Discover Tennessee’s New Amish Restaurant & Market
There’s a delicious new star rising in the Volunteer State: an Amish restaurant and market bringing authentic farm-to-table flavor, handcrafted baking, and warm, small-town hospitality to East Tennessee. Located in Greeneville, Hometown Marketplace is the must-visit food destination for anyone seeking hearty meals, artisan groceries, and the soul-satisfying quality of Amish cooking. Whether you’re after a slow-cooked sandwich, fresh-baked sweet, or a porch-swing-worthy pie, here’s what makes this new business buzz in Tennessee.
Hometown Marketplace – Greeneville, TN
Address: 72 Mt. Pleasant Rd, Greeneville, TN 37743
Webpage: hometownmarketplacetn.com
Hours: Monday–Saturday, 8am–5pm
This family-run Amish-style market is quickly winning over the region with its combination of deli meats, hand-rolled whoopie pies, fresh-baked breads, specialty jams, and a classic Southern buffet. The roots? The market is connected to the Stolus family—Pennsylvania Dutch transplants devoted to old-fashioned flavor and Mennonite-inspired hospitality.youtubehometownmarketplacetn
What’s on the Menu?
- Smash Burgers, Wraps, and Paninis: Build-your-own options, loaded with fresh veggies and Amish meats—including standout picks like habanero-jalapeno cheddar turkey, BBQ brisket, and a Reuben sandwich that sells out fast.troyersmountainviewyoutube
- Hearty Buffet Lunch Specials: Rotating daily, with favorites such as pastrami brisket, fried chicken, mac & cheese, green beans, mashed potatoes, and baked apple dessert. “The food bar was really good … well laid out, a lot of choices. I definitely want to go back there again.”youtube
- Bakery Counter: Cinnamon rolls, apple and peach pies, chess pie, fudge pie, cookies, wheat and white breads, plus seasonal fruit tarts and deep-dish take-and-bake options. Local fans say, “Baked goods were really good … the banana pudding is better than ones I’ve had in Lancaster.”troyersmountainviewyoutube
- Farm-Fresh Groceries: Eggs, Amish roll butter, local beef, jams, jellies, canned vegetables, and dip mixes ready for both the kitchen and the picnic basket.
- Homemade Sides: Redskin potato salad, creamy macaroni salad, pimento cheese, baked beans, and chicken salad with grape pecans or cranberries—perfect sides for a sandwich or a family gathering.amish-country-market-at-the-feed-mill.res-menu
Atmosphere & Amenities
- Friendly Staff: The team is known for kindness, efficiency, and eagerness to help both regulars and newcomers.
- Spacious Country Setting: Nestled near the Appalachian foothills, Hometown Marketplace offers indoor seating and an outdoor picnic area, perfect for families, groups, and solo visitors looking for a fresh meal by the mountains.hometownmarketplacetn
- Local Ownership, Amish Roots: Market-goers love the story—“I thought it was so cool that the guy was from the Stolus family. … If anybody is in the area of Greeneville, I would definitely recommend going by.”youtube
- Community Feeling: Commenters rave about the market’s welcoming energy, wide selection, and the surprise of discovering truly Amish flavor a short drive from major highways.
Rave Reviews
- “The baked goods were really good… delicious!”
- “The sampler lunch was packed with comfort food flavors. We wanted to try everything!”
- “I’d like to try one of their sandwiches next time—especially the Reuben.”
- “The brisket was really different, like pastrami—just cool and flavorful.”
- “Hometown Marketplace is a hidden gem—and the whole experience caught us off guard in a good way.”
More Amish Markets in Tennessee to Explore
If you’re traveling farther afield, other worthy Amish-style markets and restaurants include:
- Yoder’s Country Market (15275 W Andrew Johnson Hwy, Bulls Gap) [yodersmarkettn.com]—famed for deli meats, bakery sweets, and classic sandwiches.yodersmarkettn
- Troyer’s Mountain View Country Market (Highway 25/70, Limestone) [troyersmountainview.com]—full deli, sandwich shop, bakery, and grocery store with an Appalachian twist.troyersmountainview
- Nolensville Feed Mill & Amish Country Market (7280 Nolensville Rd, Nolensville) [nolensvillefeedmill.com]—famous for Buggy Wheel Sandwich, fried pies, and deeply local flavor.nolensvillefeedmill+1
- Amish Country Smoke House (49 Bud Taylor Rd, Ethridge) [amishofethridge.com/amish-country-smoke-house]—BBQ and hearty country plates in Tennessee Amish heartland.amishofethridge
- Butter Bean Cafe (Ethridge, TN) [amishofethridge.com/butter-bean-cafe]—steaks, chicken, and homemade sides.amishofethridge
Whether you’re seeking the perfect pie, a stacked sandwich, or the simple joy of a wholesome meal with a mountain view, Tennessee’s new Hometown Marketplace serves up farm-fresh flavor with Amish hospitality. From the bakery counter to the buffet bar, you’ll find plenty to love—and plenty of reasons to return (with a big appetite) again and again!
Check sources
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dsGVke3SPPU
- https://hometownmarketplacetn.com
- https://troyersmountainview.com
- https://amish-country-market-at-the-feed-mill.res-menu.com/menu
- https://yodersmarkettn.com
- https://nolensvillefeedmill.com/index.html
- https://amishofethridge.com/amish-country-smoke-house/
- https://amishofethridge.com/butter-bean-cafe/
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=Nashville%2C+TN
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=Tellico+Plains%2C+TN
- https://www.instagram.com/reel/DI1qtT9uWUj/?hl=en
- https://www.yelp.com/biz/amish-country-market-at-the-feed-mill-nolensville
- https://amishdoor.com
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g54950-d822111-r141750991-Farmers_Daughter-Chuckey_Tennessee.html
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g54945-d2616398-r697387880-Country_View_Market-Charlotte_Tennessee.html
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g54925-d8491307-r458028820-Yoder_s_Country_Market-Bulls_Gap_Tennessee.html
- https://www.yelp.com/biz/amish-country-market-at-the-feed-mill-nolensville?start=20
- https://order.nashvilledelivers.com/r/2266/restaurants/delivery/Sandwiches-Deli/Amish-Nolensville-Feed-Mill-Nolensville
- https://www.reddit.com/r/homestead/comments/17b2678/pole_barn_construction_costs/
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g55036-d27178618-Reviews-Amish_Country_Smoke_House-Ethridge_Tennessee.html