A special thanks to Deb Lambert that compiled this list.
Nestled within the picturesque landscapes of Ohio Amish Country, a hidden world of thrift store treasures awaits those with an eye for unique finds. As you venture through the rolling hills and charming villages of this region, don’t miss the opportunity to discover a diverse range of thrift shops that offer everything from vintage clothing to antique furniture. Here’s a guide to some of the most noteworthy thrift stores in the area.
Goodwill 1098 Glen Dr, Millersburg, OH Located near the Holiday Inn, Goodwill in Millersburg is the perfect starting point for your thrift store adventure. This store boasts a wide selection of clothing, housewares, and unique trinkets, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Harvest Thrift (Sugarcreek) 1915 OH-39, Sugarcreek, OH Situated conveniently across from the Walnut Creek Amish Flea Market, Harvest Thrift in Sugarcreek is a haven for bargain hunters. From gently used furniture to vintage clothing, this store is a treasure trove of eclectic finds.
Harvest Thrift (Wilmot) 102 E Main Street, Wilmot, OH Wilmot’s Harvest Thrift is a unique gem with not one but two buildings filled with secondhand delights. Near a traffic light and Cafe 8:32, this thrift store offers a wide variety of items, including antiques and collectibles.
Home & Hope Thrift 9488 Dover Rd, Apple Creek, OH Located along Rt. 250 near Waynedale High School, Home & Hope Thrift is more than just a store; it’s a place where you can support the local community while hunting for hidden treasures. Expect to find a diverse range of items, from clothing to home decor.
MCC Connections 4080 Kidron Rd, Kidron, OH Just a short drive north of Lehman’s, MCC Connections offers a unique shopping experience in the heart of Amish Country. This store is known for its fair prices and a selection that includes everything from books to kitchenware.
Mission Thrift 4475 OH-39, Millersburg, OH Right beside Troyer’s Market on Route 39 in Berlin, Mission Thrift is a must-visit destination for those seeking both great deals and a sense of community. Explore a wide array of secondhand items while immersing yourself in the local culture.
Save & Serve Thrift 1108 S Washington St, Millersburg, OH Conveniently located near Goodwill in Millersburg, Save & Serve Thrift offers a vast selection of gently used clothing, household goods, and more. It’s a fantastic place to explore, especially if you’re in the mood for some thrift store hopping.
Share & Care Thrift 4663 US-62, Millersburg Situated in Berlin, not far from the Sheiyah Market, Share & Care Thrift is a hidden gem that boasts an ever-changing inventory. Whether you’re searching for a unique souvenir or a practical item for your home, this store is worth a visit.
Trading Post Thrift 7720 OH-241, Millersburg, OH Located near Mt. Hope, at the corner of Routes 241 and 235, Trading Post Thrift is a delightful stop for those exploring the Amish countryside. You’ll find a wide range of items here, from clothing to furniture, all at thrift-friendly prices.
While you’re in the area, consider taking a short drive to discover other thrift store options, such as Helping Hearts Thrift in Strasburg, situated within the Strasburg Antique Mall. You can also explore Mission Thrift near Dollar 1 and Aldi in Wooster, or visit Mission Thrift near Save-A-Lot in Orrville.
Navigating the Thrift Store Trail
As you embark on your thrift store journey in Ohio Amish Country, it’s important to plan your route strategically to make the most of your time and maximize your chances of discovering unique items. Here are some tips to help you navigate the thrift store trail efficiently:
- Map It Out: Before hitting the road, use a map or GPS to mark the locations of the thrift stores you plan to visit. Consider grouping stores that are near each other to minimize travel time.
- Timing Matters: Thrift stores may have varying operating hours, so be sure to check in advance. Some stores might be closed on certain days of the week, so plan accordingly.
- Cash is King: While many thrift stores accept credit and debit cards, it’s a good idea to carry some cash with you. Some smaller thrift shops may prefer or only accept cash payments.
- Bring Reusable Bags: Help reduce waste by bringing your own reusable shopping bags. It’s also handy to have a few tote bags in your car for larger purchases.
- Dress Comfortably: Thrifting can be a bit of a treasure hunt, so wear comfortable clothing and shoes that are easy to slip on and off when trying on clothing or shoes.
- Inspect Thoroughly: Take your time to inspect items closely. Look for any flaws, missing pieces, or signs of wear. Sometimes, a small imperfection can be easily fixed or overlooked for a fantastic bargain.
- Haggle Politely: In some thrift stores, especially smaller ones, you may have room for negotiation on prices. Approach this with respect and politeness, and be prepared for the possibility of a deal.
- Support the Local Community: Keep in mind that your purchases at these thrift stores often go towards supporting local charities or organizations. It’s a great feeling to know that your thrift shopping is making a positive impact.
- Explore Nearby Attractions: Ohio Amish Country has much more to offer than thrift stores. Take breaks to explore Amish bakeries, dine at local restaurants, and visit the quaint shops and markets that dot the countryside.
- Be Respectful: While you’re out and about, remember to respect the Amish way of life. If you encounter an Amish horse and buggy on the road, slow down and give them plenty of space. And when visiting their stores, maintain a respectful and considerate demeanor.
Whether you’re a seasoned thrifter or just looking for a unique adventure in Ohio Amish Country, these thrift stores offer a glimpse into a world of hidden treasures waiting to be discovered. From antique furniture to vintage clothing, you’ll find a diverse range of items that tell stories of the past and present, all while immersing yourself in the charm of this scenic region. So, gather your fellow thrift enthusiasts, hit the road, and embark on a thrifting adventure you won’t soon forget in the heart of Amish Country! Happy thrifting!
