martinez. “Tourists come for the scenery, but they stay for the sense of community.”
Planning Your Visit
The best time to visit the northwestern New Jersey Amish community is from late spring through autumn, when the landscape is lush and markets are bustling. Maps and information are available at local visitor centers in Blairstown, Hope, and Stillwater.
Whether you’re seeking handmade treasures, farm-fresh flavors, or a peaceful escape, the Amish of northwestern New Jersey offer a warm welcome and a chance to experience a way of life rooted in tradition, craftsmanship, and community.