Tennessee, where rolling hills meet storied traditions, is a state that knows how to showcase its Amish heritage through vibrant markets filled with handmade goods, unbeatable baked treats, farm-fresh produce, and unmatched hospitality. As a tourism editor journeying through Tennessee’s countryside, I’ve tracked down five of the most popular Amish markets—each bursting with unique products, personality, and authentic reviews from regulars and first-timers. Here’s your ticket to discovering, tasting, and savoring the best the Volunteer State’s Amish communities have to offer.
1. Nolensville Feed Mill Amish Country Market (Nolensville)
Set in a historic mill dating to 1890, Nolensville Feed Mill transports visitors to a bygone era with the aroma of fresh breads, pies, smoked meats, and shelves piled high with Amish staples. Owner Darin Scheff preserves the mill’s rustic charm while offering an impressive array of goods sourced from Amish communities in Tennessee and Ohio.nolensvillefeedmill
Favorite Products:

- Sticky buns and cinnamon rolls
- Amish noodles, jams, pickles, and apple butter
- Cheddar and smoked cheeses
- Take-&-Bake meals
- Homemade candy and chips
Review:
“Every bite reminds me of my grandma’s kitchen—best sticky buns in Tennessee!”
2. Amish Creations & Country Market (Sevierville, Smoky Mountains)
Located in the heart of Sevierville’s shopping district, this market offers a dazzling assortment of Amish-made goods—from noodles and bulk candies to hand-carved toys, skin salves, and rustic soaps. Shoppers say it’s a place where “you find things you cannot live without and maybe one you can.”tripadvisor
Favorite Products:
- Amish cheddar and farm butter
- Hand-dipped candies and fudge
- Canning products and hand-painted cookware
- Whoopie pies and jams
- Non-GMO dry goods
Review:
“Love this market—soups to soaps, beans to butter…full of friendly staff and the best fudge anywhere!”
3. Amish Market – Ethridge
Ethridge is Tennessee’s largest Amish settlement, and its well-stocked market is an essential stop for any traveler. Bruce Stoll, the knowledgeable manager, stocks shelves with local jerky, cheeses, jams, sweetworks, molasses, honey, and the full spectrum of “Amish essentials.”amishofethridge
Favorite Products:
- Ghost pepper cheese, pepperoni, summer sausage, jerky
- Sorghum molasses, fudge, apple butter
- Chocolates and peanut brittle
- Fresh local honey
- Homemade popcorn, spices, cookbooks

Review:
“The variety is unbeatable—best molasses, cheeses, and treats. Bruce is a local legend!”
4. Englewood Farm Market (Athens)
A true hidden gem in Athens, Englewood Farm Market offers earth-grown produce, cookies, pies and breads straight from the farm and greenhouse. Run by Old Order Mennonites with Amish connections, people praise both the quality and warmth of the market staff.tripadvisor
Favorite Products:
- Fresh garden vegetables (tomatoes, cucumbers, cantaloupe, watermelon, corn)
- Bulk produce for canning
- Baked goods (pies, cookies, breads)
- Duck eggs and herbs
Review:
“Best fresh veggies in the state—friendly people, all grown right here. I always come back for more.”
5. Troyer’s Mountain View Country Market (Pikeville/East Tennessee)
A family-run market featuring a full deli, Amish country meats and cheeses, bulk foods, housewares, and sweets. Troyer’s is renowned for its “country hospitality” and the variety of specialty products on the shelves.troyersmountainview
Favorite Products:
- Amish deli meats (roast beef, turkey, bologna)
- Artisan cheeses and creamery butter
- Bulk candies and nuts
- Jams, jellies, maple syrup
- Housewares, handwoven baskets, and cookbooks
Review:
“Everything’s delicious. Fantastic sandwiches, and their jams can’t be beat. I always stock up on cheese and treats for road trips.”

Quotes & Highlights
- “Nolensville Feed Mill is like stepping into history—sticky buns, homemade candy, and friendliness at every turn.”nolensvillefeedmill
- “Ethridge market is Tennessee’s best-kept secret; the molasses and cheeses are legendary.”amishofethridge
- “Englewood Farm Market has unbeatable produce and the warmest staff—always worth a visit.”tripadvisor
- “We make weekend trips for Troyer meats, bulk snacks, and delightful jam flights!”
- “Sevierville’s Amish Creations blends tradition and variety—love the hand-carved toys and fudge.”tripadvisor
Tourism Editor’s Tips
- Many markets open seasonally—be sure to call or check online before visiting.
- Arrive early for best selections in baked goods, deli meats, and produce.
- Bring cash for roadside and bulk purchases (some accept cards, but cash is often preferred).
- Markets often stock locally made crafts, kitchenware, soaps, and seeds—great for unique gifts.
- Try something unfamiliar (like sorghum molasses or summer sausage) for a true Amish culinary adventure!

Check sources
- https://nolensvillefeedmill.com/index.html
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g55328-d2452008-Reviews-Amish_Creations_Country_Market-Sevierville_Tennessee.html
- https://amishofethridge.com/amish-market/
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g30132-d20949600-Reviews-Englewood_Farm_Market-Athens_Tennessee.html
- https://troyersmountainview.com
- https://amishamerica.com/5-things-i-regularly-buy-at-amish-stores/
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dsGVke3SPPU
- https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/experiences/tennessee/ethridge-amish-flea-market-tn
- https://www.reddit.com/r/nashville/comments/vu3zw3/anyone_driving_up_to_kentucky_for_the_amish_stores/
- https://diynatural.com/amish-made-products-we-love/
- https://www.reddit.com/r/Clarksville/comments/1dkkqe1/amish_or_farmers_market/
- https://marketwagon.com/amish-market-produce-in-chattanooga-tn
- https://experiencetn.guide/local/amish-market
- https://www.nashvillefarmersmarket.org
