Discovering the Amish of Montgomery County: A Traveler’s Guide to Eastern New York’s Hidden Gem
Nestled among the rolling hills and fertile valleys of Montgomery County, eastern New York’s Amish community offers travelers a rare window into a world defined by simplicity, craftsmanship, and enduring tradition. While Pennsylvania and Ohio may be more famous for their Amish settlements, this corner of the Empire State is quietly becoming a favorite for those seeking a genuine, off-the-beaten-path cultural experience. Whether you’re a history buff, a foodie, or simply looking for a peaceful escape, a visit to the Amish of Montgomery County promises lasting memories and a deeper appreciation for rural American life.
A Community Rooted in Tradition
The Amish first arrived in Montgomery County in the late 1980s, drawn by affordable farmland and the promise of a quieter, less crowded setting than their original homes in Pennsylvania. Today, the area around Canajoharie and Fort Plain is home to a thriving Old Order Amish settlement, with more than 300 residents living on tidy farms, running small businesses, and traveling by horse-drawn buggy along country roads.
“We came here because the land was good and the people were welcoming,” explains Amos Yoder, a local Amish farmer. “It’s a peaceful place to raise a family and live by our values.”
What to Expect as a Visitor
Unlike commercialized tourist destinations, Montgomery County’s Amish community remains refreshingly authentic. There are no theme parks or staged reenactments—just real people living their faith and working the land. Visitors are welcome, but respect for privacy and customs is essential. Photography is discouraged, especially of people, and Sunday is a day of rest with most businesses closed.
Still, there’s plenty for the curious traveler to see and do. The best way to experience Amish life is through its markets, shops, and roadside stands, where you’ll find everything from homemade pies and jams to handwoven baskets and rustic furniture.
Local Businesses and Must-Visit Stops
1. Stone Arabia Country Store
Address: 6135 State Highway 10, Fort Plain, NY
A family-run market offering Amish-made baked goods, cheeses, jams, and crafts. “Our cinnamon rolls and shoofly pies are favorites,” says store manager Rebecca Hayes. “We get customers from all over the region.”
2. Yoder’s Farm Stand
Address: 1122 River Road, Canajoharie, NY
Fresh produce, eggs, and seasonal flowers. “Everything we sell is grown right here,” says Mary Yoder. “We love meeting new people and sharing what we grow.”
3. Amish Woodworks
Address: 2049 State Route 5S, Fort Plain, NY
Handcrafted furniture, toys, and home goods. “Our furniture is made to last,” says craftsman Eli Miller. “Visitors appreciate the quality and care we put into every piece.”
4. Fort Plain Farmers Market
Address: 35 Willett St, Fort Plain, NY
Open Saturdays, this lively market features Amish vendors selling baked goods, vegetables, quilts, and more. “It’s a great place to meet the community and try something new,” says local resident Sarah Johnson.
5. The Table at Fort Plain
Address: 70 Canal St, Fort Plain, NY
While not Amish-owned, this farm-to-table restaurant sources ingredients from local Amish farms. “Their eggs and produce are the freshest around,” says chef Linda Foster. “Our customers love knowing where their food comes from.”
Voices from the Community
“We’re happy to share our way of life with respectful visitors. It’s important for people to see how we live and work together.”
— Amos Yoder, Amish farmer
“The Amish have brought new life to our area. Their markets and crafts are a big draw for tourists and locals alike.”
— Sarah Johnson, Fort Plain resident
“We love seeing new faces at the farm stand. People are always curious about our gardens and recipes.”
— Mary Yoder, farm stand owner
Things to Do
- Shop for Handcrafted Goods: From quilts and baskets to wooden toys and furniture, Amish craftsmanship is on full display.
- Taste Authentic Amish Food: Don’t miss shoofly pie, fresh bread, and homemade jams at local markets and stands.
- Explore Scenic Country Roads: Horse-drawn buggies and red barns dot the landscape. Drive slowly and enjoy the view.
- Attend the Fort Plain Farmers Market: Meet local vendors, sample produce, and chat with residents.
- Take a Farm Tour: Some Amish families offer pre-arranged tours of their farms and gardens—call ahead to arrange.
Tips for Visitors
- Be Respectful: Always ask before taking photos, and avoid photographing people.
- Bring Cash: Most Amish businesses do not accept credit cards.
- Plan Ahead: Many shops close early, and most are closed on Sundays.
- Dress Modestly: Out of respect for local customs, avoid revealing clothing.
Why Visit Montgomery County’s Amish Community?
Montgomery County offers an authentic Amish experience without the crowds. The region’s peaceful atmosphere, welcoming residents, and beautiful scenery make it ideal for a day trip or weekend getaway. As more travelers seek out genuine, meaningful experiences, this hidden gem in eastern New York stands out.
Chef Linda Foster sums it up: “People come for the food and the crafts, but they leave with a sense of peace. The Amish remind us of the value of hard work, community, and living simply.”
Looking Ahead
As the Amish community continues to grow, so does its influence on local culture and economy. New businesses, markets, and collaborations with non-Amish neighbors are enriching the region. For visitors, that means more opportunities to learn, connect, and enjoy the best of rural New York.