Venturing into Ohio’s Amish Country offers an enchanting experience, where you can discover a blend of tradition and innovation. Beyond the picturesque landscapes and simple way of life, you’ll find some truly unique Amish-run businesses that offer a fascinating glimpse into their culture and craftsmanship. Here are seven unusual Amish stores in Ohio that are well worth a visit:
1. Lehman’s
Located in Kidron, Lehman’s is not just a store; it’s a destination. This “low-tech superstore” started as a small hardware store serving the local Amish community and has grown into a massive shopping extravaganza. Comprising four pre-Civil War era buildings under one roof, Lehman’s offers a quarter-mile of shopping filled with old-fashioned treats, non-electric goods, and practical items that help you live a simpler life.
As you explore, you’ll find everything from antique kitchenware to hand-cranked appliances. One of the highlights is the Tiny House on a Tiny Homestead exhibit, showcasing how you can simplify your living space. The store also features an impressive collection of antiques, making it feel like a museum where you can purchase the exhibits. Don’t forget to check out the new and vintage toys, books, and handcrafted pottery and glassware. Lehman’s is a must-visit for anyone interested in embracing a simpler, more sustainable lifestyle.
2. Walnut Creek Amish Flea Market
Located in Sugarcreek, the Walnut Creek Amish Flea Market is a treasure trove of unique finds. This massive indoor market spans over 50,000 square feet, offering a wide variety of products, including clothing, jewelry, furniture, home decor, gifts, pet supplies, antiques, gourmet foods, and handcrafted pottery and glassware. Address: 1900 OH-39, Sugarcreek, OH 44681
What sets this market apart is its vibrant atmosphere and the sheer diversity of items available. You can even get a massage after a long day of shopping! During warmer months, local produce is available outside, along with several other vendors and live animals. The market also hosts hourly and monthly giveaways, live music, and seasonal activities, ensuring there’s always something exciting going on. It’s a fantastic place to spend a day exploring and discovering hidden gems.
3. Coblentz Chocolate Company
For those with a sweet tooth, a visit to Coblentz Chocolate Company in Walnut Creek is a must. This family-owned business has been crafting delicious chocolates since 1987. The shop offers a wide range of treats, including buckeyes, cream fills, truffles, and snappers. What makes Coblentz Chocolate Company unique is their commitment to quality and the use of traditional recipes. Address: 4917 OH-515, Walnut Creek, OH 44687
As you step into the shop, the rich aroma of chocolate envelops you, and you can watch the chocolatiers at work through large viewing windows. The beautifully crafted chocolates make perfect gifts or indulgent treats for yourself. Don’t miss their seasonal specialties and unique chocolate creations that reflect the local culture and traditions.
4. Miller’s Dry Goods
Located in Charm, Miller’s Dry Goods is a fabric lover’s paradise. What began as a small collection of fabrics has grown into a store with over 8,000 bolts of fabric and a stocked Quilt Barn. The shop offers a full line of notions, patterns, handmade quilts, and more, making it a haven for quilters and crafters. Address: 4500 OH-557, Millersburg, OH 44654
What sets Miller’s Dry Goods apart is the quality and variety of fabrics available. You’ll find everything from traditional calicos to the latest fashion prints. The Quilt Barn is a highlight, showcasing beautiful handmade quilts that reflect the skill and artistry of the Amish community. Whether you’re a seasoned quilter or just starting, Miller’s Dry Goods is a must-visit destination.
5. Helping Hands Quilt Shop
Helping Hands Quilt Shop in Berlin is another fantastic stop for quilt enthusiasts. Founded in 1974, this shop features over 3,000 bolts of fabric, notions, and other quilting tools. Visitors can browse over 100 locally made finished quilts, pillows, wall hangings, crib quilts, and table runners. Address: 4818 OH-39, Berlin, OH 44610
What makes Helping Hands Quilt Shop unique is its focus on locally made products and the large selection of fabric and quilting supplies. The shop is a favorite among crafters for its high-quality materials and the expertise of its staff. Whether you’re looking for a finished quilt or supplies for your next project, Helping Hands Quilt Shop has everything you need.
6. Broad Run Cheesehouse
Located in Dover, Broad Run Cheesehouse combines a long heritage of Swiss craftsmanship with new high-quality boutique wines, all made on-site. This family-owned business has been making cheese for over 70 years and has won numerous Grand Champion Cheesemaker awards. Address: 6011 Old Rte 39 NW, Dover, OH 44622
What sets Broad Run Cheesehouse apart is the perfect marriage of wine and cheese. The shop offers tours and tastings, allowing you to sample their delicious cheeses and wines. The scenic grounds and charming atmosphere make it a delightful place to visit. Whether you’re a cheese connoisseur or just looking for a unique experience, Broad Run Cheesehouse is a must-visit.
7. Tis the Season Christmas Shop
Located in Berlin, Tis the Season Christmas Shop is a magical destination that brings the holiday spirit to life year-round. This 20,000-square-foot store is filled with Christmas wonder, offering a wide variety of holiday decorations, ornaments, and gifts. Address: 4363 OH-39, Millersburg, OH 44654
What makes Tis the Season Christmas Shop unique is its extensive collection of holiday items and the enchanting atmosphere. The shop is beautifully decorated, creating a festive ambiance that makes you feel like it’s Christmas every day. Whether you’re looking for traditional ornaments or unique holiday decor, Tis the Season Christmas Shop has something for everyone.
These seven unusual Amish stores in Ohio offer unique products and experiences that go beyond the typical tourist attractions. Each shop provides a window into the rich traditions and innovative spirit of the Amish community, showcasing their commitment to quality, craftsmanship, and sustainability. Whether you’re looking for a one-of-a-kind souvenir or simply a memorable experience, these businesses are sure to leave a lasting impression.
Citations:
[1] https://www.bestofamishcountry.com/post/the-two-massive-amish-country-shops-you-must-see-to-believe
[2] https://ohioamishcountry.info/topics/ohio-amish-country-stores/
[3] https://ohiosamishcountry.com/shopping
[4] https://yourfamilysplace.com/blog/stores-in-amish-country-ohio/
[5] https://wng.org/articles/plain-truth-1656217623
[6] https://www.visitamishcountry.com/blog/few-best-places-shop-berlin-ohio
[7] https://ohiosamishcountry.com/businesses/shopping/lehmans
[8] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amish