Broome County, New York, is now home to a warm and welcoming Amish restaurant that brings the time-honored traditions of Pennsylvania Dutch cooking to the heart of upstate New York. “Our Country Hearts” in Endicott is more than just a place to eat—it’s an immersive experience combining home-style meals, a rustic gift shop, and hand-crafted Amish furniture, all tucked inside a log cabin setting. As a tourist editor, stepping inside feels like discovering a hidden piece of Americana. Reviews are glowing, favorite menu items are irresistible, and travelers from Binghamton and beyond find new reasons to stop and savor the flavors of Amish country.ourcountryhearts+1
Where Amish Tradition Meets Upstate Hospitality
Located on Route 26 in Endicott, “Our Country Hearts” is a destination for those craving old-fashioned comfort food and the warmth of handcrafted Amish décor. The space combines a charming restaurant, a treasure-filled country gifts store, and a furniture showroom—making each visit as much about exploring local craftsmanship as sampling homemade treats.tripadvisor+1
Upon entering, diners are often greeted with the aroma of freshly baked pies, breads, and cookies, as well as the inviting sight of hand-built tables and country antiques. It’s a true gathering spot for families, travelers, and anyone seeking respite from the bustle of modern life.
Rave Reviews and Real Voices
Customers consistently praise the atmosphere and authenticity of Our Country Hearts. “Wonderful country feeling—great food and so many unique gifts,” reports one longtime regular. Another notes, “Friendly staff, hearty portions, and you can shop for homemade bread to take home. My favorite spot after hiking in the Southern Tier.” The combination of restaurant and gift shop is repeatedly described as “just right for a weekend afternoon.”tripadvisor
A reviewer from Binghamton writes, “The service is attentive, and the menu is full of favorites—my go-to is the broasted chicken with mashed potatoes and gravy. Don’t forget the pie!”. Another diner recalls, “We enjoyed lunch and lingered to browse the beautiful Amish furniture. The cinnamon rolls are sweet, gooey, and best split with a friend.”tripadvisor
Restaurant Favorites: What’s Drawing Crowds
This Amish-inspired menu highlights distinct crowd-pleasers:
- Broasted Chicken: Extra crispy and tender, served with buttery mashed potatoes and gravy. Often described as “comfort on a plate.”
- Homemade Pies: Flavors change daily—apple, peach, and shoo-fly are top draws for dessert lovers.
- All-Day Breakfast: Think fluffy pancakes, thick slices of homemade bread turned into French toast, and farm-fresh eggs.
- Handmade Cinnamon Rolls: Soft, sweet, and frosted just right—locals line up for these.
- Hearty Sandwiches: Classic turkey and Amish cheese, freshly sliced, piled onto house-baked bread.
- Vegetable Soup: Rich, warming, and made from seasonal local produce.
- Meatloaf Dinners: Served with homemade bread and vegetables, a local favorite for Sunday suppers.
Children are welcome, and the menu includes kid-size portions of mac-n-cheese, grilled cheeses, and mini pies for smaller appetites.
Amish Ambiance: Decor, Service, and Dining Comfort
Located inside a log cabin, décor features hand-crafted tables, benches, and shelves—all available for sale in the adjacent Amish furniture showroom. Pie safes, quilt racks, and hand-stitched linens add to the sense of stepping into an old-fashioned kitchen. Staff greet guests with warmth, share menu suggestions, and are happy to chat about Amish recipes and traditions.ourcountryhearts
On weekends, the parking lot fills early with local families, visiting hikers, and antiquers stopping in for lunch before exploring the countryside. Takeout is available on most bakery items, and guests often linger for coffee, pie, and shopping after a meal.
What Diners Are Saying
- “A Friday night broasted chicken dinner is a tradition in our family—no better place than this!”
- “The cinnamon rolls are big enough to share and sweet enough to make you want another one. Paired with coffee, it’s pure happiness.”
- “From the homemade bread to the friendly staff, you feel like part of the family here.”
- “We come for the pie and stay for the crafts—such a warm way to spend an afternoon.”
- “Kids loved the pancake stacks, and everyone found something on the menu to love.”
Insider Tips for Visiting
- Arrive before noon for the freshest cinnamon rolls and best pie selection.
- The gift shop is open year-round; allow extra time to browse for crafts, soaps, and furniture.
- Broasted chicken is best on Friday and Saturday nights.
- Credit cards are accepted, and large groups are welcomed with reservations.
- Ask staff for seasonal pie specials—fall flavors often sell out quickly.
Why Our Country Hearts Stands Out
Broome County’s new Amish restaurant isn’t just a place for a quick bite—it’s an experience that blends traditional recipes, handmade craftsmanship, and heartfelt service. For tourists, weekend explorers, and hungry locals, it’s a culinary and shopping destination rolled into one.
The unique combination of restaurant, gift shop, and Amish furniture gallery means each visit invites guests to not just taste Amish heritage, but to touch and take home a piece of it. It’s quickly become a must-visit spot for anyone seeking an authentic, memorable meal in Broome County.
Check sources
- https://ourcountryhearts.com
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g47686-d3833946-Reviews-Our_Country_Hearts-Endicott_New_York.html
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/RestaurantsNear-g48465-d3596332-New_York_Amish_Trail-Randolph_Cattaraugus_County_New_York.html
- https://www.reddit.com/r/Binghamton/comments/1jbgz7u/buffet_star/
- https://dutchvillage.net
- https://amishdoor.com
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=74SxR6YSNQ4
- https://menupages.com/amish-market-west/731-9th-ave-new-york
- https://enchantedmountains.com/place/r-m-restaurant
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g47320-d2228259-Reviews-Amici-Binghamton_New_York.html
- https://amishtrail.com/tags/dining
- https://www.reddit.com/r/Binghamton/comments/1i0t776/best_buffet_spots/
- https://homeinthefingerlakes.com/amish-and-mennonite-food-stores-in-new-york/
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g47320-d5843646-Reviews-Amici-Binghamton_New_York.html
- https://broomecountyny.gov/sites/default/files/dept/senior/OFA%20Senior%20News/SeniorNews_April2024_HighQuality.pdf
- https://wnbf.com/binghamton-nyseg-substation-man-burned/
- https://amishamerica.com/amish-restaurants/
- https://www.iloveny.com/things-to-do/fall/foliage-report/