Maple Hollow Amish Market: Mercer’s New Hub for Traditional Flavors and Community
Nestled in scenic Mercer, Pennsylvania, where winding back roads border family farms and horse-drawn buggies share space with modern cars, a new market is rewriting how locals and tourists experience country living: Maple Hollow Amish Market. Open less than a year and already drawing crowds, this vibrant, family-friendly destination has quickly become Mercer’s must-visit for anyone craving authentic Amish food, handcrafted goods, and old-fashioned hospitality.
Welcome to Maple Hollow: Where Tradition Meets Community
Founded by Amos and Naomi Byler, members of Mercer’s long-established Amish community, Maple Hollow Amish Market brings the richness of the region’s agricultural tradition straight to its shelves and kitchen. Their vision—simple but ambitious—is to offer Mercer residents and visitors a taste of honest, handmade fare and a chance to slow down in a bustling world.
The market itself is a feast for the senses. Inside, hand-built wooden shelves overflow with fresh seasonal produce, home-churned butter, golden breads, and shelves of preserves shimmering in the sunlight. At the heart of the market is its open kitchen and bakery, where Naomi and her daughters prepare daily batches of cinnamon rolls, pies, and fry pies, filling the air with comforting aromas.
Outside, Amish-made furniture, garden sheds, and quilted crafts invite shoppers to linger longer, and every corner of the market radiates the warmth and simplicity that defines the Amish way.
Favorite Food Items at Maple Hollow Amish Market
Visitors come for the atmosphere—but stay for the food. Every item on Maple Hollow’s menu celebrates local ingredients and family recipes handed down for generations.
- Fresh Baked Bread: From hearty whole-wheat loaves to classic farmhouse white, bread at Maple Hollow is hand-kneaded and baked daily.
- Fry Pies: A regional Amish dessert not to be missed—mini hand pies filled with fruit preserves, glazed for sweetness. Apple, cherry, and raspberry are bestsellers.
- Homemade Apple Butter: Slow-cooked apples with cinnamon, clove, and brown sugar—sold in jars and as a key ingredient for sandwiches.
- Meats and Cheeses: Sliced smoked ham, bologna, sharp Swiss, and creamy farmer’s cheese from nearby dairies fill the market’s deli case.
- Hot Soup and Sandwiches: The eat-in deli offers homemade chicken noodle soup, beef barley stew, grilled ham and Swiss on rye, and chicken salad sandwiches.
- Pickled Vegetables: Bright jars of pickled beets, bread-and-butter pickles, and spicy kraut line the shelves.
- Jams and Preserves: Strawberry-rhubarb, blueberry, grape, and peach preserves are all small-batch and family-made.
- Kettle Chips: Hand-cut potato chips cooked in small batches, crisp and savory.
- Soft Pretzels: Made fresh and sold hot, perfect with farm cheese or honey mustard.
Specialty items rotate by season. In spring, shoppers rave about homemade maple syrup; in summer, it’s fresh strawberry pies and corn relish. Autumn brings pumpkin rolls and nut breads, while winter features hot cider, ginger cookies, and jars of mincemeat.
Reviews and Quotes from Satisfied Shoppers
Maple Hollow has quickly garnered passionate reviews from locals, tourists, and even food bloggers passing through Mercer County. A sampling:
- “Maple Hollow Amish Market is a treasure. Everything feels like a treat—try the fry pies, you won’t regret it.”
- “Stopped by for pickles and left with bread, cheese, and a fresh ham sandwich. The flavors are pure comfort.”
- “Amos greeted us like family. Their apple butter is the best I’ve tasted, and my kids loved the homemade pretzels.”
- “You can smell the bread baking from the parking lot. It’s impossible to leave empty-handed!”
- “There’s a sense of community here—the staff know your name, and the food has real soul.”
One tourist review mentions: “Felt like a step back in time. Every employee was kind, patient, and knowledgeable. We left with a pie for the road and Amish jams for gifts. Definitely coming back!”
Community Focus and Unique Experiences
Beyond food, Maple Hollow Amish Market hosts monthly workshops—bread baking, jam making, and quilt crafting—open to travelers, families, and locals. The market remains closed on Sundays in line with Amish tradition, but every Saturday, there’s a bustling outdoor farmer’s area with local honey, eggs, and fresh produce.
Children love the market’s gentle animals—rabbits and chicks most weekends—and a unique toy corner with handmade wooden puzzles and blocks. Guests can book guided “Amish Around Mercer” tours, starting at Maple Hollow, for a personalized look at Mercer’s Amish heritage.
Amos and Naomi’s market demonstrates the best of rural values: honesty, hard work, generosity—a place where transactions are really interactions.
Why You Should Visit Maple Hollow Amish Market
For anyone traveling through western Pennsylvania or seeking to reconnect with artisanal craftsmanship and wholesome food, Maple Hollow Amish Market is Mercer’s signature stop. The market is not just about buying; it’s about learning, sharing, and slowing down. Regulars recommend coming early for the best breads and pies, and staying late for good company.
Whether you’re stocking your pantry, in search of the perfect gift, or simply craving homemade comfort food, this new market delivers an unforgettable taste of Mercer’s Amish heritage.
- https://amishamerica.com/mercer-county-pennsylvania-amish/
- https://www.ohiosamishcountry.com/articles/the-great-taste-of-amish-country
- https://www.reddit.com/r/westchesterpa/comments/1jaaseb/westtown_amish_market/
- https://www.bristolamishmarket.com
- https://amishamerica.com/5-favorite-amish-foods/
- https://www.yelp.com/biz/westtown-amish-market-west-chester-3
- https://www.localharvest.org/mercer-pa/farmers-markets
- https://www.reddit.com/r/Poconos/comments/1crqnd3/amish_farmers_market/
- https://www.reddit.com/r/hagerstown/comments/1lbdatb/pennsylvania_dutch_market_changed_my_life/
- https://simplelifetours.com