Shoofly Pie In The Smokies: Inside Cherokee’s Smoky Ridge Amish Market & Deli


Smoky Ridge Amish Market & Deli

Meet “Smoky Ridge Amish Market & Deli,” a cozy, wood-sided country store tucked along a two-lane road just outside town.
Its fictional address is 2145 Big Cove Valley Road, Cherokee, NC 28719.

From the road, the market looks simple but inviting: a deep front porch lined with rocking chairs, handmade birdhouses, and hanging baskets overflowing with flowers in summer. A hand-painted wooden sign swings gently in the mountain breeze, lettered in plain black script: “Smoky Ridge Amish Market & Deli – Baked Goods – Bulk Foods – Sandwiches.”

Inside The Market

Stepping inside, the first thing visitors notice is the smell: warm bread, cinnamon, coffee, and a hint of smoked meats from the deli. The floors are polished wood, and the aisles are neatly arranged with bulk foods, canning supplies, and simple household goods. Jars of pickled beets, chow-chow, and apple butter line one wall, while another is packed with baking staples in clear plastic bags—flours, oats, sugars, noodles, dried fruits, and candies.

In the back corner is a small refrigerated section with local milk, farm-made butter, brown eggs, and blocks of cheese. A farm-fresh produce table near the door showcases what’s in season: late-summer tomatoes and sweet corn, autumn apples and winter squash, spring lettuces and strawberries.

Shoofly Pie In The Smokies: Inside Cherokee’s Smoky Ridge Amish Market & Deli

Deli And Favorite Menu Items

The heart of Smoky Ridge is its plainly marked deli counter, where an Amish husband-and-wife team builds sandwiches with quiet efficiency. A chalkboard overhead lists simple but tempting choices.

Favorite menu items might include:

  • Smoky Ridge Turkey & Swiss: Thick-sliced oven-roasted turkey, baby Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on fresh-baked country white bread, served with a side of kettle-cooked chips and a dill pickle spear.
  • Big Cove Ham & Hoop Cheese Sandwich: Slices of cured ham layered with mild hoop cheese, mustard, and a touch of house-made sweet pickle relish on soft wheat bread.
  • Cherokee Garden Veggie Stack: Sliced garden tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, and leaf lettuce with herb cream cheese on multi-grain bread—a favorite for lighter appetites.
  • Farmer’s Favorite Hot Panini: A warm pressed sandwich with roast beef, smoked provolone, sautéed onions, and a thin smear of horseradish spread on crusty sourdough.

Drinks come in glass bottles from an old-fashioned cooler—root beer, cream soda, and fruit-flavored soft drinks—along with fresh-brewed iced tea and hot coffee.

Baked Goods And Sweet Treats

Near the front counter, a long glass case shows off the daily baking. On any given day, visitors might find:

  • Thick cinnamon rolls glazed with vanilla icing
  • Shoofly pie, whoopie pies, and old-fashioned sugar cookies
  • Seasonal fruit pies (apple, peach, blackberry, and cherry)
  • Golden loaves of white, wheat, and oatmeal bread, plus soft dinner rolls

A small corner of the case is devoted to “grab-and-go” treats: individual slices of pie, cookie packs, and small containers of homemade fudge in chocolate, peanut butter, and maple.

Shoofly Pie In The Smokies: Inside Cherokee’s Smoky Ridge Amish Market & Deli

Reviews And Praise

Smoky Ridge Amish Market & Deli quickly became a beloved stop for vacationers and locals alike.

  • “We stumbled on Smoky Ridge after a morning in the national park and ended up coming back twice during our trip. The turkey and Swiss sandwich was the best I’ve had in years, and the cinnamon roll was big enough to share—but I didn’t!”
  • “This little market feels like a slice of Lancaster County tucked into the Smokies. Friendly people, fair prices, and baked goods that taste like something straight from my grandmother’s kitchen.”
  • “If you’re staying in Cherokee, make time for Smoky Ridge. The shoofly pie alone is worth the drive, and we stocked up on bread, apple butter, and bulk snacks for the cabin.”

Visitors appreciate the unhurried pace: no blaring music, no flashing signs, just the soft murmur of conversation and the quiet rhythm of bread slicing and sandwich wrapping.

Shoofly Pie In The Smokies: Inside Cherokee’s Smoky Ridge Amish Market & Deli

Atmosphere And Visitor Experience

Travelers can pick up picnic supplies before heading into Great Smoky Mountains National Park, or grab sandwiches and baked goods for a drive along the Blue Ridge Parkway. The parking lot often holds a mix of vehicles: local trucks, out-of-state SUVs, and motorcycles cooling after a twisty mountain ride.

Inside, guests are encouraged to browse, ask questions about ingredients, and watch the bakers at work through a large interior window that looks into the kitchen. There are no televisions or loud distractions—just shelves, food, and the occasional creak of the front door swinging open.

Dennis Regling

Dennis Regling is an author, educator, and marketing expert. Additionally, Dennis is an evangelist, a father, and a husband.

Recent Posts