Penn Alps Restaurant & Craft Shop in Grantsville, Maryland, is one of Western Maryland’s most beloved Amish- and Mennonite-inspired stops, blending hearty Pennsylvania Dutch cooking with history, crafts, and a scenic mountain setting that keeps road-trippers coming back year after year. For travelers cruising along I-68, it is the kind of off-exit find that turns a simple meal break into a genuine cultural detour.onlyinyourstate+1
A Mountain Stop With Amish Roots
Tucked just off the National Road in Grantsville, Penn Alps Restaurant & Craft Shop sits at 125 Casselman Rd, Grantsville, MD 21536, steps from the historic Casselman Bridge and surrounded by wooded hills that feel worlds away from the interstate. The restaurant grew out of an Amish and Mennonite nonprofit effort, and that heritage still shows in its simple country menu and German-inspired dishes.tripadvisor
Inside, guests find multiple cozy dining rooms, some with log walls and fireplaces that make the space feel like a restored 19th-century inn rather than a modern highway stop. The adjacent craft shop and artisan village showcase local handiwork, so it is easy to pair a meal with a stroll among quilts, woodwork, and regional art.onlyinyourstate+1
Homestyle Menu And Famous Buffet
The menu at Penn Alps leans into traditional country fare with a strong Pennsylvania Dutch influence, echoing the Amish and Mennonite roots of its founders. Regulars praise the daily soup-and-salad bar and the weekend buffet, which is known for offering a compact but satisfying spread rather than an overwhelming casino-style layout.tripadvisor
On a typical weekend, the buffet might feature:
- Roast beef and country steak with rich brown gravy, sliced to order at a carving station.tripadvisor
- Roast pork with sauerkraut, echoing central European and German farmhouse cooking.tripadvisor
- Breaded chicken and chicken strips, often singled out by travelers as especially tender and flavorful.tripadvisor
- Fresh rolls and several types of homemade bread, plus cakes, pies, and hand-dipped ice cream to finish.tripadvisor
Beyond the buffet, the regular menu highlights American and German comfort dishes, including hearty meats, potatoes, and vegetables that feel tailored to a cold mountain evening. Vegetarian-friendly options and lighter plates appear as well, making it easy for mixed groups to find something they like.tripadvisor
Baked Goods, Crafts, And Artisan Village
Part of the charm is that Penn Alps is much more than a restaurant. The property includes a craft shop and an artisan village where visitors can browse handmade items, often from local Amish and Mennonite artisans or their neighbors.onlyinyourstate+1
Travelers frequently plan a stop here not just to eat but to pick up:
- Homemade breads and sweet loaves, including local favorites like applesauce nut bread.tripadvisor
- Pies, cakes, and preserves that travel well and make ideal “back home” gifts.tripadvisor
- Locally crafted pieces ranging from textiles and pottery to woodwork, turning a meal into a small cultural outing.onlyinyourstate+1
For many road-trippers, the combination of a substantial meal, a walkable historic setting, and genuine local crafts makes Penn Alps feel more like a destination than a simple restaurant.onlyinyourstate+1
What Diners Are Saying
Reviews consistently highlight the atmosphere and the stick-to-your-ribs quality of the food, especially on buffet days. One guest described Penn Alps as “a unique restaurant that takes you back to another time period,” noting the multiple dining rooms and wood-burning fireplaces that give it a historic lodge feel. Another visitor raved about the weekend buffet, mentioning “fish, shrimp, roast beef, roast pork & kraut, breaded chicken, chicken strips, two kinds of soup, home-made rolls, several types of bread, three flavors of ice cream and an assortment of cakes and pies,” and concluded that the setting perfectly suited the Pennsylvania German/Dutch demographic the restaurant naturally attracts.tripadvisor
Even travelers who drop in mainly for the bakery and craft shop tend to remember specific items; one reviewer said they “often stop at Penn Alps… to pick up baked goods,” singling out the applesauce nut bread as a personal favorite while praising the adjoining craft store and nearby artisan village as worthwhile browsing. For families and groups driving I-68, several reviews mention that it has become a traditional stop—an easy place to gather, refuel, and stretch legs without resorting to fast food.tripadvisor
Practical Details For Visitors
Penn Alps Restaurant & Craft Shop is located at 125 Casselman Rd, Grantsville, MD 21536, a few minutes off Interstate 68 in Garrett County, Maryland. The restaurant typically serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, with hours that cover most travel windows; weekend buffets are especially popular, and the property includes ample parking and accessible seating.tripadvisor
The setting beside the historic Casselman Bridge and close to the old National Road makes it an appealing detour for travelers interested in American transportation history as well as Amish- and Mennonite-influenced cuisine. Combining a meal here with a quick walk to the bridge, a browse in the craft shop, and a look around the artisan village turns a routine highway stop into an unexpectedly rich cultural pause in Maryland’s mountains.onlyinyourstate+1
- https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/food/maryland/penn-alps-md
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g41175-d518240-Reviews-Penn_Alps_Restaurant_and_Craft_Shop-Grantsville_Garrett_County_Maryland.html
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c9ZKM5QTEes
- https://amishamerica.com/favorite-amish-restaurant/
- https://thecasselman.com/restaurant/
- https://www.facebook.com/groups/7249421428463585/posts/25530155179963598/
- https://amishdoor.com/lunch-dinner-menu/
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g41175-d2244329-Reviews-House_of_Yoder-Grantsville_Garrett_County_Maryland.html
- https://thecasselman.com
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish&find_loc=Grantsville%2C+MD