Dutch Country Market in Lyndonville, New York, is one of the most beloved Amish‑style markets in the state, combining a well‑stocked grocery, bakery, deli, and country décor shop into a single stop along scenic Route 18 near Lake Ontario. Visitors praise its friendly service, old‑fashioned atmosphere, and wide selection of baked goods, bulk foods, and Amish‑made items that make it feel like a slice of Pennsylvania Dutch country in western New York.orleanscountytourism+1
Name, Address, And Atmosphere
The full listing appears as Dutch Country Market, Route 18, Lyndonville, NY 14098, a “charming grocery store” described as an Amish market right on Route 18 in Orleans County. Local tourism information highlights it as an “Amish market including bakery, deli, bulk food, produce and Amish‑made décor such as handmade quilts, bird houses and Adirondack chairs,” open Monday through Saturday from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m.mapquest+1
Recent reviews mention how clean and inviting the store is, with one commenter calling it “very clean” and praising the “old fashion feel of the store,” which fits the classic country‑market image many travelers are looking for on rural drives through upstate New York. Wooden shelves, seasonal displays, and home décor items like birdhouses and Adirondack chairs reinforce the market’s mix of practical food shopping and leisurely browsing.orleanscountytourism+1
Favorite Foods And Market Highlights
Dutch Country Market earns repeat visits for its combination of bakery, deli, bulk foods, produce, and Amish‑made décor. Customers mention a “great selection of baking supplies, garden decor, home decor, groceries, deli, [and] baked goods like apple fritters [and] turnovers,” emphasizing both variety and quality.mapquest+1
Some of the standout items include:
- Bakery Treats
Visitors single out “fried pies and breads” as favorites, with one reviewer saying, “We love getting the fried pies and breads. The selection is great and I love the old fashion feel of the store.” Apple fritters, turnovers, and classic sweet breads are also noted in reviews, making the bakery case a major draw for road‑trippers looking for something fresh from the oven.mapquest - Bulk Foods And Baking Supplies
Like many Amish and Mennonite markets highlighted in upstate New York roundups, Dutch Country Market carries bulk flours, sugars, spices, baking mixes, and snacks, described as a “great selection of baking supplies” ideal for home cooks who like to stock up.amishamerica+2 - Deli And Grocery Items
The Lyndonville shop is noted for its deli and general grocery selection, including cheeses, lunch meats, and pantry staples. This follows the pattern seen across Amish and Mennonite food outlets in the state, where markets serve as one‑stop destinations for “essential groceries, fresh produce, bulk foods, deli [and] frozen foods.”justplainbusiness+3 - Produce And Seasonal Goods
Tourism descriptions mention produce alongside bulk foods and bakery, suggesting that Dutch Country Market offers fresh fruits and vegetables in season, echoing other Amish outlets that tie into local farms and New York State’s produce auctions.homeinthefingerlakes+1 - Amish‑Made Décor
Handmade quilts, birdhouses, and Adirondack chairs are highlighted as signature non‑food items, blending practical crafts with decorative pieces that give travelers something lasting to bring home beyond pie and bread.orleanscountytourism
Real Reviews And What Visitors Say
Online reviews for Dutch Country Market are solidly positive, with MapQuest showing a 4.5‑star rating and recent comments focusing on service, selection, and the baked goods.mapquest
A few examples:
- “Amish market located right on route 18 in Lyndonville. Very clean! Great selection of baking supplies, garden decor, home decor, groceries, deli, baked goods like apple fritters, turnovers…”mapquest
- “Service is fantastic! We love getting the fried pies and breads. The selection is great and I love the old fashion feel of the store.”mapquest
These remarks echo broader sentiments expressed about Amish and Mennonite food stores across upstate New York—where shoppers describe “GREAT meats,” “old‑fashioned” atmospheres, and the pleasure of finding bulk foods, smoked meats, and scratch‑baked items in one place. Dutch Country Market stands out in that landscape for its combination of bakery, deli, bulk foods, and décor under one roof along a scenic lakeside route.amishamerica+3
Why It’s A Must‑Stop In New York State
From a tourist‑editor perspective, Dutch Country Market works as both a destination and a detour: it’s appealing enough to warrant a special trip, yet easy to fold into a day of exploring Orleans County and the southern Lake Ontario shoreline. Travelers can pair a stop here with nearby farms, orchards, and small towns, using the market as a hub for snacks, picnic supplies, and gifts.orleanscountytourism+1
In the wider context, guides to Amish and Mennonite outlets in upstate New York describe a network of markets—such as Troyer’s General Store, Weaver’s Farm Market, Dutch Country Market in Fort Plain, and various Mennonite stores—that offer bulk foods, cheese curds, spelt bread, smoked meats, and other “old‑timey” staples. Dutch Country Market in Lyndonville fits squarely into that tradition, but with the added charm of Amish décor and bakery specialties that reviewers repeatedly label as standouts.homeinthefingerlakes+4
For anyone tracing an “Amish food trail” across New York State, Dutch Country Market deserves a spot near the top of the list: an accessible, friendly, and authentically country stop where you can taste, shop, and linger for a while before heading back on the road.amishamerica+2
Check sources
- https://www.orleanscountytourism.com/destinations/dutch-country-market
- https://www.mapquest.com/us/new-york/dutch-country-market-778536260
- https://amishamerica.com/12-amish-mennonite-food-outlets-in-upstate-ny/
- https://homeinthefingerlakes.com/amish-and-mennonite-food-stores-in-new-york/
- https://justplainbusiness.com/dutch-country-market/
- https://www.iloveny.com/listing/sunnycrest-markets/32812/
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g46439-d3521913-Reviews-Dutch_Country_Farmers_Market-Flemington_New_Jersey.html
- https://sunnycrestmarkets.com/about/
- https://www.mapquest.com/us/new-york/sunnycrest-orchards-442460903
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Market&find_loc=New+York%2C+NY