3 Popular Amish Restaurants in Virginia
If there’s one thing Virginia does beautifully, it’s blending Appalachian hospitality with Pennsylvania Dutch culinary tradition! Whether you’re road-tripping through rolling farmland or exploring mountain valleys, these three Amish restaurants serve up unbeatable comfort food, fresh-baked treats, and the kind of genuine welcome that makes you feel like family. From mouthwatering sandwiches to classic pies, here’s why you’ll absolutely love visiting these remarkable spots!
1. The Dutch Pantry – Rural Retreat, VA
Address: 6891 W Lee Hwy, Rural Retreat, VA 24368
Phone: (276) 686-2047
What makes it special: The Dutch Pantry is a beloved bulk food shop and deli specializing in scratch-made sandwiches, soups, fresh breads, local cheeses, candies, and classic Amish/Mennonite grocery staples. It’s a true local hangout—friendly faces, helpful staff, and the kind of bakery counter that’s dangerously good for your sweet tooth.
Favorite Menu Items:
- Hot sandwiches (especially their best-selling roast beef and ham & cheese)
- Homemade chicken salad and BBQ pork sandwiches
- Thick slices of pie (try the coconut cream or pecan)
- Fresh-baked breads and cinnamon rolls
- Signature deli salads and whoopie pies
What diners say:
“A lot of variety and wonderful bakery/deli… Amish love! …Great sandwiches, lots of items to try in the store. Feast for the senses.”
“The Dutch Pantry is a step back in time, and everything tastes like it came from Grandma’s kitchen. The coconut cream pie? Unreal!”
“Great food for the road! Filling, delicious, and super fresh.”1
The attached bakery has a cult following—so arrive early for the best cinnamon rolls!
2. Mattie’s Place – Burkes Garden, VA
Address: 930 Gose Mill Rd, Burkes Garden, VA 24651
Phone: (276) 472-2222
What makes it special: Run by Mattie Schlabach, an Amish owner, this log cabin shop and eatery offers a charming blend of Amish-prepared food, specialty groceries, and homemade baked goods. With warm wood interiors, beautiful valley views, and old-fashioned hospitality, Mattie’s Place is heart and soul Appalachian/A
mish cooking. It’s a hit with cyclists, hikers, and anyone exploring scenic Burkes Garden.
Favorite Menu Items:
- Hot soups of the day (chicken noodle, bean & ham, seasonal veggie)
- Classic deli sandwiches, like ham & cheese or meatloaf
- Homemade pizza—Amish-style with a crispy, slightly sweet crust
- Fresh pastries and donuts
- Local ice cream and old-school candies
What guests say:
“Go for the scenery, stay for the sandwiches. We had ham and cheese, chips, and sodas—delicious, and the porch view is amazing.”
“Mattie is so friendly and the store is packed with bread, pastries, jams, and deli meats. A true step back in time.”
“My husband loved the meatloaf sandwich! I browsed and left with fresh treats. The grounds are beautiful!”2
Make sure to grab some of their specialty goods to take home—you’ll want bread and jam for later!
3. Yoder’s Country Market – Madison, VA
Address: 2105 S Seminole Trail, Madison, VA 22727
Website: yoderscountrymarket.com
What makes it special: Yoder’s is a destination in itself! This spacious Amish-owned store and restaurant is famous for top-quality bulk foods, local produce, deli meats, and a robust bakery section. Grab a hearty breakfast or lunch, then shop for specialty grocery items, beautiful gifts, and even Amish-made furniture.
Favorite Menu Items:
- Breakfast: Homemade cinnamon rolls, sausage biscuit sandwiches, fresh muffins
- Lunch: Hot deli sandwiches, chicken salad, pulled pork BBQ, daily soups
- Legendary fried pies and fresh doughnuts
- Bulk snacks, nut butters, and farm-fresh eats
Yoder’s is extra popular for its family-friendly outdoor playground and petting zoo—bring the kids!
What customers say:
“We drive hours for the sandwiches and cinnamon rolls… the bakery is to die for.”
“A fantastic stop! The lunch counter serves up HUGE portions and there’s something for everyone.”
“Great deli with delicious breakfast sandwiches. If you have a sweet tooth, don’t leave without the donuts!”
“Friendly staff, beautiful market—Yoder’s is a must-do for food lovers in central Virginia!”3
Each of these Amish restaurants captures the heart of Virginia’s rural traditions—simple, generous, and absolutely delicious. For a day trip or a weekend adventure, they promise the kind of cooking you’ll crave again and again. Take your appetite, bring a friend, and taste some of the state’s richest food heritage!
Check sources
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g58149-d5008386-Reviews-The_Dutch_Pantry-Rural_Retreat_Virginia.html
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g57559-d14171400-Reviews-Mattie_s_Place-Burkes_Garden_Virginia.html
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=Harrisonburg%2C+VA
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=County+Center%2C+VA
- https://peterchangmclean.com/a-taste-of-tradition-discover-authentic-amish-cuisine-at-mcleans-best-amish-restaurant/
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=Annandale%2C+VA
- https://peterchangmclean.com/finding-the-best-chinese-food-in-virginia/
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rm54OHy3OZw
- https://www.reddit.com/r/Virginia/comments/1dj3pd3/seeking_out_the_best_mom_and_pop_style/
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c9ZKM5QTEes
- https://www.thisnthatamishoutlet.com/post/introducing-amish-dutch-food-at-our-old-town-warrenton-location
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=Gate+City%2C+VA