The Road Less Traveled: Hidden Treasures Along the Amish Country Byway

Here are some hidden gems and lesser-known spots along the Ohio Amish Country Byway:

1. End of the Commons General Store, located at 8719 OH-534, Mesopotamia, OH 44439, is Ohio’s oldest general store, operating since the 1840s. It offers old-world charm and unique products, allowing visitors to step back in time and experience a slice of history. The store’s shelves are stocked with a variety of goods, from traditional candies to practical household items, making it a must-visit destination for those exploring the Amish Country Byway.
2. Hershberger’s Farm and Bakery, situated at 5452 State Route 557, Millersburg, OH 44654, is a delightful stop that combines the best of Amish baking with farm experiences. Visitors can indulge in delicious treats like fry pies and cinnamon rolls while also enjoying the farm’s petting zoo and seasonal activities. The bakery’s aroma of freshly baked goods and the sight of Amish craftspeople at work create an immersive cultural experience.
3. Lehman’s Hardware, found at 4779 Kidron Road, Dalton, OH 44618, is a unique store specializing in antique-style appliances, non-electric kitchenware, and old-time toys. This expansive shop offers a glimpse into simpler times, with a vast array of practical and nostalgic items that appeal to both locals and tourists. Visitors can explore room after room of unique products, making it an excellent spot for souvenir shopping and learning about traditional ways of life.
4. The Farm at Walnut Creek, located at 4147 County Road 114, Sugarcreek, OH 44681, is an interactive farm featuring over 500 animals, including exotic species like giraffes. This family-friendly destination allows visitors to feed animals and experience farm life up close. The combination of traditional Amish farming practices and the opportunity to interact with a diverse range of animals makes it a unique and educational experience for all ages.
5. Sweetwater Farm, situated in Sugarcreek (exact address not provided), is a small family-run business open from May through November. This hidden gem offers visitors the chance to purchase fresh fruits and vegetables raised directly on the farm. The seasonal nature of the farm provides an authentic glimpse into the agricultural rhythms of Amish Country, making it a perfect stop for those seeking locally grown produce and a genuine farm experience.
6. Raber’s Shoe and Saddlery, while not explicitly mentioned in the search results, is likely to be found along the Amish Country Byway. This type of specialized Amish craft shop typically offers handcrafted leather goods, including shoes, boots, and horse tack. Visitors to such a shop can witness skilled artisans at work and purchase high-quality, durable products made using traditional methods. These shops often serve as both retail spaces and working workshops, allowing tourists to observe the craftsmanship that goes into creating leather goods. The unique atmosphere and opportunity to purchase authentic Amish-made products make stores like Raber’s Shoe and Saddlery a valuable stop for those seeking to experience the local culture and artistry.
7. The Victorian House Museum, located at 484 Wooster Road, Millersburg, OH 44654, offers visitors a glimpse into 19th-century life. This beautifully preserved mansion showcases period furnishings, decor, and artifacts that transport guests back in time. The museum’s intricate architecture and detailed exhibits provide a fascinating look at the lifestyle of wealthy Victorians in rural Ohio. Guided tours of the Victorian House Museum offer insights into the social customs, fashion, and daily life of the era. The museum also hosts special events and themed exhibitions throughout the year, making it an engaging destination for history enthusiasts and those interested in architectural preservation.
8. The Depot at Middlefield Historical Society, situated in Middlefield (exact address not provided), is another historical site that provides insight into the area’s past. This restored train depot serves as a museum, showcasing artifacts and exhibits related to the region’s railroad history and its impact on local communities, including the Amish. Visitors to The Depot can explore vintage railroad equipment, photographs, and memorabilia that tell the story of transportation and commerce in the area. The museum’s location in a former working depot adds authenticity to the experience, allowing guests to imagine the bustling activity of a bygone era.
9. Amish Cheese Tours, while not specifically mentioned in the search results, are likely available in the area known for its cheese production. Visitors can probably find opportunities to tour cheese-making facilities and learn about the traditional methods used by Amish cheese makers. These tours often include tastings and the chance to purchase freshly made cheeses directly from the source. Participating in an Amish cheese tour allows visitors to gain insight into the importance of dairy farming in the local economy and culture. It’s an excellent opportunity to sample a variety of artisanal cheeses and understand the craftsmanship involved in their production.
10. Baltic Meats, a local meat shop, might offer unique, locally-produced products. While not explicitly mentioned in the search results, such shops are common in Amish Country and provide visitors with the opportunity to purchase high-quality, locally sourced meats and specialty products.Visiting a local butcher shop like Baltic Meats allows tourists to experience the farm-to-table concept firsthand and support local farmers and producers. These shops often offer a range of traditional Amish-style meats, sausages, and smoked products that reflect the region’s culinary heritage.
11. Amish Country Riding Stables, while not specifically mentioned in the search results, would be an excellent option for those interested in horseback riding through the scenic countryside. Such stables typically offer guided trail rides that allow visitors to experience the beauty of Amish Country from a unique perspective. Horseback riding tours in Amish Country provide an opportunity to explore off-the-beaten-path areas, enjoy the tranquil rural landscape, and potentially catch glimpses of Amish farms and daily life. These rides are often suitable for both beginners and experienced riders, making them an accessible activity for many visitors to the area.

When you travel along the Amish Country Byway in Ohio, you’re not just in for scenic views; you’re also in for a culinary treat. The region is known for its hearty, homemade foods that reflect the Amish way of life. Here are some must-try local foods that you should sample during your journey:

1. Amish Broasted Chicken

One of the standout dishes you must try is the Amish broasted chicken. This dish is known for its crispy skin and juicy meat, typically marinated and cooked in a pressure fryer for a unique flavor. You can find this delicious offering at Farmstead Restaurant in Walnut Creek, where it’s served as part of a barn-raising buffet.

2. Fry Pies

As you explore, make sure to stop at Hershberger’s Farm and Bakery in Millersburg. Their fry pies are a local favorite, filled with fruits like apple, cherry, and peach, and fried to golden perfection. These sweet treats are perfect for a quick snack or dessert.

3. Homemade Breads and Pastries

At Walnut Creek Cheese, you’ll find a bakery that tempts your senses with fresh homemade breads and pastries. The aroma of warm bread fills the air, making it hard to resist picking up a loaf or two. Be sure to try their cinnamon rolls, which are a delightful breakfast option.

4. Shoofly Pie

A classic Amish dessert, shoofly pie is a must-try when you’re in the area. This molasses-based pie has a crumbly topping and is often served warm. You can find it at various local restaurants, including Boyd and Wurthmann in Berlin, where it’s a popular choice among diners.

5. Homemade Ice Cream

No visit to Amish Country is complete without indulging in homemade ice cream. Miller’s Creamery in Millersburg serves up a variety of flavors made with fresh ingredients. Their creamy texture and rich flavors make it a perfect treat, especially on a warm day.

6. Amish Sausage

For a savory option, try the locally made Amish sausage. You can find this at various markets along the byway, including Heini’s Cheese Chalet. The sausage is often made with traditional recipes and is a great addition to any meal or picnic.

7. Cheese Varieties

Ohio’s Amish Country is famous for its cheese production. Stop by Guggisberg Cheese to sample their award-winning Baby Swiss and over 60 other varieties. You can take a factory tour and enjoy free samples, making it a fun and tasty stop.

8. Coblentz Chocolates

If you have a sweet tooth, don’t miss Coblentz Chocolates in Walnut Creek. This shop offers a variety of handmade chocolates, including truffles and caramel treats. Their quality and craftsmanship make these chocolates a perfect gift or a special treat for yourself.

9. Fresh Produce

As you drive along the byway, keep an eye out for roadside stands selling fresh produce. Many Amish families sell seasonal fruits and vegetables, allowing you to enjoy the freshest local ingredients. Look for sweet corn, tomatoes, and peaches, depending on the season.

10. Amish-Style Buffets

For a hearty meal, consider dining at one of the many Amish-style buffets, such as Der Dutchman Restaurant. Here, you can enjoy a variety of dishes, including mashed potatoes, green beans, and homemade desserts, all served in a family-style setting.

11. Apple Butter

A staple in Amish kitchens, apple butter is a delicious spread that you can find at various markets. It’s perfect on fresh bread or biscuits and captures the essence of homemade goodness.

12. Dandelion Salad

If you’re feeling adventurous, try dandelion salad, a traditional Amish dish made with fresh dandelion greens, bacon, and a tangy dressing. It’s a unique way to experience local flavors and the resourcefulness of Amish cooking.

13. Maple Syrup

Ohio Amish Country is also known for its maple syrup. Look for locally produced syrup at markets and stores, perfect for drizzling over pancakes or waffles.

14. Pumpkin Roll

If you’re visiting in the fall, be sure to try a pumpkin roll, a seasonal favorite. This dessert features a spiced pumpkin cake rolled with cream cheese filling, and it’s often available at local bakeries and restaurants.

15. Cider and Doughnuts

Finally, don’t miss the chance to enjoy fresh apple cider and doughnuts, especially during the fall harvest season. Many orchards and markets offer these treats, making them a delightful snack as you explore the beautiful countryside.

As you travel the Amish Country Byway, these local foods will not only satisfy your hunger but also give you a taste of the rich culinary traditions of the Amish community. Enjoy your culinary adventure!

Remember that many Amish-owned businesses are small, family-run operations that may not be widely advertised. Part of the charm of the Amish Country Byway is discovering these hidden gems as you drive through the scenic countryside.

Citations:
[1] https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/nature/ohio/hidden-gems-along-the-countryside-oh
[2] https://www.planetware.com/ohio/ohios-amish-country-highlights-and-hidden-treasures-us-oh-65.htm
[3] https://www.ohiorc.org/amish-country-byway-in-ohio/
[4] https://nsbfoundation.com/nb/amish-country-byway/
[5] https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/trip-ideas/ohio/scenic-back-road-oh
[6] https://www.holmescountychamber.com/press-room/plan-amish-country-road-trip
[7] https://www.preferins.com/article/top-5-scenic-drives-in-ohio/
[8] https://www.darlingtravels.blog/post/enjoy-a-cozy-getaway-in-ohio-s-amish-country