New Jersey’s Best Amish Markets: A Taste of Lancaster County in the Garden State
Despite not having an Amish population of its own, New Jersey has become home to several thriving Amish markets that bring the flavors and craftsmanship of Lancaster County to eager Garden State residents. These markets have become popular destinations for those seeking fresh, high-quality products and a taste of simpler times. Here’s a look at some of the best Amish markets New Jersey has to offer.
Mullica Hill Amish Market
Located at 108 Swedesboro Road in Mullica Hill, this market has been a staple of the community since 2006[1]. Open Thursday through Saturday, it features nine stands offering a wide variety of Lancaster County delicacies[2]. Visitors can find fresh meats, poultry, baked goods, cheeses, jellies, candy, and produce. The market is known for its incredible soft pretzels and delicious sandwiches[2].
What sets Mullica Hill apart is its diverse array of vendors. Beiler’s Bakery, Dutch Country Deli, Dutch Family Fresh Meats, Yoder’s BBQ, and Ellie’s Cheese Barn are just a few of the Amish-run businesses that call this market home[5]. The quality and freshness of the products have made it a must-visit destination for locals and tourists alike.
Pennsylvania Dutch Farmers Market
Situated in Princeton, this market brings a slice of Lancaster County to central New Jersey. It’s home to several well-known Amish vendors, including Beiler’s dairy, Smoker’s deli, Stoltzfus’ poultry and soft pretzels, Fisher’s bakery, and the K & R lunch counter[5]. The market also offers fresh produce and juices, providing a comprehensive shopping experience for those seeking authentic Amish goods.
The Greater Bridgeton Amish Market
Located at 760 Shiloh Pike in Bridgeton, this market offers an extensive selection of Amish-made foods[5]. Visitors can find everything from baked goods and pretzels to cheeses, meats, bulk foods, candy, and salads. What sets this market apart is its community engagement. In addition to its regular offerings, the Greater Bridgeton Market hosts social events like concerts, cruise nights, and peach festivals, making it a true community hub[5].
Columbus Farmers Market
The Amish Market inside the Columbus Farmers Market is a hidden gem, open Thursday through Saturday[3]. It brings authentic foods and retail items directly from Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. Visitors can enjoy roasted chickens and ribs from Stoltzfus Bar-B-Que, fresh meats from Ben’s Meat Market, pretzels and ice cream from Dutch Pretzels, and handmade Amish crafts from King’s Crafts[3].
Other notable vendors include Dutch Bulk Dry Foods for spices and dry goods, Dutch Kountry Kitchen for bakery selections, and Riehl’s Deli and Subs for delicious meals[3]. The variety and quality of offerings make this market a must-visit for anyone in the area.
Williamstown Farmers & Village Shoppes
This market in Williamstown features Amish-made meats, pretzels, deli items, cheeses, and fresh produce[5]. What sets it apart is the on-premises Amish restaurant, allowing visitors to not only shop for Amish goods but also enjoy a full meal prepared in the Amish tradition.
These Amish markets have become more than just shopping destinations; they’re cultural bridges that allow New Jersey residents to experience the quality, craftsmanship, and traditions of the Amish community. The markets have adapted to modern needs while maintaining their core values, often accepting credit cards processed through English-operated point-of-sale systems.
The success of these markets has led to increased interest in Amish-made products throughout New Jersey. Many vendors report a surge in online orders from customers who can’t make it to the markets in person, showing the enduring appeal of Amish goods even in our digital age.
As we look to the future, these Amish markets in New Jersey continue to thrive, offering a unique shopping experience that combines tradition with convenience. They serve as a reminder of the value of quality craftsmanship, wholesome food, and the simple pleasures of life. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, a visit to one of New Jersey’s Amish markets is sure to be a memorable and delicious experience.
The top Amish markets in New Jersey are:
- Mullica Hill Amish Market in Mullica Hill: This market features a variety of Amish vendors offering fresh foods, meats, cheeses, jellies, candy, produce, and sandwiches[2][7].
- Pennsylvania Dutch Farmers Market in Princeton: This market includes Beiler’s dairy, Smoker’s deli, Stoltzfus’ poultry and soft pretzels, Fisher’s bakery, and a lunch counter[3][6].
- Columbus Farmers Market in Columbus: This market offers a wide selection of Amish-made products including fresh meats, eggs, poultry, soft pretzels, ice cream, baked goods, and more[5][6].
- Williamstown Farmers & Village Shoppes in Williamstown: This market features Amish homemade meats, pretzels, deli, cheeses, fresh produce, and an Amish restaurant[6][11].
- The Greater Bridgeton Amish Market in Bridgeton: This market offers an extensive selection of Amish homemade foods such as baked goods, pretzels, country deli, cheeses, meats, bulk foods, candy, and salads[6][8].
These markets are known for their high-quality, fresh products and authentic Amish goods. Many of them feature vendors from Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, bringing traditional Amish craftsmanship and culinary expertise to New Jersey[6][7].
Citations:
[1] http://trentonfm.com
[2] http://amishmarketmullicahill.com
[3] http://www.padutchfarmersmarket.com
[4] http://www.amishdepot.com
[5] https://www.columbusfarmersmarket.com/amish-market
[6] https://amishamerica.com/amish-markets-new-jersey/
[7] https://amishmarketmullicahill.com
[8] https://bridgetonamishmarket.com
[9] https://www.bristolamishmarket.com
[10] https://www.reddit.com/r/newjersey/comments/16fdh9h/what_are_some_good_amish_markets_in_new_jersey/
[11] https://williamstownfarmersmarket.com
[12] https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Market&find_loc=Jersey+City%2C+NJ