3 Obscure Amish Markets in New York State
If you believe all New York’s best markets are in the city, think again! From the peaceful valleys of the Finger Lakes to Manhattan’s bustling streets, authentic Amish products—crafted, baked, or grown with traditional care—find their way to cozy, lesser-known stores and bustling stalls. These three Amish markets are true treasures, each offering a flavor of Amish culture and community, heartwarming reviews, and plenty of charm. Let’s explore!
1. Windmill Farm & Craft Market – Penn Yan (Finger Lakes Region)
Address: 3900 New York 14A, Penn Yan, NY 14527
Website: thewindmill.com
Windmill is a seasonal open-air market in bucolic Finger Lakes country, bursting with everything from handmade Amish quilts and furniture to melt-in-your-mouth pastries, jams, cheeses, and bulk foods. Shoppers rave about its laid-back atmosphere and the range of one-of-a-kind Amish goods you won’t find elsewhere. The market is open Saturdays from April to November and is a favorite for lakeside road-trippers.onlyinyourstate
Review Highlights:
- “The best spot for authentic Amish crafts and food in the region—stunning handmade goods and the absolute friendliest vendors!”
- “Don’t miss the pies—absolutely out of this world. I brought home a cinnamon raisin loaf that was devoured in hours!”
- “There’s nothing like wandering the Windmill—every visit is an adventure.”onlyinyourstate
Food Editor’s Excitement: The Windmill is all about discovery with every step, especially when you stumble on an Amish bakery selling apple fritters fresh from the oven!
2. Millport Dairy – Upper West Side, New York City
Address: 2575 Broadway (between 97th & 98th St), New York, NY 10025
Coverage: amishamerica.com
Millport Dairy is the ultimate city-country success story—Amish farmer John Stoltzfoos journeys from Pennsylvania to Manhattan, selling superb farm-fresh dairy, eggs, preserves, and baked goods to a loyal city clientele. Customers are drawn by the store’s outstanding quality, especially the eggs, and the real-deal Amish pies, breads, and meats.amishamerica+1
Review Highlights:
- “I would never eat eggs from the supermarket again. The quality is just unbeatable.”
- “Pickled okra, pork roll, homemade pies—every visit reminds me of Pennsylvania Amish country.”
- “So glad Millport Dairy is here—it’s truly the best place for honest food in Manhattan.”nypost
Food Editor’s Excitement: It’s a slice of rural tradition dropped into the heart of NYC, making Amish food part of everyone’s daily city routine.
3. Dutchland Foods – Marion, NY (Wayne County)
Address: 3948 N Main St, Marion, NY 14505
Phone: (315) 926-4480
Dutchland Foods is tucked into quiet Wayne County, upstate, and is the spot for bulk staples, homemade jams, local meats, deli cuts, fresh pies, and an outstanding selection of baking supplies. This market serves the local Amish and Mennonite population but welcomes visitors hunting for honest, country flavors.homeinthefingerlakes
Review Highlights:
- “The homemade jams and jellies are the core reason I stop here, but every bread and pie I’ve tried is top notch.”
- “Bulk spices and baking supplies—great for holiday prep!”
- “You find authentic farmhouse cheeses, Amish meats, and old-fashioned sweets, all under one roof.”homeinthefingerlakes
Food Editor’s Excitement: Whether stocking up for a family get-together or just seeking an afternoon treat, Dutchland delivers true farm-to-table flavor every time.