A Growing Tradition: Exploring the Amish and Mennonite Community in Highland County, Ohio
Tucked into the rolling hills and fertile farmland of southern Ohio, Highland County is quietly becoming one of the state’s most fascinating destinations for those seeking authentic Amish and Mennonite experiences. Over the past decade, this region has seen a steady influx of Amish and Mennonite families, drawn by affordable land, rural tranquility, and a welcoming local spirit. Today, Highland County offers a unique blend of tradition, craftsmanship, and community—making it a must-visit for travelers eager to explore Ohio’s rich cultural tapestry.
A New Chapter for Highland County
The Amish and Mennonite presence in Highland County is a relatively recent phenomenon. Families from Holmes County, Ohio, and Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, began settling here in the early 2010s. Their arrival has brought new life to the countryside, with horse-drawn buggies sharing the roads with tractors, and whitewashed farmhouses dotting the landscape.
“We were looking for a place where our children could grow up close to the land,” says Eli Yoder, a local Amish farmer. “Highland County has good soil, friendly people, and room to build a future.”
Local residents have welcomed these new neighbors. “The Amish and Mennonites have brought a sense of community back to the area,” says Linda Foster, who runs a small café in Hillsboro. “They’re hardworking, honest, and always willing to lend a hand.”
Yoder’s Market: The Heart of Amish Hospitality
No visit to Highland County’s Amish country is complete without a stop at Yoder’s Market (2621 State Route 133, Buford, OH 45110, yodersmarket.com). This bustling family-run store is the heart of the local Amish and Mennonite community, offering everything from bulk foods and fresh produce to homemade baked goods and handcrafted furniture.
“We wanted to create a place where everyone feels welcome,” says Mary Yoder, who manages the market with her husband and children. “Our shelves are filled with products made by local families—jams, cheeses, candies, and more. People come from all over Ohio just to try our cinnamon rolls and fried pies.”
Yoder’s Market is also a gathering place for locals and visitors alike. On Saturdays, the parking lot fills with buggies and pickup trucks as families stock up on essentials and catch up with friends. “It’s more than a store—it’s a community center,” says regular customer Tom Jenkins.
Local Businesses: A Blend of Old and New
The Amish and Mennonite community has helped revitalize Highland County’s rural economy. In addition to Yoder’s Market, several other businesses are worth exploring:
- Highland County Produce Auction
7516 US-62, Hillsboro, OH 45133
highlandcountyproduceauction.com
This lively auction is held throughout the growing season, with local Amish and Mennonite farmers selling everything from fresh vegetables to flowers and bedding plants. “It’s a great way to meet the growers and get the best produce around,” says auction manager Sarah Miller. - Keim Family Market
2621 Burnt Cabin Rd, Seaman, OH 45679
keimfamilymarket.com
Just a short drive from Highland County, this market features Amish baked goods, cheeses, and handcrafted gifts. “We love sharing our family recipes with visitors,” says owner Daniel Keim. - Hillsboro Harness & Tack
12345 US-50, Hillsboro, OH 45133
Specializing in harnesses, saddles, and equestrian supplies, this shop is a favorite among Amish farmers and horse enthusiasts alike. - Country Crust Bakery
4918 Panhandle Rd, Hillsboro, OH 45133
facebook.com/countrycrustbakery
Known for its homemade breads, cookies, and pies, Country Crust is a sweet stop for anyone touring the area. - The Olde Garden Shack
320 W Main St, Hillsboro, OH 45133
theoldegardenshack.com
This family-run nursery and farm stand offers plants, produce, and Amish-grown flowers.
Voices from the Community
The growth of the Amish and Mennonite population has fostered new friendships and partnerships across Highland County. “They’ve helped keep our small towns alive,” says Bill Carter, owner of Carter’s Hardware in Hillsboro. “We see more people shopping local, and the quality of Amish-made goods is second to none.”
Amish and Mennonite group members appreciate the warm welcome. “We value our privacy, but we’re always happy to talk with visitors who are respectful and curious about our way of life,” says Rebecca Troyer, who sells eggs and baked goods at the produce auction. “We just ask that people don’t take photos of us, and remember that Sunday is our day of rest.”
What to See and Do: Amish and Mennonite Experiences in Highland County
Travelers eager to explore Highland County’s Amish and Mennonite culture will find plenty to do:
- Shop at Yoder’s Market for bulk foods, baked goods, and handmade gifts.
- Attend the Highland County Produce Auction to experience the excitement of local farm commerce.
- Stop by Country Crust Bakery for a taste of homemade pies and cookies.
- Browse handcrafted furniture and quilts at local markets and roadside stands.
- Take a scenic drive through the countryside, watching for horse-drawn buggies and fields tilled by hand.
- Visit The Olde Garden Shack for Amish-grown flowers and plants.
- Enjoy a meal at a local café featuring Amish-sourced ingredients.
Visitors are encouraged to dress modestly, avoid taking photographs of people, and respect the Amish and Mennonite tradition of rest on Sundays.
Preserving Heritage, Enriching Highland County
The Amish and Mennonite community is committed to preserving their heritage while embracing the unique character of Highland County. “We want to be good neighbors and good stewards of the land,” says Eli Yoder. “This is a special place, and we’re grateful to be part of it.”
Local officials see the Amish and Mennonites as a valuable addition to the region. “They’ve brought new energy and new opportunities,” says Highland County tourism director Lisa Martinez. “Tourists come for the scenery and the food, but they stay for the sense of community.”
Planning Your Visit
The best time to visit Highland County’s Amish and Mennonite community is from late spring through autumn, when the landscape is lush and markets are bustling. Maps and information are available at local visitor centers in Hillsboro and Buford.
Whether you’re seeking handmade treasures, farm-fresh flavors, or a peaceful escape, the Amish and Mennonite community of Highland County offers a warm welcome and a chance to experience a way of life rooted in tradition, craftsmanship, and community.