Have you ever wondered about the diversity within Amish communities? While you might think all Amish settlements are the same, there’s actually a surprising variety among them. Let’s explore five of the most unusual Amish communities that break the mold in fascinating ways.
Unity, Maine: The Friendly Innovators
The Amish community in Unity, Maine stands out as unique compared to other Amish settlements in several ways:
- They have a dedicated church meetinghouse, which is rare among Amish communities[1][2]. This building also serves as their school[2].
- The Unity Amish offer translators during sermons for non-Amish visitors, with one male and one female translator available[2]. This practice demonstrates their openness to outsiders.
- The community is particularly welcoming to outsiders and potential converts[2]. They seem to have a more outreach-oriented approach compared to many other Amish groups.
- Unity’s Amish have roots in an experimental church group called the Christian Communities, which influences some of their unique practices[2].
- They hold a special “Donut Day” on Wednesdays (and Saturdays in summer) at their Community Market, which has become popular with both Amish and non-Amish locals[1].
- The settlement is relatively small, consisting of about 23 families spread across 800 acres[1]. This makes up approximately 8% of Unity’s total population.
- Unlike some more conservative Amish groups, the Unity community appears to be more integrated with the local non-Amish population, running various businesses that cater to both Amish and non-Amish customers[1][3].
These characteristics make the Unity, Maine Amish community an atypical and particularly open Amish settlement compared to many others across North America.
Somerset County, Pennsylvania: The Church Builders
The Somerset County Amish community in Pennsylvania is unusual in several notable ways:
- It’s the second-oldest Amish community in North America, founded around 1772[1][2].
- Unlike most Amish communities, they worship in meetinghouses rather than homes. This practice was adopted in the late 1800s, which is highly atypical for Old Order Amish[1][2].
- Despite using meetinghouses, they’ve maintained their Old Order Amish identity and horse-and-buggy lifestyle[1].
- The community has managed to stay relatively small, with only about 1,565 Amish in 11 congregations as of 2024, despite its long history[2].
- They drive ‘Midwestern’ style buggies with slanted-in sides above the chassis, which is unusual for a Pennsylvania Amish community[1].
- The local public school is maintained by the Amish and employs Amish teachers, which is not common in most Amish settlements[1].
The Somerset County Amish buggies are distinctive in a few key ways:
- They feature a ‘Midwestern’ style design, with slanted-in sides above the chassis[2]. This is unusual for a Pennsylvania Amish community.
- Somerset County is likely the originator of this Midwestern buggy style[2]. Many Midwestern Amish settlements, such as those in Holmes County, Ohio, were founded by people who left Somerset in the 19th century and brought this buggy design with them.
- The use of this style in Somerset County is particularly noteworthy because it’s one of the oldest Amish settlements, founded around 1772[2]. Most Pennsylvania Amish communities use a different buggy style.
- Outside of Somerset County, this buggy design is primarily found in Midwestern Amish communities and in the Smicksburg community in Indiana County, Pennsylvania[2].
This unique buggy style sets Somerset County apart from other Pennsylvania Amish communities and creates an interesting historical link to Midwestern Amish settlements.
These unique characteristics make Somerset County stand out among Amish communities, blending traditional practices with some atypical customs.
Pinecraft, Florida: The Buggy-Free Beach Lovers
Nestled in the heart of Sarasota, Florida, lies a unique and fascinating community that might surprise you. Welcome to Pinecraft, an Amish and Mennonite enclave that defies stereotypes and offers a glimpse into a world where tradition meets tropical paradise.
A Snowbird’s Paradise
Pinecraft isn’t your typical Amish settlement. Unlike the large, established communities in Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Indiana, this Florida gem serves primarily as a vacation destination for Amish and Mennonite “snowbirds” seeking refuge from harsh northern winters[1]. While only about 100 Amish residents call Pinecraft home year-round, the population swells to 2,000-2,500 during peak winter months[2].
The community’s origins date back to the 1920s when a group of Amish farmers ventured south to grow celery. Although the soil proved unsuitable for their crops, they found the sunshine and warmth so agreeable that they never left[1]. Over time, Pinecraft evolved into a purpose-built accommodation center, allowing Amish vacationers to continue their traditional way of life while enjoying a change of scenery[1].
Bicycles and Golf Carts: A Twist on Tradition
One of the most striking features of Pinecraft is the absence of horse-drawn buggies, a hallmark of Amish communities elsewhere. Instead, you’ll find residents and visitors alike zipping around on adult-sized tricycles or, for those really embracing vacation mode, electric golf carts[1][2]. This departure from tradition is just one of many ways Pinecraft stands out from other Amish settlements.
A More Relaxed Approach
Pinecraft is known for its slightly more relaxed interpretation of Amish rules and customs. While still adhering to their core beliefs and values, many visitors find themselves adopting practices that might be frowned upon in their home communities[2]. For instance, some Amish who typically shun bicycles back home might be seen riding e-bikes in Pinecraft[2].
This flexibility extends to technology as well. Some Amish in Pinecraft may use computers for business purposes or even carry cell phones, albeit with restrictions like no internet connectivity[2]. It’s important to note, however, that these practices vary among individuals and groups within the community.
A Hub of Activity
Despite its laid-back atmosphere, Pinecraft buzzes with activity, especially during the winter months. Pinecraft Park serves as the community’s social center, featuring a bandstand, shuffleboard courts, and picnic areas where people gather to socialize and engage in handicrafts[1].
The Mennonite Tourist Church, purchased in 1946, plays a crucial role in community life. It serves as both a place of worship and a schoolhouse for year-round residents, offering education up to 8th grade in keeping with Amish and Mennonite traditions[1].
A Shopper’s Delight
Pinecraft is a treasure trove for those seeking authentic Amish goods. The community boasts a variety of stores selling handmade wood furniture, traditional clothing, quilts, dolls, and homemade soaps[1]. These shops offer visitors a chance to take home a piece of Amish craftsmanship and support local artisans.
Culinary Delights
No visit to Pinecraft would be complete without sampling its famous comfort food. The crown jewel of Pinecraft’s culinary scene is Yoder’s Restaurant & Amish Village, renowned for its delicious pies. With over 25 varieties baked fresh daily, Yoder’s has become a must-visit destination for both Amish visitors and curious outsiders[1][4].
Another local favorite is Der Dutchman, which was recently voted the No. 1 buffet in the country by USA Today readers[5]. These restaurants offer hearty, home-style meals that showcase the best of Amish cooking traditions.
A Welcoming Community
Despite their reputation for being closed off to outsiders, the Amish and Mennonite residents of Pinecraft are known for their welcoming attitude towards visitors[1][4]. This openness is partly due to the community’s reliance on tourism and its integration into the larger Sarasota area over time.
However, it’s important for visitors to remember that they are guests in this community. Respect for local customs and way of life is essential. While photography is generally tolerated, it’s best to be discreet and avoid taking close-up shots of individuals without permission[2].
The Rhythm of Pinecraft Life
Life in Pinecraft follows a distinct rhythm. During the week, the streets are alive with activity as visitors and residents alike enjoy the Florida sunshine, shop at local stores, and dine at popular restaurants. Sundays, however, paint a different picture. The town becomes almost deserted as the community observes their day of rest and worship[4].
A Unique Vacation Experience
For those looking to experience Pinecraft firsthand, the Carlisle Inn offers an opportunity to stay right in the heart of the community. This surprisingly upscale hotel features Amish-inspired decor and amenities that cater to both Amish visitors and curious outsiders[5].
More Than Just a Tourist Attraction
While Pinecraft welcomes tourists, it’s important to remember that it’s more than just an attraction. It’s a living, breathing community with its own customs, values, and way of life. Visitors are encouraged to approach their visit with respect and genuine curiosity about Amish and Mennonite culture.
From its humble beginnings as a celery farming experiment to its current status as a unique vacation destination, Pinecraft offers a fascinating glimpse into a world where traditional values meet modern realities. Whether you’re drawn by the promise of delicious home-cooked meals, handcrafted goods, or simply the chance to experience a different way of life, Pinecraft invites you to slow down, simplify, and savor the moment.
As you explore the streets of this charming community, riding a rented tricycle and sampling slice after slice of homemade pie, you might find yourself reflecting on your own lifestyle and values. And that, perhaps, is the true gift of Pinecraft – a chance to step out of the fast-paced modern world and into a community that cherishes simplicity, faith, and human connection above all else.
New Wilmington: The Colorful Carriage Crew
When you think of Amish buggies, you probably picture black or gray. But in New Wilmington, you’re in for a surprise[3]:
- Their buggies sport a distinctive brown or burnt-orange covering.
- This unique color sets them apart from other Amish communities.
New Wilmington: A Hidden Gem in Pennsylvania’s Countryside
Nestled in the rolling hills of western Pennsylvania, New Wilmington offers visitors a unique blend of history, culture, and natural beauty. This charming borough, established in 1863, serves as a gateway to the past while embracing the present, making it an ideal destination for travelers seeking an authentic American experience.
A Town Steeped in History
New Wilmington’s roots stretch back to the late 18th century when the first settlers arrived in the area. The town was officially platted in 1824 and became a borough in 1863[2]. Today, visitors can still feel the echoes of history as they stroll through the town’s well-preserved streets.
One of the most fascinating aspects of New Wilmington’s history is its connection to the Amish community. The town serves as a hub for the Old Order Amish community in the surrounding Wilmington Township[2]. This settlement, established in 1847, has grown to include 19 congregations and approximately 2,500 people as of 2013[2].
Educational Excellence
At the heart of New Wilmington lies Westminster College, a prestigious liberal arts institution that has been a cornerstone of the community since its founding. The college campus is not only a center of learning but also a place of beauty and contemplation. Visitors can explore the grounds and even find a labyrinth for spiritual meditation[4].
The presence of Westminster College adds a vibrant energy to the town, with students and faculty contributing to the local culture and economy. This blend of small-town charm and academic influence creates a unique atmosphere that sets New Wilmington apart from other rural communities.
The landscape surrounding New Wilmington is a testament to the beauty of Pennsylvania’s countryside. Rolling hills, lush forests, and picturesque farmlands provide a stunning backdrop for outdoor enthusiasts and nature lovers.
One of the best ways to experience the area’s natural beauty is through a self-guided driving tour of the Amish countryside. This journey offers visitors a glimpse into a simpler way of life, with scenic vistas of well-tended farms and horse-drawn buggies dotting the landscape[3].
For those seeking a more immersive experience, Simple Life Tours offers guided private tours of the Amish countryside. These two-hour excursions provide an authentic and respectful look into Amish culture, allowing visitors to gain a deeper understanding of this unique community[3].
Local Attractions and Experiences
While New Wilmington may be small in size, it offers a wealth of attractions and experiences for visitors:
- Apple Castle: This local favorite is a must-visit for fruit lovers and foodies alike. The orchard offers fresh apples, homemade treats, and a taste of rural Pennsylvania life[6].
- Irons Mills Farmstead: Experience farm life firsthand at this working farm, which offers tours and activities for visitors of all ages[6].
- The Cheese House: Indulge in artisanal cheeses and local specialties at this charming shop[7].
- Fractured Grape Wine Cellars: Wine enthusiasts can sample local vintages and enjoy the relaxed atmosphere of this boutique winery[7][8].
- Banks Covered Bridge: Step back in time as you visit this historic covered bridge, a picturesque reminder of Pennsylvania’s past[8].
Amish Culture and Craftsmanship
One of the most compelling reasons to visit New Wilmington is the opportunity to experience Amish culture firsthand. The Old Order Amish community in the area maintains many traditional practices, including the use of horse-drawn buggies and a focus on simplicity and faith.
Visitors can explore Amish-owned businesses, where handcrafted furniture, quilts, and other goods showcase the community’s renowned craftsmanship. These interactions offer a unique opportunity to learn about a way of life that has remained largely unchanged for centuries.
Seasonal Delights
New Wilmington’s charm evolves with the seasons, offering visitors different experiences throughout the year:
- Spring: Witness the countryside come to life as fruit trees blossom and farmers begin planting their crops.
- Summer: Enjoy outdoor activities, farmers’ markets, and community events that showcase the town’s vibrant spirit.
- Fall: Experience the breathtaking autumn foliage and participate in harvest-time activities at local farms.
- Winter: Embrace the quiet beauty of snow-covered landscapes and cozy up in local cafes and shops.
For those looking to extend their stay, New Wilmington offers a range of accommodations that cater to different preferences:
- The Jacqueline House of Wilmington: This bed and breakfast provides high-quality accommodations and a full breakfast, perfect for both tourists and business travelers[3].
- The Inn on Market: Located in the heart of New Wilmington, this upscale inn offers comfortable rooms and easy access to local attractions[3].
These establishments not only provide a place to rest but also offer a taste of local hospitality, ensuring visitors feel welcome and at home.
A Community-Driven Future
In recent years, New Wilmington has taken steps to enhance its appeal to visitors while maintaining its unique character. The formation of the New Wilmington Economic Development Committee in 2014 and the launch of the LIVE New Wilmington campaign in 2016 demonstrate the community’s commitment to growth and vitality[2].
These initiatives focus on promoting the town’s strengths in arts, education, environment, and community spirit. By nurturing these aspects, New Wilmington aims to create an even more vibrant and welcoming atmosphere for residents and visitors alike.
New Wilmington, Pennsylvania, may not be the first destination that comes to mind when planning a trip, but it offers a wealth of experiences for those willing to venture off the beaten path. From its rich history and educational legacy to its natural beauty and unique cultural blend, this small borough has something to offer every type of traveler.
Whether you’re interested in exploring Amish culture, enjoying outdoor activities, or simply soaking in the charm of small-town America, New Wilmington provides a refreshing alternative to more crowded tourist destinations. Its commitment to preserving tradition while embracing progress makes it a fascinating place to visit, offering insights into both America’s past and its evolving present.
As you plan your next getaway, consider adding New Wilmington to your itinerary. This hidden gem in Pennsylvania’s countryside promises an authentic, enriching, and memorable experience that will leave you with a deeper appreciation for the diverse tapestry of American life.
Guthrie, Kentucky: The Electrifying Exception
Last but not least, the Amish in Guthrie, Kentucky, might shock you with their modern convenience[3]:
- This small group of “electric New Order” Amish allows public electricity in their homes.
- They maintain other Amish traditions while embracing this technological advancement.
The Amish Community of Guthrie, Kentucky: A Unique Blend of Tradition and Progress
Nestled in the rolling hills of Todd County, Kentucky, the Amish community of Guthrie offers visitors a fascinating glimpse into a way of life that balances time-honored traditions with selective modernization. Established in 1958, this settlement holds the distinction of being the oldest Amish community in Kentucky, making it a cornerstone of Amish heritage in the Bluegrass State[1][4].
What sets the Guthrie Amish apart is their classification as “electric” New Order Amish. This unique designation means that while they maintain many traditional Amish practices, they have adopted certain modern conveniences, most notably the use of electricity in their homes[2][4]. Visitors to Guthrie might be surprised to see Amish homes with electric lights or appliances, a sight uncommon in most Amish settlements.
The Guthrie Amish still adhere to core Amish values and practices. They dress plainly, use horse-drawn buggies for local transportation, and speak Pennsylvania Dutch among themselves[4]. However, their progressive stance on technology extends beyond electricity. Tractors are widely used not just for farming but also for road transportation, a practice that distinguishes them from more conservative Amish groups[2].
Historical Roots
The origins of the Guthrie community can be traced back to Stuarts Draft, Virginia. The founders of this Kentucky settlement moved westward following a division within their Virginia church, seeking to establish a community that balanced traditional values with a more progressive outlook[1][4]. This history of thoughtful adaptation to change continues to shape the character of the Guthrie Amish today.
As of recent counts, the Guthrie settlement comprises two church districts with approximately 345 people[2]. While smaller than some Amish communities, Guthrie’s influence on Amish life in Kentucky is significant, having paved the way for other settlements throughout the state.
Economic Activities
Visitors to Guthrie will find a variety of Amish-owned businesses that showcase the community’s industriousness and craftsmanship. Family vocations include farming, sawmills, pallet shops, and carpentry[1]. These businesses not only sustain the community but also provide unique shopping opportunities for tourists.
Schlabach’s Bakery: A Must-Visit Destination
One of the crown jewels of Guthrie’s Amish businesses is Schlabach’s Bakery. Founded in 1970, it stands as potentially one of the oldest continuously operating Amish bakeries in the country[2]. Located at 6225 Guthrie Road, this charming establishment offers a wide array of baked goods that have been delighting locals and visitors for over half a century.
Visitors to Schlabach’s can expect to find an impressive selection of treats, including:
- Cinnamon rolls (a best-seller)
- Sourdough bread
- Pies
- Granola
- Fried pies
- Banana bread
- Traditional breads
- Cakes
The bakery also offers a variety of honey, jams, and other canned goods[2]. Its cozy garden setting and simple, old-fashioned signage add to the charm of the experience.
Experiencing Amish Life in Guthrie
For tourists interested in experiencing Amish culture, Guthrie offers several unique opportunities:
- Self-guided driving tours: Take a leisurely drive through the countryside to observe Amish farms and businesses. Keep an eye out for the distinctive blue or red tractors parked outside Amish homes[2].
- Shopping at Amish stores: Visit local Amish-owned businesses to purchase handcrafted furniture, quilts, and other goods that showcase traditional Amish craftsmanship.
- Seasonal activities: Depending on the time of year, visitors might observe Amish farmers working in the fields or participate in harvest-time activities.
- Dining experiences: While respecting Amish privacy, some establishments may offer opportunities to taste traditional Amish cuisine.
The Broader Context: Amish in Kentucky
The Guthrie settlement is part of a larger Amish presence in Kentucky. As of 2024, the state is home to nearly 16,000 Amish people living in over 50 communities[3]. This makes Kentucky’s Amish population the 8th largest in the United States, a remarkable fact considering Amish settlement in the state only began in the 1950s.
While Guthrie represents the “electric” New Order Amish, Kentucky is home to a diverse range of Amish groups, including Old Order and ultra-conservative Swartzentruber Amish[3]. This diversity offers visitors a chance to observe and appreciate the various ways Amish communities interpret and live out their faith and traditions.
Planning Your Visit
The best times to visit Guthrie depend on your interests:
- Spring and summer offer beautiful views of Amish farms in full production.
- Fall provides stunning foliage and harvest-time activities.
- Winter, while quieter, can offer a serene glimpse into Amish life during the colder months.
Remember to check operating hours for businesses like Schlabach’s Bakery before your visit. Many Amish businesses are closed on Sundays and may have limited hours during the week[2].
The Amish community of Guthrie, Kentucky, presents a unique opportunity for visitors to witness a fascinating blend of traditional Amish life and selective modernization. From its historical significance as Kentucky’s oldest Amish settlement to its distinctive “electric” New Order practices, Guthrie offers insights into the diversity and adaptability of Amish culture.
Whether you’re sampling fresh-baked goods at Schlabach’s Bakery, observing Amish farmers at work, or simply enjoying the picturesque countryside, a visit to Guthrie promises a memorable and educational experience. As you explore this unique community, you’ll gain a deeper appreciation for the Amish way of life and the ongoing dialogue between tradition and progress that shapes their world.
These unusual communities show that Amish life isn’t one-size-fits-all. Each settlement has its own character and customs, making the Amish world more diverse than you might have imagined. So next time you’re near one of these places, why not stop by? You might be surprised by what you discover!
Citations:
[1] https://amishamerica.com/atypical-amish-community-unity-maine/
[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p1e5UIpKLVo
[3] https://www.dutchcrafters.com/blog/unusual-amish-communities/
[4] https://ohiosamishcountry.com/articles/amish-business
[5] https://amishamerica.com/5-amish-businesses-you-should-visit/
[6] https://www.discoverlancaster.com/blog/amish-facts/
[7] https://www.reddit.com/r/AskEurope/comments/qo47sf/are_there_any_amishlike_communities_in_europe/
[8] https://www.dutchcrafters.com/blog/everything-you-want-to-know-about-amish-businesses/