The 3 Most Amazing Amish Restaurants in New York State
If you crave soul-satisfying comfort food, bakery-fresh bread, and true small-town hospitality, it’s time to experience New York’s Amish restaurants! These remarkable spots serve up time-honored recipes and genuinely warm service, offering a taste of Amish tradition that’s both unforgettable and heartwarming. Get ready for massive portions, extraordinary baked goods, and memories you’ll cherish!
1. Dutch Village Restaurant – Clymer, NY
Address: 8729 East Main Street, Clymer, NY 14724
Website: dutchvillage.net
Phone: 716-355-9922
Nestled in charming Clymer, Dutch Village Restaurant is a beloved staple that’s been feeding the community with Amish-inspired comfort food for over 100 years. Run by Deborah White for nearly half a century, this restaurant is famous for its homey atmosphere and incredible homemade dishes. Come hungry—you’ll want to try the delicious breakfasts (think fresh-baked bread turned into French toast and BLTs), real mashed potatoes & gravy, subs on soft sub rolls, and classic roast beef sandwiches.
Their extensive gluten-free menu, made from scratch, welcomes everyone. Plus, the 4,500sqft gift shop is a must-browse, loaded with candles, furniture, décor, and artisan Amish goods. Each meal is prepared with care and local farm ingredients, so it feels like Mom’s home cooking at its best—plus you can snag their giant cinnamon rolls or a loaf of bread from the bakery!
Quote:
“Our cooks prepare every dish with care to ensure our customers enjoy the best dining experience possible. Casual, everyday style food made from fresh, natural ingredients from local farms makes our menu reminiscent of Mom’s home cooking.” dutchvillage
Insider Tip:
Don’t miss the Friday Fish Fry and the Sunday breakfast buffet, which are local legends!
2. Amish Market East – New York City, NY
Address: 240 E 45th St, New York City, NY 10017-3302
Website: Amish Market East – Tripadvisor
Phone: 212-370-1761
You might not expect an Amish restaurant in the bustle of Midtown Manhattan, but Amish Market East brings farm-fresh flavors—and a dazzling array of deli-goods, bakery treats, and hot buffet options—right to the city’s heart. The breakfast, lunch, and dinner offerings are vast, and you can even enjoy vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. Shoppers rave about the freshness of their produce, quality meats from the counter, excellent salads, and decadent baked goods like red velvet cake and cheesecake brownies.
Diners gush about the superior customer service—staff will assemble custom gift baskets and cater to nearly every request. Prices may be a bit higher, but the variety and convenience win fans from all over. Whether you’re grabbing lunch or stocking up for dinner, expect classic Amish service and hearty flavors.
Reviews:
“A very good selection of fruits, veggies and some speciality items. I must say though that their meat counter is amazing and the quality of all of their meats is fantastic.” – Nestless, Tripadvisor
“Great grocery store, great variety, prepared food, and really superior customer service. Delish food, wonderful selection.” – Various Tripadvisor reviewers tripadvisor
Insider Tip:
Visit after 7PM for hot buffet discounts; grab the brick oven pizza and fresh salads!
3. R & M Restaurant – Randolph, NY
Address: 18 Jamestown St, Randolph, NY 14772
Website: Enchanted Mountains R & M Restaurant
Phone: 716-358-2211
Located in the heart of New York’s Amish country, R & M Restaurant is a charming spot serving breakfast all day, along with lunch and dinner. The walls are adorned with Amish quilts, and the menu is stacked with comfort favorites made from local Amish producers. Guests rave about the “home away from home” feeling, huge portions, and friendly service.
Expect fresh eggs, country ham, sausage, fluffy pancakes, and daily specials—plus classic pies. This is a local favorite thanks to the cozy, folksy vibe and their commitment to true small-town service.
Quote:
“Located in the heart of Amish Country, R & M Restaurant serves breakfast all day, lunch, and dinner. Amish quilts adorn the walls, and lucky patrons can purchase one of these unique pieces to take home.” enchantedmountains
Insider Tip:
Arrive early for breakfast—locals say it’s the best way to start your upstate New York adventure.
These three incredible Amish restaurants promise something for every appetite—homey simplicity, legendary pies, and the kind of hospitality that makes you feel like family. From downtown Manhattan to upstate communities, New York State’s Amish eateries offer heart and tradition in every bite. Don’t miss out!
Check sources
- https://dutchvillage.net
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g60763-d424278-Reviews-Amish_Market_East-New_York_City_New_York.html
- https://enchantedmountains.com/place/r-m-restaurant
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=New+York%2C+NY
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=Midtown+East%2C+Manhattan%2C+NY
- https://openingnight.online/amish-dining-a-tasty-adventure-at-katies-kitchen/
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=Westfield%2C+NY
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g60763-d3315312-Reviews-Amish_Fine_Foods-New_York_City_New_York.html
- https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1j3hysn/amish_produce_in_nyc/
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/RestaurantsNear-g48465-d3596332-New_York_Amish_Trail-Randolph_Cattaraugus_County_New_York.html
- https://www.freemansrestaurant.com
- https://www.nytimes.com/reviews/dining
- https://www.tourchautauqua.com/directory/cornerstone-restaurant-and-bakery
- https://www.reddit.com/r/upstate_new_york/comments/1aw4qij/any_good_places_to_get_amish_baked_goods_and_such/
- https://www.eastamish45.com
- https://peterchangmclean.com/best-amish-restaurant-near-you-a-taste-of-simplicity-and-tradition/
- https://www.amishfinefood.com
- https://www.reddit.com/r/upstate_new_york/comments/18etyu2/legit_good_dining_innear_claytonwatertown/