Pennsylvania’s Best Amish Restaurants Outside Lancaster County
Pennsylvania is renowned for its deep-rooted Amish culture and the hearty comfort foods that define Pennsylvania Dutch cuisine. While Lancaster County is typically the first stop for Amish dining, venturing beyond the 50-mile radius reveals hidden culinary gems, each offering authentic, home-cooked experiences. Dive into three of the finest Amish restaurants in the state—far from the bustling tourist crowds of Lancaster.
1. Dutch Eating Place – Reading Terminal Market, Philadelphia
Address: 1136 Arch St, Philadelphia, PA 19107
Webpage: (readingterminalmarket.org/vendor/dutch-eating-place)
Situated in the iconic Reading Terminal Market, the Dutch Eating Place brings the flavors of Amish country to the heart of Philadelphia. Amish women, easily recognized by their bonnets and plain dress, serve up breakfast and lunch in an open kitchen environment where guests can watch their meals being prepared.
Favorite Menu Items:
- Blueberry Pancakes: Fluffy and pillowy, loaded with fresh blueberries, a perennial favorite.
- Apple Dumplings: Traditional and served warm, these dumplings come drizzled with sweet syrup and a dollop of cream.
- Chicken Corn Soup: Comfort in a bowl, loaded with shredded chicken and sweet corn, best enjoyed with their homemade rolls.
- Shoofly Pie: Soft, sweet, and dripping with molasses—a classic Pennsylvania Dutch dessert.
Whether you’re starting your day or grabbing a hearty lunch, the Dutch Eating Place delivers a genuine taste of Amish kitchen traditions. amish-heritage
2. The Amish Touch – Belleville, Mifflin County
Address: 5271 E Main St, Belleville, PA 17004
Webpage: theamishtouch.com
Nestled in the heart of Big Valley, Belleville is home to one of Pennsylvania’s most authentic Amish communities—far off the beaten path. The Amish Touch isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a country store offering homemade goods, quilts, furniture, and an eatery specializing in classic Amish fare.
Favorite Menu Items:
- Homemade Chicken Pot Pie: Generous chunks of slow-cooked chicken, vegetables, and noodles in a rich gravy.
- Dutch Potato Filling: A local twist on mashed potatoes mixed with homemade stuffing.
- Sticky Buns: Sweet yeast rolls baked in caramel and pecans, a must-have for visitors.
- Apple Schnitz Pie: Spiced dried apple pie, served at Sunday church dinners.
Grab a table or take your meal to go and stroll through the market, where baked goods, cured meats, and homemade jams abound. Few experiences in Pennsylvania rival a meal at The Amish Touch when it comes to authenticity. amish-heritage
3. Yoder’s Country Market & Buffet – New Holland, Chester County
Address: 14 S Tower Rd, New Holland, PA 17557
Webpage: yoderscountrymarket.com
Located in rural Chester County, Yoder’s Country Market & Buffet is a true celebration of Amish culinary heritage. Though technically near the edge of the Lancaster region, it’s just outside the 50-mile circle and well worth the trip. The smorgasbord buffet style allows you to sample a little bit of everything—a treat for anyone seeking the full spectrum of Amish cuisine.
Favorite Menu Items:
- Beef & Noodles: Slow-cooked beef with homemade buttered noodles and brown gravy.
- Creamed Corn Fritters: Sweet, crispy corn morsels fried to golden perfection.
- Chicken Croquettes: Chopped chicken in thick creamy sauce, formed into balls, breaded, and fried.
- Homemade Donuts and Pies: Whoopie pies, shoofly pie, and hand-rolled donuts are customer staples.
Yoder’s prides itself on using local produce from Amish and Mennonite farms, ensuring each recipe is packed with farm-fresh flavor. Their buffet experience is perfect for families and travelers eager to sample the culinary staples of Amish life. amishfurniturefactory
What Makes These Restaurants Special?
Far from Lancaster’s crowds, these three restaurants focus on tradition, simplicity, and the cherished recipes handed down through generations. Amish cooks create dishes from scratch, using local ingredients—heartwarming stews, fresh breads, sticky buns, classic pies, and satisfying casseroles. Every meal feels like home, every bite brimming with heritage.
If you want to immerse yourself in authentic Amish dining, check their hours before you go; many operate on limited schedules and close on Sundays in keeping with Amish religious customs.
Explore Amish cuisine off the tourist trail for a taste of Pennsylvania’s genuine flavor. Whether you’re hunting for blueberry pancakes in the city or chicken pot pie in Big Valley, these restaurants offer warmth, authenticity, and the delicious simplicity of Amish life.
Check sources
- https://amish-heritage.org/amish-food-traditional-amish-food-recipes/
- https://www.amishfurniturefactory.com/amishblog/5-best-amish-restaurants-2/
- https://amishamerica.com/5-favorite-amish-foods/
- https://sacredwanderings.com/best-amish-restaurants-lancaster-pa/
- http://www.katiesamishkitchen.com
- https://www.reddit.com/r/lancaster/comments/1ftu3s1/old_fashioned_amish_food_available_anywhere/
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=Lancaster%2C+PA
- https://www.discoverlancaster.com/blog/amish-owned-restaurants/
- https://www.plainandfancyfarm.com/traditional-amish-feat-menu/
- https://eatathometown.com
- https://bird-in-hand.com/restaurant-smorgasbord/
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowTopic-g28959-i112-k9814083-Best_Amish_Food_in_or_around_Lancaster-Pennsylvania.html
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=Manheim%2C+PA
- https://www.millerssmorgasbord.com
- https://amishexperience.com/groups-20/group-meal-options/
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SiLLYPtuB_w
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowTopic-g52970-i325-k5199796-Amish_restaurants_and_markets-Lancaster_Lancaster_County_Pennsylvania.html
- https://forums.egullet.org/topic/144850-working-our-way-to-lancaster-pa-%E2%80%93-what-to-eat-in-amish-country/