A Day Trip to the Amish Community in Guthrie, Kentucky: Where Tradition Meets Progress
Nestled in the rolling hills of Todd County, Kentucky, the Amish community of Guthrie offers visitors a unique glimpse into a way of life that balances time-honored traditions with selective modernization. As the oldest Amish settlement in Kentucky, established in 1958, Guthrie provides a fascinating destination for those interested in Amish culture, craftsmanship, and rural charm.
Getting There
Guthrie is located in southern Kentucky, near the Tennessee border. It’s easily accessible by car, approximately 50 miles northwest of Nashville, Tennessee. Plan to arrive early in the morning to make the most of your day trip.
What Makes Guthrie Unique
The Guthrie Amish community is classified as “electric” New Order Amish, setting it apart from many other Amish settlements[1]. This designation means that while they maintain many traditional Amish practices, they have adopted certain modern conveniences, most notably the use of electricity in their homes. Visitors might be surprised to see Amish homes with electric lights or appliances, a sight uncommon in most Amish settlements.
Despite these modern allowances, the Guthrie Amish still adhere to core Amish values. They dress plainly, use horse-drawn buggies for local transportation, and speak Pennsylvania Dutch among themselves. However, their progressive stance on technology extends beyond electricity. Tractors are widely used not just for farming but also for road transportation, a practice that distinguishes them from more conservative Amish groups[1].
Morning Activities
Schlabach’s Bakery
Start your day with a visit to Schlabach’s Bakery, a cornerstone of the community since 1970. Located at 6225 Guthrie Road, this charming establishment is potentially one of the oldest continuously operating Amish bakeries in the country[3].
As you approach, you’ll be greeted by simple, old-fashioned signage and a cozy garden setting. Inside, you’ll find an impressive array of baked goods and local products:
- Cinnamon rolls (a best-seller)
- Sourdough bread
- Pies
- Granola
- Fried pies
- Banana bread
- Traditional breads
- Cakes
- Honey and jams
The bakery is open from 8 AM to 5 PM Monday through Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday[3]. Be sure to arrive early for the best selection, as popular items can sell out quickly.
Country Pantry Store
After indulging your sweet tooth, head to the Country Pantry Store. This Amish-owned establishment offers a wide variety of bulk goods and home products. It’s an excellent place to stock up on pantry staples, spices, and unique food items. Don’t miss their selection of scented candles, which make for lovely souvenirs or gifts[5].
The store is open from 8:30 AM to 5 PM Monday through Saturday. You can reach them at (270) 483-0555 for any inquiries[5].
Midday Explorations
Self-Guided Driving Tour
As the day progresses, embark on a self-guided driving tour of the Amish countryside. The rolling hills and well-tended farms provide a picturesque backdrop for your journey. Keep an eye out for:
- Horse-drawn buggies on the roads
- Amish children walking to or from school
- Well-maintained Amish farms
- Distinctive blue or red tractors parked outside Amish homes
Remember to drive carefully, especially on rural roads where you might encounter horse-drawn vehicles.
Amish-Owned Businesses
Throughout your drive, you’ll come across various Amish-owned businesses. These may include:
- Sawmills
- Pallet shops
- Carpentry workshops
- Furniture stores
Many of these establishments welcome visitors, offering a chance to purchase high-quality, handcrafted goods directly from Amish artisans. Look for signs indicating business hours and whether visitors are welcome.
Afternoon Activities
Lunch at Country View Creamery
For lunch, make your way to Country View Creamery, an Amish-owned dairy barn-style creamery. While technically located in nearby Trenton, it’s worth the short drive. They offer a deli with delicious sandwiches, but the real stars are their dairy products, especially the ice cream[5].
The creamery is open Monday through Friday from 9 AM to 5 PM and Saturdays from 9 AM to 4 PM. You can contact them at (270) 466-0990 for more information[5].
Visit to a Local Farm
In the afternoon, if possible, arrange a visit to a local Amish farm. While respecting the privacy of the Amish community, some farms may offer tours or allow visitors to observe daily activities. This can provide invaluable insights into Amish agricultural practices and daily life.
Shopping for Amish Crafts
Dedicate some time in the afternoon to shopping for Amish-made goods. Look for:
- Handcrafted furniture
- Quilts and textiles
- Homemade jams and preserves
- Handmade toys and crafts
Remember that many Amish businesses operate on a cash-only basis, so come prepared.
Evening Wind-Down
Sunset Drive
As the day comes to a close, take a leisurely drive through the countryside to enjoy the sunset over the Amish farms. The sight of Amish families returning from work in their buggies against the backdrop of a Kentucky sunset is truly memorable.
Dinner in Guthrie
While there may not be Amish-run restaurants in the area, the town of Guthrie itself offers several dining options where you can reflect on your day while enjoying a meal.
Planning Your Visit
Best Time to Visit
The Guthrie Amish community can be visited year-round, but each season offers a unique experience:
- Spring and summer showcase Amish farms in full production.
- Fall provides stunning foliage and harvest-time activities.
- Winter, while quieter, offers a serene glimpse into Amish life during the colder months.
Respecting Amish Culture
When visiting the Guthrie Amish community, it’s crucial to remember that you’re entering a living, working community, not a tourist attraction. Here are some guidelines for respectful interaction:
- Always ask permission before taking photographs, especially of Amish individuals.
- Dress modestly out of respect for Amish values.
- Drive carefully, as you’ll likely encounter horse-drawn buggies on the roads.
- Respect private property and only visit businesses that are clearly open to the public.
What to Bring
- Cash: Many Amish businesses don’t accept credit cards.
- A cooler: For perishable goods you might purchase.
- Comfortable walking shoes: For exploring farms and shops.
- A camera: For capturing the beautiful countryside (but remember to ask permission before photographing people).
Historical Context
Understanding the history of the Guthrie Amish community can enrich your visit. The settlement was established in 1958 by families from Stuarts Draft, Virginia, following a division within their original church. This move was part of a broader pattern of Amish migration and community formation[1].
The Guthrie settlement played a significant role in establishing Amish presence in Kentucky. As of 2024, Kentucky is home to nearly 16,000 Amish people living in over 50 communities, making it the 8th largest Amish population in the United States[2].
Educational Aspects
The Guthrie Amish community offers several educational opportunities for visitors:
Amish Schools
While you can’t visit Amish schools, you might see Amish children walking to or from their schoolhouses. The Guthrie community established its own parochial school, Guthrie Christian School, in 1969[1].
Agricultural Practices
Observing Amish farms provides insights into sustainable and traditional farming methods. The Amish are known for their efficient, small-scale farming techniques.
Craftsmanship
Visiting Amish workshops and stores allows you to appreciate the high level of skill and craftsmanship in Amish-made goods.
Beyond Guthrie
If you have more time or are interested in exploring further, consider visiting other Amish and Mennonite communities in the region:
Pembroke Amish Community
About 30 miles east of Guthrie, the Pembroke Amish community in Christian County is the second-largest Amish settlement in Kentucky. Established in 1989, it’s home to around 2,200 Old Order Amish living in 15 church districts[5].
Fairview Produce Auction
Located in Pembroke, this large auction house is where Amish and Mennonite farmers come together with locals to sell their produce. It’s open Monday through Friday from 9 AM to 5 PM, and Saturdays from 9 AM to 12 PM[5].
Conclusion
A day trip to the Amish community in Guthrie, Kentucky, offers a unique opportunity to witness a fascinating blend of traditional Amish life and selective modernization. From the delightful treats at Schlabach’s Bakery to the picturesque countryside dotted with Amish farms and businesses, Guthrie provides a rich, educational, and memorable experience.
As you explore this unique community, you’ll gain a deeper appreciation for the Amish way of life and the ongoing dialogue between tradition and progress that shapes their world. Remember to approach your visit with respect and curiosity, and you’re sure to come away with a newfound understanding of this distinctive American subculture.
Whether you’re a history enthusiast, a lover of handcrafted goods, or simply someone seeking a peaceful retreat from the fast pace of modern life, the Amish community in Guthrie has something to offer. Your day trip will not only be an exploration of a different way of life but also a journey into the heart of Kentucky’s rich cultural tapestry.
Citations:
[1] https://gameo.org/index.php?title=Guthrie_New_Order_Amish_Settlement_%28Guthrie%2C_Kentucky%2C_USA%29
[2] https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/experiences/kentucky/amish-country-ky
[3] https://amishamerica.com/schlabachs-bakery-guthrie-kentucky/
[4] https://toddchamber.com/the-amish-experience/
[5] https://amishofethridge.com/northern-tennessee-amish-map-10/
[6] https://amishamerica.com/amish-kentucky/
[7] https://www.amish365.com/where-are-the-amish-communities-in-kentucky/
[8] https://www.clarksvilleonline.com/2011/06/06/day-trip-four-guthrie-stops-you-don%E2%80%99t-want-to-miss/