A New Amish Market Brings Old-World Charm and Fresh Opportunity to Long Island
A wave of excitement is sweeping through Long Island as a new Amish market opens its doors, promising a unique blend of tradition, quality, and community spirit. Nestled in the heart of the region’s bustling farmers market scene, this new addition is quickly becoming a destination for locals and visitors seeking fresh, handmade goods and a taste of Amish heritage.
Reviving Tradition in a Modern Setting
The Long Island Amish Market, which debuted this spring, stands out for its dedication to handmade and homemade products. “Our market is dedicated, basically, to handmade and homemade products,” says market organizer Lisa Denlea. “Many of our vendors prioritize healthy ingredients, and most produce stands don’t use pesticides.”1 The market’s offerings include everything from farm-fresh fruits and vegetables to baked goods, jams, and handcrafted furniture-each item reflecting the Amish commitment to quality and simplicity.
Local Enthusiasm and Community Impact
The response from the Long Island community has been overwhelmingly positive. “The community is very, very enthusiastic,” Denlea shares. “I’ve received so many emails from customers happy to see the market’s expansion.”1 Shoppers flock to the market every weekend, eager to sample the latest treats and stock up on wholesome essentials.
Sarah Johnson, a local resident, remarks, “It’s a breath of fresh air to have a market like this. The produce is always fresh, and you can really taste the difference in the baked goods. It reminds me of visiting markets upstate as a kid.”
Supporting Local Businesses and Farmers
The Amish market isn’t just about bringing in outside vendors-it’s about supporting Long Island’s own farmers and artisans. Many of last year’s vendors were local businesses, including Plainview’s Side Hustle Artisanal Bread Company and Hicksville’s Pam’s Jamz, both of which have become staples at the market.1 “We love working alongside the Amish vendors,” says Pam Russo of Pam’s Jamz. “Their approach to food is all about honesty and quality, which matches our own philosophy.”
The market’s mission aligns closely with that of the broader Long Island farmers market movement: uplifting local agriculture and creating a vibrant, family-friendly environment. “Every purchase helps support small farms, local artisans, and our shared community,” says a spokesperson for Long Island Farmers Markets. “You’re part of the local economy, so you understand how important it is to keep this town vibrant and moving forward.”4
A Unique Shopping Experience
Visitors to the Amish market are treated to more than just shopping-they’re invited into a community experience. Live entertainment, guest vendors, and special events are a regular feature, making each visit unique. “There’s truly something for everyone,” says Denlea.1 The market’s social media pages keep customers updated on weekly offerings and special happenings, encouraging repeat visits and a sense of belonging.
On TikTok and other platforms, shoppers share their experiences, highlighting the market’s cozy atmosphere and delightful treats.3 “Discover the best of Amish Market Long Island with fresh food, cozy shopping, and delightful treats every week!” one post reads, capturing the spirit of the market.
Amish Values Meet Long Island Tastes
For the Amish vendors themselves, the market is an opportunity to share their heritage and values with a new audience. “We want people to know where their food comes from,” says Eli Miller, an Amish farmer who travels in from Pennsylvania each week. “Everything we bring is grown or made by hand, with care for the land and the people who eat it.”
Mary Stoltzfus, who oversees the baked goods stall, adds, “We’re grateful for the warm welcome. Long Island is different from what we’re used to, but people here appreciate good, honest food and hard work.”
Partnerships with Local Businesses
The Amish market’s arrival has also created new opportunities for collaboration. Local coffee shops and restaurants have begun sourcing ingredients from the market, featuring Amish-baked pies and breads on their menus. “It’s been great for business,” says Linda Foster, owner of a nearby café. “Customers love knowing their food is local and made with care.”
Even established gourmet markets like Amish Market West in Manhattan have noticed the trend. “We try to support local Upstate New York farmers, but it’s great to see Amish vendors on Long Island connecting directly with customers,” says Sam Sevinc, managing director of Amish Market West. “People want authenticity and quality, and the Amish deliver that.”2
Looking Ahead: A Lasting Legacy
As the season progresses, the Amish market is poised to become a fixture in Long Island’s food landscape. Open every Saturday from May through November at the Syosset train station, and with additional locations in Babylon and Huntington Villages on Sundays, the market offers easy access for families across the region.14
“We want this to be a place where people feel connected-to their food, to their neighbors, and to the traditions that make our region special,” says Denlea.1 With plans for more special events and expanded offerings, the future looks bright for this new community hub.
Voices from the Market
“It’s a breath of fresh air to have a market like this. The produce is always fresh, and you can really taste the difference in the baked goods.”
- Sarah Johnson, local resident
“Their approach to food is all about honesty and quality, which matches our own philosophy.”
- Pam Russo, Pam’s Jamz
“We want people to know where their food comes from. Everything we bring is grown or made by hand.”
- Eli Miller, Amish vendor
“Customers love knowing their food is local and made with care.”
- Linda Foster, café owner
Local Business Highlights
| Business Name | Specialty | Location |
|---|---|---|
| Side Hustle Artisanal Bread Company | Handmade breads and baked goods | Plainview, NY |
| Pam’s Jamz | Small-batch jams and preserves | Hicksville, NY |
| Amish Market West | Gourmet groceries, produce, Amish goods | Manhattan, NY |
| Local Farmers Markets | Fresh produce, local vendors, entertainment | Babylon, NY; Huntington, NY |
Citations:
- https://www.longislandpress.com/2025/04/03/syosset-farmers-market-2025/
- https://www.producebusiness.com/amish-market-west/
- https://www.tiktok.com/discover/amish-market-long-island
- https://longislandfarmersmarkets.com
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g48465-d3596332-Reviews-New_York_Amish_Trail-Randolph_Cattaraugus_County_New_York.html
- https://libn.com/2025/02/24/wegmans-opens-its-first-long-island-store-this-week/
- https://www.reddit.com/r/povertyfinance/comments/18tww6i/13167_from_my_local_amish_market/
- https://homeinthefingerlakes.com/amish-and-mennonite-food-stores-in-new-york/
- https://www.amishcraftbarn.com
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=amish+market&find_loc=Manhattan%2C+NY
- https://www.amishfinefood.com
- https://ilovetheupperwestside.com/amish-dairy-farm-to-open-upper-west-side-store/
- https://www.amishcraftbarn.com/about-us
- https://www.angi.com/companylist/us/ny/seaford/amish-craft-barn-and-gift-shop-reviews-408113.htm
- https://www.yelp.com/biz/the-amish-market-new-york-2
- https://www.instagram.com/longislandfarmersmarkets/
- https://www.tiktok.com/discover/amish-market-long-island
- https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/experiences/new-york/amish-market-ny
- https://www.leadmarketingstrategies.com/boosting-long-island-business-sales-with-seo-insights/
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=amish+market&find_loc=Long+Island+City%2C+Queens%2C+NY
- https://amishamerica.com/amish-markets/
- https://designmemarketing.com/why-local-seo-matters-more-than-ever-for-long-island-businesses/
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Market&find_loc=Long+Island+City%2C+Queens%2C+NY+11101
- https://nypost.com/2024/05/18/us-news/amish-farmer-commutes-each-day-to-bring-products-to-his-nyc-store/
- https://www.linkedin.com/posts/sleek-web-designs_how-local-seo-services-are-driving-long-island-activity-7254124284984406016-jOz9
- https://agriculture.ny.gov/food-safety/home-processing
- https://www.fodors.com/community/united-states/amish-country-near-long-island-city-ny-944659/
- https://optimizelongisland.com
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Market&find_loc=Long+Island+City%2C+Queens%2C+NY
- https://greaterlongisland.com/wegmans-on-pace-to-open-first-li-store-in-early-2025/
- https://amishamerica.com/amish-farmer-opens-new-york-city-store/
- https://amishamerica.com/amish-business-directory/
- https://www.indeed.com/q-drive-the-amish-jobs.html
- https://www.bloomberg.com/businessweek
- https://www.samsclub.com
- https://www.farfetch.com/shopping/women/sale/all/items.aspx
- https://designmemarketing.com/top-10-seo-services-every-long-island-business-needs/