The 3 Outstanding Amish Markets in Upstate New York
Upstate New York is home to a vibrant Amish and Mennonite community, known for their old-world traditions, wholesome foods, and meticulous craftsmanship. Tucked among rolling hills and charming towns, several Amish markets offer visitors a chance to experience authentic homemade goods, farm-fresh eats, and unique treasures — all delivered with warmth and hospitality. Here are three standout markets, each with its own special menu items and atmosphere.
1. The Windmill Farm & Craft Market
Address: 3900 NY-14A, Penn Yan, NY 14527
Website: thewindmill.com
Nestled in the scenic Finger Lakes, The Windmill Farm & Craft Market is arguably the largest and most well-known Amish-influenced market in the region. Established over 35 years ago and open every Saturday from April through November, this sprawling outdoor-and-indoor market is a bustling hub of local vendors, drawing visitors from New York, Pennsylvania, and beyond. thewindmill+1
What Makes The Windmill Unique:
- 175+ Indoor/Outdoor Shops: Everything from fresh produce, hand-stitched quilts, and floral arrangements to custom cabinetry and hand-crafted furniture.
- Amish-Made Specialties: Daily baked goods such as classic cinnamon rolls, shoo-fly pie, fruit pies, cookies, and sticky buns.
- Bulk Foods: Grains, flours, baking essentials, and nut butters, plus locally sourced maple syrup, honey, and homemade jams.
- Dining & Snacks: Sample homemade pretzels, popcorn, fudge, smoked meats, and gourmet cheeses. Multiple vendor stalls offer full meals, snacks, and beverages, accommodating both sit-down and grab-and-go options.
- Crafts & Gifts: Quilts, pottery, wooden toys, woven baskets, and seasonal decorations.
- Produce: Fresh fruits and vegetables, organic eggs, cheese curds, and deli meats.
- Family Fun: Pony rides, craft demonstrations, and live entertainment.
Insider Tip: Start the day with a cup of Amish-roasted coffee and a fresh cinnamon bun, then browse the market’s streets for gifts, produce, and locally made sweets. Stay for lunch and sample homemade chicken pot pie or hearty soups, served with slices of home-baked bread.
2. Sauders Store (Market & Cafe)
Address: 2146 River Road, Seneca Falls, NY 13148
Website: discoverseneca.com/listing/sauders-market-&-store/210/
Sauders Store is a Mennonite family-run market steady in its commitment to authentic quality and selection, located in the heart of the Finger Lakes. Renowned for its extensive grocery selection and inviting atmosphere, Sauders blends Amish and Mennonite culinary traditions, making it a favorite stop for both locals and tourists. discoverseneca
Sauders Store Highlights:
- Homemade Baked Goods: Pies (apple, cherry, blueberry), fresh breads (wheat, white, rye), cookies, and pastries.
- Bulk Foods: Dried fruits, flours, organic grains, beans, local honey, pasta, seasonings, and more.
- Deli & Café: Freshly made sandwiches, soups, and deli meats/cheeses cut to order. Popular menu items include turkey and Swiss sandwiches, homemade salads, and “Amish potato salad.”
- Seasonal Fruits & Vegetables: Locally grown produce, jams, pickles, and canned goods.
- Specialty Groceries: Amish butter, cheese curds, nut butters, granola, and unique snack mixes.
Insider Tip: Try the famous “Whoopie Pie” and artisanal cheese curds. Friendly staff can help you select a picnic lunch to enjoy at nearby Seneca Lake or Montezuma Wildlife Refuge.
3. Sunnycrest Markets
Address: 7869 NY-10, Sharon Springs, NY 13459
Website: sunnycrestmarkets.com
A newer yet highly promising addition, Sunnycrest Markets is a family-friendly Amish-style market that brings charming homemade fare and handcrafted wares to the picturesque countryside around Sharon Springs. Sunnycrest offers indoor and outdoor shopping, with friendly owners always ready to share stories behind their goods. sunnycrestmarkets
Sunnycrest Markets Highlights:
- Fresh-Baked Pretzels: Sweet and savory soft pretzels made daily.
- Bulk Groceries: Beans, grains, pastas, baking ingredients, and regional specialties.
- Playsets & Furniture: Wooden swings, picnic tables, and backyard playsets crafted by local Amish artisans.
- Handmade Sweets: Fudge, fruit pies, honey, maple syrup, and more.
- Local Produce & Pantry Items: Seasonal fruits, veggies, and a selection of canned jams and spreads.
- Family-Focused Atmosphere: Free samples, play areas for kids, and regular community events.
Insider Tip: Snack on a homemade pretzel while shopping for unique wooden toys or furniture, then take home a basket of fresh produce and Amish candy.
Popular Menu Items at Amish Markets
At these markets, customer favorites include:
- Cinnamon Rolls, Shoo-fly Pie, Apple and Fruit Pies
- Freshly Baked Breads (white, wheat, rye)
- Amish Potato Salad, Macaroni Salad, Homemade Soups
- Smoked Meats, Cheese Curds, Deli Sandwiches
- Whoopie Pies, Fudge, Nut Butters
- Soft Pretzels, Donuts, Cookies
- Organic Eggs, Maple Syrup, Raw Honey
- Seasonal Produce: apples, berries, corn, pumpkins
- Snack Mixes, Dried Fruits, Granola
Final Thoughts
Exploring Amish markets in Upstate New York is more than a shopping trip — it’s an immersion into a culture that prizes craftsmanship, simplicity, and community. Each market offers its own distinct flavors and surprises, from mouthwatering baked goods to handmade wooden toys. Whether you seek the bustle of The Windmill, the cozy hospitality of Sauders Store, or the family-friendly warmth of Sunnycrest Markets, you will encounter upstate New York’s best through the authentic taste and artistry of its Amish residents. onlyinyourstate+3
Check sources
- https://www.thewindmill.com
- https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/experiences/new-york/amish-market-ny
- https://www.discoverseneca.com/listing/sauders-market-&-store/210/
- https://sunnycrestmarkets.com
- https://www.amishfinefood.com
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Market&find_loc=New+York%2C+NY
- https://homeinthefingerlakes.com/amish-and-mennonite-food-stores-in-new-york/
- https://amishamerica.com/12-amish-mennonite-food-outlets-in-upstate-ny/
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Market&find_loc=Rochester%2C+NY
- https://www.reddit.com/r/Kentucky/comments/1063por/what_you_get_for_200_when_shopping_at_amish/
- https://www.orleanscountytourism.com/shop/amish-and-mennonite-store
- https://www.tripadvisor.com.au/ShowTopic-g60763-i5-k6247445-Authentic_Amish_crafts-New_York_City_New_York.html
- https://amishamerica.com/amish-business-map-livingston-county-new-york/
- https://www.reddit.com/r/upstate_new_york/comments/1aw4qij/any_good_places_to_get_amish_baked_goods_and_such/
- https://www.thisiscooperstown.com/listing/weavers-farm-market/2182/
- https://www.eastamish45.com
- https://amishtrail.com/map