Wisconsin is home to the fourth-largest Amish population in North America, with an estimated 25,000 Amish residents as of 2024. While Wisconsin lacks a single signature tourist-friendly Amish community like those found in other states, it offers visitors a diverse array of Amish settlements to explore. This guide will help you navigate the rich tapestry of Amish culture and commerce across Wisconsin’s picturesque countryside.
Major Amish Settlements in Wisconsin
Cashton Area
The largest Amish settlement in Wisconsin is located in the Cashton area, situated in the state’s beautiful Driftless Region. This community, established in the early 1970s, has grown significantly over the years.
Popular Businesses:
- Old Country Cheese
Address: S502 County Rd D, Cashton, WI 54619
This cheese factory uses milk from local Amish farms to produce over 20 varieties of cheese. Their on-site factory outlet store offers cheese along with other Amish-made goods like jams, candy, maple syrup, and crafts. - Down A Country Road
Address: 12651 State Hwy 33, Cashton, WI 54619
This Amish-focused gift shop offers a wide variety of handcrafted items, including furniture, quilts, and food products. They also provide guided tours of the local Amish community.
Dalton/Kingston Area
Located northeast of Madison in Green Lake County, this community offers numerous opportunities to experience Amish culture and commerce.
Popular Businesses:
- Pleasant View Bakery
Address: N9541 Kiefer Rd, Dalton, WI 53926
Open: Summer (April 1-Sept 30) Tue, Wed, Fri & Sat 8am-4pm; Winter (Oct 1-March 31) Fri & Sat 8am-4pm
This beloved Amish bakery is known for its freshly baked goods, including cinnamon rolls, breads, cookies, pies, and more. They also offer homemade jams, jellies, and noodles. - Lilac Wood Shop
Address: N9578 Barry Rd, Dalton, WI 53926
This shop showcases hand-crafted oak and cherry furniture, from complete bedroom sets to outdoor lounge furniture. - Mishler’s Country Store
Address: N9575 Barry Rd, Dalton, WI 53926
Located across from Lilac Wood Shop, this popular store offers a wide array of goods, including bulk spices, canned items, and doilies.
Augusta Area
While smaller than some other Wisconsin Amish communities, the Augusta settlement in Eau Claire County offers unique experiences for visitors.
Popular Business:
The Wood Shed
Address: E23281 Hwy 27, Augusta, WI 54722
This furniture store offers a variety of handcrafted furniture pieces, quilts, and other crafts. They also arrange tours through the Amish countryside, providing an inside look at the local community.
Planning Your Visit
When visiting Wisconsin’s Amish communities, keep these tips in mind:
- Respect privacy: While many Amish businesses welcome visitors, remember that you’re entering a private community. Avoid taking photographs of Amish people, as most prefer not to be photographed.
- Dress modestly: Out of respect for Amish customs, consider dressing conservatively when visiting their communities.
- Be prepared for limited technology: Many Amish businesses operate without electricity. Bring cash, as credit cards are rarely accepted.
- Mind the roads: Be cautious when driving, as you may encounter horse-drawn buggies. Give them plenty of space and pass carefully when it’s safe to do so.
- Observe Sunday closures: Most Amish businesses are closed on Sundays, as it’s a day of rest and worship for the community.
Exploring Amish Culture
To gain a deeper understanding of Amish life and culture, consider taking a guided tour. Several businesses offer tours that provide insight into Amish history, traditions, and daily life.
Tour Options:
- Down A Country Road Tours (Cashton area)
Address: 12651 State Hwy 33, Cashton, WI 54619
These tours offer a glimpse into the history, traditions, and customs of the Amish through the eyes of experienced guides. - The Wood Shed Tours (Augusta area)
Address: E23281 Hwy 27, Augusta, WI 54722
Offering seasonal tours from late April through October, these excursions take you through the Amish countryside, visiting homes, farms, and stores.
Where Are The Largest Amish Communities?
Amish Craftsmanship and Products
Wisconsin’s Amish communities are renowned for their high-quality craftsmanship and products. Here are some items to look out for during your visit:
- Furniture: Amish-made furniture is prized for its durability and craftsmanship. Look for pieces made from solid wood, often oak or cherry.
- Quilts: Amish quilts are known for their intricate designs and expert stitching. These make for beautiful and functional souvenirs.
- Food products: From baked goods to preserves, Amish food products are made using traditional methods and often feature locally sourced ingredients.
- Baskets: Hand-woven Amish baskets come in various sizes and styles, perfect for both decorative and practical use.
- Wooden toys: Simple yet charming, Amish-made wooden toys are popular among visitors looking for unique gifts.
Seasonal Considerations
While Amish communities can be visited year-round, certain seasons offer unique experiences:
- Spring and Summer: These seasons are ideal for exploring the countryside and visiting outdoor markets. Many Amish farms sell fresh produce during this time.
- Fall: Autumn brings beautiful foliage to Wisconsin’s rural areas, making it a picturesque time to visit. You might also find seasonal products like pumpkins and apples.
- Winter: While some businesses may have reduced hours, winter can offer a serene and less crowded experience. Be prepared for potential snow and ice on rural roads.
Amish Dining Experiences
While there aren’t many Amish-run restaurants open to the public in Wisconsin, you can still enjoy Amish cuisine through various means:
- Bakeries: Many Amish communities have bakeries that offer traditional treats like shoofly pie, whoopie pies, and homemade bread.
- Farmers Markets: Local farmers markets often feature Amish vendors selling baked goods, preserves, and fresh produce.
- Specialty Stores: Some Amish-run stores offer deli items or pre-made meals that you can take away.
- Home-based Businesses: Some Amish families operate small eateries from their homes, though these can be harder to find and may require local knowledge.
While not Amish-run, some restaurants in areas near Amish communities offer Amish-inspired cuisine:
- WeatherVane Restaurant
Address: 101 S Main St, Greenwood, WI 54437
This restaurant offers home-style cooking with some Amish-inspired dishes. - Red Hill Royal Restaurant
Address: 1025 Hwy 12, Black River Falls, WI 54615
Known for its hearty, country-style meals, this restaurant is located near Amish communities.
When visiting Wisconsin, indulging in Amish cuisine offers a unique and delightful experience. The state’s Amish communities are known for their hearty, home-cooked meals made from fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. This guide highlights the best places to eat Amish cuisine in Wisconsin, featuring restaurants, bakeries, and markets that showcase traditional dishes and flavors.
Best Places to Eat Amish Cuisine in Wisconsin
1. Menzel’s Amish Shelter & Fabrication
Address: 1831 County Rd V, Columbus, WI 53925
Rating: 4.9
Overview: While primarily known as a furniture store and fabrication shop, Menzel’s also features a small eatery that serves delicious chicken and other comfort foods. Visitors can enjoy a casual dining experience with a taste of Amish-style cooking.
2. Amish House
Address: 217 N Pioneer Park Rd, Westfield, WI 53964
Phone: (608) 296-2728
Rating: 4.5
Overview: The Amish House is a grocery store that offers a variety of homemade products, including jams, jellies, and baked goods. While it’s not a full-service restaurant, the store features an onsite deli where visitors can grab sandwiches and other light meals made with fresh ingredients.
3. Princeton Amish Country Store
Address: 101 Mechanic St, Princeton, WI 54968
Phone: (920) 481-0194
Rating: 4.8
Overview: This charming country store sells a variety of food items, including homemade baked goods and canned goods. It’s a great spot to pick up snacks or ingredients for a picnic while exploring the area.
4. Horseradish Kitchen + Market
Address: 505 W Water St, Princeton, WI 54968
Phone: (920) 481-0239
Rating: 4.9
Overview: Known for its cozy atmosphere and delicious comfort food, Horseradish Kitchen offers lunch and brunch options inspired by traditional Amish recipes. Their menu features seasonal dishes made from locally sourced ingredients.
5. Walker’s Diner & Bakery
Address: 813 Park Ave, Beaver Dam, WI 53916
Phone: (920) 885-9041
Rating: 4.3
Overview: A family-owned diner that serves homestyle American meals alongside a bakery case filled with sweet treats. Walker’s is popular for breakfast and lunch and often features dishes inspired by Amish cooking traditions.
6. Countryside Bent & Dent (Amish Grocery Store)
Address: 363 Atkinson Rd, Albany, WI 53502
Phone: (608) 897-2867
Rating: 4.7
Overview: This grocery store specializes in discounted food products and offers various homemade items typical of Amish cuisine. It’s a great place to find unique snacks and ingredients for your own meals.
7. Mr. and Mrs. P’s Eatery
Address: 1100 W Fond Du Lac St, Ripon, WI 54971
Phone: (920) 896-0696
Rating: 4.7
Overview: This eatery is known for its hearty breakfasts and comfort food options that often reflect Amish culinary traditions. The menu includes favorites like pork chops, eggs, and hash browns.
Additional Notable Mentions
A Taste of Amish-Style Cooking in the Midwest
While not exclusively in Wisconsin but worth mentioning for those traveling to nearby states:
- Das Dutchman Essenhaus
Located in Middlebury, Indiana, this restaurant is famous for its buffet-style dining featuring hearty Amish dishes like fried chicken and homemade pies. - Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery
Situated in Shipshewana, Indiana, it offers family-style dining with a wide variety of traditional dishes that reflect the rich culinary heritage of the Amish.
What to Expect from Amish Cuisine
Amish cuisine is characterized by its simplicity and heartiness. Common ingredients include:
- Meats: Fried chicken is a staple dish along with roast beef and pork.
- Sides: Expect generous servings of mashed potatoes with gravy, buttered corn, noodles, and casseroles.
- Breads & Pastries: Homemade bread rolls are often served alongside meals; desserts typically include pies (like shoofly pie), cakes, and cookies.
- Preserves & Jams: Many establishments offer homemade jams that are perfect for breakfast or as gifts.
Conclusion
Wisconsin’s Amish communities offer an array of dining options that showcase their rich culinary traditions. From cozy diners to charming country stores filled with homemade goods, there’s something for everyone looking to experience authentic Amish cuisine. Be sure to explore these establishments during your visit to fully appreciate the flavors of this unique culture!
Responsible Tourism
As you explore Wisconsin’s Amish communities, it’s crucial to practice responsible tourism:
- Support local businesses: Purchasing directly from Amish-run businesses helps support their way of life.
- Be mindful of cultural differences: The Amish lifestyle may differ significantly from your own. Approach these differences with respect and an open mind.
- Ask permission: Always ask before taking photos of Amish property, and respect their wishes if they decline.
- Drive safely: Be extra cautious on rural roads, especially when passing horse-drawn buggies.
- Leave no trace: Respect the environment and the communities you visit by not littering and leaving things as you found them.
Beyond Shopping: Experiencing Amish Culture
While shopping is a significant part of many visitors’ experiences in Amish country, there are other ways to learn about and appreciate Amish culture:
- Attend a Public Auction: Some Amish communities hold public auctions where you can observe and participate in local commerce.
- Visit During a Festival: Some areas host festivals that celebrate local culture, including Amish contributions.
- Take a Scenic Drive: Simply driving through Amish country can provide a glimpse into their way of life. Look for farms with windmills, clotheslines full of plain garments, and horse-drawn buggies on the road.
- Learn About Amish History: Visit local historical societies or museums to learn about the history of Amish settlement in Wisconsin.
Conclusion
Visiting Wisconsin’s Amish communities offers a unique opportunity to step back in time and experience a simpler way of life. From handcrafted furniture to homemade baked goods, the products of Amish craftsmanship provide tangible connections to this fascinating culture. By approaching your visit with respect, curiosity, and an open mind, you can gain valuable insights into the Amish way of life while supporting local communities.
Remember that each Amish settlement is unique, with its own customs and level of engagement with the outside world. Take the time to learn about the specific communities you plan to visit, and always prioritize respect for their privacy and way of life. Whether you’re browsing a quaint country store, taking a guided tour, or simply enjoying the picturesque countryside, a visit to Wisconsin’s Amish communities promises to be a memorable and enriching experience.
Citations:
[1] https://www.travelwisconsin.com/article/tours/wisconsins-amish-communities-experience-shop-and-learn
[2] https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/food/wisconsin/wi-amish-homemade-goods
[3] https://driftlesswisconsin.com/explore/wisconsin-amish-country/
[4] https://www.travelwisconsin.com/shopping/pleasant-view-bakery-237135
[5] https://adelinesretreat.com/amish-country/
[6] https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Restaurant&find_loc=Markesan%2C+WI
[7] https://www.downacountryroad.com/tours.php
[8] https://shopamishcountry.com/category/family-amish-restaurants/state/wisconsin
[9] https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/trip-ideas/wisconsin/tomah-amish-tour-wi
[10] https://amishamerica.com/wisconsin-amish/