Oodles Of Noodles And Tons Of Honey: Inside Dutch Country Market In Middlebury, Indiana

Dutch Country Market in Middlebury, Indiana, is one of Amish Country’s most charming small markets, famous for its hand‑rolled noodles, “tons of honey,” and shelves that feel like a well‑stocked grandma’s pantry. Set along the Quilt Garden Trail just east of town, it’s a favorite stop for tour guides, road‑trippers, and locals who come back again and again for noodles, jams, and a warm hello from the Lehman family.tripadvisor+3

Name, Address, And Setting

Dutch Country Market is located at 11351 County Road 16, Middlebury, IN 46540 (often listed simply as “CR 16” along the Quilt Garden Trail between Shipshewana and Middlebury). Visitors’ bureaus describe it as a place where “local made is not a trend,” noting that Katie’s homemade noodles and peanut butter spread are “renowned in Amish Country.”visitelkhartcounty+2

Outside, the market is a modest Amish‑country storefront, but it sits beside one of the area’s quilt gardens—a living flower pattern that’s part of Elkhart County’s Quilt Garden Trail. One reviewer said they stopped while following the trail, enjoyed an elevated viewing platform for the quilt garden, and then stepped inside “a good place to get local foods” run by an “interesting” Amish gentleman.tripadvisor+1

Oodles Of Noodles, Tons Of Honey

Dutch Country Market is best known for two things: Katie’s Homemade Noodles and Dutch Country Honey, both made right on site. Promotional write‑ups invite visitors to “prepare to be amazed” as they watch Katie’s daughters rolling out dough and cutting noodles, while an observation window lets guests see bees working in a hive that Norman Lehman has tended for more than 30 years.visitshipshewana+1

Highlights include:

Grandma’s Pantry: Jams, Fudge, And More

Katie’s Homemade Noodles
The noodles are “made from scratch using no preservatives,” and guests can watch them being rolled and cut during the day. One Tripadvisor reviewer called the shop a “small Amish market with a lot to offer,” noting that “the girls were making noodles while we were there which was very interesting to watch,” and praising the reasonable prices and selection of noodles, jams, cookies, baking items, honey, spices, and seasonings.visitelkhartcounty+2
Dutch Country Honey & Spun Honey
Norman’s hives supply pure Indiana honey “from our own beehives as well as beekeeper friends throughout the state,” including 11 flavors of gourmet spun honey produced on site. Visitors can watch the bees through the interior hive window and often chat with Norm if he’s there; the market notes that he “happily answers questions concerning bees, beekeeping and honey.”visitshipshewana+1
Peanut Butter–n–Honey Spread
The shop’s peanut butter‑and‑honey spread is highlighted as a customer favorite, described alongside spun honey as something guests should definitely try.visitshipshewana

Beyond noodles and honey, Dutch Country Market “specializes in a veritable grandma’s pantry of jams, apple butter, salsas, pickles, peaches and beets.” Shelves are stacked with preserves and canned goods ideal for stocking a home pantry or creating gift baskets.mapquest+1

Additional favorites include:

Jams, Apple Butter, Salsas, Pickles, And Beets
Visit Elkhart County highlights this broad range, emphasizing that the market is the place to find old‑fashioned spreads and condiments that taste homemade.visitelkhartcounty
Fudge, Candy, And Saltwater Taffy
Guests are invited to “indulge in sumptuous fudge, 15 different flavors of salt water taffy, and locally produced maple syrup,” making the shop as much a candy stop as a grocery.visitelkhartcounty
Spices, Baking Items, And Local Honey
MapQuest’s listing describes Dutch Country Market as “a charming grocery store with a large variety of candies, jams, jellies and many Amish products and noodles,” as well as “a wide range of spices and local honey.”mapquest
Locally Made Crafts And Body Products
You’ll also find “locally made crafts, soaps, lotions, hand woven rugs and much more,” rounding out the experience with non‑food souvenirs that feel distinctly Amish Country.visitelkhartcounty

What Visitors Are Saying

Tripadvisor and local tourism sites paint a picture of a small but memorable stop. One reviewer wrote that Dutch Country Market is “always one of our stops on our annual visit to the area,” adding that “Traffic Jam, the noodles, cookies, and other Amish homemade goodies fill our basket! The owners and their employees are always helpful, patient and kind. A true gem.”tripadvisor

Other review snippets include:

“Small Amish market with a lot to offer. The girls were making noodles while we were there… Reasonable prices, noodles, jams, cookies, baking items, honey, spices, seasonings… Nice stop.”tripadvisor
“Nice Market Place on the Quilt Garden Trail… It was a good place to get local foods… The shop is small but has a lot to offer. They even had an apiary inside where you can see bees doing their work.”tripadvisor
“One of my favorite local spots. I’m a local tour guide, and I take many of my guests to Dutch Country Market. A perfect place to pick up some goodies to take home. My husband and I also shop there regularly for ourselves. Amish‑owned – the Lehmans are great people.”tripadvisor
“Lovely Amish country store… Run by wonderful Amish people. It has food & items reflecting the local culture.”tripadvisor

Together, these comments underscore why the market stands out: live noodle‑making, an indoor hive, genuinely friendly Amish owners, and the sense that you’ve stumbled onto something both authentic and approachable.

A Perfect Stop Between Shipshewana And Middlebury

Travel forums often advise visitors choosing between Shipshewana and Middlebury to make time for Dutch Country Market. One suggestion reads, “While in Middlebury, suggest you pop out to the Dutch Country Market east of town on Route 16. It’s run by an Amish family, and they make their own noodles on site,” framing it as a must‑see stop for food lovers and curious travelers.tripadvisor+1

Because it sits along County Road 16, the shop fits easily into itineraries that include:

Exploring Shipshewana’s flea market and downtown shops.
Driving the Quilt Garden Trail, with Dutch Country Market hosting one of the 16 quilt gardens and offering a viewing platform.visitelkhartcounty+1
Visiting other Amish‑owned businesses and farm stands scattered through the countryside.

Open Monday–Friday from 8:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. and Saturday from 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m., Dutch Country Market is ideal for morning or afternoon stops—long enough to watch noodles being made, sample peanut butter‑and‑honey spread, and pick up jams, fudge, and honey before moving on.visitelkhartcounty

Check sources

Oodles Of Noodles And Tons Of Honey: Inside Dutch Country Market In Middlebury, Indiana

Name, Address, And Setting

Oodles Of Noodles, Tons Of Honey

What Visitors Are Saying

A Perfect Stop Between Shipshewana And Middlebury

Like this:

Recent Posts

Name, Address, And Setting

Oodles Of Noodles, Tons Of Honey

What Visitors Are Saying

A Perfect Stop Between Shipshewana And Middlebury

Share this:

Like this:

Recent Posts