Beyond the Buggy Rides: 5 More Amish Culinary Gems in Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania’s Amish Country offers a delightful blend of culture, history, and of course, incredible food. Here are five additional restaurants that will tantalize your taste buds and immerse you in the Amish culinary tradition:
1. The Plain and Fancy Farm Restaurant (Lancaster): This charming restaurant provides a unique dining experience. Enjoy delicious Amish fare like baked chicken and roast beef while surrounded by stunning farmland views. Afterward, explore the on-site shops for Amish crafts and souvenirs.
Plain & Fancy Restaurant
3121 Old Philadelphia Pike (Route 340)
Bird-in-Hand, PA 17505
717-431-8400
In the heart of Lancaster, Pennsylvania, where the verdant fields stretch endlessly and the Amish way of life flourishes, lies a culinary oasis known as The Plain and Fancy Farm Restaurant. Nestled amidst the picturesque landscape, this restaurant transcends mere dining; it offers an immersive experience that celebrates tradition, community, and the simple joys of life.
Stepping into The Plain and Fancy Farm Restaurant is like entering a time capsule where the heritage of the Amish culture comes to life. The warm ambiance, characterized by rustic wooden beams and charming country décor, evokes a sense of nostalgia and tranquility. Here, modernity takes a backseat, allowing guests to savor moments of unhurried dining and genuine connection.
At the heart of the restaurant’s allure lies its commitment to preserving the culinary heritage of the Amish community. The menu, crafted with reverence for tradition and a passion for quality ingredients, showcases an array of hearty, homestyle dishes that pay homage to the region’s agricultural bounty. From tender roast turkey and savory pot roast to rich shoofly pie and creamy chowders, each dish is a testament to the timeless art of Amish cooking.
But what truly sets The Plain and Fancy Farm Restaurant apart is its dedication to authenticity. Unlike typical restaurants, where chefs toil behind closed doors, here, guests are invited to witness the culinary magic firsthand. The restaurant features an open kitchen concept, allowing diners to observe skilled Amish cooks as they knead dough, stir bubbling pots, and craft delectable desserts with practiced hands. It’s a spectacle that not only tantalizes the taste buds but also nourishes the soul with a deeper appreciation for the culinary craft.
Beyond its culinary delights, The Plain and Fancy Farm Restaurant offers a window into the Amish way of life. Throughout the dining experience, guests are treated to glimpses of Amish traditions, from the meticulously tended gardens that supply the restaurant’s fresh produce to the handcrafted furnishings that adorn its interiors. It’s a holistic immersion that invites visitors to pause, reflect, and reconnect with a simpler, more authentic way of living.
Moreover, dining at The Plain and Fancy Farm Restaurant is more than just a meal; it’s a celebration of community. The restaurant serves as a gathering place where locals and travelers alike come together to share stories, forge connections, and break bread in the spirit of camaraderie. Whether seated at a cozy table for two or joining a lively group in the communal dining area, guests are welcomed with warmth and hospitality that is as genuine as it is infectious.
In an age marked by constant hustle and bustle, The Plain and Fancy Farm Restaurant stands as a beacon of serenity and tradition. It’s a place where time slows down, and the simple pleasures of good food, good company, and good living take center stage. So, whether you’re a weary traveler in search of respite or a curious epicurean eager to explore the flavors of Lancaster, a visit to The Plain and Fancy Farm Restaurant promises an experience that is both enriching and unforgettable.
2. A Taste of Heaven (Intercourse): This family-owned eatery focuses on fresh, seasonal ingredients. Their menu boasts classic Amish dishes with a gourmet touch, such as herb-roasted chicken and apple-glazed pork chops. Don’t miss their mouthwatering desserts, like shoofly pie and freshly baked cookies.
From the moment one steps through the charming entrance adorned with blooming flower baskets, it’s evident that A Taste of Heaven is more than just a restaurant; it’s an experience. The ambiance exudes warmth and tranquility, with soft lighting, elegant décor, and a welcoming atmosphere that immediately puts guests at ease. Whether seeking a romantic dinner for two or a gathering of friends and family, this establishment caters to all, offering a respite from the chaos of everyday life.
But it’s not just the ambiance that sets A Taste of Heaven apart; it’s the culinary journey that awaits within. Led by a team of visionary chefs who view cooking as an art form, the menu is a symphony of flavors, textures, and aromas that tantalize the senses and awaken the palate. Drawing inspiration from both local ingredients and global culinary traditions, each dish is a masterpiece in its own right, created with meticulous attention to detail and a reverence for quality.
One cannot talk about A Taste of Heaven without mentioning their signature dish: the Heavenly Chicken. A culinary revelation that has earned rave reviews from locals and visitors alike, this dish features succulent chicken breast smothered in a velvety mushroom sauce, served alongside buttery mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables. With each bite, diners are transported to culinary nirvana, savoring the harmonious blend of flavors and the undeniable passion infused into every ingredient.
3. Miller’s Smorgasbord (Shrewsbury): This Amish- Mennonite restaurant offers a vast buffet spread. From traditional Pennsylvania Dutch specialties like scrapple and pot roast to comfort food favorites like fried chicken and mashed potatoes, there’s something to satisfy every craving.
Renowned for its expansive buffet offerings and commitment to quality, Miller’s Smorgasbord is more than just a restaurant; it’s a destination where food lovers can indulge in a symphony of flavors, textures, and aromas that celebrate the rich culinary heritage of the region.
As one steps through the doors of Miller’s Smorgasbord, they are greeted by the tantalizing scent of freshly baked bread, sizzling meats, and savory sauces—a sensory feast that sets the stage for the culinary adventure to come. The ambiance is warm and inviting, with rustic décor, cozy seating areas, and a friendly atmosphere that makes guests feel right at home.
But the true star of the show at Miller’s Smorgasbord is the food itself. The buffet stretches as far as the eye can see, offering an array of dishes that cater to every palate and preference. From hearty comfort foods like fried chicken, mashed potatoes, and macaroni and cheese to lighter fare such as crisp salads and fresh seafood, there’s something to satisfy every craving and culinary whim.
One cannot talk about Miller’s Smorgasbord without mentioning their legendary roast beef. Cooked to perfection and carved to order, this succulent dish is a favorite among patrons, drawing diners back time and time again with its melt-in-your-mouth tenderness and rich flavor. And let’s not forget about the homemade desserts—a sinful indulgence that is not to be missed. From decadent cakes and pies to creamy puddings and cobblers, each sweet treat is a labor of love, crafted with care and attention to detail.
But what truly sets Miller’s Smorgasbord apart is its commitment to quality and tradition. Many of the recipes served here have been passed down through generations, preserving the culinary heritage of the region and ensuring that each dish is imbued with a sense of history and authenticity. Moreover, the ingredients used are sourced locally whenever possible, supporting area farmers and producers and ensuring the freshest flavors in every bite.
Yet, perhaps the most memorable aspect of dining at Miller’s Smorgasbord is the sense of camaraderie and community that pervades the atmosphere. Whether seated at a table for two or joining a bustling group of friends and family, guests are united by their love of good food and good company, forging connections and creating memories that last a lifetime.
In a world filled with fast food and instant gratification, Miller’s Smorgasbord stands as a testament to the timeless joy of slow dining and shared experience. It’s a place where strangers become friends, where meals become memories, and where every bite is a celebration of the rich tapestry of flavors that make up the culinary landscape of Pennsylvania. So, whether you’re a seasoned foodie in search of your next gastronomic adventure or simply seeking a taste of home, a visit to Miller’s Smorgasbord promises an experience that is as satisfying as it is unforgettable.
4. Dutch Pantry Family Restaurant: 14680 Clearfield Shawville Hwy, Clearfield, PA 16830
Nestled in a historic stone mill, this restaurant offers a charming ambiance alongside delicious Amish cooking. Their menu features hearty stews, succulent roast meats, and fresh-baked breads. Be sure to try their unique shoofly pie recipe, a local favorite.
Discovering Home at Dutch Pantry Family Restaurant in Clearfield, PA
Nestled along the scenic Clearfield Shawville Highway in Pennsylvania, Dutch Pantry Family Restaurant beckons travelers and locals alike with the promise of hearty meals, warm hospitality, and a taste of home. More than just a place to eat, Dutch Pantry embodies the essence of family, community, and the timeless traditions that have shaped the region for generations.
As one approaches Dutch Pantry, they are greeted by the inviting sight of a quaint, red-brick building adorned with flower-filled window boxes—a charming prelude to the heartwarming experience that awaits within. Stepping through the doors, guests are welcomed by the comforting aroma of home-cooked meals and the friendly smiles of the restaurant’s staff, setting the stage for a truly memorable dining experience.
The interior of Dutch Pantry exudes a cozy, nostalgic charm, with wooden accents, checkered tablecloths, and vintage décor that harkens back to simpler times. Here, diners are invited to pull up a chair and settle in for a feast of comfort food classics that celebrate the flavors of Pennsylvania Dutch country.
The menu at Dutch Pantry is a veritable treasure trove of homestyle delights, with offerings to please every palate and preference. From hearty breakfasts of fluffy pancakes and sizzling bacon to soul-warming lunches of savory soups and sandwiches, each dish is crafted with care and served with a generous helping of hospitality.
No visit to Dutch Pantry is complete without sampling their famous Pennsylvania Dutch specialties, which pay homage to the region’s rich culinary heritage. Indulge in platters of tender roast pork smothered in savory gravy, accompanied by buttery mashed potatoes and tangy sauerkraut, or savor the crispy perfection of their homemade chicken pot pie, brimming with chunks of tender meat and garden-fresh vegetables.
But perhaps the true star of the show at Dutch Pantry is their legendary pies—handcrafted delights that have earned the restaurant a reputation as a dessert destination. From flaky apple crumb to rich chocolate cream, each pie is a labor of love, made from scratch with only the finest ingredients and served with a dollop of whipped cream or a scoop of creamy vanilla ice cream.
Yet, beyond its delicious fare, Dutch Pantry holds a special place in the hearts of its patrons as a gathering spot for family and friends. Whether sharing a meal with loved ones, catching up with neighbors over coffee, or simply enjoying a moment of solitude with a slice of pie, guests are united by a sense of camaraderie and community that permeates the restaurant’s cozy confines.
In a world that often moves too fast, Dutch Pantry offers a welcome respite—a place where time slows down, and the simple pleasures of good food, good company, and good conversation take center stage. So, whether you’re a weary traveler in need of sustenance or a local seeking a taste of home, a visit to Dutch Pantry Family Restaurant promises an experience that nourishes both body and soul.
5. Lapp Valley Farm Creamery & Cafe (Lancaster): This quaint cafe combines fresh, local dairy products with delectable Amish fare. Savor their savory sandwiches made with locally-sourced meats and cheeses, or opt for a lighter option like their homemade quiche. Top it all off with a scoop of their award-winning ice cream for a truly satisfying meal. 4040 Old Philadelphia Pike, Gordonville, PA 17529
In the heart of Lancaster County, where lush green fields stretch as far as the eye can see and the gentle hum of dairy cows fills the air, lies a hidden gem that embodies the essence of wholesome goodness and farm-fresh delights: Lapp Valley Farm Creamery & Cafe. Nestled amidst the rolling hills and picturesque landscapes, this family-owned establishment invites visitors on a journey to savor the simple joys of life, one scoop at a time.
As you arrive at Lapp Valley Farm, the first thing that captivates your senses is the fresh, clean scent of the countryside—a refreshing departure from the hustle and bustle of city life. The sprawling dairy farm, with its red barns and grazing cows, sets the scene for an authentic farm-to-table experience that celebrates the beauty of nature and the bounty of the land.
Stepping into the Creamery & Cafe, you are greeted by the inviting aroma of freshly churned ice cream and the warm smiles of the Lapp family, who have been tending to their beloved farm for generations. The rustic charm of the interior, with its wooden accents and cozy seating areas, immediately puts you at ease, inviting you to linger and soak in the tranquil atmosphere.
But the true star of the show at Lapp Valley Farm is, without a doubt, the ice cream—a creamy indulgence that is made from the freshest milk produced right on the farm. With flavors ranging from classic favorites like vanilla bean and chocolate fudge brownie to seasonal specialties like strawberry rhubarb and pumpkin pie, there’s something to satisfy every craving and delight every palate.
What sets Lapp Valley Farm’s ice cream apart is not just its exceptional taste, but also the commitment to quality and sustainability that underpins every scoop. The milk used to make the ice cream comes from the farm’s own herd of Holstein cows, who graze on nutrient-rich pastures and enjoy the highest standards of care and welfare. This dedication to ethical farming practices ensures that each spoonful of ice cream is not only delicious but also a reflection of the farm’s deep-rooted values.
In addition to their delectable ice cream offerings, Lapp Valley Farm Creamery & Cafe also serves up a variety of other treats, including freshly baked cookies, homemade pies, and refreshing milkshakes. Whether you’re craving a sweet pick-me-up or a hearty snack to fuel your adventures, there’s no shortage of options to tempt your taste buds.
But perhaps the most magical aspect of visiting Lapp Valley Farm is the opportunity to connect with the land and the people who tend to it. Guests are invited to take a stroll around the farm, where they can watch the cows graze in the pastures, learn about the dairy farming process, and even sample some of the farm’s other products, such as fresh milk and artisanal cheeses.
In a world that often feels disconnected from the source of its food, Lapp Valley Farm Creamery & Cafe offers a refreshing reminder of the beauty and simplicity of farm life. It’s a place where time slows down, and moments are savored, where the flavors of the land come to life in every bite, and where the spirit of community and kinship thrives. So, whether you’re a local looking for a taste of home or a traveler seeking an authentic farm experience, a visit to Lapp Valley Farm promises an adventure that nourishes both body and soul.
