The 3 Must-Visit Amish Markets in the Finger Lakes Region of New York State
If you love discovering farm-fresh produce, hand-rolled pies, and the neighborly warmth of an authentic country store, the Finger Lakes region is your paradise—and the Amish markets here offer some of the most delicious, charming, and welcoming stops in upstate New York. Whether you’re stocking up on pantry staples or just want to taste the best rhubarb pie in the state, these three standout markets showcase why the Finger Lakes are a haven for foodies and fans of tradition alike!
1. The Windmill Farm & Craft Market — Penn Yan
Address: 3900 NY-14A, Penn Yan, NY 14527
Website: thewindmill.com
Nestled between Keuka and Seneca Lakes, the Windmill is a unique destination—spanning 44 acres with over 160 vendors, it’s one of the largest rural open-air markets in New York and a hub for Amish-made food, crafts, and goods. Open Saturdays from April to November, it’s where handmade pastries, fresh produce, country furniture, wine tastings, jams, and crafts fill booth after booth.tripadvisor+1
What People Love:
- Genuine Amish baked goods (whoopie pies, cinnamon raisin bread, fresh donuts)
- Beautiful wood furniture and home decor
- Fresh produce straight from Amish gardens
- Six on-site wineries, loads of local honey, and a lively, picnic-friendly vibe
Quotes & Reviews:
- “There’s nothing like wandering the Windmill—every visit is an adventure. The bakery counter is a must, and the strawberry-rhubarb pie is out of this world!”
- “As tourists, this was our favorite stop for locally made crafts and farm goods. The Amish wood furniture and baked goods are top-notch.”tripadvisor
- “Clean, well-organized, and with plenty of variety. Worth a stop for anyone visiting the region!”
2. Sauders Store — Seneca Falls
Address: 2146 River Rd., Seneca Falls, NY 13148
Website: saudersstore.com
Sauders Store is famous for its sprawling bakery, bulk foods, Dutch Country deli, cheese shop, and fresh produce—all offered in a cheerful, Mennonite-run grocery that’s a local institution. Taste real farm-to-table fare, discover hard-to-find spices, and enjoy friendly Amish-Mennonite hospitality. Sauders features a “country cookin’ cafe,” freshly smoked meats, and a delightful selection of jams and sweets, making it a favorite for day trippers and passing travelers.discoverseneca+2
Favorites:
- Homemade breads and pies (try the apple fritters and Dutch crumb pie!)
- Smoked meats and cheeses
- “Swiss Deli” sandwiches and farm-fresh eggs
- Bulk spices, beans, candy—perfect for stocking up the pantry
Quotes & Reviews:
- “Sauders always has something new to try—every pie and bread is fresh from the oven, and the deli meats are the best in New York.”
- “The cheese counter is a wonder, and the service is always old-fashioned polite. I could browse for hours!”
- “If you’re looking for real Amish flavor in the Finger Lakes, this is the place.”
3. Oak Hill Bulk Foods — Penn Yan
Address: 3173 Route 14A, Penn Yan, NY 14527
Website: oakhillbulkfoods.com
A local favorite for bulk baking supplies, fresh produce, and garden-to-table fare, Oak Hill Bulk Foods is where home cooks, bakers, and fans of simple goodness go to stock up. Family-owned and proudly Mennonite, the store boasts a bakery (with famous cookies and breads), a full deli, and a cozy in-store café for soups, sandwiches, and desserts. Oak Hill is praised for friendly staff and unbeatable value.oakhillbulkfoods+1
Best Finds:
- Fresh cookies, cinnamon rolls, loaf breads, and pies
- Bulk ingredients—oats, flour, beans, nuts—for every recipe
- Homemade salads and deli sandwiches
- Local jams, preserves, and salsas
Quotes & Reviews:
- “Oak Hill is my favorite Amish market—I drive two hours to stock up! The cinnamon rolls and pies are crazy good, and the bulk foods save me a fortune.”tripadvisor
- “Super friendly service, with everything you need to fill your pantry. Can’t leave without a sticky bun!”
- “Oak Hill is a hidden treasure in the Finger Lakes. Great selection, great staff, and the food is fresh and delicious.”
The Amish markets of the Finger Lakes are full of country charm, unbeatable flavor, and neighborly spirit. Bring a big basket—these stores offer everything from fresh-picked produce and garden pies to handcrafted furniture and pantry staples. Every visit is a delicious adventure, and you’ll leave wishing you could shop Amish every day!
Check sources
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g48378-d672664-Reviews-The_Windmill_Farm_Craft_Market-Penn_Yan_Finger_Lakes_New_York.html
- https://www.thewindmill.com
- https://www.discoverseneca.com/listing/sauders-market-&-store/210/
- https://www.saudersstore.com
- https://www.iloveny.com/listing/sauders-market-&-store/465/
- https://oakhillbulkfoods.com
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g48378-d7331751-r578179768-Oak_Hill_Bulk_Foods-Penn_Yan_Finger_Lakes_New_York.html
- https://homeinthefingerlakes.com/amish-and-mennonite-food-stores-in-new-york/
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish&find_loc=Seneca+Falls%2C+NY+13148
- https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/experiences/new-york/amish-market-ny
- https://secretamericatravel.com/amish-finger-lakes-new-york/
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Market&find_loc=Penn+Yan%2C+NY+14527
- https://roadslesstraveled.us/amish-farms-of-the-ny-finger-lakes/
- https://secretamericatravel.com/best-amish-markets-in-finger-lakes-by-season/
- https://www.reddit.com/r/Syracuse/comments/e1wyxr/amish_markets_outside_of_syracuse/
- https://www.yelp.com/biz/the-windmill-farm-and-craft-market-penn-yan?start=40