Ohio Amish Bakeries
Visiting one of the many Ohio Amish bakeries is a great way to spend a day. Not only will you find tasty baked goods, but you’ll also get a great look into life in the Amish community. Many of the Amish bakeries have been family owned and operated for generations. They offer a wide variety of baked goods, including bread, cakes, cookies, pies, and more.
Hershberger’s Farm & Bakery
Located in the heart of Ohio’s Amish Country, Hershberger’s Farm & Bakery is a unique destination. It features an array of farm animals, a produce market, a petting zoo, a food trailer, and a country craft store. You’ll also find a full range of baked goods, including doughnuts, sweet rolls, iced cakes, pound cakes, and more. You can also enjoy a horse-drawn buggy ride or pony ride, for a small fee.
Hershberger’s Farm & Bakery has been in business for over thirty-five years. It is a family-friendly destination that welcomes field trips, families, and friends. You’ll also enjoy a wide selection of baked goods, produce, canned goods, leather goods, home decor, and toys.
The Bakery Cafe is a popular destination. It features freshly baked pies made with seasonal fruit and doughnuts. It was originally a small, in-home bakery, but the bakery expanded in 2014. Today, the Bakery Cafe serves a variety of baked goods. It also has a food trailer and offers outdoor seating.
The Farm and Bakery are open to the public on Monday through Saturday from 8 AM to 5 PM. During the summer, they offer a kid-friendly petting zoo. In the fall, they feature pumpkin picking. The farm and bakery are also great places to bring the family for a light lunch.
Hershberger’s Farm and Bakery also has a large selection of canned goods and produce. Originally, they sold vegetables to the city, but the farm and bakery now sell locally grown produce.
Miller’s Bakery
Located in Holmes County, Miller’s Bakery is an Amish bakery. This business has been baking baked goods for the local community for over 30 years.
The bakery sells many types of baked goods, including soft pretzels, apple fritters, and cinnamon rolls. It also carries a variety of bulk food items. The bakery is closed on Christmas Eve and Christmas Day. However, it is open on Saturday and Sunday.
Miller’s Bakery is run by the Miller family. They are friends with the owners of Guggisberg Cheese. They have also been selling furniture in Holmes County for many years.
Miller’s Bakery was founded in 1967. When it first opened, it was located in Miller’s home. It started out as a place where truckers could get meals. The family eventually started selling bulk foods and craft items.
Miller’s Bakery is run on a very small scale. It has one oven and six employees. The bakery has a lot of products that it makes each day.
One of Miller’s products that are popular is its Shoofly Pie. This pie has a homemade buttery, flaky crust. It’s also filled with molasses and cinnamon-brown sugar. It’s best served with vanilla ice cream.
The Amish Country bakery is also popular for its other products. They make 12 types of cookies, snitz pies, cream sticks, and fry pies. They also make handmade chocolate candies and whoopie pies.
Four Mile Bakery & General Store
Located in the heart of Amish Country, this small, but mighty family-owned bakery and general store is a must-stop for travelers of all ages. The store features a plethora of confections, as well as antique farm supplies, home decor items, and homegrown seasonal produce. They also have a free oh-so-cool petting zoo and a horse & buggy ride for the kids. You can visit the store on Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays from 7 am to 3 pm.
The best part is that the Four Mile Bakery & General Store is a mere 35 miles from Point Pleasant, Ohio, making it an easy stop on a long road trip. They also have a unisex restroom. They have been in business for over fourteen years and are still run by the Amish and Mennonite children of the aforementioned proprietors. They offer an eclectic mix of wares, but the biggest draw is their donuts.
In addition to their wares, the Four Mile Bakery & General Store boasts a family-friendly staff and a friendly atmosphere, making it a worthwhile stop. They also have a few of the best fried pies you’ll ever taste. If you’re looking for a small gift or something for your oh-so-picky wife, you’re in luck. They have a plethora of home goods and a great assortment of jelly sticks. They have a plethora of fun facts to tell you about their local wares and have a few items to enlighten you about the Amish and Mennonite cultures.
Yoder’s Bakery & Furniture
Whether you want to stock up on bulk foods or get a fresh meal, Yoder’s is a good place to start. The store specializes in Amish meats and other bulk foods. They have a wide variety of items, including spices, books, kitchen gadgets, and more.
Yoder’s is owned by Wayne Yoder from the Wheat Ridge Amish community. He started the business as a small roadside stand selling pies. It grew into a larger store with a variety of products. Yoder’s also has a bargain store that sells unique items.
Yoder’s has been in business for over a decade, and they carry a large variety of Amish products. Their store features an Amish bakery, which produces homemade donuts, bread, and baked goods. The store also features a restaurant with authentic Amish food.
Yoder’s is also known for its quality hardwood furniture. The store features a variety of items, including dining tables, full bedroom sets, and outdoor furniture. The store also offers free quotes.
The store also carries a large selection of home improvement items. Their showroom includes locally crafted furniture. The store also sells books and hand-carved candles.
They also have a large selection of tools, including hand tools and wood crafting tools. The store also has a huge selection of fabrics and patterns.
Yoder’s is a great place to shop for home improvement items, and they also carry a variety of Amish products. They are a family-owned business, so you can expect a friendly experience when you stop by.
Troyer Country Market
Located in Millersburg, Ohio, Troyer Country Market is one of the best Ohio Amish bakeries. The store is a family-owned business that carries a wide selection of Ohio Amish baked goods. The deli is stocked with fresh meats and cheeses, and there are a large number of bulk foods for sale.
Troyer’s Country Market is a great place to pick up a few items to take home. This family-owned business has been around since 1961. The store’s owner, Jonas Troyer, was inspired by relatives who owned similar businesses in eastern Tennessee.
Troyer’s Country Market is known for its high-quality products and excellent customer service. The store has a bright red roof and is filled with seasonal produce. Aside from local produce, Troyer’s also carries items from across the country. For example, they sell apples from New York and strawberries from the Carolinas.
Troyer’s also carries a few novelty items. For example, they sell their own brand of fudge. They also grind their own peanut butter, and fill their own honey bottles.
Troyer’s also has a specialty line of Amish Wedding Foods. These products are produced by Troyer Farms, which also produces Backroad Country candies. There are over 100 different types of fruit butter, jams, and jellies available.
You can also purchase Troyer’s glazed doughnuts. The deli has a large selection of cheeses, as well as award-winning deli meats. They also sell fresh meats and vegetables, ice cream, and local snacks.
Dutch Valley Bakery
Located in the heart of Amish Country, Dutch Valley Bakery is the go-to for delicious Amish-style baked goods. The company makes its products on-site from fresh, local ingredients. The main menu offers a variety of hot and cold sandwiches, roasted meats, and kid-size meals.
The company’s other flagship facility is the all-inclusive Dutch Valley Campus in Walnut Creek. The campus is a great place to stay while in Amish Country. It features a spa, golf course, indoor pool, and more. Aside from the typical Amish fare, the facility also offers a wide array of entertainment, including Broadway-style musical productions, gospel groups, and comedy groups.
Another highlight of the complex is the Dutch Valley Market. The market, which is located just beyond the complex, boasts an impressive array of artisanal food items. This includes a salad bar, chargrilled meats and hot and cold sandwiches. The best part is that it is free!
The company’s other mainstay, the Farmstead Bakery, offers lighter meals and house-made preserves. The company also offers the requisite cookies and a few desserts. In addition, the company offers an all-you-can-eat buffet and a few specialties.
The Dutch Valley Restaurant & Bakery also has a small, but impressive, gift shop. The store has a variety of whimsical ceramic frogs and wooden birdhouses. The gift shop also has a small display of beaded lampshades and fleece throws.
BONUS: Amish Country Donuts & Cafe
I don’t consider this one of my favorite bakeries – but I love the donuts. Everything here, donuts, coffee and baked goods are excellent.
