Amish Market Brings Lancaster Traditions and Fresh Flavors to New Jersey
Mullica Hill, NJ — The aroma of fresh-baked bread and the sight of bustling market stalls greet visitors at the newly opened Mullica Hill Amish Market, a vibrant addition to New Jersey’s growing appetite for authentic, farm-fresh fare. Drawing vendors and recipes straight from Pennsylvania’s Amish heartland, the market is quickly becoming a beloved destination for locals and travelers alike, offering a unique blend of traditional foods, handcrafted goods, and a warm, family-friendly atmosphere.
A Taste of Lancaster in the Garden State
Though New Jersey has no permanent Amish population, the state has become home to several Amish markets, with Mullica Hill’s new market leading the way. Vendors travel weekly from Lancaster County, PA, bringing with them the finest meats, cheeses, baked goods, and crafts that have made Amish food culture famous.
“We wanted to bring a little bit of Lancaster to New Jersey,” said Samuel King, a vendor whose family runs Dutch Country Deli. “People here appreciate quality, and we’re proud to share what we do best.”
The market boasts over a dozen stands, each specializing in traditional Amish fare. Shoppers can find everything from hand-rolled soft pretzels and smoked sausages to homemade jams and pickles. “The freshness is unbeatable,” said local resident Angela Thomas. “You can taste the difference in every bite.”
Local Businesses Welcome the Amish Touch
The arrival of the Amish market has energized the local business community. Priya Patel, owner of a nearby café, noted, “We’ve seen more foot traffic since the market opened. People come for the pretzels and pies, then stop by for coffee or lunch. It’s good for everyone on Main Street.”
Other local businesses have begun collaborating with Amish vendors. The Mullica Hill Garden Center now sources seasonal produce from Amish farmers, while the town’s historic inn features Amish-baked pies on its dessert menu. “It’s a win-win,” said innkeeper Bill Jenkins. “Guests love the authenticity, and it supports our local economy.”
Homey Atmosphere and Hearty Portions
At the heart of the market is My Father’s Place, a family-run Amish restaurant renowned for its generous portions and home-cooked meals. “We make everything from scratch — soups, breads, pies — using recipes passed down from my mother and grandmother,” said Lillian Stoltzfus, who oversees the kitchen. “Our chicken pot pie and homemade soups are especially popular in the winter.”
Chris Stoltzfus, Lillian’s husband, added, “We want everyone who eats here to feel like family. That’s why we focus on quality and service. It’s not just about the food, but the experience.”
Diners agree. “It’s like going back in time,” said regular customer Mark Rivera. “The food is comforting, the staff is friendly, and you always leave full.”
Signature Offerings and Market Highlights
The market’s vendors offer a wide variety of specialties:
- Beiler’s Bakery: Famous for sticky buns, whoopie pies, and shoofly pie.
- Dutch Country Deli: Hand-sliced meats, cheeses, and made-to-order sandwiches.
- Yoder’s BBQ: Slow-smoked ribs and rotisserie chicken that draw crowds every weekend.
- Ellie’s Cheese Barn: Over 30 varieties of cheese, including local favorites and unique Amish blends.
- King’s Crafts: Handmade wooden toys, furniture, and home décor.
“We bake our bread fresh every morning,” said Mary Beiler, whose family runs the bakery stand. “People come early for the cinnamon rolls — they sell out fast!”
Community Connection and Family Values
The market is more than just a place to shop; it’s a gathering spot for the community. “We see families, friends, and neighbors catching up over a meal or a cup of coffee,” said Samuel King. “That’s what the Amish markets are all about — bringing people together.”
Family values are evident in every aspect of the market’s operation. Lillian Stoltzfus shared, “My mother still makes all the soups, and our children help with baking and serving. It’s a labor of love.”
Customer Reactions: “Worth the Trip”
The response from the community has been overwhelmingly positive. “I drive 30 minutes every week just for the fresh bread and pies,” said local resident Diane Foster. “It’s worth the trip — you can’t get this quality anywhere else.”
Online reviews echo the praise. “The market is always clean, the staff is friendly, and the food is amazing,” wrote one visitor. “It’s become our go-to spot for family meals and special treats.”
Looking Ahead: A New Tradition in New Jersey
With its combination of quality, tradition, and community spirit, the Mullica Hill Amish Market is poised to become a staple in the region for years to come. “We’re grateful for the warm welcome,” said Chris Stoltzfus. “We hope to keep serving the community and sharing our way of life.”
As the market continues to grow, locals and newcomers alike are discovering the simple pleasures of Amish cooking and craftsmanship — and finding a new tradition to call their own.
Citations:
- https://www.nj.com/mosaic/food_culture/2025/03/fresh-delicious-meals-worth-the-wait-at-nj-amish-market.html
- https://amishmarketmullicahill.com
- https://amishamerica.com/amish-markets-new-jersey/
- https://www.reddit.com/r/newjersey/comments/16fdh9h/what_are_some_good_amish_markets_in_new_jersey/
- https://www.columbusfarmersmarket.com/amish-market
- https://visitsouthjersey.com/directory/mullica-hill-amish-farmers-market/
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g46439-d3521913-Reviews-Dutch_Country_Farmers_Market-Flemington_New_Jersey.html
- https://bridgetonamishmarket.com
- https://newjerseyisntboring.com/new-jersey-spring-farmers-markets-4/
- https://www.bristolamishmarket.com
- https://bridgetonamishmarket.com
- https://www.instagram.com/reel/DHQyf5FRsm2/
- https://www.instagram.com/greaterbridgetonamishmarket/
- https://williamstownfarmersmarket.com
- https://www.reddit.com/r/newjersey/comments/16fdh9h/what_are_some_good_amish_markets_in_new_jersey/
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=amish+market&find_loc=Newark%2C+NJ
- https://www.reddit.com/r/newjersey/comments/1hwlell/2025_guide_to_new_jersey_winter_farmers_markets/
- https://visittheamish.com/southern-new-jersey-welcomes-its-first-ever-amish-community/
- https://thetrentonfarmersmarket.com
- https://www.tiktok.com/discover/amish-market-in-new-jersey-newly-opened-in-january-2025
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish&find_loc=Paterson%2C+NJ
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Market&find_loc=Morristown%2C+NJ+07960
- https://www.yelp.com/biz/dutch-wagon-amish-market-medford
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=amish+market&find_loc=Jersey+City%2C+NJ
- https://bridgetonamishmarket.com/about/
- https://www.indeed.com/q-drive-the-amish-jobs.html
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g46655-d3254487-Reviews-Amish_Market-Mullica_Hill_New_Jersey.html
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Market&find_loc=Flemington%2C+NJ+08822
- https://www.bloomberg.com/businessweek
- https://www.reddit.com/r/lancaster/comments/1cvd9jp/amish_in_nyc_farmer_commutes_6_hours_a_day_to/
- https://www.acg.aaa.com/discounts.html
- https://amishmarketmullicahill.com
- https://www.samsclub.com