The Best Amish Bakeries In Pennsylvania

Amish Bakeries

Amish baked goods are irresistibly delectable treats made with simple ingredients like sugar and flour, along with animal fat such as lard for richer flavors in baked goods.

Martha Ropp works hard in her family bakery to prepare for Christmas and community weddings, yet is drawn to Ambrose Hershberger but remains too timid to initiate contact.

Dutch Haven Shoofly Pie Bakery

East Lampeter Township boasts a roadside attraction marked by a windmill: East Lampeter Luncheonette & Bakery was opened in the 1920s as a luncheonette and bakery serving Pennsylvania Dutch cuisine, but later evolved into a luncheonette, bakery, gift shop, and became well known for its signature Shoofly Pie (molasses-based treat with crumb topping) being shipped nationwide and even earning them recognition from Time Magazine! Additionally, recently visitors included members from History Channel show Pawn Stars!

The bakery features thousands of kitschy tourist items, from T-shirts and mugs to jams and jellies, gifts and souvenirs. Additionally, it sells an extensive selection of breads and pastries. A visit to this popular tourist spot wouldn’t be complete without experiencing some Shoo-fly pie!

Dutch Haven Bakery in Lancaster County offers delicious pies with superior service that make this bakery a must-see for anyone with a sweet tooth or interest in Pennsylvania Dutch cuisine. Visitors from all over have traveled from around the world just to taste these mouthwatering treats; lucky for them they offer shipping as well! Dutch Haven offers an inviting atmosphere where visitors feel right at home while offering many souvenirs of Lancaster County in its gift shop – definitely making Dutch Haven part of any tour through Lancaster County!

Dutch Haven Crafts Store

Dutch Haven on Route 30 is an exciting and kitschy stop on any Lancaster Amish Country tour, making an excellent place for families looking to create memories from their Lancaster trip. Families should make time to visit Dutch Haven as it provides souvenirs and gifts suitable for everyone – from T-shirts, Amish Wrought Iron Crafts, Fudge, Books Cards Posters Music posters & much more – there’s sure to be something here that everyone would enjoy! Additionally the store carries doormats, top quality weathervanes/Cupolas as well as quirky signs!

Dutch Haven was originally established in 1946. Today it remains one of Lancaster’s top tourist spots due to their deliciously sweet Shoo-fly pies, made using their original recipe.

This unique bakery provides an unforgettable glimpse into Amish life and culture, with a buggy ride around its dirt roads, exploring a one-room schoolhouse, barn and stable; handcrafted goods including rugs, pottery, furniture clothing and jewelry for sale as well as the opportunity for buggy rides around its farm’s dirt roads.

Amish Country offers delicious treats, from rich and sticky desserts like Shoo-fly Pie (described below) to an abundance of covered bridges for horse-drawn buggy tours or shopping locally made jams and relishes at Kitchen Kettle Village nearby. Don’t leave without trying one or all three!

Shrewsbury Amish Market

The Markets at Shrewsbury is an established Amish farmers market located in Glen Rock, Pennsylvania and conveniently accessible from York, Harrisburg and Maryland. Offering fresh produce, baked and canned goods from Amish kitchens, farm-fresh meats & cheeses from farms nearby as well as crafts & gifts; in addition to featuring many eateries all under one convenient roof – The Markets at Shrewsbury provides shoppers with all that is necessary for a fulfilling shopping experience!

The store boasts approximately 20 merchants who specialize in Amish goods, artisan-crafted furniture, home decorations, kitchenware and food such as french fries and soft pretzels as well as ice cream and donuts. They’re open Thursday through Saturday though some stands may close early to prepare for busy Saturday days ahead.

Shrewsbury Amish Market was first opened by its family-run ownership in 1839. Their dedication to offering superior customer service and creating a name in the Amish community have resulted in many familiar faces working there today; its knowledgeable staff members and unique handmade items.

This store features an impressive selection of Amish-built sheds and shed accessories. Their owners, both Amish themselves, take immense pride in the craftsmanship that goes into their products – providing customers with additional storage space in your yard! These structures can help increase storage capacity.

Shrewsbury Amish Market

Pennsylvania Dutch markets are more than just stores; they’re an exciting environment that offers something for all the family. Their staff may not always fit your typical notions of Amish people – in many cases they run these markets family style with parents both involved and kids assisting at all levels – making this an excellent spot to bring all your loved ones!

These markets provide more than food; you can also purchase arts and gifts such as handmade quilts, wooden furniture and homemade jams and pies – in addition to local produce as well as traditional PA Dutch market meats!

Shrewsbury Amish Market in Pennsylvania, conveniently situated close to York and Maryland. The Markets at Shrewsbury features over 15 Amish merchants such as Flower Patch offering gifts; Penn Dutch Furniture selling quality outdoor furniture; Sheds by Pine Creek Structures selling custom and ready-to-deliver sheds.

The Shrewsbury Amish Market is an excellent shopping destination in York County’s southwest corner, just minutes from both York City and Gettysburg – offering residents of York County convenient shopping experience at competitive prices. A shuttle service runs daily between York Mall and Shrewsbury Amish Market for added convenience!

Pennsylvania is renowned for its Amish communities, where traditions and craftsmanship thrive. One of the most delightful aspects of Amish culture is their mastery of baking. From freshly baked bread to delectable pastries, the Amish bakeries in Pennsylvania offer a glimpse into a bygone era of simple yet exquisite culinary creations. In this article, we will explore the 10 best Amish bakeries in Pennsylvania, including their addresses and a brief review of their mouthwatering treats.

1. Miller’s Bakery Address: 2888 Miller Lane, Bird-in-Hand, PA 17505 Review: Miller’s Bakery is a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Bird-in-Hand. Their warm, cinnamon-infused sticky buns and homemade pies are simply divine. The friendly staff and rustic ambiance make every visit a memorable experience.
2. Dutch Haven Bakery Address: 2857 Lincoln Highway East, Ronks, PA 17572 Review: Dutch Haven Bakery is a must-visit destination in Ronks. The aroma of their freshly baked shoofly pies is irresistible. Pair it with a steaming cup of coffee for a delightful Amish treat. Don’t forget to take home a jar of their homemade apple butter.
3. Beiler’s Bakery Address: 772 Gap Road, Strasburg, PA 17579 Review: Beiler’s Bakery is famous for their soft pretzels and mouthwatering donuts. The bakers here pay meticulous attention to detail, ensuring each treat is made to perfection. Their cream-filled doughnuts are an absolute delight.
4. Lapp’s Dutch Market Address: 1406 West Kings Highway, Coatesville, PA 19380 Review: Lapp’s Dutch Market is a haven for those seeking an authentic Amish bakery experience. Their freshly baked bread, made with traditional techniques, is a true taste of the past. The market’s homemade whoopie pies and cinnamon rolls are not to be missed.
5. Achenbach’s Pastry Address: 3755 East Newport Road, Gordonville, PA 17529 Review: Achenbach’s Pastry is a family-owned bakery known for its extensive selection of pastries. From cream-filled eclairs to fruit tarts, their treats are made with love and expertise. Their seasonal specialties, such as pumpkin rolls in the fall, are a delightful surprise.
6. Kauffman’s Fruit Farm and Market Address: 3097 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird-in-Hand, PA 17505 Review: Kauffman’s Fruit Farm and Market is more than just a bakery; it’s a destination for all things fresh and delicious. Their apple cider donuts, bursting with flavor, are a crowd favorite. Take a stroll through their market and explore their selection of homemade jams and jellies.
7. Fisher’s Bakery Address: 2826 Lincoln Highway East, Ronks, PA 17572 Review: Fisher’s Bakery is a small, family-run establishment that embodies the essence of Amish baking. Their homemade pies, crafted with the freshest ingredients, are renowned throughout the region. Don’t miss their fluffy, melt-in-your-mouth sugar cookies.
8. Smucker’s Gourmet Pretzels Address: 3121 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird-in-Hand, PA 17505 Review: Smucker’s Gourmet Pretzels is a delightful bakery specializing in hand-rolled pretzels. Their pretzels come in a variety of flavors, including traditional, cinnamon sugar, and garlic parmesan. These warm, soft pretzels are a perfect snack for any time of day.
9. Lantz’s Bulk Foods and Bakery Address: 2557 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird-in-Hand, PA 17505 Review: Lantz’s Bulk Foods and Bakery is a haven for those seeking quality Amish baked goods. Their bakery section offers an array of treats, from flaky pastries to heavenly pies. Their pecan sticky buns and homemade bread are highly recommended.

10. Byler’s Homemade Candy Address: 2580 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird-in-Hand, PA 17505 Review: Byler’s Homemade Candy may not be solely a bakery, but their selection of homemade candies and chocolates will satisfy any sweet tooth. From chocolate-covered pretzels to fudge, their treats are crafted with care. Don’t forget to try their melt-in-your-mouth peanut butter cups.

Exploring the Amish bakeries in Pennsylvania is a delightful journey that takes you back to a simpler time. These bakeries not only offer exceptional baked goods but also provide an opportunity to experience the rich traditions and warm hospitality of the Amish community. From the iconic shoofly pie to the irresistible cinnamon rolls, each bakery on this list has something unique to offer. So, next time you find yourself in Pennsylvania, be sure to visit these 11 best Amish bakeries and treat yourself to an unforgettable culinary experience.