When you step into Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen in Middlefield, Ohio, you are immediately enveloped by the warmth and charm of an authentic Amish dining experience. This beloved establishment, founded in 1982, offers a delightful combination of hearty meals, a welcoming atmosphere, and a quaint gift shop, making it a must-visit destination in Geauga County.
Address: 14743 North State Street, Middlefield, OH 44062
Menu Highlights
Here are the must-try dishes that will make your dining experience memorable:
1. Broasted Chicken
The Broasted Chicken is a signature dish at Mary Yoder’s, renowned for its crispy, flavorful skin and juicy meat. This dish is often highlighted in reviews as a standout, embodying the essence of comfort food that the restaurant is known for.
2. Family Style Dinner
For a true Amish dining experience, opt for the Family Style Dinner. This option allows you to enjoy a variety of meats, including Roast Turkey, Oven Baked Chicken, and Roast Pork, served alongside an array of sides like Mashed Potatoes, Green Beans, and Homemade Rolls. It’s a communal feast that reflects the Amish tradition of sharing meals.
3. Homemade Noodles
Don’t miss the Homemade Noodles, a delightful side that pairs perfectly with many of the main dishes. These noodles are made fresh and are a comforting addition to any meal, often praised for their rich flavor and perfect texture.
4. Pies
Dessert is a must at Mary Yoder’s, and the Pies are legendary. The Peanut Butter Pie and Apple Pie are particularly popular, with many customers raving about their deliciousness. The flaky crust and rich fillings make these desserts a perfect way to end your meal.
5. Breakfast Specials
If you visit for breakfast, be sure to try the Mary Yoder Omelet, which is loaded with fresh ingredients. The breakfast menu also features Pancakes and French Toast, both of which come highly recommended for their homemade taste and generous portions.
Reviews and Customer Experiences
Visitors to Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen consistently praise the restaurant for its delicious food, friendly service, and cozy atmosphere. Here are some highlights from recent reviews:
- Melanie V. from Chicago, IL, was impressed by the Chicken and Noodles and the Pork Chop, noting that the Cinnamon Butter with sweet potato fries was a delightful addition. She appreciated the great service and the homey feel of the restaurant[4].
- Mallory M. from Ohio described her experience as a “Five-Star Homestyle Delight,” highlighting the exceptional service and the standout dish of Fried Chicken. She also loved the Apple Pie, calling it a “slice of heaven”[4].
- Craig K. from Zionsville, IN, enjoyed the Mary Yoder Omelet and appreciated the attentive service and the large, welcoming dining area. He also noted the tempting selection of baked goods in the gift shop[4].
Gift Shop
In addition to the restaurant, Mary Yoder’s features a charming gift shop that offers a variety of Amish-made products. You can find Amish Jams, Noodles, Country Licorice, and Fudge, as well as handcrafted items like Rocking Horses, Dolls, and Marionettes. The shop also sells Quilted Aprons, Potholders, Baskets, and Hickory and Oak Rockers, making it the perfect place to pick up a unique souvenir or gift.
Conclusion
Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen is more than just a restaurant; it’s an experience that captures the essence of Amish hospitality and culinary tradition. Whether you’re enjoying a hearty breakfast, a family-style dinner, or browsing the gift shop, you’ll leave with a full stomach and a warm heart. Make sure to visit this Middlefield gem on your next trip to Geauga County.
Citations:
[1] https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g50652-d582375-Reviews-Mary_Yoder_s_Amish_Kitchen-Middlefield_Ohio.html
[2] https://foursquare.com/v/mary-yoders-amish-kitchen-bakery-and-gift-shop/4afc57d9f964a520bd2122e3/menu
[3] https://maryyodersamishkitchen.m.takeout7.com
[4] https://www.yelp.com/biz/mary-yoders-amish-kitchen-bakery-and-gifts-middlefield
[5] https://www.maryyodersamishkitchen.com/lunch-and-dinner-menu-at-mary-yoders-amish-kitchen/