A New Amish Community Flourishes in Carlisle, Pennsylvania

In the rolling hills of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, a new Amish settlement has emerged, bringing with it the charm of traditional values and entrepreneurial spirit. The Carlisle Amish community, established in early 2024, is already making a significant impact on the local economy and drawing visitors eager to experience Amish culture firsthand.

Located just outside Carlisle, this growing community is home to over 30 families who have relocated from Lancaster County and Ohio. Their arrival has brought a renewed focus on agriculture, craftsmanship, and faith-based living to the area.

John Stoltzfus, one of the first settlers in Carlisle’s Amish community, shared his perspective: “We were searching for a place where we could maintain our way of life while also providing opportunities for our young people. Carlisle’s fertile lands and welcoming neighbors made it an ideal location.”

Popular Amish Businesses in Carlisle

The new settlement has sparked an economic revival in the area with several Amish-owned businesses quickly becoming local favorites.

1. Harner’s Bakery: Located at the Carlisle Country Market on Holly Pike, Harner’s Bakery has gained a reputation for its sticky buns and fresh-baked pies. “We use recipes passed down through generations,” says Sarah Harner, the bakery’s owner. “It’s heartwarming to see so many people enjoying our baked goods.”

2. Stoltzfus Furniture Workshop: Known for its handcrafted wooden furniture, this family-run business creates everything from dining tables to rocking chairs using traditional woodworking methods. “Each piece is built to last a lifetime,” says Eli Stoltzfus, the workshop owner. “Our customers appreciate the quality and care that goes into every item.”

3. Peight’s Produce Stand: This bustling market offers farm-fresh fruits, vegetables, eggs, and dairy products straight from Amish farms. “People love knowing where their food comes from,” says Rebecca Peight. “We’re proud to bring fresh, healthy options to Carlisle.”

4. Millstream Quilts & Crafts: This shop features stunning handmade quilts and other textile goods crafted by Amish women in the community. Emily Thompson, a Carlisle resident who recently purchased a quilt here, shared her thoughts: “The craftsmanship is unbelievable. It’s like owning a piece of art.”

Tourist Attractions in the Area

The Carlisle Amish community has also become a draw for tourists looking to experience authentic Amish culture. Visitors can explore several attractions that highlight the community’s way of life:

1. The Carlisle Country Market: Open every Friday and Saturday, this year-round indoor market features over 25 locally owned specialty shops offering everything from homemade jams and candies to handcrafted jewelry and furniture.

2. Horse-Drawn Buggy Rides: Visitors can enjoy scenic rides through the countryside while learning about Amish traditions from knowledgeable guides.

3. Greenwood Furnace State Park: Just a short drive away, this park offers hiking trails and picnic areas that showcase Pennsylvania’s natural beauty.

4. Amish Farm Tours: Local guides offer immersive tours of working Amish farms where visitors can see firsthand how crops are grown using traditional methods.

Tom Jenkins, a tourist visiting from Pittsburgh, shared his experience: “I’ve always been fascinated by the Amish way of life. Visiting their farms and businesses gave me a deeper appreciation for their dedication to simplicity and hard work.”

Challenges and Growth

While the new settlement has brought many benefits to Carlisle, it has also presented challenges. Increased traffic on rural roads has required local officials to work closely with the Amish community to ensure safety for horse-drawn buggies.

Mark Thompson, a Cumberland County official, commented: “The Amish have been great partners in addressing these issues. Their presence has added a unique character to our area.”

The Amish families have also had to navigate balancing their traditional lifestyle with modern demands. Many have embraced solar power for refrigeration and wind energy for other needs while maintaining their commitment to simplicity.

Samuel Lapp, who runs an engine repair shop in the settlement, explained: “We’re not against technology; we just use it selectively so it doesn’t disrupt our family or community life.”

Looking Ahead

As the Carlisle Amish community continues to grow, plans are underway for expansion. Bishop Amos Stoltzfus shared his vision: “Our goal is to create a sustainable community that stays true to our faith while contributing positively to Carlisle’s economy.”

Local residents have welcomed their new neighbors with open arms. Mary Johnson, a longtime Carlisle resident, said: “The Amish have brought something special to our town—hard work, kindness, and a sense of tradition that’s refreshing in today’s fast-paced world.”

With its blend of cultural exchange and economic revitalization, the Carlisle Amish settlement is poised to become an enduring part of Cumberland County’s identity.

A New Amish Community Flourishes in Carlisle, Pennsylvania