Hidden in the Mohawk Valley: The Real Amish Deli Experience You Have to Try
When most people think of upstate New York, they picture the Adirondack peaks or the Finger Lakes. But tucked right into the Mohawk Valley of Eastern New York is a thriving Amish community, and with it comes some of the most hearty, authentic, and high-quality food in the region.
Located in Fort Plain, Dutch Country Market isn’t a tourist trap relying on “Amish-style” marketing. It is a genuine, no-frills bulk food store and deli that serves up incredible made-to-order sandwiches, fresh pantry staples, and local dairy. If you are taking a scenic drive through Montgomery County, or just out running weekend errands with your wife and twin daughters, a stop at this deli counter is guaranteed to keep the whole family well-fed and happy without breaking the bank.
The Details
- Name: Dutch Country Market
- Address: 56 Willett Street, Fort Plain, NY 13339
- Hours: Monday – Saturday (Closed Sundays and major Christian holidays)
The Favorites: What to Look For
- The 12-Inch Made-to-Order Subs: The deli counter is the undeniable main event. They stack high-quality, thickly sliced meats and cheeses on fresh bread. The portions are huge—easily enough to split if you aren’t completely ravenous.
- Custom Sub Platters: If you are feeding a crowd, the deli creates beautifully arranged sub platters loaded with all the trimmings, including pickles, cucumbers, black olives, and banana peppers.
- Friday Baked Goods: While the grocery and deli are open all week, the fresh, from-scratch baked goods arrive on Fridays. You have to get there early if you want the best selection of traditional breads and sweet treats.
- Walnut Creek Foods & Amish Staples: The shelves are packed with traditional Walnut Creek jams, jellies, and jarred goods, alongside authentic Mrs. Miller’s homemade egg noodles.
- The Coffee & Sandwich Bar: Beyond the cold cuts, they offer a great little coffee station to pair with your breakfast or lunch sandwich.
What Real Shoppers Are Saying
The secret is definitely out among the locals. Here is what real reviewers have to say about their trips to Dutch Country Market:
“What a great store!!! Clean and prices are right! They have a great Deli, coffee and sandwich bar is amazing. The quality candy selection is outstanding… Worth a trip. Next door is a great place for gifts and fabulous fabrics.”
— Trish OC
“We ordered sub platters for a baby shower and they were beyond delicious, beautifully made and placed on platters with tons of extra sides including pickles, cucumbers, black olives and banana peppers! Everyone raved about how good they were!”
— Melanie S.
“I have been here three or four times in the past year. They have great prices and a good variety of products. I wish I lived closer so I could make weekly visits.”
— Rocco C.