The Casselman Inn & Restaurant in Grantsville, Maryland is a historic, Amish- and Pennsylvania Dutch–influenced country restaurant known for its homemade breads, generous breakfasts, and comforting roast dinners that keep travelers timing their trips around a meal here. Set in an 1842 stagecoach inn on the old National Road, it offers the kind of old-fashioned hospitality and cooking that feels straight out of a different era.yelp+3
A Historic Amish-Influenced Stop
The full name you will see on signs is The Casselman Inn, Restaurant & Bakery, 113 Main St, Grantsville, MD 21536. Originally built in 1842 to serve travelers crossing the mountains on the National Road, the inn and restaurant still welcome guests with creaking floors, colonial-style decor, and a dining room warmed by a traditional fireplace.tripadvisor+3
The kitchen leans into simple country food rooted in Pennsylvania Dutch and Amish family recipes, reflecting the background of the owners and the rural culture of Garrett County. Downstairs, bakers turn out breads, cinnamon rolls, pies, and cookies from scratch, and visitors are invited to watch the baking and browse an antique shop near the ovens.thecasselman+1
Favorite Menu Items And Bakery Treats
Casselman’s menu is classic comfort cooking: hearty, unfussy dishes built on scratch-made bread, real roasted meats, and familiar sides.thecasselman+2
Some favorite items that travelers routinely mention include:
- Colossal Cinnamon Roll – A massive breakfast roll offered with maple or vanilla icing; one guest called it “a phenomenal must-order” and “the best that he has ever had, and he’s had a lot.”yelp+1
- Traditional breakfast plates – Eggs, bacon, hash browns, breakfast burritos, French toast, and omelets, often described as filling and freshly prepared, with hot coffee that “they kept…coming.”yelp+1
- Hot Roast Beef Sandwich – Tender roast beef on homemade bread with mashed potatoes and gravy; one reviewer said, “It really hit the spot. Everything was homemade down to the bread.”yelp
- Hot Turkey Sandwich – Slow-roasted turkey breast on house bread, covered in gravy made from pan drippings and served with mashed potatoes and coleslaw, emphasizing the “real turkey pulled from the bird.”thecasselman+1
- Maryland Crab Soup – A local favorite loaded with vegetables and potatoes; a regular visitor wrote, “I always get the Maryland Crab soup… It is loaded with lots of vegetables and potatoes, also has the right amount spice.”yelp+1
- Country entrées – Honey-dipped chicken, beef stroganoff over buttered noodles, baked haddock, fried chicken, turkey dinners, and sides such as stuffing, green beans, peas and carrots, buttered corn, and homemade applesauce.thecasselman+1
Desserts and baked goods are a major draw: whole loaves of bread, maple cinnamon rolls, pies, sweet breads, cookies, and jams fill the bakery cases. One visitor singled out the peanut butter blossom cookies as “amazing” and another simply summed up the experience by saying, “They brought out a whole loaf of home made bread. WOW.”thecasselman+2
Real Reviews From The Road
Reviews of The Casselman Inn & Restaurant often read like travel diary entries, because the building and story are so intertwined with Route 40 history. One diner wrote that this “beautiful historic Inn with dining room in Grantsville is worth a visit,” praising the lovely gardens, inviting front porch, and colonial decor that “transport you back 175 years.”thecasselman.myshopify+1
Others highlight how the food matches the setting:
- A traveler noted, “Our lunch covered the menu – cod, omelets, Reuben, and turkey dinner. Make no mistake, this is real turkey pulled from the bird… Comfort dining at its best.”yelp
- A breakfast guest before a local folk festival said, “We opted for the breakfast buffet. The food was fresh and delicious—especially the maple cinnamon rolls,” later adding that their roast beef sandwich and mashed potatoes were “absolutely delicious” and that “everything was homemade down to the bread.”yelp
- A loyal customer shared, “I haven’t been here a lot but whenever I do come I always get the Maryland Crab soup… They are also always so pleasant whenever I come.”yelp
- Another review concluded, “Love their cooking. They are always above and beyond great waitresses! We will continue to time our trips around Casselman Inn!”yelp
There are occasional critiques—one reviewer found a buffet visit underwhelming—but even mixed reviews tend to acknowledge standouts like the apple butter, breakfast plates, or the quality of the bread and baked goods. For many families traveling between Deep Creek Lake, Western Maryland, and points west, Casselman has become the kind of landmark where “we stop every trip,” not just for the food but for the feeling of returning to a familiar mountain inn.tripadvisor+2
Atmosphere, Service, And Practical Tips
Inside, the main dining room features wooden floors, simple colonial decor, and a fireplace that reinforces the inn’s 19th-century character. A newer dining room added in the 1970s seats larger groups comfortably while preserving the same country feel, making it easy to host bus tours, reunions, and hungry road-trip parties.thecasselman+1
Servers come up frequently in reviews, with guests praising polite, attentive staff who check in often and offer suggestions—from pointing out specials like smoked beef brisket to recommending cinnamon rolls or crab soup. The restaurant serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, with some days featuring an all-you-can-eat soup and salad bar, and the inn offers complimentary breakfast items like cinnamon rolls, pancakes, or eggs to overnight guests.facebook+3
For travelers planning a Western Maryland itinerary, The Casselman Inn & Restaurant at 113 Main St, Grantsville, MD 21536 sits just off I-68 (Exit 19) and the historic U.S. Route 40, making it an easy and atmospheric stop between mountain hikes, Deep Creek Lake adventures, or a visit to the nearby Casselman Bridge. Pairing a meal of hot roast turkey, fresh bread, and a colossal cinnamon roll with a stroll through town delivers exactly the kind of small-town, Amish-country–influenced experience many visitors hope to find when they leave the interstate.tripadvisor+3
Check sources
- https://www.yelp.com/biz/the-casselman-restaurant-grantsville
- https://thecasselman.com/restaurant/
- https://thecasselman.com
- https://thecasselman.myshopify.com/blogs/news/welcome-to-the-casselman-inn-and-restaurant
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g41175-d519123-Reviews-The_Casselman_Inn_and_Restaurant-Grantsville_Garrett_County_Maryland.html
- https://thecasselman.com/wp-content/uploads/LunchDinner-Menu-December-2021-1.pdf
- https://www.yelp.com/biz/the-casselman-inn-grantsville
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g41175-d953642-r595472329-The_Casselman_Inn-Grantsville_Garrett_County_Maryland.html
- https://www.facebook.com/groups/Route40/posts/8222802841158773/
- https://www.menupix.com/maryland/restaurants/444366/The-Casselman-Inn-Menu-Grantsville-MD