3 Popular Amish Restaurants in Wisconsin
The rolling hills and farmland of Wisconsin are home to remarkable Amish settlements—and dining at their restaurants is an adventure every food lover should experience! The state’s top Amish eateries serve up handmade breads, indulgent pastries, and hearty, home-cooked meals made with generations of tradition. Here are the three Amish restaurants people rave about, why they’re so loved, and what you must try when you visit. Let’s dig in!
1. Toasty Oven Bakery-Amish – New Holstein, WI
Address: 2300 Kiel Road, New Holstein, WI 53061
Phone: (920) 894-1776
TripAdvisor: Toasty Oven Bakery-Amish
About:
Nestled in the Wisconsin countryside, Toasty Oven Bakery-Amish is beloved for its authenticity, warm hospitality, and absolutely mouthwatering baked goods. Family-run by Amish owners, it’s a spot where “cake” means old-fashioned pies, turnovers, cookies, and the fluffiest breads you’ll ever taste. Enjoy breakfast or lunch at this hidden gem—arrive early before the shelves empty!
Favorite Menu Items:
- Turnovers and cookies in all flavors
- Sticky cinnamon rolls and doughnuts
- Jams, noodles, pickles, and naturally crafted food
What customers say:
- “Some of the best home-made fare in the state. The owner and his family put their heart and soul into every bite.”
- “It’s worth a drive—authentic and welcoming. The turnovers and cookies are particularly delicious.”
- “Nice little bakery…You can visit the farm or see them at the Fond du Lac farmers market.” tripadvisor
Travel Blogger Tip: Stop by on your next road trip, and bring cash for these country treats!
2. Pleasant View Bakery – Dalton, WI
Address: W4668 Liberty St, Dalton, WI 53926
TripAdvisor: Pleasant View Bakery
About:
Located inside the basement of a country house, Pleasant View Bakery is a true Amish hidden gem—famous for generous pastries, pies, donuts, and dense, flavorful bread loaves. You’ll be greeted by the smell of baked treats, friendly bakers (often singing as they work!), and parking lot views of horses and buggies. Go early for the best selection, and don’t skip the incredible pretzels!
Favorite Menu Items:
- Fabulous pretzel (ask at checkout!)
- Cinnamon rolls, pumpkin bars, and donuts
- Flaky pies and jars of jam or preserves
- Bacon cheese and cinnamon breads
What customers say:
- “Great bakery—real Amish bakery, good prices, and a lot of variety. Worth a drive!”
- “The ladies in the kitchen are singing while baking—so fun. Everything is heavy, dense, and satisfying.”
- “Pretzel was fabulous…cinnamon rolls, donuts, and pumpkin bars were delicious. Prices are extremely reasonable.” tripadvisor
Travel Blogger Tip: This bakery is cash only—great for stocking up before a camping trip!
3. Amish Kitchen – Delavan, WI
Address: 1741 E Geneva St, Delavan, WI 53115
Map: Amish Kitchen Location
About:
Amish Kitchen is known for its big portions and homestyle cooking, offering breakfast, lunch, and dinner menus that focus on old-fashioned Amish comfort food. The setting is cozy, welcoming, and packed with delicious smells. Enjoy savory dinners, fresh bread baskets, and classic pies all made in an atmosphere that blends rural lived-in charm with hospitality.
Favorite Menu Items:
- Fresh-baked breads and muffins
- Roast chicken and mashed potatoes, classic meatloaf
- Hearty soups and daily specials
- Fruit pies and churned ice cream
What customers say:
- “Feels like eating at grandma’s table; food is filling, flavorful, and genuinely rustic.”
- “Prices are fair, bread is amazing, and the staff is always smiling.”
- “The pie and ice cream are worth the drive alone!” mapquest
Travel Blogger Tip: Expect family-style service and don’t skip dessert—everyone loves the fruit pies!
Wisconsin’s Amish restaurants are all about generosity, community, and unforgettable tastes. Stop at any of these and you’ll leave with a happy belly, new friends, and a handful of the best baked goods in the Midwest. I’m so excited for you to discover each one—bring your appetite and enjoy every hearty bite!
Check sources
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g60136-d12686296-Reviews-Toasty_Oven_Bakery_Amish-New_Holstein_Wisconsin.html
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g59811-d14916658-Reviews-Pleasant_View_Bakery-Dalton_Wisconsin.html
- https://www.mapquest.com/us/wisconsin/amish-kitchen-462011950
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=Milwaukee%2C+WI
- https://leisuregrouptravel.com/a-taste-of-amish-style-cooking-in-the-midwest/
- https://www.travelwisconsin.com/article/tours/wisconsins-amish-communities-experience-shop-and-learn
- https://amishamerica.com/amish-restaurants/
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=Delafield%2C+WI
- https://www.reddit.com/r/wisconsin/comments/1go14v9/best_amish_stores_around_cashton/
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=Bristol%2C+WI